Pension Deficits in Insolvency: The New Priority Rules
Pension deficits in insolvency will rank ahead of secured lenders from 27 April 2027 for existing plans. The 2023 Pension Protection Act extended BIA security to special payments and unfunded liabilities and requires CCAA plans and proposals to pay them. This note explains the changes, their ranking and what lenders and sponsors should do now.

Key takeaways
- The Pension Protection Act received royal assent on 27 April 2023.
- For existing plan sponsors, the changes apply from the fourth anniversary: 27 April 2027.
- BIA ss. 81.5 and 81.6 will secure special payments and unfunded liabilities in bankruptcy and receivership.
- CCAA plans and BIA proposals must provide for payment of the expanded pension amounts.
- The new security ranks above secured creditors, subject to narrow exceptions.
How pension deficits in insolvency will rank from April 2027
Pension deficits in insolvency are about to move up the priority ladder. The federal Pension Protection Act (S.C. 2023, c. 6), which received royal assent on 27 April 2023, amended the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA) and the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) so that unfunded liabilities and solvency deficiencies of defined benefit pension plans are secured by a super-priority charge in bankruptcy and receivership, and must be paid before a CCAA plan or BIA proposal can be approved. For employers that already sponsored a prescribed pension plan when the Act took effect, the changes apply only from the fourth anniversary of its coming into force, which is 27 April 2027. Lenders, sponsors and acquirers of companies with underfunded plans need to plan for that date now.

Before the amendments, federal insolvency law protected only current contributions: amounts deducted from employees' pay and unpaid normal cost contributions owed by the employer. Special payments to amortize a deficit, and the deficit that crystallizes when a plan is wound up, were generally unsecured in bankruptcy, although provincial deemed trusts sometimes gave them priority outside formal proceedings. The 2023 Act closes that gap at the federal level. This note explains what is covered, how the new security ranks, how it interacts with existing deemed trusts and what it means for lending and restructuring.
What the Pension Protection Act changes
The Act amends four sets of provisions:
- Bankruptcy (BIA s. 81.5). The security on all of a bankrupt employer's assets for unpaid pension amounts now extends to special payments required to liquidate an unfunded liability or a solvency deficiency and to "any amount required to liquidate any other unfunded liability or solvency deficiency of the fund".
- Receivership (BIA s. 81.6). The same expanded amounts are secured when an employer's property is in the possession or control of a receiver.
- Proposals (BIA s. 60(1.5)). A court may approve a commercial proposal by an employer participating in a prescribed pension plan only if it provides for payment of the expanded amounts, including deficits determined at the filing of the notice of intention or proposal, unless the parties agree otherwise with regulatory approval.
- CCAA plans (CCAA s. 6(6)). A court may sanction a compromise or arrangement only if it provides for payment of the same expanded amounts, determined on the day proceedings commence, subject to similar agreed alternatives.
These requirements apply to "prescribed pension plans", a category defined by regulation. The statutory text deals separately with plans regulated by an Act of Parliament and with "any other prescribed pension plan", for which amounts are measured as if the plan were federally regulated, so provincially regulated plans that fall within the prescribed category are also captured. The Act also requires the federal Superintendent of Financial Institutions to report annually on pension plan funding.
| Amount owing to the pension fund | Before the 2023 Act | After the transition (from 27 April 2027 for existing plans) |
|---|---|---|
| Employee contributions deducted but not remitted | Secured (BIA ss. 81.5–81.6) | Secured |
| Unpaid employer normal cost | Secured | Secured |
| Unpaid special payments to amortize deficits | Generally unsecured | Secured |
| Other unfunded liability or solvency deficiency (including wind-up deficits) | Generally unsecured | Secured |
| Payment required to approve a CCAA plan or BIA proposal | Contributions and normal cost | Adds special payments and deficits |
Ranking of the new pension security
The security under BIA s. 81.5 ranks above every other claim, right, charge or security against the bankrupt's assets, regardless of when it arose, with limited exceptions: the rights of unpaid suppliers to repossess goods and of farmers, fishermen and aquaculturists under ss. 81.1 and 81.2, amounts deemed held in trust under s. 67(3) (essentially Crown source-deduction trusts), and the wage security in ss. 81.3 and 81.4. In receiverships, s. 81.6 provides similar ranking. In practical terms, the full pension deficit will rank ahead of secured lenders, including those with first-ranking security over all assets.
The trustee or receiver that realizes assets subject to the security is personally liable for the secured amounts to the extent of the proceeds, and is subrogated to the pension fund's rights. That makes trustees and receivers careful to establish the deficit early, usually with the plan administrator and an actuary, before distributing anything to secured creditors.
Existing deemed trusts and pension deficits in insolvency
Provincial pension statutes have long created deemed trusts for unpaid contributions and, in some provinces, for wind-up deficiencies. Outside formal insolvency, these trusts can give pension claims priority over secured creditors under provincial law. Inside CCAA proceedings, however, courts can order priming charges that rank ahead of provincial deemed trusts because of federal paramountcy, as the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed in Sun Indalex Finance, LLC v. United Steelworkers, 2013 SCC 6. In bankruptcy, provincial deemed trusts that do not meet the general trust requirements generally do not survive, because the BIA's scheme of distribution governs.
The 2023 amendments change that landscape. Instead of relying on provincial deemed trusts that may or may not survive a federal filing, pension funds will have express federal security in bankruptcy and receivership and an express payment requirement in CCAA plans and BIA proposals. The open question is how courts will treat court-ordered priming charges, such as DIP and administration charges, against the expanded pension claims in a CCAA proceeding that later converts into bankruptcy.
