Property Controls Under the Competition Act
Property controls, such as lease exclusivity clauses and restrictive covenants on land, can now be challenged under s. 90.1 of the Competition Act even when the parties are not competitors. Since 15 December 2024, a significant anti-competitive purpose plus substantial effects is enough. This note explains the amendments, penalties, private access and how to draft safer controls.

Key takeaways
- Section 90.1(1.01) reaches non-competitor agreements with a significant anti-competitive purpose.
- The change applied from 15 December 2024, one year after royal assent.
- AMPs can reach the greater of CAD 10 million and three times the benefit or 3% of revenues.
- Private parties can seek Tribunal leave to challenge agreements since 20 June 2025.
- Narrow, time-limited controls tied to a tenant's investment are more defensible.
What property controls are and why the law changed
Property controls are restrictions that limit how real estate can be used, usually to keep a competitor out. They take two main forms: exclusivity clauses in commercial leases, which prevent a landlord from leasing other space in a shopping centre to a competitor of the tenant, and restrictive covenants registered on title when land is sold, which prevent the buyer from using the land for a competing business, sometimes for decades. Property controls have long been common in retail, especially grocery, pharmacy and fuel. Many are legitimate: a tenant that anchors a shopping centre may reasonably insist that the landlord not lease next door to its direct rival. But some are designed mainly to block entry, and in concentrated local markets they can reduce choice and raise prices.

Until recently, the civil provision on anti-competitive agreements in s. 90.1 of the Competition Act applied only to agreements between competitors. A grocer's restrictive covenant on land sold to a developer, or an exclusivity clause agreed with a landlord, was usually not an agreement between competitors, so it fell outside that provision. Amendments made in 2023 changed that, and amendments in 2024 added penalties and private access. This note explains the new rules, how they apply to leases and land sales, and how to draft property controls that are less likely to be challenged.
The section 90.1 amendments
New s. 90.1(1.01) provides that if the Competition Tribunal finds that "a significant purpose" of an agreement or arrangement, or any part of it, is to prevent or lessen competition in any market, it may make an order under s. 90.1(1) even if none of the parties are competitors. The Bureau's guide to the December 2023 amendments explains that the provision now applies to agreements that are not between competitors if a significant purpose of the agreement is to harm competition and the agreement has the effect of preventing or lessening competition substantially, and that this change came into force on 15 December 2024, one year after royal assent.
The June 2024 amendments then strengthened s. 90.1 generally. According to the Bureau's guide to those amendments, the provision now covers past agreements going back up to three years, the Tribunal can impose monetary penalties and order steps to restore competition, and private parties can apply directly to the Tribunal with leave, a change that took effect on 20 June 2025.
| Element | Before | Now |
|---|---|---|
| Who must be party to the agreement | Two or more competitors | Competitors, or non-competitors where a significant purpose is to prevent or lessen competition (s. 90.1(1.01)) |
| Effects test | Substantial prevention or lessening | Same |
| Remedies | Prohibition orders; other action by consent | Prohibition orders; orders to restore competition (s. 90.1(1.1)); AMPs |
| Penalties | None under s. 90.1 | Greater of CAD 10M (15M subsequent) and 3x benefit or 3% of worldwide revenues (s. 90.1(1.3)) |
| Who can apply | Commissioner only | Commissioner, or private party with Tribunal leave (s. 103.1) |
Lease exclusivity clauses
Exclusivity clauses in commercial leases are the most common property controls. They typically prohibit the landlord from leasing any other premises in the centre for a specified competing use, sometimes extending to adjacent properties the landlord owns. Under the amended s. 90.1, an exclusivity clause can be reviewed if a significant purpose is to prevent or lessen competition and it has, or is likely to have, that effect substantially in a relevant market.
Factors that tend to make exclusivity clauses more defensible include a clear link to the tenant's investment (for example, an anchor tenant whose presence draws traffic to the centre), a defined and narrow scope of restricted uses, a limited geographic reach, a duration tied to the tenant's actual occupancy, and a market with many alternative sites. Factors that raise concern include clauses that survive after the tenant leaves or ceases to operate (so-called "go-dark" situations), broad definitions that catch any business selling overlapping products, extensions to neighbouring properties and a pattern of similar clauses across a region.
Restrictive covenants on land sales
When a retailer sells or closes a store, it may register a restrictive covenant preventing the property from being used for a competing business. Such covenants can last for many years and bind successive owners. They are the clearest example of a property control that can serve no purpose other than limiting competition, particularly where the retailer no longer operates nearby, which is why they were a focus of the policy debate that led to the amendments.
Under s. 90.1(1.01), a covenant whose significant purpose is to keep a competitor off the land, and which substantially lessens competition in a local market, can be the subject of an order prohibiting enforcement, and potentially a monetary penalty. Owners of land encumbered by such covenants, and competitors seeking sites, may also consider private applications with leave.
Restrictive covenants also raise property-law questions that sit alongside competition law. Provincial land titles systems and common-law rules on the enforceability of covenants, including whether a covenant benefits identifiable land and whether it is too broad or uncertain, can independently limit enforcement. In some provinces, owners can apply to court to modify or discharge obsolete covenants. A party seeking to remove a covenant may therefore have both a competition-law route and a property-law route, and the two can reinforce each other.
