Skip to content
Leading Court Decisions

Uber v Heller: Unconscionable Arbitration Clauses

Uber v Heller is the Supreme Court of Canada's leading case on unconscionable standard-form terms. It struck down an arbitration clause that would have cost a delivery driver most of a year's income just to start a claim, and it restated the unconscionability test that now governs contracts across Canada.

Delivery courier using a smartphone app, illustrating the standard-form contract in Uber v Heller

Key takeaways

  • Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16, was released on 26 June 2020.
  • Unconscionability needs inequality of bargaining power and a resulting improvident bargain.
  • Proof that the stronger party knowingly exploited the weaker party is not required.
  • Courts may decide validity where the challenge would otherwise never reach an arbitrator.
  • Standard-form arbitration clauses for individuals need proportionate cost and an accessible forum.

What Uber v Heller decided

Uber v Heller, formally Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16, is the Supreme Court of Canada's leading decision on unconscionable contract terms and on when courts, rather than arbitrators, decide challenges to arbitration clauses. Released on 26 June 2020, it held that an arbitration clause in Uber's standard-form driver agreement was unconscionable and therefore invalid, allowing a proposed class action by Ontario drivers to proceed in court. In doing so, the majority restated the unconscionability doctrine for the whole of Canadian common law.

Delivery courier using a smartphone app, illustrating the standard-form contract in Uber v Heller
Uber v Heller reshaped how Canadian courts treat standard-form arbitration clauses imposed on individuals with little bargaining power.

The decision matters well beyond the gig economy. Any business that relies on click-through terms, standard supplier or contractor agreements, or arbitration clauses with distant seats and high fees should read it as a warning about drafting dispute resolution provisions for counterparties who cannot negotiate.

The facts: a driver, a click-through contract and a Dutch arbitration

David Heller provided food delivery services through UberEats in Toronto. To use the app, he had to accept Uber's standard-form services agreement by clicking "I agree"; there was no opportunity to negotiate. The agreement required all disputes to be mediated and then arbitrated under the International Chamber of Commerce rules in the Netherlands, under Dutch law.

According to the Supreme Court's Case in Brief, starting an ICC arbitration would have cost almost US$15,000 in up-front administrative fees, before legal fees, travel and lost income. Mr. Heller earned between $400 and $600 a week before taxes and expenses. None of this was disclosed when he accepted the terms. In 2017, he started a proposed class action in Ontario alleging that drivers were employees entitled to the protections of Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000. Uber moved to stay the action in favour of arbitration.

The motion judge stayed the action, holding that the arbitrator should decide the validity of the clause. The Court of Appeal for Ontario reversed. The Supreme Court dismissed Uber's appeal.

Who decides: court or arbitrator?

Ordinarily, Canadian courts apply the competence-competence principle: challenges to an arbitrator's jurisdiction should first be resolved by the arbitrator. Section 7(1) of Ontario's Arbitration Act, 1991 requires a court to stay a proceeding covered by an arbitration agreement, but s. 7(2) lists exceptions, including where "the arbitration agreement is invalid".

The majority, written by Abella and Rowe JJ., confirmed that a court may decide a challenge to arbitral jurisdiction where it raises a pure question of law, or a question of mixed fact and law requiring only superficial consideration of the evidence. It added a further route: where there is a real prospect that, if the stay is granted, the challenge to jurisdiction will never be resolved by the arbitrator. That was the case here. Because the fees made arbitration practically inaccessible to Mr. Heller, sending the validity question to the arbitrator would effectively have denied him any forum at all.

The modernized unconscionability test in Uber v Heller

The most enduring part of Uber v Heller is its restatement of unconscionability. The majority held that the doctrine requires two elements:

  1. An inequality of bargaining power, which can arise from many sources, including the use of a standard-form contract, a lack of opportunity to negotiate, the complexity of terms, financial need, or a lack of understanding or sophistication.
  2. A resulting improvident bargain, one that unduly advantages the stronger party or unduly disadvantages the weaker party, assessed in the context of the whole transaction when it was made.

