Tenant Insolvency: Landlord Rights in Canadian Proceedings
A tenant insolvency suspends a landlord's usual remedies. Tenants can disclaim leases under BIA s. 65.2 or CCAA s. 32, assign them over objection with cures, and in bankruptcy the landlord's preferred claim is limited to three months' arrears and up to three months' accelerated rent. Letters of credit and fast action make the difference.

Key takeaways
- CCAA s. 34(2) bars termination of a lease merely because of filing, insolvency or pre-filing arrears.
- Tenants may disclaim leases on 30 days' notice; landlords have 15 days to challenge.
- In bankruptcy, landlords have a preferred claim for 3 months' arrears and up to 3 months' accelerated rent.
- Courts may assign leases over objection if monetary defaults are cured.
- Standby letters of credit remain drawable despite the tenant's insolvency.
Landlord rights when a tenant files
Tenant insolvency changes a commercial landlord's rights overnight. Once a tenant files a notice of intention or proposal under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), obtains an initial order under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) or goes bankrupt, a statutory stay stops the landlord from terminating the lease for pre-filing defaults, distraining for rent or suing for arrears. The tenant may then disclaim the lease, keep it, or assign it to a buyer over the landlord's objection. What the landlord recovers depends on which proceeding the tenant chose, the terms of the lease and how quickly the landlord acts.

This note explains the main rules for commercial landlords: disclaimer of leases under BIA s. 65.2 and CCAA s. 32, the three-month preferred claim and accelerated rent in bankruptcy, assignment over objection, limits on distraint, security deposits and letters of credit, and lessons from retail restructurings.
The stay and ipso facto protection
The first effect of a tenant's filing is the stay of proceedings. In a CCAA case, s. 34(2) provides that a lessor may not terminate or amend a lease by reason only that proceedings commenced, that the tenant is insolvent or that the tenant has not paid rent for a period before the filing. Similar protections apply in BIA proposals. Lease clauses that make insolvency or filing an event of default ("ipso facto" clauses) are therefore unenforceable while the stay is in place.
The stay does not oblige the landlord to provide free occupancy. Under s. 11.01 of the CCAA, no order can prohibit a person from requiring immediate payment for the use of leased property provided after the order, and in practice initial orders require tenants to pay post-filing rent, usually monthly or twice monthly in advance. A landlord that is not being paid in full and on time for post-filing occupancy should raise the issue promptly with the monitor or proposal trustee and, if needed, the court.
Disclaimer of leases in proposals and CCAA cases
An insolvent tenant can shed unprofitable leases. In BIA proposals, s. 65.2 allows a commercial tenant to disclaim a lease of real property on 30 days' notice to the landlord, at any time between the notice of intention and the filing of the proposal, or on the filing of the proposal. The landlord has 15 days to apply to court to set aside the disclaimer, but the court must uphold it if the tenant could not make a viable proposal without disclaiming that lease and the others it has disclaimed (s. 65.2(3)).
In CCAA proceedings, s. 32 allows the debtor to disclaim any agreement, including a lease, on notice to the counterparty and the monitor, if the monitor approves; without monitor approval, the debtor must apply to court. The landlord may apply within 15 days to prevent the disclaimer, and the court considers whether the monitor approved, whether the disclaimer would enhance the prospects of a viable plan and whether it would likely cause significant financial hardship to the landlord (s. 32(4)). The disclaimer takes effect 30 days after notice unless the court sets a later date. The landlord then has a provable claim for its losses (s. 32(7)).
| Issue | BIA proposal | CCAA | Bankruptcy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Disclaimer of lease | s. 65.2: 30 days' notice; landlord may challenge within 15 days | s. 32: with monitor approval or court order; 30 days' notice | Trustee may disclaim or retain under provincial law and lease terms |
| Landlord's claim after disclaimer | As the proposal provides: actual losses, or lesser of first year's rent plus 15% of remainder and three years' rent (s. 65.2(4)) | Provable claim for losses (s. 32(7)); usually compromised under the plan | Preferred claim for 3 months' arrears and up to 3 months' accelerated rent, capped by realization from property on premises (s. 136(1)(f)) |
| Termination for insolvency | Stayed | Prohibited (s. 34(2)) | Governed by provincial law, subject to BIA |
| Assignment over objection | Court order possible | s. 11.3, with cure of monetary defaults | s. 84.1, with cure of monetary defaults |
The three-month priority and accelerated rent in bankruptcy
If a tenant goes bankrupt, the landlord's rights are determined by the law of the province where the premises are located, subject to the BIA's priority rules (s. 146). The landlord has a preferred claim under s. 136(1)(f) for arrears of rent for the three months immediately before the bankruptcy and for accelerated rent for up to three months after the bankruptcy, if the lease provides for acceleration. The total preferred claim cannot exceed the realization from the property on the leased premises, and any accelerated rent paid is credited against occupation rent the trustee owes. Rent beyond these limits is an unsecured claim.
The trustee may occupy the premises for a period to realize assets, paying occupation rent, and may then disclaim or retain the lease in accordance with provincial law. Provincial commercial tenancy statutes, such as Ontario's, set out how long a trustee has to elect and what rent is payable meanwhile, so landlords should check the provincial rules for each site. In Ontario, the Commercial Tenancies Act contains specific provisions on the landlord's position when a tenant becomes bankrupt or makes an assignment for the benefit of creditors, including the trustee's ability to retain the premises and the rent payable while it does so. Similar statutes exist in other common-law provinces, and Quebec applies the Civil Code's rules on leases alongside the BIA.
