Skip to content
Tax

How an Estate Freeze Works in Canada

An estate freeze fixes the value of an owner's interest in a company at today's level so that future growth accrues to the next generation or a family trust. It is a core succession tool in Canada, but the freeze shares, the trust and the follow-up all have to be designed with the tax rules in mind.

Family business owners and adviser discussing an estate freeze and new trust shares

Key takeaways

  • A freeze exchanges common shares for fixed-value preferred shares, usually under s. 86 or s. 85 ITA.
  • New common shares then go to children or a discretionary family trust at nominal value.
  • A price adjustment clause protects against a CRA challenge to the freeze value.
  • TOSI, corporate attribution and the 21-year deemed disposition rule shape the design.
  • Freezes can be refrozen or thawed as values and family circumstances change.
  • Courts will not rescind a completed freeze simply because the tax result was unexpected.

What an estate freeze does

An estate freeze is a reorganization in which the owner of a private company exchanges growth shares, usually common shares, for preferred shares with a fixed redemption value equal to the company's current fair market value. New common shares are then issued, for nominal consideration, to the next generation or to a family trust. From that point, the owner's interest is frozen in value and any future increase in the company's value accrues to the new common shareholders.

Family business owners and adviser discussing an estate freeze and new trust shares
An estate freeze caps the owner's tax exposure at today's value and shifts future growth to the family.

The main objective is to limit the capital gain that will be deemed realized on the owner's death under s. 70(5) of the Income Tax Act (ITA). A freeze also allows an owner to keep control through voting rights, to fund retirement through redemptions of the freeze shares, and to multiply access to the lifetime capital gains exemption where the growth shares are held by a trust. It does not remove tax on the frozen value; it caps it.

An estate freeze is often combined with other succession steps, including shareholder agreements, wills dealing with private company shares, and insurance to fund the eventual tax on the frozen value.

Section 86 and section 85 freezes

There are two main statutory routes. In an internal freeze under s. 86, the owner exchanges all shares of a class held for new preferred shares of the same corporation in the course of a reorganization of capital. If the owner receives no non-share consideration in excess of the paid-up capital and adjusted cost base, the exchange occurs on a tax-deferred basis automatically, without an election. In a s. 85 freeze, the owner transfers shares to a new holding company in exchange for preferred shares of the holding company and files a joint election to set the transfer price.

FeatureSection 86 internal freezeSection 85 holding company freeze
Election requiredNo, automatic if conditions metYes, joint election (Form T2057)
Corporate structureSame operating companyNew holding company above the operating company
FlexibilitySimpler, fewer stepsAllows selective transfer and creditor protection planning
Typical useSingle company with straightforward share structureGroups, or where a holding company is wanted for other reasons

Section 86(2) is the key trap. If the fair market value of the freeze shares and other consideration received is less than the value of the old shares, and it is reasonable to regard the shortfall as a benefit conferred on a related person, the shortfall is treated as proceeds and can create an immediate gain. Getting the value right, and protecting it, is therefore central.

Designing the freeze shares

Freeze shares are usually redeemable and retractable at the frozen value, entitled to a non-cumulative preferential dividend at a fixed maximum rate, and voting where the owner wants to keep control. They should rank ahead of the common shares on a winding-up and carry restrictions that prevent the company from paying dividends on other shares if that would impair the redemption value. These features support the conclusion that the freeze shares are worth their redemption amount.

A price adjustment clause provides that, if the CRA or a court determines a different fair market value, the redemption amount is adjusted to match. The CRA has long accepted these clauses where the parties made a bona fide attempt to value the shares, ideally supported by an independent valuation, and the clause applies to the same extent to everyone affected. A clause is not a substitute for a reasonable valuation.

Practical point

In Canada (Attorney General) v. Collins Family Trust, 2022 SCC 26, the Supreme Court of Canada refused to allow equitable rescission to unwind transactions because of unforeseen tax consequences. If an estate freeze is implemented on the wrong facts or values, the parties cannot count on a court to undo it later. Careful valuation and drafting up front matter more than ever.

Family trusts in an estate freeze

Most freezes issue the new common shares to a discretionary family trust rather than directly to children. The trust lets the owner postpone decisions about which child benefits, protects assets from a child's creditors or matrimonial claims, and allows capital gains to be allocated among several beneficiaries, which can multiply the lifetime capital gains exemption on a sale of qualifying shares.

The trust deed must be drafted to avoid s. 75(2), which can attribute income and gains back to the person who contributed property to the trust if that person can get it back or control who receives it. A trust settled with a gold coin or nominal cash by an unrelated settlor, with beneficiaries who subscribe for shares using their own or borrowed funds, is the usual approach. The trust must also file annual T3 returns with beneficial ownership information.

TOSI and attribution limits

The tax on split income (TOSI) rules in s. 120.4 apply the top marginal rate to dividends paid to family members from a private business unless an exclusion applies. Dividends paid through a family trust to adult children who do not work in the business are often caught. The estate freeze therefore shifts growth but does not automatically allow income to be distributed at low rates.

The corporate attribution rule in s. 74.4 can also apply where an individual transfers property to a corporation and one of the main purposes is to benefit a designated person, such as a spouse or a minor child, who is a specified shareholder. It deems the transferor to receive interest at the prescribed rate unless the corporation is a small business corporation throughout. Freezes that involve minor beneficiaries are commonly structured so that the trust deed prevents minors from benefiting while the company is not a small business corporation.

The 21-year rule, refreezes and thaws

Under s. 104(4), most personal trusts are deemed to dispose of their capital property at fair market value every 21 years. A family trust that holds growth shares after an estate freeze will face a deemed gain on its 21st anniversary unless it distributes the shares to Canadian-resident beneficiaries on a tax-deferred basis under s. 107(2) beforehand. Distributions to non-resident beneficiaries do not qualify for rollover treatment. Planning for the 21-year date should start several years in advance.