Importantly, the majority held that the stronger party need not have knowingly taken advantage of the weaker party. Unconscionability is concerned with the fairness of the bargain and the process that produced it, not with proof of intent to exploit.

Applying the test, the majority found clear inequality of bargaining power: a standard-form contract presented by a multinational to a driver with no ability to negotiate, and terms that did not disclose the cost of arbitration. The bargain was improvident because the fees, the foreign seat and the foreign law together made arbitration effectively unavailable for any claim Mr. Heller was likely to bring. The arbitration clause was invalid, and the action could continue.

Brown J. concurred in the result on a different basis, finding the clause contrary to public policy because it denied access to justice. Côté J. dissented, emphasizing respect for the parties' agreement to arbitrate and favouring a conditional stay.

IssueHolding in Uber v HellerDrafting implication
Who decides validity?A court may decide where there is a real prospect the challenge would otherwise never reach the arbitratorMake arbitration genuinely accessible, so the stay is granted
Inequality of bargaining powerStandard-form, non-negotiable terms and undisclosed costs can establish itDisclose key terms, including cost, clearly and up front
Improvident bargainFees and a foreign seat that make claims impractical are improvidentUse proportionate fees, local seats and virtual hearings for individuals
Intent to exploitNot requiredGood intentions will not save an unfair clause

Consumers, employees and Quebec

Statutes already limit arbitration in some relationships. In Ontario, s. 7(2) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2002 invalidates terms requiring consumers to arbitrate disputes insofar as they prevent the consumer from suing in the Superior Court of Justice under that Act; the 2002 Act is slated to be replaced by the Consumer Protection Act, 2023 on a date to be proclaimed. In Quebec, s. 11.1 of the Consumer Protection Act prohibits stipulations requiring a consumer to arbitrate, restricting the right to go to court or barring class actions.

Uber v Heller reaches beyond these statutory protections. It applies to independent contractors, small suppliers, franchisees and other individuals or small businesses who are not consumers but who accept standard terms from a much larger party. The Supreme Court had addressed Ontario's arbitration legislation shortly before in TELUS Communications Inc. v. Wellman, where it applied the stay provisions to a class action involving business customers; Uber v Heller shows the limits of that approach where the arbitration clause itself is unfair.

Practical point

Whether a worker is an employee or a contractor remains a live question across Canada. Platform businesses should assume that an arbitration clause will be tested both on unconscionability and on whether it can oust statutory employment rights, and should design dispute resolution that would survive either challenge. Our page on employment law covers classification issues.

Unconscionability beyond arbitration clauses

Although the dispute concerned arbitration, the restated doctrine applies to any contractual term. Since Uber v Heller, parties challenging standard-form contracts routinely invoke it against other provisions that operate harshly against a weaker party. Businesses should review the following terms with the two-part test in mind:

  • Limitation and exclusion of liability clauses that leave an individual or small business without any meaningful remedy for the stronger party's core obligations;
  • Forum selection and governing law clauses that require a local counterparty to litigate abroad under foreign law, which the Supreme Court had already scrutinized in consumer settings;
  • Short contractual limitation periods buried in terms and conditions;
  • Unilateral amendment rights allowing the drafter to change fees or terms without meaningful notice;
  • Termination and forfeiture provisions that strip accrued compensation from contractors or franchisees.

The two elements must both be present. Inequality of bargaining power alone does not make a term unconscionable; standard-form contracts are a normal part of commerce. The question is whether the term, assessed at the time of contracting and in light of the whole transaction, unduly advantages the stronger party. A term that is commercially reasonable, clearly disclosed and proportionate is likely to survive even in a non-negotiated contract.

Responding to a stay motion after Uber v Heller

For businesses defending a court action brought in breach of an arbitration clause, the decision reshapes the stay motion. Courts will still generally refer jurisdictional disputes to the arbitrator, but plaintiffs now have a clear path to argue that the court should decide validity itself. A defendant seeking a stay should be ready to show, with evidence, that arbitration is realistically accessible to the plaintiff: the actual cost, any fee advances or caps the business will offer, the availability of virtual hearings and the time a decision will take. Offering to fund the arbitration after a dispute arises may help, but courts assess unconscionability at the time the contract was made, so an after-the-fact offer is no substitute for a fair clause.

