Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Employer Compliance Inspections for Foreign Workers

Employer compliance inspections by IRCC and ESDC can reach back six years and end in penalties, bans and public listing. This guide explains the conditions that employers of temporary foreign workers and LMIA-exempt workers must meet, how inspections unfold, which justifications work and how to prepare before the letter arrives.

HR manager organizing payroll records ahead of employer compliance inspections for foreign workers in Canada

Key takeaways

  • IRCC inspects LMIA-exempt employers; ESDC inspects Temporary Foreign Worker Program employers.
  • Inspections can be random; records must be kept for six years from the permit's start.
  • Wages, duties and conditions must stay substantially the same as the offer.
  • Repaying underpaid workers can justify good-faith or administrative errors.
  • Penalties reach CAD 100,000 per violation, CAD 1 million per notice, plus bans and public listing.

What employer compliance inspections are and who runs them

Employer compliance inspections are the federal government's way of checking, after the fact, that an employer who hired a foreign national on a work permit kept the promises it made to get that permit. Two departments share the work. Employment and Social Development Canada (ESDC) inspects employers in the Temporary Foreign Worker Program (TFWP), where a Labour Market Impact Assessment (LMIA) was required. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) inspects employers who hired under the International Mobility Program (IMP), where the worker was LMIA-exempt and the employer submitted an offer of employment through the Employer Portal.

HR manager organizing payroll records ahead of employer compliance inspections for foreign workers in Canada
Employer compliance inspections test whether the wages, duties and working conditions actually provided match the offer used to obtain the work permit.

The rules sit in Part 11, Divisions 4 to 6 of the Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (IRPR). Section 209.2 sets the conditions for IMP employers and s. 209.3 those for TFWP employers; s. 209.4 obliges both to cooperate with an inspection; and ss. 209.93 to 209.997 set out the administrative monetary penalty (AMP), ineligibility and public-listing regime. Because the conditions attach to the offer itself, they apply whether the worker is a senior engineer on an intra-company transfer or a seasonal agricultural worker.

Inspections are not rare. In a committee briefing published by IRCC, the government reported 1,435 ESDC inspections of TFWP employers and 4,328 IRCC inspections of IMP employers in 2024–2025, with penalties under the TFWP more than doubling year over year (IRCC committee briefing, December 2025). For any employer with a meaningful foreign workforce, an inspection is a realistic event to plan for, not a remote risk.

When an inspection can start

Section 209.5 IRPR lists the circumstances in which officers may use their inspection powers. Some are fault-based, others are not:

  • Reason to suspect that the employer is not complying, or has not complied, with a condition (often triggered by a worker complaint, a tip or information from another regulator);
  • Past non-compliance, so an employer with a prior finding can expect renewed attention;
  • Random verification, which means an employer with an unblemished record can still be selected;
  • public-health circumstances under the Quarantine Act or Emergencies Act, a residue of the pandemic period.

The look-back window is long. The duty to be able to prove the accuracy of information provided, and to keep records, runs for six years from the first day of the period of employment for which the permit was issued (s. 209.2(1)(b) and the parallel TFWP condition in s. 209.3). An inspection opened today can therefore reach back to permits issued well before the current HR team, payroll provider or office manager arrived.

Conditions employer compliance inspections test

The conditions differ slightly between the two programs, but the core obligations are the same. The table summarizes what employer compliance inspections typically examine and the evidence officers ask for.

Condition (IRPR)What it means in practiceEvidence usually requested
Actively engaged in the business (ss. 209.2(1)(a)(i), 209.3(1)(a)(i))The business that made the offer is operating and genuinely needs the roleBusiness licences, tax filings, financial statements, photos of premises
Same occupation, substantially the same wages and working conditionsThe worker does the job described, at the wage offered, with the hours and conditions promisedPay stubs, payroll registers, timesheets, job descriptions, organization charts
Compliance with provincial and federal employment and recruitment lawsEmployment standards, health and safety and recruiter licensing rules are respectedStatements of hours, overtime records, vacation pay, safety training records
Reasonable efforts to provide a workplace free of abusePolicies, training and complaint channels exist and workHarassment and violence policies, investigation files, training logs
Rights information and a signed employment agreement on or before day one (s. 209.2(1)(a.1))The worker received the prescribed information and a copy of the agreement in their chosen official languageSigned and dated acknowledgements, the agreement itself
No recruitment fees charged to the worker (ss. 209.2(1)(a)(ix)-(x))Neither the employer nor its recruiters recover recruitment costs from the workerRecruiter contracts, payroll deductions, worker attestations
Six-year record retention and accuracy of information (s. 209.2(1)(b))The employer can show that what it told IRCC or ESDC was trueThe LMIA or offer submission, supporting documents, correspondence

