Canada North Group: Court-Ordered Charges vs Crown Deemed Trusts
Canada North Group settled a long-running priority fight in CCAA restructurings. A 5-4 Supreme Court held that supervising judges can rank interim financing, administration and directors' charges ahead of the Crown's deemed trust for unremitted source deductions, but only where that priority is necessary.

Key takeaways
- Canada v. Canada North Group Inc., 2021 SCC 30, was decided 5-4 on 28 July 2021.
- Section 11 CCAA lets courts rank priming charges ahead of the source deduction deemed trust.
- The plurality held a court-ordered charge is not a 'security interest' under the Income Tax Act.
- Section 6(3) CCAA still requires plans to pay these Crown amounts within six months.
- Courts should grant priority over the deemed trust only when necessary, with Crown notice.
What Canada North Group decided
In Canada v. Canada North Group Inc., 2021 SCC 30, decided on 28 July 2021, a 5-4 Supreme Court of Canada held that a court supervising a restructuring under the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) can order that interim financing, administration and directors' charges rank ahead of the Crown's deemed trust for unremitted employee source deductions. Canada North Group is the leading authority on the reach of the supervising judge's general power in s. 11 CCAA and on how far the Crown's statutory priority can be displaced to keep a restructuring alive.

For interim lenders, monitors, insolvency counsel and directors, the decision provides comfort that priming charges approved by the court will be respected, even against one of the strongest priorities in Canadian law. It also contains an important caution: priority over the deemed trust should be granted only where it is necessary. This note explains the facts, the competing opinions, the statutory framework, and practical points for debtors and lenders. It is general information, not legal advice.
The facts: priming charges in an Alberta CCAA filing
Canada North Group Inc., an Alberta provider of remote workforce accommodation, and six related companies obtained an initial order under the CCAA on 5 July 2017. The order created three court-ordered charges ranking ahead of the companies' secured creditors:
- an administration charge for the fees of counsel, the monitor and a chief restructuring officer;
- an interim financing charge (often called a DIP charge) securing an interim lender's advances; and
- a directors' charge indemnifying directors and officers for liabilities incurred after the filing.
The Crown was owed unremitted employee source deductions and GST. It moved to vary the order on the basis that the charges could not rank ahead of its deemed trust under s. 227(4.1) of the Income Tax Act (ITA). The Court of Queen's Bench of Alberta dismissed the motion and the Court of Appeal of Alberta dismissed the Crown's appeal. Although there was enough money to pay everyone in the end, the Supreme Court heard the case to settle the law, and dismissed the Crown's further appeal.
The statutory collision behind Canada North Group
Two federal statutes pointed in different directions. Under s. 227(4) and (4.1) ITA, an employer that deducts tax from employees is deemed to hold it in trust for the Crown, and if it is not remitted, property of the employer and property held by its secured creditors equal in value is deemed held in trust and to form no part of the employer's estate, notwithstanding the BIA, any other federal or provincial law and any security interest.
The CCAA, by contrast, gives the supervising court broad powers. Under s. 11 CCAA, the court may make any order that it considers appropriate in the circumstances. Sections 11.2, 11.51 and 11.52 expressly authorize interim financing, directors' and administration charges that may rank ahead of secured creditors. And while s. 37(1) generally neutralizes statutory deemed trusts in favour of the Crown, s. 37(2) preserves the source deduction trusts under the ITA, the Canada Pension Plan and the Employment Insurance Act. Section 6(3) adds that, unless the Crown agrees otherwise, a plan can be sanctioned only if it provides for payment in full of these amounts within six months after sanction.
