Majority Voting and Say-on-Pay Under the CBCA
Majority voting has applied to uncontested director elections of CBCA distributing corporations since August 2022. This guide explains the s. 106(3.4) rule, holdover and reappointment limits, TSX majority voting requirements, the for/against form of proxy, and why CBCA say-on-pay and clawback provisions are still not in force.

Key takeaways
- Since 31 August 2022, CBCA nominees in uncontested elections need a majority of votes cast.
- A defeated incumbent may stay for at most 90 days or until a successor is appointed.
- Defeated candidates cannot be reappointed before the next election except in prescribed circumstances.
- TSX policy requires an immediate resignation, a decision within 90 days and acceptance absent exceptional circumstances.
- CBCA say-on-pay (s. 172.4) and clawback disclosure (s. 172.3) remain not in force.
Majority voting under the CBCA: the rule
Since 31 August 2022, the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA) has required majority voting in uncontested director elections of distributing corporations. Under s. 106(3.4) of the CBCA, where there is only one candidate nominated for each board position, each candidate is elected only if the votes cast in their favour represent a majority of the votes cast for and against them by shareholders present or represented by proxy, unless the articles require more. Prescribed classes of distributing corporations can be excluded by regulation.

Before the amendment, Canadian director elections used a plurality system with a "for" or "withhold" choice. A withhold vote was not a vote against, so in an uncontested election a nominee could be elected with a single vote. The TSX responded by requiring listed issuers to adopt majority voting policies, under which a director who received more withhold than for votes had to tender a resignation. The CBCA amendment went further by making majority voting a matter of corporate law for federal distributing corporations: a candidate who fails is simply not elected.
Holdover directors and reappointment limits
The CBCA addresses the "holdover" problem that arises when an incumbent fails to be re-elected. Normally, if directors are not elected, incumbents continue in office until successors are elected (s. 106(6)). Under s. 106(6.1), however, an incumbent who was a candidate in a majority voting election and was not elected may continue in office only until the earlier of the 90th day after the election and the day on which a successor is appointed or elected.
The board also cannot simply reappoint the defeated candidate. Section 106(8.1) provides that an individual who was not elected in such an election is not to be appointed as a director under s. 106(8) or s. 111(1) before the next meeting of shareholders at which directors are to be elected, except in prescribed circumstances. The Canada Business Corporations Regulations set out those circumstances, and boards should check them before assuming a defeated director can be brought back.
| Question | CBCA distributing corporations | TSX requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Source | s. 106(3.4) CBCA (in force 31 August 2022) | TSX Company Manual s. 461.3 and staff guidance |
| Applies to | Uncontested elections of distributing corporations, unless prescribed otherwise | Uncontested elections of TSX-listed issuers, subject to TSX exemptions |
| Effect of failing majority | Not elected | Must immediately tender resignation |
| Holdover | Until the earlier of 90 days or a successor's appointment (s. 106(6.1)) | Board decides on resignation within 90 days |
| Reappointment | Not before next election, except in prescribed circumstances (s. 106(8.1)) | Resignation accepted absent exceptional circumstances |
| Form of proxy | "For" or "against" each nominee | Individual voting for each nominee |
TSX majority voting requirements
For TSX-listed issuers, the exchange's requirement continues to apply alongside, or instead of, corporate law. In TSX Staff Notice 2017-0001 (9 March 2017), the TSX explained its expectations: each director who does not receive a majority of the votes cast must immediately tender a resignation; the board must decide within 90 days after the meeting whether to accept it; and the board must accept the resignation absent exceptional circumstances. The TSX said exceptional circumstances are expected to meet a high threshold, giving examples such as a resignation that would breach legal or contractual board-composition requirements, and stated that a director's tenure, qualifications or contribution are not exceptional circumstances.
For CBCA issuers listed on the TSX, the corporate law rule determines whether the candidate is elected at all, and the TSX policy remains relevant for issuers governed by statutes without a majority voting rule. Issuers incorporated in other jurisdictions should confirm their governing statute and keep their TSX policy current.
Form of proxy: "for" and "against"
Majority voting changed the form of proxy. For CBCA distributing corporations, the form of proxy for uncontested elections must allow holders to vote "for" or "against" each nominee, rather than "for" or "withhold". Securities law originally required a "withhold" option under s. 9.4(6) of National Instrument 51-102, creating a conflict. CSA jurisdictions first issued blanket orders in January 2023, and then amended NI 51-102. As described in the CSA notice of publication dated 19 June 2025, new s. 9.4(6.1) provides that the "withhold" requirement does not apply to a form of proxy for a reporting issuer governed by the CBCA that complies with the relevant CBCA regulation. The notice stated that Ontario's local blanket order would expire on 31 January 2026.
Confirm that the form of proxy, voting instruction form and online voting platform all show "for" and "against" for CBCA issuers in uncontested elections, and that the circular explains the consequence of failing to receive a majority, including the 90-day holdover limit.
Circular disclosure and voting mechanics
The management information circular should explain the voting standard clearly. For CBCA distributing corporations, that means stating that each nominee must receive a majority of the votes cast for and against, describing the 90-day holdover limit and the restriction on reappointment, and explaining how abstentions and broker non-votes are treated. TSX-listed issuers should also describe their resignation policy and how the board will consider any resignation.