The wage and working-conditions condition causes the most findings in practice. The problem is rarely deliberate underpayment; it is drift. A worker hired at a stated hourly rate is moved to a different shift pattern, a role is reorganized, a pay increase given to Canadian colleagues is not extended, or a remote-work arrangement changes the work location named in the offer. Each change can make the actual employment no longer "substantially the same" as the offer.

How employer compliance inspections unfold

Most employer compliance inspections begin with a letter or email from IRCC or ESDC identifying the worker or workers concerned, the period under review and a list of documents to be produced by a deadline. Under ss. 209.6 and 209.7 IRPR, officers can require the employer to report at a specified time and place to answer questions, require the employer to provide any document relating to compliance, and require third parties, such as payroll providers or recruiters, to hand over documents in their possession. Sections 209.8 and 209.9 allow on-site inspections, without a warrant, of premises where the worker performs work (and, for TFWP employers, accommodation the employer provides), subject to restrictions on entering dwellings.

Section 209.4 makes cooperation itself a condition. Failing to report, to produce documents or to attend an inspection is a separate violation, justified only where the employer made all reasonable efforts or acted in good faith. Ignoring an inspection letter, even one sent to an outdated address, is therefore one of the most expensive mistakes an employer can make. The government's own briefing material notes that non-responsive employers face significant penalties and multi-year bans.

  1. Acknowledge and calendar. Confirm receipt, note the deadline and, if the volume of documents justifies it, ask for an extension early and in writing.
  2. Collect before you explain. Pull payroll, time records and the original offer or LMIA file for each named worker before drafting any narrative.
  3. Reconcile. Compare actual wages, hours, duties and location with the offer, month by month. Identify gaps yourself before the officer does.
  4. Remediate where possible. If a worker was underpaid through an administrative error, pay the difference with a clear record of the calculation.
  5. Respond in an organized package. Index the documents, explain any discrepancies and invoke the relevant justification expressly.
Practical point

Build an "inspection-ready" file at the moment each work permit is issued: the offer or LMIA, the signed employment agreement, proof the rights information was provided, and a standing payroll report for that worker. Updating the file on every change of role, wage or location turns a six-year look-back from a forensic exercise into a routine export.

Justifications that can answer a finding

An apparent breach is not automatically a violation. Section 209.2(3) (and the matching provisions for TFWP employers) treats a failure as justified if it results from, among other things:

  • a change in federal or provincial law, or in the provisions of a collective agreement;
  • measures taken in response to a dramatic change in economic conditions that directly affected the business, provided they were not directed disproportionately at foreign nationals;
  • a good-faith error in interpretation of the employer's obligations, or an accounting or administrative error, if the employer subsequently compensated (or made sufficient efforts to compensate) every affected worker;
  • circumstances similar to these, or superior force (force majeure).

For recruitment fees, the justification is narrower: the employer must have made all reasonable efforts to comply and fully reimbursed the worker (s. 209.2(3.1)). For record-keeping, the employer must show all reasonable efforts (s. 209.2(4)). The common thread is that justifications reward employers that find and fix problems. An underpayment repaid with interest before the officer asks reads very differently from one repaid after a preliminary finding.

Penalties, bans and public listing

If the officer concludes a violation occurred, the employer first receives a notice of preliminary finding (s. 209.993) and generally has 30 days to make written submissions or request an extension (s. 209.994). Only after considering those submissions does the officer issue a notice of final determination (s. 209.996). The submissions stage is often decisive and deserves the same care as a litigation brief.

Penalties are calculated by points under Schedule 2 IRPR. Each violation is classified as Type A, B or C, and points accumulate according to the nature of the violation, the employer's compliance history and the employer's size. Table 2 of Schedule 2 scales AMPs from CAD 500 up to CAD 100,000 per violation, and a separate violation is counted for each foreign national affected (s. 209.96). Where one notice covers several violations, the amounts are cumulative but capped at CAD 1 million (s. 209.992). Table 3 adds periods of ineligibility of one, two, five or ten years, and a permanent ban at the top of the scale.

