Skip to content
Corporate & M&A

Plan of Arrangement Steps: From Interim Order to Final Order

A plan of arrangement lets a buyer acquire all of a Canadian company in one court-approved transaction. This insight explains each step under CBCA s. 192, OBCA s. 182 and the BCBCA, from the interim order and meeting to dissent, the BCE fairness hearing and the US 3(a)(10) exemption.

Court documents and circular for a plan of arrangement from interim order to final order

Key takeaways

  • CBCA s. 192(3) is available only to a corporation that is not insolvent.
  • Interim orders set the meeting, voting classes, thresholds and dissent procedure.
  • CBCA special resolutions need two-thirds of votes cast; BC articles can set up to three-quarters.
  • BCE, 2008 SCC 69: statutory compliance, good faith, and a fair and reasonable arrangement.
  • Court approval after a fairness hearing supports the s. 3(a)(10) US registration exemption.

Plan of arrangement: the court timeline in brief

A plan of arrangement is the most common way to complete a negotiated acquisition of a Canadian public company. It is a court-supervised corporate procedure: the target applies for an interim order setting the rules for a security holder meeting, holds the meeting and obtains the required approvals, and then returns to court for a final order approving the arrangement as fair and reasonable. Once the final order is made and the articles of arrangement are filed, the arrangement binds every security holder, which allows a buyer to acquire 100% of the target in one step.

Court documents and circular for a plan of arrangement from interim order to final order
From arrangement agreement to interim order, meeting, final order and filing.

This insight walks through each step under s. 192 of the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA), s. 182 of Ontario's Business Corporations Act (OBCA) and the British Columbia Business Corporations Act (BCBCA), including voting thresholds, minority approval under MI 61-101, dissent rights, the fairness hearing and the US securities exemption. For the broader context, see our public M&A and take-over bids page.

Statutory basis for a plan of arrangement

Under s. 192(1) of the CBCA, an "arrangement" includes amendments to the articles, amalgamations, transfers of all or substantially all property, exchanges of securities for property, money or other securities, going-private and squeeze-out transactions, and liquidations, or any combination of them. Section 192(3) allows a corporation that is not insolvent to apply to court for approval where it is "not practicable" to effect a fundamental change of that nature under another provision of the Act. Courts have interpreted the practicability requirement flexibly for acquisitions, because an arrangement achieves in one transaction what would otherwise need several steps.

The court's powers in s. 192(4) include ordering notice, appointing counsel for shareholders, requiring meetings, permitting dissent under s. 190, and approving the arrangement as proposed or amended. Under s. 192(5), the applicant must give the Director appointed under the CBCA notice of any interim or final order application, and the Director may appear. After the final order, articles of arrangement are sent to the Director under s. 192(6); the filing fee is CAD 500 under the CBCA Regulations.

Ontario's s. 182 follows a similar structure. A corporation prepares a statement of the arrangement for shareholder approval, the arrangement is adopted when approved by special resolution of shareholders and of any class entitled to vote separately, and the corporation may then apply for a court order approving it. Under s. 182(5), the court may give advice and directions at any time, including orders on notice, additional meetings or separate votes, dissent under s. 185 and the appointment of counsel. In British Columbia, ss. 288 to 299 of the BCBCA govern arrangements, and s. 291 sets out the court's powers.

Step 1: the arrangement agreement and interim order

The buyer and target first sign an arrangement agreement containing the plan of arrangement as a schedule, deal protections, conditions and covenants to seek the court orders. The target then applies, usually without notice to shareholders, for an interim order. The interim order typically sets the record date and meeting date, approves the form of notice and the management information circular, fixes the required voting thresholds and classes, grants dissent rights, and establishes the procedure for any security holder who wishes to appear at the final hearing.

The CBCA Regulations require notice of a shareholder meeting to be sent not less than 21 days and not more than 60 days before the meeting, and the record date must be fixed within the same range. Courts often adopt or adjust these periods in the interim order. Where convertible securities, options or debt are affected, the interim order also decides whether their holders vote and in which class.

