Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Multi-Jurisdictional and Parallel Class Actions in Canada

Multi-jurisdictional class actions are a fact of life for companies operating across Canada. This guide explains national classes and Ontario's 2020 rules for parallel proceedings, carriage motions and stays, Quebec authorization, the judicial protocol and joint hearings after Endean, and how to structure a settlement that binds class members in every province.

Map of Canadian provinces illustrating multi-jurisdictional class actions and parallel proceedings

Key takeaways

  • Ontario's CPA requires courts to consider whether another province is the preferable forum.
  • Ontario carriage motions must be brought within 60 days and are not appealable.
  • Quebec authorization under art. 575 CCP is a separate, low-threshold gate.
  • Judges may sit outside their province for joint hearings (Endean, 2016 SCC 42).
  • National settlements need aligned classes, approvals in each court and robust releases.

Why multi-jurisdictional class actions arise

Multi-jurisdictional class actions arise because Canada has no single national class action court. Class proceedings are governed by provincial legislation, and a product recall, data breach, price-fixing allegation or securities misstatement that affects people across the country can be sued on in several provinces at once, often by different plaintiffs' firms seeking to represent overlapping classes. For defendants, that means duplicated costs, the risk of inconsistent rulings and difficult questions about how to achieve a single, final resolution. For plaintiffs, it means competition for carriage and the challenge of building a class that courts in other provinces will respect.

Map of Canadian provinces illustrating multi-jurisdictional class actions and parallel proceedings
Multi-jurisdictional class actions require coordination across provincial courts, statutes and settlement approvals.

Courts and legislatures have developed tools to manage the problem: statutory rules for national classes and for deferring to proceedings elsewhere, carriage motions, stays, a judicial protocol for cross-border coordination, and joint settlement approval hearings. Quebec, with its own authorization procedure and civil law framework, adds a further layer that defendants must plan for from the outset.

National classes and the statutory framework

Ontario's Class Proceedings Act, 1992 (CPA), as amended in 2020, expressly addresses multi-jurisdictional class actions. It defines a "multi-jurisdictional class proceeding" as one brought on behalf of a class that includes residents of two or more provinces or territories and certified under the Act or the law of another Canadian jurisdiction (s. 1). Where a class proceeding involving the same or similar subject matter and some of the same class members has been commenced elsewhere in Canada, s. 5(6) requires the court to determine whether it would be preferable for some or all of the claims or common issues to be resolved in the other proceeding instead.

Under s. 5(7), the court is guided by the objectives of giving due consideration to the interests of all parties in each jurisdiction, serving the ends of justice, avoiding irreconcilable judgments where possible and promoting judicial economy. It must consider factors including the basis of liability and differences in the applicable laws, the stage each proceeding has reached, the litigation plans and resources of each proceeding, and the location of class members and representative plaintiffs.

Section 5.1 then allows the court, on a motion to certify a multi-jurisdictional class proceeding, to certify it if Ontario is the appropriate venue, to refuse certification because the proceeding should continue elsewhere, or to exclude class members who can be included in a proceeding in another province. It can also create Ontario resident and non-resident subclasses with separate representatives.

British Columbia's Class Proceedings Act contains a parallel requirement: where a class proceeding involving the same or similar subject matter has been commenced elsewhere, the court must determine whether it would be preferable for some or all of the claims or common issues to be resolved there. Several other provinces have adopted similar provisions based on the uniform model legislation.

