Deemed Trusts and Crown Priorities in Canadian Insolvency
Deemed trusts let the Crown treat unpaid taxes as trust property, but most disappear in formal insolvency. Employee source deductions survive and can prime secured lenders, while GST/HST and most provincial trusts fall away. This note explains the rules under the BIA and CCAA, court-ordered charges, Quebec specifics and how lenders reserve.

Key takeaways
- Source-deduction deemed trusts under ITA s. 227(4.1) survive CCAA and BIA proceedings.
- Other Crown deemed trusts, including GST/HST, fall away under CCAA s. 37(1) and BIA s. 67(2).
- Canada North Group, 2021 SCC 30, lets CCAA charges rank ahead of the source-deduction trust.
- Quebec source-deduction trusts survive; QST trusts fall away like GST/HST.
- Lenders use priority payable reserves, remittance covenants and audits to manage the risk.
Which deemed trusts survive insolvency?
Deemed trusts are statutory devices that treat money a business owes the government as if it were held in trust, separate from the business's own property. Outside insolvency, many federal and provincial statutes create these statutory trusts, and some purport to rank ahead of secured lenders. Inside a formal proceeding, however, most of them disappear, and knowing which ones survive is essential for anyone lending to, buying from or advising a distressed business.

The general rule under both the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) and the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) is that statutory deemed trusts in favour of the Crown are ignored unless the property would be held in trust anyway. The main exception is for employee source deductions: income tax withholdings, Canada Pension Plan contributions and Employment Insurance premiums, and equivalent provincial amounts. Those trusts survive, and the federal one reaches property held by secured creditors.
For lenders, this distinction drives how much of a borrowing base can be lent against and what reserves are needed. For directors, it matters because unremitted source deductions and GST/HST can lead to personal liability. This note explains which trusts survive, which fall away, how court-ordered super-priority charges interact with them, the Quebec specifics, and how lenders reserve for the risk.
Source deductions: ITA s. 227(4) and (4.1)
An employer that deducts or withholds income tax from employees' pay is deemed to hold the amount in trust for the Crown (s. 227(4) of the Income Tax Act).
If the amount is not remitted on time, s. 227(4.1) extends the trust in striking terms: notwithstanding any other provision of the ITA, the BIA (except ss. 81.1 and 81.2), any other federal or provincial enactment or any other law, property of the employer, and property held by any secured creditor that would be the employer's property but for the security interest, equal in value to the unremitted amount, is deemed held in trust for the Crown from the time the amount was withheld, "whether or not the property is subject to such a security interest". The Canada Pension Plan and the Employment Insurance Act contain parallel provisions.
The effect is that unremitted source deductions rank ahead of secured lenders, including lenders with earlier perfected security. The CCAA preserves these trusts expressly (s. 37(2)), and so does the BIA (s. 67(3)). Provincial equivalents survive too, if they relate to a provincial income tax similar to the federal tax or to a provincial pension plan like the Quebec Pension Plan, and the province's deemed trust is given the same effect and scope as the federal one.
Deemed trusts that fall away: GST/HST and most provincial trusts
Other Crown trusts do not survive. Under s. 37(1) of the CCAA, despite any federal or provincial provision deeming property to be held in trust for the Crown, a debtor company's property is not regarded as held in trust unless it would be in the absence of the statute. Section 67(2) of the BIA has the same effect in bankruptcy. The Excise Tax Act deemed trust for collected GST/HST (s. 222(1)) itself provides that it does not apply to amounts collected before a person becomes bankrupt (s. 222(1.1)).
In CCAA proceedings, the Supreme Court of Canada held in Century Services Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), 2010 SCC 60, that the GST deemed trust does not survive.