| Provision | What it does |
|---|---|
| s. 227(4), (4.1) ITA | Deemed trust for unremitted source deductions, with priority over security interests |
| s. 11 CCAA | General power to make any order appropriate in the circumstances |
| ss. 11.2, 11.51, 11.52 CCAA | Interim financing, directors' and administration charges that may prime secured creditors |
| s. 37(2) CCAA | Preserves the source deduction deemed trusts in CCAA proceedings |
| s. 6(3) CCAA | Plan must pay source deduction amounts in full within six months of sanction, unless the Crown agrees otherwise |
The holding in Canada North Group: three opinions, one result
Justice Côté (with Chief Justice Wagner and Justice Kasirer) held that the deemed trust does not give the Crown a proprietary interest in specific property of the kind a true trust would, and that in Quebec it is not a civil law trust. A court-ordered priming charge is not a "security interest" as defined in s. 224(1.3) ITA, because it serves the restructuring and all stakeholders rather than securing a debt for its holder. There was therefore no conflict, and s. 11 CCAA authorized the court to rank the charges first. The specific powers in ss. 11.2, 11.51 and 11.52 do not narrow s. 11, and s. 37(2) preserves the deemed trust without changing its character.
Justice Karakatsanis (with Justice Martin) agreed in the result. In her view the deemed trust is a security interest, but the CCAA provisions and the ITA do not conflict: the Crown is protected by s. 6(3), which ensures it is paid in full under any plan, and s. 11 allows a court to rank charges ahead where that furthers the CCAA's remedial goals.
The dissents. Justices Brown and Rowe (with Justice Abella) would have held that the "notwithstanding" language in s. 227(4.1) gives the deemed trust absolute priority, that priming charges fall within the broad definition of security interest, and that s. 37(2) preserves that priority in the CCAA. Justice Moldaver, dissenting separately, agreed in substance and suggested that the Crown should be flexible where its priority threatens a restructuring.
Canada North Group is a power, not an entitlement. The majority cautioned that priority over the Crown's deemed trust should be granted only where necessary. Debtors seeking priming charges should give the Crown notice, show why the charges and their amounts are needed, and explain how the plan will meet s. 6(3).
Why Canada North Group matters to lenders and directors
Restructurings depend on professionals and lenders willing to take risk. Interim lenders will not advance funds, and monitors, counsel and directors will not stay, unless they are confident their charges will be paid first. If the Crown's deemed trust could leapfrog those charges, the cost and availability of interim financing would change, and many viable restructurings would fail. The Case in Brief captures the majority's reasoning: it would be unfair for experts to put themselves at financial risk only to discover later that other creditors must be paid first.
At the same time, the decision does not erase the Crown's position. Source deductions remain protected by s. 37(2), and a plan cannot be sanctioned unless it pays them within six months, absent Crown agreement. In practice, the Crown's claim usually ranks behind the court-ordered charges but ahead of ordinary secured and unsecured creditors in the distribution. Our note on deemed trusts and Crown priorities covers the wider priority picture, including GST/HST and pension deemed trusts.
| Stakeholder | Effect of the decision |
|---|---|
| Interim (DIP) lender | Court-approved charge can rank ahead of the source deduction deemed trust |
| Monitor, counsel, CRO | Administration charge can be protected in the same way |
| Directors and officers | Directors' charge can prime the deemed trust, supporting retention during the filing |
| Crown (CRA) | Retains s. 37(2) and s. 6(3) protection; can oppose charges that are unnecessary or excessive |
| Pre-filing secured lenders | Rank behind both the charges and, generally, the deemed trust |
The decision in context: the breadth of s. 11 CCAA
The ruling builds on the Supreme Court's 2020 decision in 9354-9186 Québec inc. v. Callidus Capital Corp., 2020 SCC 10, which described the supervising judge's discretion under s. 11 as broad and flexible, to be exercised in furtherance of the CCAA's remedial objectives and with appropriateness, good faith and due diligence as baseline considerations. Read together, the two cases confirm that the specific powers added to the CCAA over time do not exhaust what a supervising judge can do. They guide and structure the general power rather than confine it.
