Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Discoverability and Ultimate Limitation Periods

Discoverability and limitation periods decide whether a commercial claim can be heard at all. This guide explains when the two-year clock starts after Grant Thornton v. New Brunswick, the 15-year Ontario and 10-year Alberta ultimate periods, continuous acts, corporate knowledge in fraud cases, contribution claims and how to use tolling agreements safely.

Calendar and case file illustrating discoverability and limitation periods in a Canadian lawsuit

Key takeaways

  • Ontario and Alberta give two years from discovery to sue.
  • A claim is discovered once facts support a plausible inference of liability (2021 SCC 31).
  • Ultimate periods: 15 years in Ontario, 10 years in Alberta.
  • Ontario contribution claims run from service of the main claim (s. 18).
  • Tolling agreements work, but the 15-year period can be extended only after discovery.

How discoverability and limitation periods work together

Discoverability and limitation periods are two halves of one rule. Most Canadian provinces give a claimant two years to sue, but the two years usually start running only when the claim is "discovered", meaning when the claimant knew or ought to have known the essential facts. To prevent claims from staying alive forever, the statutes add an "ultimate" period that runs from the act or omission regardless of discovery: 15 years in Ontario and 10 years in Alberta. Getting the start date wrong is one of the most common, and least forgivable, ways to lose a commercial claim.

Calendar and case file illustrating discoverability and limitation periods in a Canadian lawsuit
Discoverability and limitation periods: a two-year clock from discovery, capped by an ultimate period from the underlying act.

In Ontario, s. 4 of the Limitations Act, 2002 provides that no proceeding may be commenced after the second anniversary of the day the claim was discovered, and s. 15(2) provides that no proceeding may be commenced after the 15th anniversary of the day the act or omission took place. Alberta's Limitations Act, s. 3(1), combines both rules in one provision: the defendant is immune if the claimant does not seek a remedial order within two years after it first knew, or ought to have known, the relevant facts, or within 10 years after the claim arose, whichever expires first.

When a claim is discovered

Section 5(1) of Ontario's Act lists four things the claimant must know: that injury, loss or damage occurred; that it was caused or contributed to by an act or omission; that the act or omission was that of the defendant; and that, having regard to the nature of the loss, a proceeding would be an appropriate means to remedy it. The claim is discovered on the earlier of the day the claimant actually knew those things and the day a reasonable person with the claimant's abilities and in its circumstances ought to have known them (s. 5(1)(b)). Section 5(2) presumes knowledge on the day of the act or omission unless the contrary is proved.

The Supreme Court of Canada clarified the level of knowledge required in Grant Thornton LLP v. New Brunswick, 2021 SCC 31. New Brunswick had guaranteed CAD 50 million in loans to a company on the strength of an audit; when the company failed, the province received a draft report from new auditors on 4 February 2011 showing that the financial statements were wrong, but did not sue the original auditors until 23 June 2014.

The Court held that a claim is discovered when the plaintiff has knowledge, actual or constructive, of the material facts from which a plausible inference of the defendant's liability can be drawn. Certainty is not required, nor is knowledge of the precise extent of the loss or of every element of the cause of action. The province's claim was out of time.

IssueOntarioAlberta
Basic period2 years from discovery (s. 4)2 years from when the claimant knew or ought to have known (s. 3(1)(a))
Ultimate period15 years from the act or omission (s. 15(2))10 years after the claim arose (s. 3(1)(b))
Continuous actsUltimate period runs from when the act ceases (s. 15(6)(a))Claim arises when the conduct terminates or the last act occurs (s. 3(3)(a))
Contribution and indemnityDeemed act date is when the first wrongdoer was served (s. 18)2 years from service or later knowledge, subject to the 10-year cap (s. 3(1.1))
Contracting outBusiness agreements may vary or exclude the basic period (s. 22(5))Agreements may expressly extend periods (s. 7(1)); reductions are invalid (s. 7(2))

For businesses, Grant Thornton means that, on discoverability and limitation periods, the clock usually starts earlier than claimants hope. A draft report, an internal audit finding or a credible whistleblower complaint can be enough. Waiting for a final report, a forensic accounting or a regulator's decision before suing is risky unless the facts genuinely did not support a plausible inference of liability until then.

