Drafting Enforceable Termination Clauses in Canada
Well-drafted termination clauses can limit an employee's entitlement on dismissal to statutory minimums or a defined formula, saving employers months of pay. Poorly drafted clauses are struck out entirely, exposing the employer to common law reasonable notice. Ontario courts in particular have become strict, so every clause needs to be checked against current case law.

Key takeaways
- Without an enforceable clause, non-unionized employees are entitled to reasonable notice at common law.
- A clause that could breach employment standards minimums in any scenario is void.
- Under Waksdale, 2020 ONCA 391, an illegal just-cause clause can invalidate a valid without-cause clause.
- Clauses must preserve benefits continuation and all statutory entitlements during the notice period.
- Wording giving the employer a right to terminate at any time in its sole discretion has been attacked.
- Quebec employees cannot waive their right to reasonable notice in advance.
Why termination clauses matter
Canadian employment law gives non-unionized employees an implied right to reasonable notice of termination without cause, unless the employment contract clearly limits it. Common law reasonable notice can reach 24 months or more for long-service senior employees. Termination clauses that limit entitlements to the minimums in employment standards legislation, or to a defined formula, are therefore among the most valuable provisions in an employment agreement. The catch is that courts read termination clauses strictly against employers, and a single defect can void the whole clause.

The leading principles come from the Supreme Court of Canada. In Machtinger v. HOJ Industries Ltd., [1992] 1 SCR 986, the Court held that a clause providing less than the statutory minimum is void, and the presumption of reasonable notice then applies, rather than the statutory minimum. Courts apply the same logic to clauses that could, in some circumstances, produce a breach of employment standards, even if the employer would in fact pay more.
Provincial employment standards statutes set the floor. In Ontario, the Employment Standards Act, 2000 (ESA) requires termination notice or pay in lieu of up to eight weeks, continuation of benefits during the statutory notice period, and severance pay of up to 26 weeks for employees with five or more years of service where the employer's payroll is at least CAD 2.5 million. Other provinces have their own minimums. Termination clauses must respect all of them.
Waksdale and reading the contract as a whole
In Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, the Court of Appeal for Ontario held that an employment contract's termination provisions must be read as a whole. The employee was dismissed without cause, and the without-cause clause on its own complied with the ESA. But a separate "for cause" clause allowed termination without notice for conduct that did not meet the ESA's higher standard of wilful misconduct. Because the termination provisions together could breach the ESA, the court held that both were unenforceable. The employer was unable to rely on the without-cause clause, even though it had not dismissed for cause.
Waksdale also held that a severability clause cannot save an illegal termination provision. Severability clauses still have a role elsewhere in a contract, but they will not rescue termination clauses that offend the ESA. Following Waksdale, Ontario courts routinely scrutinize every provision dealing with termination, including probation clauses, resignation provisions and clauses in bonus or equity plans.
Just cause wording that exceeds the ESA
The common law test for just cause, discussed in our insight on just cause, is not the same as the ESA's exemption from termination and severance pay. Under the Ontario regulations, an employee loses statutory entitlements only for wilful misconduct, disobedience or wilful neglect of duty that is not trivial and has not been condoned. Careless or incompetent conduct can amount to common law cause without being wilful. A clause that says the employer may terminate "for cause" without notice or pay, and defines cause broadly, can therefore deny ESA entitlements in some cases, which is fatal under Waksdale.
The safe approach is to provide that, on termination for cause, the employee will receive any minimum entitlements required by the ESA, or to define the cause that removes all entitlements by reference to the ESA standard. Drafting should avoid lists of examples that include conduct falling short of wilful misconduct.
Common reasons termination clauses fail
| Defect | Why it fails | Safer approach |
|---|---|---|
| Cause clause broader than ESA wilful misconduct | Could deny statutory entitlements | Preserve ESA entitlements on termination for cause |
| No benefits continuation during statutory notice | ESA requires benefit continuation | Expressly continue benefits as required by the ESA |
| Pay limited to "base salary" | ESA termination pay includes regular wages and some other amounts | Provide all amounts required by the ESA |
| No reference to severance pay where it applies | Could exclude statutory severance | Provide severance pay where required |
| "At any time" in the employer's "sole discretion" | Courts have read this as permitting termination in breach of ESA protections | Avoid absolute discretion language; make the clause subject to the ESA |
| Ambiguity | Interpreted in the employee's favour | Plain, specific language |
In Wood v. Fred Deeley Imports Ltd., 2017 ONCA 158, the Court of Appeal struck a clause that did not clearly provide for benefits continuation and severance pay, emphasizing that termination clauses are interpreted in favour of employees because of the power imbalance and the remedial purpose of the ESA. Later decisions, including a 2024 Ontario Superior Court ruling on "at any time" and "sole discretion" language, have extended scrutiny to wording that many employers had used for years.
Drafting enforceable termination clauses
- Provide on termination without cause at least the ESA notice or pay, benefits continuation and severance pay, and say so expressly.
- If offering more than the minimum, state the formula clearly and confirm that ESA entitlements are included, not in addition.
- Avoid unrestricted employer discretion over termination timing or the way notice is given.
- Align the cause provision with the ESA standard or preserve statutory entitlements on cause termination.
- Check probation, resignation, layoff and change-of-control provisions for consistency.
- Review incentive and equity plan termination language at the same time.
Termination clauses must be agreed when the employee is hired, or supported by fresh consideration if introduced later. A clause in a contract signed after the employee has started work, with no new benefit given in exchange, may be unenforceable for lack of consideration, regardless of how well it is drafted.