Step 2: circular, meeting and approvals

The management information circular must give security holders enough information to make a reasoned decision: the background to the transaction, the board's recommendation and reasons, any fairness opinion, the special committee process where there are conflicts, tax consequences, dissent rights and the effect of the arrangement on each class. Securities law disclosure requirements apply to reporting issuers, and the circular may be tested at the final hearing if holders complain that it was misleading.

ApprovalThresholdSource
CBCA special resolutionAt least two-thirds of votes castCBCA s. 2(1) "special resolution"; interim order
OBCA arrangementSpecial resolution of shareholders and of each class entitled to vote separatelyOBCA s. 182(3)
BCBCA arrangementSpecial resolution, requiring the special majority set by the articles, between two-thirds and three-quarters of votes cast (two-thirds by default)BCBCA ss. 1, 289
MI 61-101 minority approvalSimple majority of votes cast, excluding interested parties, related parties and joint actorsMI 61-101 Part 8
Other classesAs set by the interim order, often two-thirds for affected classesInterim order

Multilateral Instrument 61-101 adds minority protection where the arrangement is a "business combination", broadly a transaction in which holders' interests can be terminated without their consent and an interested party, such as a related party acquirer or an insider receiving a collateral benefit, is involved.

In those cases the arrangement must also receive minority approval, a majority of the votes cast by holders other than the interested parties, their related parties and joint actors, and a formal valuation may be required where an interested party is acquiring the issuer, subject to exemptions. Where a bidder first acquires shares under a take-over bid, s. 8.2 of MI 61-101 allows shares tendered to the bid to be counted in the second-step vote in prescribed circumstances. See our insight on going-private transactions and MI 61-101.

Step 3: dissent rights

Shareholders who vote against the arrangement and follow the required procedure can demand to be paid the fair value of their shares. Under the CBCA, dissent arises through an order under s. 192(4)(d), which permits dissent under s. 190; under the OBCA, through an order under s. 182(5)(c) permitting dissent under s. 185; and under the BCBCA, under s. 238 and the interim order. Interim orders often modify the statutory procedure, for example by requiring the written objection to be delivered before the meeting.

Dissent rights matter for deal certainty and cost. Buyers commonly include a closing condition that dissent has not been exercised for more than a set percentage of shares, often in the single digits, because dissenting holders are paid fair value determined by the court, which may exceed the deal price, and the payment is usually made in cash.

Practical point

Read the interim order's dissent procedure carefully and describe it clearly in the circular. Dissent notices that miss a deadline or a required step are a common source of disputes, and an unclear description can be raised against the company at the final hearing.

Step 4: the final order and the BCE fairness test

After the meeting, the company returns to court for a final order. In BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, the Supreme Court of Canada held that the applicant must show that the statutory procedures have been complied with, that the application is put forward in good faith, and that the arrangement is fair and reasonable.

To be fair and reasonable, the arrangement must have a valid business purpose and must resolve the objections of those whose legal rights are being arranged in a fair and balanced way. The court does not substitute its business judgment for that of the board or the security holders, and a strong shareholder vote is an important indicator of fairness, although it is not determinative.

In BCE, the Court also held that only holders whose legal rights are being arranged are generally entitled to vote, and that the debentureholders, whose economic interests were affected but whose legal rights were not arranged, were not entitled to a vote. Objecting parties can appear at the final hearing under the procedure set in the interim order. The decision is available from the Supreme Court of Canada.

The section 3(a)(10) exemption for US holders

When a plan of arrangement issues securities to holders in the United States, for example in a share-for-share merger, the issuer usually relies on the exemption in s. 3(a)(10) of the US Securities Act of 1933. As codified in 15 U.S.C. 77c(a)(10), it exempts securities issued in exchange for outstanding securities, claims or property interests where the terms and conditions are approved, "after a hearing upon the fairness of such terms and conditions", by a court or authorized governmental authority, at a hearing all persons to whom securities will be issued have the right to attend.