Corporate knowledge, fraud and the attribution problem

Corporations know things through people, so a key question is whose knowledge counts. In Scott v. Golden Oaks Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 32, the trustee in bankruptcy of a company that had been run as a Ponzi scheme sued investors and a recruiter to recover unlawful payments.

The defendants argued that the fraudster's knowledge, as the company's sole officer and shareholder, should be attributed to the company, so that its claims were discovered long before the bankruptcy. The Supreme Court disagreed. Corporate attribution must be applied purposively, contextually and pragmatically, and attributing the fraudster's knowledge would not have promoted the purposes of the Limitations Act, 2002 or the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act. The trustee's claims were not statute-barred.

Wilful concealment also matters for the ultimate period. Under s. 15(4)(c) of Ontario's Act, the 15-year period does not run while the defendant wilfully conceals the loss, its cause or the defendant's role, or wilfully misleads the claimant about whether a proceeding is appropriate. The claimant bears the burden of proving the exception (s. 15(5)).

Continuous acts, series of acts and demand obligations

Many commercial claims involve conduct over time: a long-running overbilling scheme, an ongoing nuisance, or a series of defective deliveries. For the ultimate period, s. 15(6) of Ontario's Act provides that the act or omission takes place, for a continuous act or omission, on the day it ceases; for a series of acts or omissions in respect of the same obligation, on the day the last one occurs; and for a demand obligation, on the first day there is a failure to perform after a demand is made.

The basic two-year period is analysed differently. Each new breach can give rise to a new claim with its own discovery date, but courts look closely at whether the later events are really fresh wrongs or simply continuing consequences of an earlier one. For loans and guarantees, the demand rule means the clock on a demand obligation generally starts only after demand is made and not met, which is why lenders document demands carefully.

Practical point

When a potential claim emerges, diarize the earliest plausible discovery date, not the date you would prefer, and work backwards. If you need more time to investigate or negotiate, put a written tolling agreement in place before that date rather than relying on arguments about when the claim was discovered.

Contribution claims and adding parties

Defendants who want to shift liability to others face their own deadlines. In Ontario, s. 18 deems the act or omission underlying a contribution and indemnity claim to have occurred on the day the first alleged wrongdoer was served with the claim. The two-year period for a third-party claim therefore usually starts on service of the statement of claim, subject to discoverability. Alberta's s. 3(1.1) sets a two-year period running from the later of service of the pleading and the date the claimant first knew or ought to have known of the other party's liability, capped by a 10-year period.

Plaintiffs cannot avoid an expired limitation period by adding a defendant to an existing action: s. 21(1) of Ontario's Act prohibits pursuing a claim against a person by adding them as a party after the limitation period against them has expired, although misnaming or misdescription can be corrected (s. 21(2)). Early investigation of every potentially responsible party, including professionals, insurers and affiliates, is essential.

Tolling agreements and contractual limitation clauses

Parties often want time to negotiate without issuing a claim. Ontario allows this, but within limits set by s. 22:

  • the basic limitation period may be suspended or extended by an agreement made on or after 19 October 2006 (s. 22(3));
  • the 15-year ultimate period may be suspended or extended, but only if the claim has been discovered (s. 22(4));
  • in business agreements, meaning agreements in which no party is a consumer, the basic period may also be varied or excluded, and the ultimate period may be varied, subject to the s. 22(4) rule for suspensions and extensions (s. 22(5)).

A good tolling agreement identifies the claims and parties precisely, states the start and end of the tolling period, preserves defences that existed on the start date, and provides for termination on notice. Contractual clauses that shorten limitation periods, common in supply, technology and construction contracts, are enforceable in business agreements in Ontario if clearly drafted, while Alberta's s. 7(2) invalidates agreements that purport to reduce a statutory limitation period, so such clauses should be checked at the outset of any dispute. Our insight on limitation of liability clauses discusses related drafting.