Finally, s. 209.997 requires the government to publish the employer's name and address, the conditions breached, the date of the determination, the employer's eligibility status and any penalty or ban on a public list of non-compliant employers, unless the outcome was a warning. For many businesses the publicity, and the knock-on effect on pending permits, LMIAs and permanent-residence nominations, matters more than the fine.

How employers prepare for employer compliance inspections

Preparation for employer compliance inspections is largely an HR operations exercise. The employers that come through cleanly tend to share four habits:

  • Change control. No change to a foreign worker's title, duties, wage, hours or work location without checking it against the offer, and, where needed, a new LMIA or permit.
  • Wage parity reviews. Annual increases given to Canadian staff in the same role are given to foreign workers too, as the TFWP wage condition generally expects.
  • Recruiter oversight. Written contracts that prohibit fee recovery from workers, audit rights and an attestation from each worker at onboarding.
  • A single owner. One person or team receives government correspondence, tracks deadlines and holds the six-year files.

Illustration: a hypothetical Ontario manufacturer hires three welders under LMIAs at a stated wage. Two years later it moves the night shift to a four-day compressed week and, by error, stops paying a shift premium promised in the offer. An inspection is opened at random. Because the employer had already identified the error in an internal audit and repaid the premium with a documented calculation, it can rely on the administrative-error justification; had it waited for the preliminary finding, the same facts would likely have produced a violation for each of the three workers.

Inspection risk also overlaps with other employment obligations. The same payroll records answer employment-standards claims, and workers who allege abuse may also bring human rights or workplace-safety complaints. Our insights on contractor misclassification and business visitors cover adjacent risks for employers that rely on foreign talent.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise employers on Canadian business immigration compliance and on the employment law issues that inspections expose. In practice, we build inspection-ready file structures and change-control protocols for foreign workers; run privileged pre-inspection audits that reconcile payroll and duties against each offer or LMIA; help employers respond to inspection letters and on-site visits; draft submissions on notices of preliminary finding, including the justification analysis; and coordinate with Canadian-licensed counsel or regulated immigration consultants where a step requires one, including judicial review in the Federal Court. Nothing on this page is legal advice for a specific situation. To discuss an open inspection or a compliance review, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Can an employer be inspected even if nothing has gone wrong?

Yes. Section 209.5 IRPR allows officers to verify compliance as part of a random selection, as well as where they have a reason to suspect non-compliance or where the employer has a history of non-compliance. A clean record does not prevent an inspection, but it does reduce the points used to calculate any penalty if a violation is later found.

How long must employers keep records for foreign workers?

The IRPR conditions require employers to keep any document relating to compliance, and to be able to demonstrate the accuracy of information they provided, for six years beginning on the first day of the period of employment for which the work permit was issued. Records should therefore survive staff turnover, payroll provider changes and system migrations.

What is the maximum penalty after an inspection?

Under Schedule 2 IRPR, an administrative monetary penalty can reach CAD 100,000 per violation, each affected worker can count as a separate violation, and cumulative penalties in one notice are capped at CAD 1 million. Periods of ineligibility of one to ten years, or a permanent ban, can apply, and most determinations are published on a public list.

Can a violation be avoided by paying workers what they were owed?

Often, if it is done properly. A good-faith interpretation error or an accounting or administrative error is justified if the employer subsequently compensated every affected worker, or made sufficient efforts to do so. Repayment should be documented, calculated carefully and ideally completed before the officer issues a preliminary finding.

Do the same rules apply to LMIA-exempt workers?

Largely yes. Employers who hired under the International Mobility Program are subject to the conditions in s. 209.2 IRPR and are inspected by IRCC, while TFWP employers are subject to s. 209.3 and inspected by ESDC. The conditions, cooperation duties and penalty scale are closely aligned between the two programs.

Sources

  1. Immigration and Refugee Protection Regulations (SOR/2002-227), ss. 209.1–209.997 and Schedule 2
  2. IRCC: Temporary foreign workers, CIMM committee briefing (December 2025)
  3. ESDC: Temporary Foreign Worker Program compliance regime (June 2024)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.