ToolWherePurpose
Preferable-forum analysisOntario CPA s. 5(6)–(7); BC Class Proceedings Act; similar provisions elsewhereDecide whether claims should proceed in another province's action
Multi-jurisdictional certification ordersOntario CPA s. 5.1Certify national classes, carve out members or create subclasses
Carriage motionOntario CPA s. 13.1 (within 60 days of first proceeding)Choose among competing Ontario actions
Notice to other representative plaintiffsOntario CPA s. 5(4)–(5)Allow parties in other provinces to make submissions at certification
AuthorizationQuebec Code of Civil Procedure, art. 575Gatekeeping test for Quebec class actions
Joint hearings and judicial protocolCourts across CanadaCoordinate certification and settlement approval

Carriage motions and stays

Competing actions within the same province are resolved by carriage motions. In Ontario, s. 13.1 of the CPA provides that a carriage motion must be brought no later than 60 days after the first proceeding was commenced and heard as soon as practicable. The court determines which proceeding would best advance the claims of class members efficiently and cost-effectively, considering each plaintiff's theory of the case and work done to date, the relative likelihood of success, counsel's expertise and experience, and the funding of each proceeding. The decision is final and not subject to appeal (s. 13.1(5)).

Across provinces, the tools are different. A court cannot grant carriage of another province's action, but it can stay its own proceeding, decline to certify a national class, or exclude residents of a province where an action is advancing. Defendants frequently move to stay duplicative actions or ask courts in different provinces to coordinate schedules. Where actions in several provinces are moving at different speeds, defendants must decide whether to fight certification everywhere or to focus on the leading action and seek stays elsewhere.

Practical point

When a national class action is filed, map every related proceeding across Canada and the United States within the first weeks: who filed, where, for which class and at what stage. That map drives the stay, carriage and certification strategy, and early cooperation among defence counsel in different provinces avoids inconsistent positions that plaintiffs can exploit.

Quebec authorization and parallel Quebec actions

Quebec class actions require authorization under art. 575 of the Code of Civil Procedure: the claims must raise identical, similar or related issues; the facts alleged must appear to justify the conclusions sought; the composition of the class must make joinder or mandate impracticable; and the representative must be adequate. Quebec courts have generally treated authorization as a low screening threshold, and actions are often filed in Quebec in parallel with proceedings elsewhere to protect Quebec residents.

Defendants therefore often face a Quebec action covering Quebec residents and a national action in another province that purports to include them. Quebec courts consider whether the other proceeding adequately protects Quebec members, and Quebec's procedural and language rules apply to notices and settlement approvals for Quebec class members. Settlements of multi-jurisdictional class actions usually require approval in Quebec as well as in the common law provinces.

The judicial protocol and joint hearings

To reduce friction, the Canadian Bar Association developed a judicial protocol for the management of multi-jurisdictional class actions, which many courts follow. It encourages notice to other courts and counsel when an overlapping action is filed, communication between case management judges, and joint or simultaneous hearings, particularly for settlement approval. The protocol is guidance rather than law, but courts often refer to it when coordinating.

Joint hearings are constitutionally possible. In Endean v. British Columbia, 2016 SCC 42 (SCC docket 35843), arising from the national hepatitis C settlement, the Supreme Court held that superior court judges may sit outside their home province to hear class action matters, which supports joint hearings in which judges from several provinces sit together. The Court allowed the appeal and restored the order of the British Columbia chambers judge.

Settling multi-jurisdictional class actions

For defendants, the main goal is a settlement that binds as many class members as possible in every relevant province. That requires careful structuring:

  1. Class definitions that align across actions, so that no group is left out or covered twice.
  2. Approval in each court with jurisdiction over a certified or proposed class, usually through coordinated or joint hearings, with consistent notice and opt-out procedures.
  3. Releases and bar orders that extinguish claims against all settling defendants and address claims for contribution by non-settling defendants.
  4. Allocation of the settlement fund among provincial classes, which courts scrutinize to ensure fairness to each group.
  5. Fee approval for class counsel in each jurisdiction, which can become contentious when several firms were involved.
  6. Cross-border coordination with any US class action, including how Canadian residents are treated in the US settlement.

Our insight on class action settlement approval discusses the approval test in more detail, and our data breach class actions insight shows how these issues play out in privacy cases.

Illustration: a hypothetical consumer electronics company faces proposed class actions over a defective battery in Ontario, British Columbia and Quebec, and a US class action. Defence counsel in each province coordinate, the company seeks a stay of a late-filed Saskatchewan action, and the parties negotiate a single settlement with a national class outside Quebec and a separate Quebec class. The settlement is approved at a joint hearing of the Ontario and British Columbia courts, with a parallel Quebec approval hearing, giving the company a release across Canada.