Illustration: a hypothetical Ontario manufacturer learns from an internal audit in March 2025 that a logistics provider has been overcharging since 2021. It wants to negotiate before suing. Treating March 2025 as the likely discovery date for the earliest overcharges, it signs a tolling agreement in January 2027 suspending the basic period for six months. Without that agreement, its claims for overcharges discovered in March 2025 would have been at risk from March 2027.

Managing discoverability and limitation periods in practice

Because the rules on discoverability and limitation periods turn on what a company knew and when, internal processes matter as much as legal analysis. Companies that rarely miss deadlines tend to follow a few simple disciplines:

  1. Log potential claims centrally. Legal, finance and operations should report audit findings, customer complaints, supplier failures and whistleblower reports to one place, with the date the information arrived.
  2. Assess the discovery date early. For each potential claim, record the earliest date a court might find the claim discovered, applying the plausible-inference standard rather than the date certainty arrived.
  3. Identify all potential defendants. Include affiliates, guarantors, professionals and insurers, because each may have a different discovery date and the rule against adding parties after expiry is strict.
  4. Check contracts. Notice provisions, contractual limitation clauses and dispute-resolution steps can shorten the practical window well below two years.
  5. Toll or issue. If the investigation or negotiation will run close to the deadline, sign a tolling agreement or issue a protective claim.

Discoverability and limitation periods also interact with insurance. Notice requirements under liability and crime policies often run from when the insured first became aware of circumstances, and late notice can jeopardize coverage even where the limitation period against the wrongdoer has not expired. Coordinating legal, insurance and finance timelines avoids that trap. For defendants, the same discipline works in reverse: an early, documented analysis of discoverability and limitation periods can support a summary judgment motion that ends a stale claim at a fraction of the cost of trial.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise companies on discoverability and limitation periods as part of our commercial litigation work, and on related deadlines in class actions. That includes assessing when a claim was discovered, preparing and negotiating tolling and standstill agreements, reviewing contractual limitation clauses, bringing or defending summary judgment motions on limitation grounds, and building investigation timelines that protect claims. Court proceedings in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel, and we work with them where needed. This page is general information rather than legal advice. To review a deadline, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

When does the two-year limitation period start in Ontario?

On the day the claim is discovered under s. 5 of the Limitations Act, 2002: the earlier of the day the claimant actually knew the injury occurred, was caused by the defendant's act or omission and that a proceeding was appropriate, and the day a reasonable person in its circumstances ought to have known those facts.

How much knowledge is needed to discover a claim?

Enough to draw a plausible inference of the defendant's liability. In Grant Thornton LLP v. New Brunswick, 2021 SCC 31, the Supreme Court held that certainty and knowledge of the full extent of the loss are not required. A draft report showing the problem was enough to start the clock.

What is the ultimate limitation period?

It is an outer limit that runs from the act or omission regardless of discovery: 15 years in Ontario under s. 15(2) of the Limitations Act, 2002, and 10 years in Alberta under s. 3(1)(b) of its Limitations Act. Ontario suspends the 15-year period in limited cases, including wilful concealment by the defendant.

Can parties agree to extend a limitation period?

In Ontario, yes. The basic period can be suspended or extended by agreement, and in business agreements it can also be varied or excluded. The 15-year ultimate period can be suspended or extended only once the claim has been discovered. Tolling agreements should be in writing and precise.

When must a defendant bring a third-party claim for contribution?

In Ontario, s. 18 deems the relevant act or omission to occur when the defendant was served with the claim, so the two-year period for contribution and indemnity usually starts on service. In Alberta, the period runs two years from the later of service and knowledge of the other party's liability, subject to a 10-year cap.

Sources

  1. Limitations Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c. 24, Sched. B
  2. Limitations Act, R.S.A. 2000, c. L-12 (Alberta King's Printer)
  3. Grant Thornton LLP v. New Brunswick, 2021 SCC 31 (case in brief)
  4. Scott v. Golden Oaks Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 32 (case in brief)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.