Document Preservation, Litigation Holds and Spoliation
Document preservation became a sharper risk in 2026, when the Supreme Court held in SS&C v. BNY Mellon that spoliation triggers a mandatory adverse presumption. This guide explains when the duty to preserve arises, how to issue litigation holds that work, the Sedona Canada principles, collaboration tools and ephemeral messaging, and the sanctions for getting it wrong.

Key takeaways
- The duty to preserve arises when litigation is reasonably anticipated, often before a claim.
- SS&C (2026 SCC 29): proven spoliation triggers a mandatory unfavourable presumption.
- Ontario discovery plans must have regard to the Sedona Canada Principles (r. 29.1.03(4)).
- Holds must cover chats, personal devices and AI tools, not just email.
- Refusing a preservation request is one of the riskiest positions a litigant can take.
Why document preservation matters more after 2026
Document preservation is the obligation to keep relevant evidence once litigation is reasonably anticipated. It has always mattered, but the Supreme Court of Canada raised the stakes in SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, decided on 31 July 2026. The Court held that once spoliation is established, courts must presume that the missing evidence would have been unfavourable to the party responsible, and have discretion to choose a remedy that makes up for the loss. For any business facing a dispute, the practical lesson is simple: a weak document preservation process can turn a defensible case into a losing one.

In SS&C, a pricing-data provider discovered that its data had been passed on, without charge, to an affiliate of its customer after the affiliate's own contract had ended. It asked the bank to preserve information showing how the data had been redistributed, to whom and how much the bank had earned from it. The bank refused.
The trial judge found a breach of contract, and the Court of Appeal agreed that the bank had been wrong not to keep the information. The Supreme Court unanimously held that the bank committed spoliation, described as intentionally destroying, changing, hiding or failing to keep relevant evidence to influence the outcome of a lawsuit, and that the trial judge's presumptions had not been unfavourable enough to the bank. It set aside the damages and sent the matter back for a new assessment.
When the duty to preserve arises
The duty arises when litigation is reasonably anticipated, which is often well before a statement of claim is served. Common triggers include:
- a demand letter, preservation request or notice of claim, as in SS&C;
- an internal discovery of a problem likely to lead to a claim, such as a product defect, data breach or financial irregularity;
- a regulator's inquiry, search or request for information;
- the company's own decision to sue or to take steps, such as terminating a contract or an executive, that are likely to be challenged;
- a whistleblower complaint or internal investigation.
The trigger date matters for both sides. A company that waits until it is served may have allowed routine deletion to destroy evidence it was already obliged to keep. A claimant that intends to sue should send a clear preservation request early, both to protect evidence and to set up a spoliation argument if the request is ignored. Because limitation periods often start running at about the same time, our insight on discoverability and limitation periods is a useful companion.
Litigation hold notices that work
A litigation hold notice suspends normal deletion for relevant information and tells custodians what to keep. Effective notices share several features:
- Clear scope. Describe the subject matter, the relevant time period and the types of records in plain language, with examples.
- Named custodians. Identify the people likely to hold relevant information, including former employees whose accounts may still exist, and assistants and teams who work for them.
- Systems, not just people. Instruct IT to suspend auto-deletion on email, collaboration platforms, shared drives, databases, backup rotation and device wiping for the relevant accounts.
- Acknowledgement and reminders. Require custodians to confirm receipt, and send periodic reminders while the hold is in place.
- Release. Lift the hold formally when the matter ends, so that ordinary retention can resume.
Document preservation should be proportionate. The duty is to take reasonable steps to preserve relevant information, not to freeze every system in the company. Documenting the reasoning behind scope decisions is the best protection if they are later challenged. Where the scope is uncertain, discussing it with opposing counsel early, and recording any agreement, can remove the issue from the dispute entirely.
Sedona Canada principles and discovery plans
Canadian courts expect parties to manage electronic evidence cooperatively and proportionately. In Ontario, r. 29.1.03 of the Rules of Civil Procedure requires parties to agree a written discovery plan, generally within 60 days after the close of pleadings, and r. 29.1.03(4) requires them to consult and have regard to The Sedona Canada Principles Addressing Electronic Discovery when preparing it. The Sedona Canada Principles emphasize proportionality, early discussion of electronic information, reasonable preservation efforts and cooperation between counsel. Other provinces refer to the same principles in practice directions and case law.
A good discovery plan records what has been preserved, from which systems and custodians, and how it will be collected, searched and produced. Agreeing those points early reduces later fights about whether a party took reasonable preservation steps. It is also the natural place to agree on protocols for privileged material and inadvertent production.
| Data source | Typical preservation step | Common failure |
|---|---|---|
| Email and shared drives | Suspend auto-deletion; place custodian accounts on hold | Mailbox of departed employee deleted under routine policy |
| Collaboration tools (Teams, Slack and similar) | Apply retention holds to channels and chats | Default short retention on chats left unchanged |
| Ephemeral and personal messaging (WhatsApp, Signal, SMS) | Instruct custodians to disable disappearing messages; image devices where needed | Business conducted on personal phones with auto-delete enabled |
| Databases and transactional systems | Preserve snapshots or reports showing relevant data at key dates | Overwriting of live data with no historical extract |
| AI tools and meeting transcripts | Retain prompts, outputs and transcripts for custodians | Vendor default deletion after 30 days |
Ephemeral messaging and collaboration tools
The biggest modern risk to document preservation is not deliberate destruction; it is business conducted on channels the company does not control. Executives negotiating by text message, teams coordinating in disappearing-message apps and project groups on collaboration platforms with short default retention can all leave gaps. Courts have little sympathy for the argument that messages were deleted automatically when the company allowed the practice and did not suspend it after the duty arose.