Plaintiffs, for their part, typically file evidence on their income, the cost of the prescribed process and the absence of any opportunity to negotiate. Class action counsel now examine arbitration clauses early, since an unenforceable clause removes one of the most effective defences to certification. Our page on class actions explains how these issues arise in practice.

Drafting dispute clauses after Uber v Heller

For business-to-business contracts between sophisticated parties, Uber v Heller changes little; Canadian courts continue to enforce negotiated arbitration agreements. For contracts with individuals, contractors and small businesses on standard terms, the following steps reduce risk:

  • Proportionate cost. Cap the individual's share of fees at a level comparable to court filing fees, with the business advancing the balance.
  • Accessible seat and format. Choose a seat in the province where the individual works or lives, allow virtual hearings and consider expedited rules for small claims.
  • Local law and carve-outs. Avoid foreign governing law for local work, and carve out small claims and statutory complaints that cannot lawfully be arbitrated.
  • Transparency. Summarize the dispute process and its costs prominently, not only in linked terms.
  • Opt-out window. Consider giving individuals a period to opt out of arbitration without penalty.
  • Review cycle. Revisit the clause whenever fees, institutional rules or the user base change, since a clause that was proportionate at launch can become oppressive as the business grows.
  • Class action waivers. Assess separately; in Quebec consumer contracts they are prohibited, and elsewhere they can strengthen an unconscionability argument.

Illustration: a hypothetical delivery platform operating in Ontario and Quebec revises its courier terms. It replaces an ICC clause seated abroad with arbitration seated in Toronto or Montreal under domestic rules, caps courier fees at a modest amount, offers virtual hearings and a 30-day opt-out, and excludes employment standards complaints. A court applying Uber v Heller would be far less likely to find that arrangement unconscionable. See our page on international arbitration and our insight on drafting enforceable termination clauses.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise platforms, franchisors, technology companies and employers on dispute resolution clauses for Canadian contracts. We review standard terms against Uber v Heller and consumer protection statutes, design proportionate arbitration and escalation mechanisms, and assess enforceability when a stay motion or class action is threatened, working with litigation counsel in the relevant province where required. This article is general information, not legal advice. To review your contract terms, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Did Uber v Heller ban arbitration clauses in Canada?

No. The Court held that this particular clause was unconscionable because of its cost, foreign seat and the parties' unequal bargaining power. Negotiated arbitration agreements between commercial parties remain enforceable, and even standard-form clauses can be upheld if they give the weaker party a genuinely accessible forum.

What is the test for unconscionability after Uber v Heller?

The majority required two elements: an inequality of bargaining power, and a resulting improvident bargain that unduly advantages the stronger party or disadvantages the weaker one. The stronger party need not have knowingly taken advantage, and the bargain is assessed when the contract was made.

When will a court decide an arbitration clause's validity instead of the arbitrator?

Where the challenge raises a question of law, or of mixed fact and law needing only superficial review of the evidence, and also where there is a real prospect that the challenge would never be resolved by the arbitrator if a stay were granted, for example because the cost of arbitration makes it inaccessible.

Does Uber v Heller apply in Quebec?

The decision interprets Ontario law and the common-law unconscionability doctrine. Quebec applies the Civil Code instead, including rules on abusive clauses in contracts of adhesion, and its Consumer Protection Act prohibits arbitration clauses and class action waivers in consumer contracts. The policy concerns are similar, but the legal tests differ.

Are class action waivers enforceable in Canada?

It depends on the province and the relationship. Quebec prohibits them in consumer contracts, and Ontario consumer legislation limits mandatory arbitration of consumer claims. Outside those statutes, a waiver combined with expensive or inaccessible arbitration may support an unconscionability finding under Uber v Heller.

Sources

  1. Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16 (full text)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller
  3. Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c. 17, s. 7
  4. Consumer Protection Act, 2002, S.O. 2002, c. 30, Sched. A, s. 7
  5. Consumer Protection Act (Quebec), CQLR c. P-40.1, s. 11.1

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.