Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Independent Contractor or Employee? Misclassification Risks

Calling a worker an independent contractor does not make them one. Canadian courts, tribunals and the CRA look at the substance of the relationship, and misclassification can expose a business to notice claims, employment standards orders, unremitted payroll deductions, and, for federally regulated employers, a statutory prohibition with the burden of proof on the employer.

Freelance professional invoicing a client as an independent contractor

Key takeaways

  • Courts apply the Sagaz test: whose business is the worker carrying on?
  • Control, ownership of tools, chance of profit and risk of loss are key factors.
  • Dependent contractors who rely heavily on one client can be entitled to reasonable notice.
  • Misclassification can create liability for CPP, EI, income tax withholding, penalties and interest.
  • The Canada Labour Code prohibits treating employees as non-employees and puts the burden of proof on employers.
  • Contracts help, but the actual working relationship decides status.

Why independent contractor status matters

Businesses engage independent contractors for flexibility and lower fixed costs. Contractors are not entitled to employment standards protections such as minimum wage, overtime, vacation pay and termination pay, and the business does not withhold income tax or pay Canada Pension Plan (CPP) contributions and employment insurance (EI) premiums for them. Those differences explain why misclassification is so costly when it is discovered: the protections and deductions apply retroactively to the true relationship, regardless of the label.

Freelance professional invoicing a client as an independent contractor
Whether a worker is an independent contractor depends on the reality of the relationship, not the contract's label.

Misclassification surfaces in several ways: a worker whose contract ends sues for reasonable notice; a worker files an employment standards complaint for unpaid overtime or vacation pay; the CRA audits payroll or a worker requests a CPP/EI ruling; a workers' compensation board assesses premiums; or a federally regulated employer faces a complaint under the Canada Labour Code. Each forum applies a similar but not identical test.

The Sagaz test

The leading authority is 671122 Ontario Ltd. v. Sagaz Industries Canada Inc., 2001 SCC 59. The Supreme Court held that the central question is whether the person engaged to perform the services is performing them as a person in business on their own account. No single factor is conclusive. Relevant factors include the level of control the business has over the worker's activities, whether the worker provides their own equipment, whether the worker hires helpers, the degree of financial risk the worker takes, the worker's investment and management responsibility, and the worker's opportunity for profit.

FactorPoints toward employeePoints toward independent contractor
ControlBusiness sets hours, methods, supervision and performance reviewsWorker decides how, when and where to do the work
Tools and equipmentProvided by the businessOwned and maintained by the worker
HelpersWorker must perform personallyWorker can hire or substitute others
Financial riskFixed pay regardless of results; expenses reimbursedWorker bears costs and can lose money
Chance of profitLimited to hours workedCan increase profit through efficiency or more clients
IntegrationWorker is part of the core organization and presented as staffWorker serves multiple clients and markets their own business

The parties' intention, expressed in a written contract, is relevant, particularly in tax cases, but it is not decisive if the actual relationship points the other way. A contract stating that the worker is an independent contractor, while the business controls every aspect of the work, will not prevent a finding of employment.

Dependent contractors

Canadian common law recognizes an intermediate category: the dependent contractor. A worker who is not an employee but who is economically dependent on a single business, typically through exclusivity or near-exclusivity over a long period, can be entitled to reasonable notice of termination. The Court of Appeal for Ontario confirmed this category in McKee v. Reid's Heritage Homes Ltd., 2009 ONCA 916. Long-term consultants who work only for one client, often through a personal corporation, are the classic example. Businesses that terminate such relationships without notice can face claims similar to wrongful dismissal claims, even if the worker was properly treated as a contractor for tax purposes.

CPP, EI and income tax exposure

For payroll purposes, the CRA and the Tax Court of Canada apply the same central question as Sagaz, giving weight to the parties' intention where the facts are consistent with it. If a worker is found to be an employee, the business is liable for the employer and employee portions of CPP contributions and EI premiums it failed to remit, together with penalties and interest, and for income tax it failed to withhold, subject to limits. Recovery of the employee portion from the worker after the fact is often impractical. Either the business or the worker can request a ruling from the CRA on status, and decisions can be appealed to the Tax Court.

GST/HST is also affected. Independent contractors above the small-supplier threshold charge GST/HST, while employees do not. Recharacterization can raise questions about input tax credits previously claimed.

The Canada Labour Code prohibition

For federally regulated employers, the Canada Labour Code now includes express rules. Section 167.1 provides that an employer is prohibited from treating an employee as if they were not their employee. Section 167.2 provides that, in proceedings under Part III (other than prosecutions) and related administrative monetary penalty proceedings, if an employer alleges that a person is not its employee, the burden of proof is on the employer. These provisions were enacted by S.C. 2024, c. 17 and apply to contraventions alleged to have occurred on or after royal assent. Banks, telecommunications companies, airlines and trucking companies that rely on owner-operators or contractors should review those arrangements.

Practical point

Federally regulated employers can no longer rely on a worker's inability to prove employment. Under s. 167.2 of the Canada Labour Code, the employer must prove that a worker is not its employee. Keep records showing the commercial nature of each contractor relationship: other clients, invoices, insurance, tools and independence in how work is done.

Platform and gig workers

App-based platforms have tested classification rules. In Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16, the Supreme Court held that an arbitration clause requiring Ontario drivers to arbitrate in the Netherlands was unconscionable, allowing a proposed class action alleging that drivers were employees to proceed. Ontario's Digital Platform Workers' Rights Act, 2022 sets minimum standards for digital platform workers performing ride-share, delivery and courier work, without deciding whether they are employees. British Columbia has introduced its own minimum standards for ride-hail and delivery workers. Platform businesses should monitor these regimes closely.