Companies should adopt communication policies that require business communications to be conducted on approved, retained channels, prohibit disappearing-message settings for business use, and provide for preservation from personal devices when a hold is issued. AI meeting assistants and generative AI chats should be covered as well; our insight on AI in litigation discusses why those records may be discoverable.
Write a one-page "first 48 hours" protocol for disputes: who decides that a hold is needed, who sends it, which systems IT must lock down and how personal-device messages are captured. When a demand letter arrives, following the protocol is faster than improvising, and it creates a record of reasonable preservation steps that will matter if spoliation is ever alleged.
Spoliation inferences and sanctions
Before SS&C, Canadian courts generally treated spoliation as an evidentiary matter: where relevant evidence was intentionally destroyed, the court could infer that it would have been unfavourable to the destroying party, with the strength of the inference depending on the facts. SS&C strengthens that position in two ways.
Once spoliation is established, the presumption that the missing evidence was unfavourable is mandatory rather than optional, and the remedy must be sufficient to make up for the missing evidence; a presumption that is too mild, as the trial judge's was in that case, is an error. Courts retain discretion to choose among remedies, which can include adverse presumptions on damages, costs and, in serious cases, striking pleadings.
Unintentional loss of evidence is treated differently. Negligent failures to preserve may still lead to remedies under the rules of court, such as costs or limits on the evidence a party can lead, but the spoliation presumption described in SS&C is aimed at intentional conduct, including a deliberate failure to keep evidence after a request.
Refusing a reasonable preservation request, as the bank did, is therefore one of the riskiest positions a litigant can take. Electronic evidence must also be authenticated when offered; under s. 31.1 of the Canada Evidence Act the party relying on an electronic document must prove it is what it purports to be, which is far easier when the original records were preserved properly.
Illustration: a hypothetical Canadian distributor receives a letter from a former supplier alleging that it misused confidential pricing data and asking it to preserve records of how the data was used. The distributor's legal team issues a hold to sales and IT the same week, suspends deletion on the relevant mailboxes and chat channels, and records the steps. Two years later, at trial, the supplier argues that some messages are missing. Because the company can show what it preserved, when and why, the court treats the gap as minor and declines to draw any adverse presumption.
Document preservation in transactions, investigations and cross-border cases
Some situations make document preservation harder than usual. Three deserve specific planning.
Mergers, carve-outs and insolvencies. When a business is sold, records often move to the buyer, are left with the seller or are scheduled for destruction as systems are decommissioned. Purchase agreements should allocate custody of pre-closing records, require cooperation for litigation and preserve access where a known dispute exists. In receiverships and bankruptcies, the officer taking control should identify pending or threatened claims early, because routine shutdown of email and servers can destroy evidence that creditors or the estate will need.
Internal investigations. An investigation into misconduct usually triggers the duty to preserve, both for the company's own claims and for claims against it. The hold should issue before interviews start, so that custodians do not delete material once they learn of the inquiry, and forensic imaging of key devices may be justified. Decisions about privilege over the investigation should be taken at the same time.
Cross-border data. Multinational groups may hold relevant information in several countries, subject to data protection laws that restrict transfer or review. Preservation in place is usually permitted even where transfer is not, so the first step is to stop deletion locally and then work out lawful collection. Coordinating document preservation with foreign counsel and privacy teams avoids both spoliation and data protection breaches.
Records retention schedules should be designed with these situations in mind. A schedule that destroys records promptly when they are no longer needed is good practice, provided it includes a mechanism that suspends destruction whenever a hold applies.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise companies on document preservation and litigation holds as part of our commercial litigation and privacy and data protection work. That includes drafting hold notices and first-48-hours protocols, aligning records retention and messaging policies with preservation duties, preparing discovery plans that reflect the Sedona Canada Principles, sending and responding to preservation requests, and advising on spoliation claims after SS&C. Court proceedings in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel, and we work alongside them. This page is general information rather than legal advice. To set up or review a hold, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
When does a company have to start preserving documents?
When litigation is reasonably anticipated, which can be well before a claim is served. A demand or preservation letter, a regulator's inquiry, discovery of a problem likely to lead to a claim, or the company's own decision to sue are common triggers. Routine deletion of relevant records should be suspended from that point.
What did the Supreme Court decide in SS&C v. BNY Mellon?
In SS&C Technologies Canada Corp. v. Bank of New York Mellon Corp., 2026 SCC 29, the Court held that once spoliation is established, courts must presume the missing evidence was unfavourable to the party responsible and choose a remedy that makes up for it. It found the bank's refusal to preserve requested information was spoliation and ordered damages reassessed.
Are text messages and chat apps covered by a litigation hold?
Yes, if they contain relevant information. Business communications on text, WhatsApp, Signal, Teams or Slack are documents like email. Holds should instruct custodians to disable disappearing messages and, where needed, provide for imaging of personal devices used for business.
What are the Sedona Canada Principles?
They are principles on electronic discovery developed by The Sedona Conference, emphasizing proportionality, cooperation, early discussion of electronic information and reasonable preservation. In Ontario, r. 29.1.03(4) of the Rules of Civil Procedure requires parties to consult and have regard to them when preparing a discovery plan.
Does accidental deletion count as spoliation?
The spoliation presumption described in SS&C is aimed at intentional destruction, alteration, concealment or failure to keep evidence to influence litigation. Negligent loss may still lead to remedies under the rules of court, such as costs or evidentiary limits, so reasonable, documented preservation steps remain essential.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