To rely on it, the interim order provides for notice of the final hearing to all holders and their right to appear, and issuers follow the US Securities and Exchange Commission staff's published guidance on the exemption's conditions when preparing the court materials. This is one reason why a plan of arrangement is preferred over a take-over bid for share consideration deals with US holders.

Timeline and closing

A typical sequence runs: signing of the arrangement agreement; interim order a few weeks later; mailing of the circular at least 21 days before the meeting; the meeting; the final order shortly after; and closing once regulatory conditions, such as Competition Act clearance and Investment Canada Act approval, are satisfied. The final order is usually obtained before regulatory approvals, so the arrangement agreement sets an outside date long enough to obtain them. On closing, the articles of arrangement are filed and the steps in the plan occur in the sequence it prescribes, often within minutes of each other.

Illustration: a hypothetical US acquirer agrees to buy a CBCA-incorporated, TSX-listed target for a mix of cash and acquirer shares. The target obtains an interim order fixing a two-thirds threshold and providing for MI 61-101 minority approval because two officers will receive collateral benefits under retention arrangements. The circular includes a fairness opinion, the special committee's reasons and the dissent procedure. After a strong vote, the court grants the final order applying the BCE test, and the parties rely on s. 3(a)(10) for the acquirer shares issued to US holders. Closing follows Competition Act and Investment Canada Act approvals.

Compared with a take-over bid, a plan of arrangement requires the target board's cooperation, so it is used for friendly deals. In exchange, it offers certainty: a single vote at a two-thirds threshold delivers 100% ownership, without the 105-day bid period, the more-than-50% minimum tender condition or a second-step squeeze-out. It also accommodates complex consideration, pre-closing reorganizations, treatment of options and convertible securities, and tax elections in one integrated set of steps. A take-over bid remains the route for unsolicited offers, or where the buyer wants to start acquiring shares before a meeting can be held.

A plan of arrangement is also used for solvent restructurings of debt; see our insight on CBCA restructurings and solvent arrangements, and our mergers and acquisitions page.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise acquirers, targets, special committees and investors on each step of a plan of arrangement: arrangement agreements and deal protections, interim order applications, circulars and MI 61-101 compliance, dissent procedures, final order hearings and US exemption planning. We coordinate with counsel licensed in the relevant province for court appearances where required. This insight is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a transaction, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What approval does a plan of arrangement need?

Usually a special resolution, two-thirds of votes cast under the CBCA, plus any class votes and thresholds set in the interim order. Under the BCBCA, the special majority is between two-thirds and three-quarters as set by the articles. If MI 61-101 applies, minority approval excluding interested parties is also required.

What is an interim order?

An order the court makes at the start of the process, usually on the company's application without notice to shareholders. It sets the meeting and record dates, approves the notice and circular, fixes voting classes and thresholds, grants or modifies dissent rights and sets the procedure for objecting holders to appear at the final hearing.

What test does the court apply at the final hearing?

Under BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, the applicant must show statutory compliance, good faith, and that the arrangement is fair and reasonable. That requires a valid business purpose and a fair and balanced resolution of objections by those whose legal rights are being arranged.

Can shareholders dissent from an arrangement?

Yes, if the interim order permits it, as it usually does. Dissenting shareholders who follow the procedure are entitled to be paid the fair value of their shares. Under the CBCA, dissent applies through an order under s. 192(4)(d) and s. 190; under the OBCA, through s. 182(5)(c) and s. 185.

Why is a plan of arrangement useful for deals with US shareholders?

Court approval after a fairness hearing at which all holders may appear allows the issuer to rely on s. 3(a)(10) of the US Securities Act of 1933 for securities issued in the exchange, avoiding US registration. The interim order and court materials must be designed to meet the conditions.

Sources

  1. Canada Business Corporations Act, ss. 190, 192
  2. Ontario Business Corporations Act, ss. 182, 185
  3. BC Business Corporations Act, ss. 238, 288-291
  4. OSC: MI 61-101 Protection of Minority Security Holders (unofficial consolidation)
  5. BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69
  6. 15 U.S.C. 77c(a)(10) (govinfo)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.