Effect on lenders, sponsors and restructurings
For lenders, the new treatment of pension deficits in insolvency converts what was often an unsecured risk into a priority claim that can absorb collateral value. Borrowing bases and covenants that exclude or reserve against pension deficits will become standard for employers with defined benefit plans, and credit committees will look closely at solvency valuations, not just going-concern funding positions. Some lenders may reduce availability or require plan funding commitments as conditions of credit.
For restructurings, the CCAA and BIA payment requirements mean that a plan or proposal cannot simply compromise the pension deficit unless the parties agree otherwise and the pension regulator approves. That makes a liquidating sale outside a plan, a negotiated arrangement with the pension regulator, or a transfer of the plan to a purchaser more likely outcomes for heavily underfunded employers. Purchasers in distressed M&A should expect sellers and monitors to price the plan explicitly. Unions and retiree groups, often represented by court-appointed representative counsel, will also be at the table, and their support can be decisive for any negotiated solution that the pension regulator must approve.
If a borrower sponsors a defined benefit plan, obtain the latest actuarial valuation, including the solvency and wind-up position, and model the deficit as a priority claim from 27 April 2027. Credit agreements signed now should include reporting on valuations and special payments, and a reserve mechanism that can be activated before the transition date.
Transition and open questions
The four-year transition for pension deficits in insolvency applies to employers that participated in a prescribed pension plan on the day before the amendments came into force (s. 7 of the 2023 Act). New plans established after that date were subject to the changes immediately. Several questions remain open:
- How the deficit will be measured in each case, and which valuation date and actuarial assumptions courts will accept.
- Whether proceedings started shortly before 27 April 2027 will be affected by the timing of the "initial bankruptcy event" or the commencement of CCAA proceedings.
- How the payment requirement in CCAA plans will interact with reverse vesting orders and sales that do not involve a plan.
- Whether provinces will adjust their own pension benefit guarantee or deemed trust rules in response.
Employers facing financial pressure before 2027 should take advice on how the timing of any filing affects stakeholders, without assuming that a filing before the date will avoid scrutiny. Directors must continue to act in the best interests of the corporation, and courts will look closely at transactions that appear designed to defeat pension claims.
Measuring pension deficits in insolvency
Pension deficits in insolvency are not a single number. A plan's going-concern valuation assumes the plan continues indefinitely and usually shows a smaller shortfall than its solvency valuation, which assumes the plan is terminated on the valuation date and benefits are settled by purchasing annuities or paying commuted values. The amendments refer to special payments determined under the federal Pension Benefits Standards Regulations, 1985, and to any amount required to liquidate any other unfunded liability or solvency deficiency, which points toward the larger solvency or wind-up measure in a liquidation scenario.
Interest rates and annuity pricing move these numbers substantially. A plan that looks fully funded when long-term rates are high can show a meaningful solvency deficit when rates fall. Lenders and acquirers should therefore ask for sensitivity analysis from the plan actuary, not just the headline figures in the last filed valuation, and should understand any funding relief, letters of credit or contribution holidays that the sponsor has used.
In a CCAA proceeding, the CCAA measures the deficit as of the day proceedings commence. In a BIA proposal, the relevant time is the filing of the notice of intention or the proposal. For bankruptcy and receivership, the security attaches to amounts unpaid immediately before the bankruptcy or the appointment of the receiver. Each of these dates can produce a different figure, so parties should agree early with the administrator and the pension regulator on how and when the deficit will be calculated.
Practical steps for employers, lenders and acquirers
- Identify all defined benefit plans, their regulators and their latest solvency and wind-up valuations.
- Track special payments and any funding relief, contribution deferrals or letters of credit used to meet them.
- Update credit agreements with pension reporting, reserves and events of default tied to funding.
- In M&A, price the deficit as a priority debt-like item from 2027 onward.
- Engage early with the pension regulator and plan administrator in any restructuring.
- Coordinate with employment and benefits advisers on member communications.
- Revisit the analysis whenever interest rates, annuity prices or plan membership change materially.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise lenders, employers, plan sponsors, purchasers and monitors' counsel teams on pension deficits in insolvency and restructuring. Our work includes credit agreement terms for pension risk, transaction structuring for employers with defined benefit plans, CCAA and BIA strategy, and negotiations with pension regulators and administrators, alongside actuarial and benefits advisers. See our pages on pensions and benefits and CCAA restructuring, and our note on deemed trusts and Crown priorities. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss pension risk, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
When do the new pension priority rules apply?
The Pension Protection Act received royal assent on 27 April 2023. For employers that already participated in a prescribed pension plan the day before the amendments took effect, the BIA and CCAA changes do not apply until the fourth anniversary of the Act's coming into force, which is 27 April 2027.
Which pension amounts become secured?
In addition to employee contributions and employer normal cost, which were already secured, the amendments secure special payments required to liquidate an unfunded liability or solvency deficiency and any amount required to liquidate any other unfunded liability or solvency deficiency of the fund, in bankruptcy and receivership under BIA ss. 81.5 and 81.6.
Does the pension security rank ahead of secured lenders?
Yes. It ranks above every other claim, right, charge or security against the employer's assets, except a few listed rights such as unpaid supplier repossession rights, certain Crown deemed trusts under s. 67(3) and employee wage security under ss. 81.3 and 81.4. For many borrowers, that means the deficit will rank ahead of first-lien lenders.
Can a CCAA plan compromise a pension deficit?
Under the amended s. 6(6) of the CCAA, a court may sanction a plan for a company participating in a prescribed pension plan only if it provides for payment of the specified amounts, including deficits determined on the day proceedings commence, unless the parties agree to a different arrangement approved by the relevant pension regulator.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