Cross-border and regulatory overlap

Many multi-jurisdictional class actions in Canada shadow proceedings in the United States, and the interaction between the two systems matters for strategy and timing. Canadian residents may be included in, or excluded from, a US class; a US settlement may or may not be recognized in Canada; and discovery obtained in US litigation can surface in Canadian actions. Defendants should decide early whether to pursue a coordinated North American resolution or to resolve the Canadian actions separately, bearing in mind that Canadian courts will scrutinize whether a foreign settlement gave Canadian class members adequate notice and a fair opportunity to opt out before treating it as binding.

Regulatory proceedings also run alongside. Competition Bureau investigations, securities commission enforcement, privacy commissioner findings and product recalls often precede or accompany class actions, and findings in those proceedings can be used by plaintiffs. Statements made to regulators should be prepared with the class actions in mind, and cooperation agreements, such as those under the Competition Bureau's immunity and leniency programs, should be reviewed for their effect on civil exposure.

Limitation periods, which differ by province, add complexity. Class proceedings statutes generally suspend limitation periods for class members while a proposed class proceeding is pending, but the rules on when suspension starts and ends, and which members it covers, are not uniform. A member excluded from a national class by a court in one province may need to rely on a proceeding elsewhere, or on its own claim, to protect its rights.

Finally, insurance and funding shape behaviour on both sides. Defendants should notify liability insurers of every overlapping proceeding, because policies may treat related actions as a single claim subject to one limit. Plaintiffs increasingly use third-party litigation funding, and courts in Ontario consider funding arrangements in carriage and approval decisions. Understanding who is funding each action helps predict how hard it will be pursued, how long it can be sustained and when it may settle.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise companies facing multi-jurisdictional class actions as part of our class actions and commercial litigation work. That includes mapping overlapping proceedings in Canada and the United States, developing stay, carriage and certification strategy, coordinating defence counsel across provinces and in Quebec, structuring national settlements and approval hearings, and managing parallel regulatory inquiries. Court proceedings in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel in each province, and we work alongside them. This page is general information rather than legal advice. To discuss a class proceeding, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Can one Canadian court certify a national class?

Yes. Courts in Ontario, British Columbia and other provinces can certify classes that include residents of other provinces. Ontario's Class Proceedings Act, 1992 now expressly governs multi-jurisdictional class proceedings, and courts consider whether another province is the preferable forum for some or all of the claims.

What is a carriage motion?

It is a motion to decide which of two or more competing class actions in the same province should proceed. In Ontario, s. 13.1 of the Class Proceedings Act, 1992 requires it to be brought within 60 days after the first action is commenced, and the court considers the theory of the case, likelihood of success, counsel's experience and funding.

Do Quebec class actions follow the same rules?

No. Quebec class actions require authorization under art. 575 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which is generally treated as a low threshold. Quebec courts also consider whether proceedings elsewhere protect Quebec residents, and settlements affecting Quebec class members usually need Quebec court approval.

Can judges from different provinces hold a joint hearing?

Yes. In Endean v. British Columbia, 2016 SCC 42, the Supreme Court held that superior court judges may sit outside their home province to hear class action matters. Joint hearings are commonly used for settlement approvals in national class actions.

How can a defendant achieve a national settlement?

By aligning class definitions across actions, obtaining approval from each court with jurisdiction, often at joint or coordinated hearings, and including releases and bar orders that bind class members in every province. Quebec approval and any parallel US settlement must be coordinated.

Sources

  1. Class Proceedings Act, 1992, S.O. 1992, c. 6, ss. 1, 5, 5.1, 13.1
  2. Class Proceedings Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 50
  3. Code of Civil Procedure (Quebec), CQLR c. C-25.01, art. 575
  4. Supreme Court of Canada docket 35843 (Endean v. British Columbia, 2016 SCC 42)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.