Inventory your portfolio of exclusivity clauses and restrictive covenants. For each, record the legitimate purpose, the scope, the duration and whether you still operate nearby. Release or narrow controls you cannot justify, especially covenants on sites you have left. A documented review is strong evidence that remaining controls serve legitimate purposes.
How a challenge would be assessed
An application under s. 90.1 involving property controls would require the applicant to establish two things. The first is purpose: that a significant purpose of the agreement, or of the relevant clause, is to prevent or lessen competition. Purpose can be inferred from the terms themselves, the circumstances in which they were negotiated and internal documents. A covenant imposed by a departing grocer on the sale of its own former store, with no continuing business reason, tells its own story. An exclusivity clause negotiated by an anchor tenant as a condition of committing to a new centre, limited to its own category and its own occupancy, tells a different one.
The second is effect: that the agreement prevents or lessens competition substantially in a market. That requires defining the relevant product and geographic market, often a local one for retail, and showing that the control materially impedes entry or expansion. A single exclusivity clause in a centre surrounded by other available sites may have little effect; a network of controls covering most suitable sites in a town may have a substantial one. The Tribunal may consider factors such as barriers to entry, the availability of substitutes and the extent of remaining competition, which are listed in s. 90.1(2).
If both elements are proved, the Tribunal can prohibit enforcement of the control, order other steps by consent, impose an administrative monetary penalty and, in private applications, order payments to affected persons up to the value of the benefit derived (s. 90.1(10.1)).
What about existing controls?
Many property controls in force today were agreed long before the amendments. The statute does not grandfather them: an existing exclusivity clause or covenant that continues to operate is an agreement the Tribunal can examine, and the June 2024 amendments extend s. 90.1 to agreements that ended within the previous three years. Parties should not assume that an old covenant is safe because it predates the law. At the same time, applying the significant purpose test to clauses negotiated decades ago will depend heavily on the circumstances, and controls that still serve a legitimate purpose remain defensible. The practical response is a portfolio review that identifies which controls still matter commercially, which can be narrowed and which should simply be released.
Grocery, pharmacy and retail focus
Property controls in the grocery sector have attracted particular public and regulatory attention in Canada, because food retail is concentrated in many local markets and new entrants need suitable sites. The policy rationale for the 2023 amendment was to give the Bureau a tool to address controls that prevent entry by competing grocers and other retailers. Pharmacies, fuel retailers, fitness centres and restaurants also commonly use exclusivity clauses and covenants. Landlords and developers should expect tenants, competitors and the Bureau to look more closely at these clauses than in the past, and should not assume that a clause is enforceable simply because it has been accepted in the market for years.
Drafting safer property controls
- Tie the restriction to a legitimate interest, such as the tenant's investment in a site, and say so in the lease.
- Define restricted uses narrowly, by primary business rather than any overlap in products.
- Limit geography to the centre or immediately adjacent property the landlord controls.
- Limit duration to the tenant's actual operation, with automatic termination if it goes dark or leaves.
- Avoid perpetual covenants on land sales; use short terms with clear expiry.
- Review portfolios regularly and release controls that no longer serve a purpose.
- Consider local market conditions, especially where the tenant or covenant holder has a high share.
- Keep records of the business reasons for each control at the time it is negotiated.
Property controls for landlords, lenders and investors
Landlords, REITs and lenders are directly affected. A landlord that agrees to an exclusivity clause is party to the agreement and may face an order, even if the tenant drafted the clause. Purchasers of shopping centres and land should diligence existing exclusivity clauses and registered covenants, both for their effect on leasing flexibility and for competition law risk. Lenders valuing retail properties should consider whether controls could be unenforceable, which may increase leasing options, or whether the property carries litigation risk. Our notes on tenant insolvency and private access to the Competition Tribunal cover related issues.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise retailers, landlords, REITs, developers, lenders and investors on property controls under the amended Competition Act. Our work includes portfolio reviews of exclusivity clauses and restrictive covenants, drafting of defensible restrictions, transaction diligence, releases and amendments, and responses to Bureau inquiries or private applications. We work with Canadian real estate counsel for title registration steps. See our pages on civil competition provisions and commercial real estate. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss your property controls, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What are property controls?
They are restrictions on the use of real estate that limit competition, mainly exclusivity clauses in commercial leases that stop a landlord from leasing to a tenant's competitor, and restrictive covenants registered on land that prevent a buyer from operating a competing business. They are common in grocery, pharmacy and other retail sectors.
How does the Competition Act now apply to property controls?
Since 15 December 2024, s. 90.1(1.01) allows the Competition Tribunal to make orders against agreements between non-competitors where a significant purpose is to prevent or lessen competition and the agreement substantially prevents or lessens competition. Landlord-tenant exclusivity clauses and covenants on land sales can therefore be reviewed.
Can private parties challenge a restrictive covenant?
Yes, with leave of the Competition Tribunal. Since the June 2024 amendments took effect in June 2025, private parties can seek leave under s. 103.1 to apply under s. 90.1, and the Tribunal may order payments to affected persons as well as prohibition orders.
What penalties apply?
Under s. 90.1(1.3), the Tribunal can impose an administrative monetary penalty of up to the greater of CAD 10 million (CAD 15 million for subsequent orders) and three times the benefit derived, or 3% of annual worldwide gross revenues if the benefit cannot reasonably be determined.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