Probation, fixed terms and protected leaves
Probation clauses deserve the same care. In Ontario, the ESA's notice requirements do not apply during the first three months of employment, but a contractual probation period longer than three months does not extend that exemption. A clause that allows termination without notice "at any time during probation", where probation runs for six months, may breach the ESA after the third month and, under Waksdale, taint the other termination provisions. Probation clauses should either track the statutory period or provide statutory entitlements after it.
Fixed-term contracts raise a different risk. If a fixed-term contract has no enforceable early termination clause, an employer that ends it early may owe the balance of the term, which can exceed common law notice. The Court of Appeal for Ontario has held that employees in that situation have no duty to mitigate unless the contract provides one. Employers using fixed terms should include a clear early termination clause that complies with the ESA.
Clauses must also respect protected leaves and reprisal prohibitions. A clause that appears to allow termination during pregnancy or parental leave, or because an employee asserted ESA rights, can be read as contrary to the statute. Expressly making the clause subject to the ESA's protections helps, but cannot cure language that plainly authorizes prohibited conduct.
Bonuses, commissions and equity on termination
Termination clauses often say nothing about incentive pay, leaving the issue to bonus and equity plans. After Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26, an employee entitled to common law notice is presumed to be entitled to incentive compensation that would have been earned during the notice period, unless the plan contains clear and unambiguous language removing that entitlement, brought to the employee's attention. Where a termination clause is enforceable and limits notice to the statutory period, the employee may still be entitled to incentive amounts the ESA treats as wages during that period. Consistent drafting across the employment agreement and the incentive plans is essential.
Timing and consideration
An employment contract is formed when the offer is accepted, usually before the start date. Contracts presented on the first day of work, or after the employee has resigned from a previous job, are vulnerable. Employers updating contracts for existing staff should provide genuine consideration, such as a raise, bonus eligibility or promotion, and give the employee time to review. Courts also consider whether the employee had a real opportunity to read the terms. Online acceptance flows should record when and how the employee agreed.
Outside Ontario
Most common law provinces apply similar principles, but appellate courts have not all followed Ontario's strict approach in every respect. British Columbia, Alberta and other provinces have their own employment standards minimums and case law. Employers with national workforces should either draft province-specific clauses or use a clause that expressly provides the greater of the applicable statutory entitlements and a contractual formula.
Quebec is different. Article 2092 of the Civil Code of Québec provides that an employee cannot renounce the right to obtain compensation for injury suffered where insufficient notice of termination is given or where the manner of resiliation is abusive. Contractual notice limits are therefore treated as minimums, and courts assess reasonable notice regardless. Federally regulated employers have their own Canada Labour Code minimums and an unjust dismissal regime for non-managerial employees with 12 months' service.
If a clause is challenged
When a dismissed employee challenges a termination clause, the court first decides whether the clause is enforceable. If it is not, the employee receives common law reasonable notice, subject to the duty to mitigate. Employers can sometimes reduce exposure through mitigation evidence, or by showing that the employee found comparable work quickly. Settlement value depends heavily on the enforceability analysis, so a prompt review of the clause by counsel is worthwhile before any termination meeting. The termination letter should also be consistent with the clause, paying exactly what it promises and no less.
Illustration: a manager with ten years' service and a contract limiting entitlements to "the minimum required by the ESA" is dismissed without cause. If the clause is enforceable, the employer owes eight weeks of termination pay, benefits continuation and 10 weeks of severance pay. If a defective cause clause elsewhere in the contract voids it, the manager may claim common law notice that could exceed a year.
Reviewing termination clauses regularly
Because the case law keeps evolving, employers should review their standard termination clauses at least annually and after every significant appellate decision. Legacy contracts for long-service employees are a particular risk, since they were drafted before Waksdale. Rolling out new contracts requires consideration, communication and a plan for employees who decline to sign. Employers should also keep signed copies centrally, because the enforceability of termination clauses often depends on proving exactly which version an employee accepted and when.
How TRW & Co helps
We draft and review termination clauses and employment agreements for employers across Canada, advise on contract rollouts and consideration, and assess enforceability when terminations are planned or challenged. We work within our employment law practice and with our litigation team, and see our insights on reasonable notice and executive employment agreements. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your contracts.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the court void the clause in Waksdale?
In Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, the termination provisions read as a whole included a for-cause clause that could deny ESA entitlements for conduct short of wilful misconduct. Because the provisions together could breach the ESA, the without-cause clause was also unenforceable, and a severability clause could not save it.
Can an employer limit notice to ESA minimums?
Yes, if the clause is clear, complies with the ESA in every scenario, provides benefits continuation and severance pay where required, and was agreed with consideration. If it fails, the employee is presumed entitled to common law reasonable notice, as held in Machtinger v. HOJ Industries Ltd.
What is wrong with 'at any time' language?
Ontario courts have read clauses allowing termination at any time in the employer's sole discretion as permitting termination in circumstances the ESA prohibits, such as during protected leaves or in reprisal. Clauses should avoid absolute discretion and be expressly subject to the ESA.
Do these rules apply in Quebec?
Quebec applies the Civil Code. Under article 2092, employees cannot waive in advance their right to compensation for insufficient notice or abusive termination, so contractual limits are treated as minimums and courts assess reasonable notice regardless of the clause.
Can we add a termination clause for existing employees?
Yes, but only with fresh consideration, such as a raise, promotion or new benefit, and with a fair opportunity to review. A new clause imposed without consideration may be unenforceable even if well drafted.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