Employment standards and workers' compensation

Employment standards officers decide status for their own statutes, often applying a broad interpretation consistent with the remedial purpose of the legislation. Workers' compensation boards also have their own tests and can assess premiums for "workers" who would be contractors elsewhere, including some independent operators. A business may therefore win in one forum and lose in another. Consistency in how the relationship is structured and documented reduces the risk of conflicting outcomes.

Practical evidence matters in every forum. Officers and judges look at invoices, emails giving instructions, schedules, access badges, business cards and how the worker was introduced to customers. A relationship that is commercial on paper but treated as employment in daily practice will usually be classified as employment.

Designing genuine independent contractor relationships

  1. Engage the contractor for defined deliverables or projects rather than open-ended roles.
  2. Let the contractor control methods, hours and location, within reasonable project requirements.
  3. Require the contractor to supply tools, insurance and, where appropriate, helpers.
  4. Pay on invoices for deliverables or rates, without employee benefits or expense reimbursement policies.
  5. Allow and expect the contractor to serve other clients.
  6. Avoid integrating contractors into organizational charts, titles, email signatures and performance processes.
  7. Include termination provisions that reflect a commercial relationship, with notice periods suited to any dependency.

Quebec and the Civil Code

In Quebec, the distinction is between a contract of employment under article 2085 of the Civil Code, which involves work under the direction or control of the employer, and a contract of enterprise or for services under article 2098, in which the contractor is free to choose the means of performance and there is no relationship of subordination. Quebec courts focus on subordination, examining integration into the business, control over work methods and schedules, and economic dependence. Quebec's labour standards legislation and the CNESST also have their own approaches, and Revenu Québec rules on status for provincial payroll purposes. A worker's status may therefore need to be assessed separately for Quebec.

Staffing agencies and employers of record

Using a staffing agency or employer of record does not eliminate risk. The agency is usually the legal employer, responsible for payroll and employment standards, but the client can still face claims if it exercises day-to-day control, and in Ontario, clients of temporary help agencies share liability for certain unpaid wages and have reprisal obligations. Where agency workers stay with a client for years, courts may find that the client is a common or true employer. Contracts with agencies should allocate responsibilities clearly and require compliance with employment standards and tax obligations.

Intellectual property and confidentiality for an independent contractor

Ownership of work product is another reason classification matters. Under Canadian copyright law, works made by employees in the course of employment generally belong to the employer, absent agreement to the contrary, while works made by an independent contractor belong to the contractor unless assigned in writing. Patentable inventions raise similar issues. Every contractor agreement should therefore include an express assignment of intellectual property, a waiver of moral rights, and confidentiality obligations. Businesses that have used contractors to build core technology without such terms should fix the gap before a financing or sale, when buyers and investors will check.

Personal service corporations

Many contractors operate through their own corporations. That does not change the employment law analysis, but it has tax consequences. Where an individual provides services through a corporation and would reasonably be regarded as an employee of the client if not for the corporation, the corporation may be carrying on a "personal services business", which loses access to the small business deduction and faces restrictions on deductible expenses. Clients should understand that engaging a worker through a corporation does not, on its own, remove employment law risk, and the worker's corporation may face reassessment if the CRA treats it as a personal services business.

Correcting misclassification

Where an audit shows that workers are likely employees, options include converting them to employment on a go-forward basis, restructuring the relationships to make them genuinely independent, and assessing whether to correct past payroll obligations. Conversion should be handled carefully, since offering employment may be taken as an admission for past periods, and terminating the contractor relationships may trigger dependent contractor claims. The voluntary disclosures program can reduce penalties for past unremitted payroll amounts if the CRA has not yet made contact.

Illustration: a software company engages a developer through her corporation for three years, full time, using company laptops and tools, attending daily stand-ups, with no other clients. If the company ends the arrangement without notice, she may claim reasonable notice as an employee or dependent contractor, and a CRA ruling may treat her as an employee for CPP and EI purposes.

How TRW & Co helps

We help businesses decide when to use an independent contractor, structure and document contractor relationships, audit workforces for misclassification, respond to CRA rulings and employment standards complaints, and defend notice claims. Our employment law practice works with our tax disputes team. See also our insights on federally regulated employers and start-up employment law. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your arrangements.

Frequently asked questions

What is the test for an independent contractor in Canada?

Under 671122 Ontario Ltd. v. Sagaz Industries, 2001 SCC 59, the central question is whether the worker performs services as a person in business on their own account. Courts weigh control, ownership of tools, hiring of helpers, financial risk, investment and opportunity for profit. No single factor decides.

What is a dependent contractor?

A worker who is not an employee but is economically dependent on one business, usually through exclusivity over a long period. Ontario courts, including in McKee v. Reid's Heritage Homes, 2009 ONCA 916, have held that dependent contractors are entitled to reasonable notice of termination.

What happens if the CRA finds a contractor is an employee?

The business can be assessed for unremitted CPP contributions and EI premiums, both employer and employee portions, plus penalties and interest, and for income tax it should have withheld. Rulings can be requested from the CRA and appealed to the Tax Court of Canada.

What changed in the Canada Labour Code?

Section 167.1 prohibits federally regulated employers from treating employees as non-employees, and s. 167.2 places the burden of proving that a person is not an employee on the employer in Part III proceedings other than prosecutions. Both were enacted by S.C. 2024, c. 17.

Does a contractor agreement settle the question?

No. The agreement shows the parties' intention and helps in tax cases, but courts and tribunals look at the real relationship. If the business controls the work like an employer, the label does not prevent a finding of employment.

Sources

  1. 671122 Ontario Ltd. v. Sagaz Industries Canada Inc., 2001 SCC 59
  2. Canada Labour Code, ss. 167.1-167.2
  3. Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.