Provincial statutory trusts for retail sales tax, employer health tax, workers' compensation premiums and similar amounts also generally fall away, unless they meet the general law of trusts (for example, because funds were actually segregated). In addition, Crown claims, including secured claims, rank as unsecured in CCAA proceedings unless they are secured by a kind of security that persons other than the Crown could also obtain, or by certain registered security described in s. 39 (CCAA s. 38); the BIA has a similar rule (s. 86).
| Claim | Outside insolvency | In CCAA / BIA proposal | In bankruptcy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Federal income tax source deductions, CPP, EI | Deemed trust; primes secured creditors | Survives (CCAA s. 37(2)) | Survives (BIA s. 67(3)) |
| Equivalent provincial source deductions (e.g., Quebec) | Provincial deemed trust | Survives if within s. 37(2) criteria | Survives if within s. 67(3) criteria |
| GST/HST collected | Deemed trust (ETA s. 222) | Does not survive (Century Services) | Does not survive (ETA s. 222(1.1); BIA s. 67(2)) |
| Provincial sales tax and most other provincial trusts | Deemed trust under provincial law | Does not survive (s. 37(1)) | Does not survive (s. 67(2)) |
| Other Crown claims | Various statutory liens and priorities | Unsecured unless registered general-type security (s. 38) | Unsecured subject to s. 86 exceptions |
Super-priority charges and deemed trusts
CCAA courts routinely grant administration, interim financing and directors' charges that rank ahead of secured creditors. Whether those charges could also rank ahead of the surviving source-deduction deemed trust was settled in Canada v. Canada North Group Inc., 2021 SCC 30. A majority of the Supreme Court held that the court may give court-ordered restructuring charges priority over the Crown's deemed trust for employee source deductions. The judges in the majority differed on whether the deemed trust is a security interest, but agreed on the result. Three judges dissented, reasoning that the ITA gives the deemed trust absolute priority.
The decision gives DIP lenders and monitors comfort that their charges can sit ahead of unremitted source deductions, but it does not eliminate the Crown's claim. Courts will still consider prejudice to the Crown when sizing charges, and the deemed trust continues to rank ahead of pre-filing secured lenders. Debtors are also expected to remit post-filing source deductions in the ordinary course, and DIP budgets should provide for them.
Before an initial CCAA hearing, ask the debtor to confirm in its affidavit whether source deductions and GST/HST are current, and give notice to the Canada Revenue Agency and provincial tax authorities. Courts are more willing to grant priority charges when the Crown has had a fair chance to respond.
Deemed trusts outside formal proceedings
The rules that make most deemed trusts disappear apply only once a BIA or CCAA proceeding begins. Before that, and in private enforcement, Crown trusts operate on their own terms. A lender that appoints a private receiver or enforces against receivables without a formal filing may face competing claims from the Canada Revenue Agency or a provincial tax authority asserting a deemed trust for GST/HST, provincial sales tax or other amounts. The Crown also has powerful collection tools, such as requirements to pay that oblige third parties, including the borrower's customers and banks, to pay money owed to the tax debtor directly to the Crown.
This creates a strategic choice for secured creditors. A court-appointed receivership under the BIA or a bankruptcy can neutralize GST/HST and most provincial deemed trusts, while leaving source deductions in place. Private enforcement may be faster and cheaper but exposes realizations to a wider range of trust claims. Many lenders with significant tax arrears in the borrower therefore prefer a court process, or a bankruptcy layered on top of a receivership, so that the BIA distribution scheme applies.
Timing also matters. The source-deduction trust under s. 227(4.1) is deemed to operate from the time the amounts were withheld, so it can reach collateral that was realized before the Crown made any demand. Purchasers of assets from a receiver should make sure vesting orders deal expressly with Crown claims and that the receiver has reserved for any surviving trust amounts before distributing proceeds to secured creditors.