Voting mechanics deserve equal care. Transfer agents and intermediaries must configure their systems to show "against" rather than "withhold" for CBCA issuers, while issuers governed by other statutes may still use "withhold". Groups with subsidiaries incorporated in different jurisdictions should check each one separately. After the meeting, the report of voting results should show the votes for and against each nominee, so that shareholders can see how close any election was.
Board succession planning after a failed election
A failed election is no longer a theoretical risk, so nominating committees should plan for it in the same way they plan for unexpected resignations. A practical plan identifies potential candidates for key roles (board chair, audit committee chair, financial expert), confirms which board and committee composition requirements could be breached if a director leaves, and sets out who will lead communications with investors.
The plan should also consider the corporation's other obligations. A director's departure can affect independence requirements under securities law, the audit committee's composition, the resident Canadian director requirement under s. 105(3) of the CBCA, lending covenants that require particular directors, and the terms of investor or shareholder agreements that grant board nomination rights. Mapping those links in advance allows the board to act within the 90-day period rather than react after it ends.
Finally, boards should treat a high "against" vote that falls short of defeat as a warning. A director who wins with a narrow margin may face a stronger campaign the following year, and engagement with the shareholders who voted against can reveal concerns that the board can address before they become a contest.
Say-on-pay and clawback disclosure: status in 2026
Parliament enacted CBCA amendments in 2019 (S.C. 2019, c. 29) that would introduce a mandatory, non-binding say-on-pay vote and new disclosure for "prescribed corporations". Under new s. 172.4, the directors would have to place the corporation's approach to remuneration before shareholders at every annual meeting; shareholders would vote on it; the result would not be binding; and the corporation would disclose the result. New s. 172.3 would require prescribed information on the recovery of incentive benefits (clawbacks) paid to directors and senior management, and s. 172.2 information on the well-being of employees, retirees and pensioners.
As of the CBCA consolidation current to 19 October 2026, these provisions are listed under "Amendments Not in Force". They require an order in council and supporting regulations, including the definition of "prescribed corporation". Some listed issuers already hold voluntary advisory say-on-pay votes in response to investor expectations, and securities law executive compensation disclosure under Form 51-102F6 already requires detailed reporting of pay. Boards should track the federal provisions, but they are not yet mandatory.
Practical implications of majority voting for boards
The CBCA rule has changed the dynamics of director elections. A "vote against" campaign by an activist or a negative recommendation from a proxy adviser can now unseat a director under the CBCA without a dissident slate. Boards should therefore:
- monitor shareholder sentiment on each director, including attendance, overboarding, tenure and committee performance;
- engage with large holders and proxy advisers well before the meeting when concerns are signalled;
- plan for a failed vote, including who will fill any vacancy within the 90-day period and how board committees and quorum will be maintained;
- check that the articles do not require a higher threshold unintentionally; and
- ensure that resident Canadian director and independence requirements can still be met if a director is not elected.
Illustration (hypothetical): At a CBCA issuer's annual meeting, a long-serving audit committee chair receives 45% "for" and 55% "against" after a proxy adviser criticizes the audit process. She is not elected. She may remain in office for up to 90 days or until a successor is appointed, whichever is earlier. The board uses that time to appoint a new independent director with accounting expertise, so that the audit committee remains properly constituted.
Majority voting does not apply to contested elections
The CBCA rule applies only where there is one candidate for each position. In a contested election, such as a proxy contest with a dissident slate, the plurality rule applies, and the candidates with the most votes fill the available seats. Universal proxies and clear voting instructions are particularly important in that setting, because shareholders may be choosing among more candidates than there are seats.
Issuers should also consider how the election will be treated if a dissident withdraws its nominees close to the meeting. If the election becomes uncontested, majority voting will apply, and the circular and proxy should anticipate that scenario.
The distinction also affects settlement negotiations. If a dissident agrees to withdraw in exchange for board seats, the resulting single slate will be elected under the CBCA standard, so the parties should consider whether any agreed nominee might fail to win a majority and what the settlement agreement requires in that event. Drafting a mutual commitment to support the agreed slate, and a mechanism for replacing a nominee who is not elected, avoids uncertainty after the meeting.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise boards, nominating committees and investors on majority voting under the CBCA and TSX rules: reviewing articles, by-laws and majority voting policies, preparing forms of proxy and circular disclosure, planning for failed votes and holdover periods, and tracking the status of CBCA say-on-pay and clawback provisions. We work with Canadian counsel where a provincial licence is required. See also corporate governance and continuous disclosure, and our insights on proxy contests and executive compensation disclosure. To discuss your next meeting, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Does majority voting apply to all CBCA corporations?
No. Section 106(3.4) applies to distributing corporations, other than any prescribed class, in elections where there is only one candidate for each position. Private CBCA corporations and contested elections are not covered, although articles can impose stricter requirements.
What happens to a director who loses a majority vote?
Under the CBCA, the candidate is not elected. An incumbent may remain until the earlier of the 90th day after the election and the appointment or election of a successor, and cannot be reappointed before the next election except in prescribed circumstances.
Is say-on-pay mandatory in Canada?
Not under the CBCA yet. Section 172.4, enacted in 2019, would require a non-binding vote on the approach to remuneration for prescribed corporations, but it is listed under amendments not in force in the consolidation current to 19 October 2026. Many issuers hold voluntary advisory votes.
Do TSX majority voting policies still matter for CBCA issuers?
For CBCA issuers the statute determines whether a nominee is elected, but the TSX requirement continues to apply to listed issuers generally and is particularly important for issuers governed by statutes without a majority voting rule. Policies should be kept consistent with the governing statute.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