A refreeze exchanges the original freeze shares for new freeze shares with a lower value when the company's value has fallen, reducing the owner's eventual tax and allowing growth to be shifted again. A thaw lets the owner participate in future growth again, for example by issuing new common shares to the owner, where the family's needs or the owner's retirement plans have changed. Both steps raise valuation and benefit-conferral questions similar to the original freeze.

Implementation checklist

  1. Obtain a supportable valuation of the company at the freeze date.
  2. Choose between s. 86 and s. 85 and settle the share terms, including the price adjustment clause.
  3. Settle the family trust, choose trustees, and fund the subscription for new shares independently.
  4. Update the shareholder agreement and the owner's wills, including secondary wills where available for private company shares.
  5. Review TOSI, attribution and the s. 75(2) risk for each beneficiary.
  6. Diarize the 21-year date and periodic reviews of the dividend and redemption strategy.

Owners in Quebec need civil law trust and succession advice as well, since the trust is governed by the Civil Code of Québec.

An estate freeze in numbers

Illustration: an owner holds all 100 common shares of an operating company valued at CAD 8 million. Under a s. 86 reorganization, she exchanges them for 8,000,000 preferred shares redeemable at CAD 1 each, with voting rights and a price adjustment clause. A family trust for her spouse and three children subscribes for 100 new common shares at CAD 10 each, funded by a loan from an arm's length lender rather than by the owner.

Ten years later the company is worth CAD 20 million. The owner's preferred shares are still worth CAD 8 million (less any redemptions she has used to fund retirement), so the gain deemed realized on her death is capped by reference to that value. The CAD 12 million of growth belongs to the trust. If the company qualifies for the lifetime capital gains exemption at a later sale, the trust can allocate gains to several beneficiaries, each of whom may claim the exemption. If no sale occurs, the trust must plan for its 21-year deemed disposition.

The same structure also supports governance. Because the owner keeps voting control through the freeze shares, she can continue to run the company while the next generation's economic stake grows. A shareholder agreement among the owner, the trust and any children who later receive shares should set out how directors are appointed, how shares are valued on a death or departure, and how disputes are resolved.

The owner can also redeem freeze shares gradually. Each redemption produces a deemed dividend, which reduces the frozen value and therefore the tax that will fall due on death. Insurance is commonly used to fund the remaining tax on the frozen value.

Cross-border families

Where children or other beneficiaries live outside Canada, an estate freeze needs additional care. Distributions of trust property to non-resident beneficiaries do not benefit from the s. 107(2) rollover, and the trust may need to retain assets or realize gains before the 21-year date. A beneficiary who is a United States person may face US reporting and anti-deferral rules on interests in a Canadian trust or private company. If the owner plans to emigrate, the departure tax in s. 128.1 deems a disposition of most property, including the freeze shares, at fair market value. These issues are best addressed when the freeze is designed, not when a child moves abroad.

Trust residence also matters. A trust is generally resident where its central management and control is exercised, so appointing a trustee who lives abroad, or letting a non-resident beneficiary make the real decisions, can change the trust's tax status. Conversely, a foreign trust with Canadian-resident contributors can be deemed resident in Canada under s. 94. Families should choose trustees with residence in mind and record where trustee meetings and decisions take place. The CRA's 2026 trust reporting guidance also confirms that family trusts must file annual T3 returns with beneficial ownership schedules unless an exception applies.

How TRW & Co helps

We design and document estate freeze transactions for owners of Canadian private companies and international families with Canadian holdings. Our work covers share terms, price adjustment clauses, trust deeds, s. 85 elections, TOSI and attribution review, and long-range planning for the 21-year date. We coordinate with valuators and accountants, and link the freeze to exit planning under the lifetime capital gains exemption and to TOSI analysis. See our private client, trusts and estates practice and our corporate structuring work. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to plan a freeze.

Frequently asked questions

Is an estate freeze taxable when it is done?

Not if it is structured correctly. A s. 86 exchange is automatically tax-deferred if the conditions are met, and a s. 85 transfer is deferred through a joint election. Tax can arise if the freeze shares are worth less than the old shares and a benefit is conferred on a related person, or if non-share consideration exceeds the relevant tax attributes.

Why is a price adjustment clause used?

It adjusts the redemption amount of the freeze shares if the CRA or a court finds a different fair market value. The CRA accepts such clauses where there was a bona fide attempt to determine value. The clause helps avoid an unintended benefit under s. 86(2) or s. 15(1), but it does not replace a proper valuation.

What happens to the family trust after 21 years?

Most personal trusts are deemed to dispose of their capital property at fair market value every 21 years under s. 104(4). To avoid the resulting tax, trusts often distribute shares to Canadian-resident beneficiaries on a rollover basis before the anniversary. Distributions to non-resident beneficiaries do not qualify for the rollover.

Can a freeze be reversed?

Values can be refrozen at a lower level or the freeze can be thawed so the owner shares in growth again, but each step has tax consequences. After Collins Family Trust, 2022 SCC 26, owners should not expect courts to rescind a completed freeze to cure unforeseen tax results.

Does an estate freeze let us pay dividends to family members at low rates?

Usually not on its own. The TOSI rules apply the top marginal rate to many dividends paid to family members from a private business, unless an exclusion applies, such as active involvement in the business or ownership of excluded shares by a beneficiary aged 25 or older.

Sources

  1. Income Tax Act, ss. 70, 74.4, 85, 86, 104, 120.4
  2. Canada (Attorney General) v. Collins Family Trust, 2022 SCC 26
  3. CRA: Trust reporting requirements update for the 2025 taxation year

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.