That breadth has limits. The court must act within the CCAA's purposes, respect express statutory restrictions, and, as Canada North Group emphasizes, take account of the distinct nature of the Crown's interest. Courts will typically consider:
- whether the charges are needed to keep the business operating and the restructuring viable;
- whether the amounts are reasonable in light of the cash-flow forecast and the size of the business;
- the position of the monitor, which reports to the court on the reasonableness of the charges;
- whether affected creditors, including the Crown, received notice and had the opportunity to respond; and
- whether the plan or sale contemplated is likely to satisfy the Crown's claims as required by s. 6(3).
A request that is supported by the monitor, tied to a realistic forecast and accompanied by a credible path to paying the Crown is far more likely to succeed than a broad request for priming charges at the outset of a filing.
Practical points for CCAA filings
- Quantify the deemed trust early. Determine unremitted source deductions and other Crown claims before filing, and build them into the cash-flow forecast.
- Justify each charge. Support the amount and ranking of the interim financing, administration and directors' charges with evidence; under s. 11.001, relief in the initial order is limited to what is reasonably necessary for the initial stay period.
- Give the Crown notice. Where charges are to prime the deemed trust, serve the Crown and address its position directly.
- Plan for s. 6(3). Ensure the plan, or a sale process, will pay the source deduction amounts within six months of sanction or obtain the Crown's agreement.
- Directors' exposure. Directors can be personally liable for unremitted source deductions under the ITA. A directors' charge and D&O insurance help, but directors should press for remittances to be current; see our note on directors' duties in the zone of insolvency.
Illustration (hypothetical): a manufacturer files under the CCAA with CAD 1.2 million of unremitted source deductions and needs CAD 5 million of interim financing. The lender will lend only if its charge ranks first. Applying Canada North Group, the court can rank the charge ahead of the deemed trust if it is satisfied the financing is necessary, but the plan must still provide for payment of the source deductions in full within six months of sanction unless the Crown agrees otherwise.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise debtors, interim lenders, secured creditors, directors and purchasers in CCAA and BIA proceedings, including the structuring and ranking of interim financing, administration and directors' charges, Crown and deemed trust claims, and the tax consequences of restructuring plans. We prepare the evidentiary case for priming charges, negotiate with the CRA and other creditors, and work with monitors, licensed insolvency trustees and Canadian-licensed litigation counsel on court applications. See our CCAA restructuring page and our note on DIP financing, or contact us.
Sources: Supreme Court of Canada, Case in Brief: Canada v. Canada North Group Inc.; full reasons, 2021 SCC 30.
Frequently asked questions
What is the source deduction deemed trust?
Under s. 227(4) and (4.1) of the Income Tax Act, an employer is deemed to hold income tax deducted from employees' pay in trust for the Crown. If the amounts are not remitted, property of the employer and of its secured creditors equal in value is deemed held in trust for the Crown, with priority over security interests. Similar trusts apply to CPP and EI contributions.
Which charges can rank ahead of the deemed trust?
In Canada North Group, the court-ordered administration charge, interim financing charge and directors' charge were all allowed to rank first. The supervising court's authority comes from the general power in s. 11 CCAA, informed by the specific provisions in ss. 11.2, 11.51 and 11.52.
Does the Crown lose its priority entirely?
No. The deemed trust is preserved in CCAA proceedings by s. 37(2), and s. 6(3) prevents a court from sanctioning a plan unless the Crown's source deduction claims are paid in full within six months after sanction, unless the Crown agrees otherwise. The decision mainly affects ranking against court-ordered charges.
Does the decision apply to GST/HST deemed trusts?
The GST/HST deemed trust is generally not preserved in CCAA proceedings, because s. 37(1) neutralizes Crown deemed trusts other than those listed in s. 37(2). The Supreme Court's analysis focused on the source deduction trust, which s. 37(2) preserves.
What should a debtor do before seeking priming charges?
Quantify Crown claims, prepare evidence showing why each charge and its amount is necessary, give notice to the Crown and affected secured creditors, and show how a plan or sale will satisfy s. 6(3). Courts expect justification rather than routine requests.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