Quebec specifics
Quebec runs its own income tax and pension plan, so employers in Quebec withhold Quebec income tax and Quebec Pension Plan contributions as well as federal amounts. Because Quebec's laws create statutory trusts for source deductions that fit the criteria in CCAA s. 37(2) and BIA s. 67(3), those trusts survive insolvency with the same scope as the federal ones, giving Revenu Québec a priority claim for unremitted employee withholdings. Quebec sales tax (QST) collected and not remitted is treated like GST/HST: the deemed trust falls away in formal proceedings.
Quebec's civil law adds another layer. Security takes the form of hypothecs, and prior claims under the Civil Code rank ahead of hypothecs for certain debts, including some amounts owed to the State. Lenders financing Quebec operations should map these prior claims alongside the federal deemed trust rules.
Director liability for unremitted amounts
Statutory trusts are only part of the Crown's protection. Collection tools such as requirements to pay and set-off against refunds also matter, and directors can be personally liable for unremitted source deductions under s. 227.1 of the ITA and for unremitted GST/HST under s. 323 of the Excise Tax Act, subject to a due diligence defence and limitation periods. Provincial statutes contain similar rules.
Directors of distressed companies therefore watch remittances closely, and many resign when remittances fall behind. In CCAA proceedings, the directors' charge is often sized partly by reference to these exposures. Directors who want to rely on the due diligence defence should be able to show that they took positive steps to prevent the failure to remit, such as insisting on remittance before other payments, rather than simply learning of the arrears after the fact.
How lenders reserve for deemed trusts
Lenders manage deemed trust risk through:
- Priority payable reserves in borrowing base facilities, covering source deductions, GST/HST, provincial sales taxes, wages and vacation pay, pension contributions and other amounts that could rank ahead.
- Covenants and reporting requiring timely remittance and monthly certificates confirming that remittances are current.
- Audit rights to verify remittance records and payroll processes.
- Events of default triggered by any failure to remit or by Crown garnishment or requirements to pay.
- Payroll controls, such as requiring a third-party payroll provider that remits automatically.
Reserves for GST/HST and other trusts that fall away in insolvency may seem unnecessary, but they protect against enforcement outside formal proceedings, where those trusts and Crown garnishment powers can still bite. Our notes on pension deficits in insolvency and asset-based lending cover related priority issues.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise lenders, DIP lenders, debtors, directors and purchasers on deemed trusts and Crown priorities in Canadian insolvencies. We review borrowing base reserves and remittance covenants, prepare court materials on priority charges, negotiate with tax authorities in restructurings and advise directors on remittance exposure. We work with tax advisers and Canadian litigation counsel where needed. See our pages on CCAA restructuring and tax disputes. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a priority question, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Which deemed trusts survive a CCAA filing?
Only deemed trusts for employee source deductions: income tax withheld under s. 227(4) and (4.1) of the Income Tax Act, Canada Pension Plan contributions and Employment Insurance premiums, plus provincial equivalents meeting the criteria in s. 37(2) of the CCAA. Other Crown deemed trusts, including the GST/HST trust, are disregarded unless the property would be held in trust without the statute.
Does the GST/HST deemed trust survive bankruptcy?
No. Section 222(1.1) of the Excise Tax Act provides that the deemed trust does not apply to amounts collected before the person became bankrupt, and s. 67(2) of the BIA removes Crown deemed trusts generally. In CCAA proceedings, Century Services Inc. v. Canada, 2010 SCC 60, held that the GST deemed trust does not survive.
Can a DIP charge rank ahead of the source-deduction deemed trust?
Yes. In Canada v. Canada North Group Inc., 2021 SCC 30, a majority of the Supreme Court of Canada held that a CCAA court may order restructuring charges to rank ahead of the Crown's deemed trust for employee source deductions, although the judges in the majority gave different reasons.
How do lenders protect against deemed trust priority?
By reserving for priority payables in borrowing bases, requiring regular confirmation that remittances are current, auditing payroll, using third-party payroll providers and making any failure to remit an event of default. These steps limit exposure to the source-deduction trust, which can rank ahead of even prior perfected security.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