Assignment of leases over the landlord's objection
Valuable leases can be sold. In a CCAA case, s. 11.3 lets the court assign the debtor's rights and obligations under an agreement to a willing assignee, even if the lease requires the landlord's consent. The court considers whether the monitor approved, whether the assignee can perform the obligations and whether assignment is appropriate, and it may not make the order unless monetary defaults (other than those arising only from insolvency, the filing or a failure to perform a non-monetary obligation) will be cured by a fixed date (s. 11.3(4)). Section 84.1 of the BIA gives trustees a similar power in bankruptcy.
Landlords opposing an assignment usually focus on the assignee's covenant strength, its proposed use, co-tenancy and radius issues in shopping centres, and whether the cure amount includes all arrears. Courts expect evidence, not assertions or generic concerns about change, so landlords should gather financial information about the assignee and explain concretely why the assignment would harm the property.
Distraint, deposits and letters of credit
The stay prevents a landlord from distraining for pre-filing rent, and in bankruptcy, property under seizure for rent must be delivered to the trustee on production of the bankruptcy order, subject to payment of distress costs (s. 73(4)). Landlords that distrained shortly before a filing may have to return the goods.
Security deposits and letters of credit are more reliable protection. A cash deposit held by the landlord under the lease may be applied according to the lease terms, although courts may scrutinize application during a stay, and the landlord should confirm whether the deposit is held in trust or as a general debt. A standby letter of credit from a bank is independent of the tenant's insolvency: the landlord can draw on it according to its terms, because the bank's obligation is its own. That is why landlords of retail and office space increasingly ask for letters of credit rather than cash deposits for weaker covenants.
When a tenant insolvency is announced, calendar the 15-day window to challenge a disclaimer under BIA s. 65.2 or CCAA s. 32, and check whether any letter of credit expires during the stay. Missing either deadline can forfeit the landlord's best remedies.
Guarantees, indemnities and tenant insolvency claims
A tenant insolvency does not automatically release guarantors or indemnitors. A parent company, franchisor or principal that guaranteed the lease remains liable according to the guarantee, unless the guarantor is itself in proceedings, the guarantee contains limits, or a court-approved plan validly releases the guarantor. Landlords should read the guarantee carefully: some are expressed to survive disclaimer or termination of the lease and to cover the full rent for the remaining term, while others are limited to arrears or to a fixed period. Courts generally enforce guarantees that clearly survive the tenant's disclaimer, because the guarantor's obligation is independent of the tenant's statutory right to disclaim.
Third-party releases in CCAA plans are an important exception to watch. Plans sometimes propose to release parent companies or principals that contribute value to the restructuring. Landlords with valuable guarantees should object early if a plan would release their guarantor without adequate compensation, and should ensure the claims process allows them to prove both the tenant claim and any separate claim against a co-applicant guarantor.
Valuing the landlord's claim is the other key task. For a disclaimed lease, the claim generally reflects unpaid rent plus damages for the remaining term, reduced by the landlord's duty to mitigate by re-letting. In BIA proposals, the formula in s. 65.2(4) may cap the claim, and in bankruptcy only part of the claim is preferred. Landlords should prepare a credible re-letting analysis, including incentives and downtime, because monitors and trustees will test the assumptions.
Retail restructurings and tenant insolvency strategy
Retail restructurings show how these rules play out. Tenants with large store networks typically file under the CCAA, close underperforming stores through liquidation sales approved by the court, disclaim those leases and seek to sell the remaining leases to buyers. Landlords negotiate liquidation sale guidelines (hours, signage, duration, removal of fixtures), seek payment of post-filing rent and deal with the claims process for disclaimed leases, where their losses are often compromised under the plan.
For landlords facing a tenant insolvency, the practical priorities are: register for service and monitor the case website; review the lease for guarantees, indemnities and letter of credit rights; track post-filing rent; challenge disclaimers that are unnecessary; and value claims carefully, including mitigation by re-letting. Our notes on supplier rights and distressed real estate address related issues.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise commercial landlords, REITs, tenants and purchasers of lease portfolios on tenant insolvency in Canada. Our work includes responding to disclaimers and assignment motions, negotiating liquidation sale terms, enforcing letters of credit and guarantees, preparing proofs of claim and lease amendments with distressed tenants. We work with Canadian real estate and litigation counsel where needed. See our pages on commercial real estate and CCAA restructuring, and our page for real estate and REITs. This is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a tenant insolvency, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Can a landlord terminate a lease when a tenant files under the CCAA?
Not merely because of the filing, the tenant's insolvency or unpaid pre-filing rent. Section 34(2) of the CCAA prohibits termination or amendment on those grounds. The landlord can insist on payment of post-filing rent, and may seek relief from the court if the tenant fails to pay for ongoing occupancy.
What can a landlord claim if a lease is disclaimed in a BIA proposal?
The landlord has no claim for accelerated rent. The proposal must say whether the landlord may claim its actual losses or a formula amount equal to the lesser of the first year's rent after disclaimer plus 15% of the remaining rent, and three years' rent. The landlord then files a proof of claim accordingly.
What priority does a landlord have in a tenant's bankruptcy?
Under s. 136(1)(f) of the BIA, a preferred claim for three months' rent arrears before the bankruptcy and up to three months' accelerated rent after it, if the lease provides for acceleration, capped at the realization from property on the premises. Other rent claims are unsecured.
Can a court force a landlord to accept an assignee?
Yes. Under s. 11.3 of the CCAA, or s. 84.1 of the BIA in bankruptcy, the court can assign a lease to a willing assignee despite a consent requirement, considering whether the assignee can perform. Monetary defaults, other than those arising from insolvency or the filing, must be cured by a date the court fixes.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


