Skip to content
Banking, Finance & Fintech

Criminal Interest Rate: The 35% APR Cap and Commercial Exemptions

Since 1 January 2025, the criminal interest rate in s. 347 of the Criminal Code is an APR above 35%, down from a 60% effective annual rate. This note explains what counts as interest, the exemptions for business loans to non-individuals, the transition for older loans and how to draft savings clauses that courts will respect.

Loan officer calculating an annual percentage rate to stay below the criminal interest rate in Canada

Key takeaways

  • The criminal rate is an APR exceeding 35% on credit advanced, effective 1 January 2025.
  • Interest includes fees, premiums, penalties and commissions, not just stated interest.
  • Business loans to non-individuals above CAD 500,000 are exempt from s. 347.
  • Loans of CAD 10,000 to 500,000 to non-individuals are exempt if the APR does not exceed 48%.
  • Pre-2025 agreements are tested under the former 60% effective annual rate.

What is the criminal interest rate?

The criminal interest rate is the maximum cost of credit permitted by s. 347 of the Criminal Code. Since 1 January 2025, it is an annual percentage rate (APR), calculated in accordance with generally accepted actuarial practices and principles, that exceeds 35% on the credit advanced. Anyone who enters or offers to enter into an agreement to receive interest at a criminal rate, advertises such an offer, or receives a payment of interest at that rate commits an offence, punishable on indictment by up to five years' imprisonment or on summary conviction by a fine of up to CAD 25,000, imprisonment of up to two years less a day, or both.

Loan officer calculating an annual percentage rate to stay below the criminal interest rate in Canada
Since 2025, the criminal interest rate is an APR above 35%, but most larger commercial loans to non-individuals are exempt.

Before 2025 the threshold was an effective annual rate above 60%. Parliament replaced it in the Budget Implementation Act, 2023, No. 1 (S.C. 2023, c. 26, ss. 610 to 615), which also gave the federal Cabinet power to exempt classes of agreements by regulation. The Criminal Interest Rate Regulations (SOR/2024-114) took effect on the same day. The combined effect is a much lower ceiling for consumer and small business credit, but broad relief for commercial lending.

Prosecutions are rare. The real significance of s. 347 is civil: a borrower can argue that an agreement providing for interest above the limit is illegal and unenforceable, at least in part. Lenders therefore need to know when the criminal interest rate applies, how "interest" is calculated, and how to draft agreements so that a court is likely to adjust rather than strike down the bargain.

What counts as interest under s. 347

"Interest" in s. 347(2) is defined much more broadly than in ordinary usage. It means the aggregate of all charges and expenses, whether a fee, fine, penalty, commission or anything else, paid or payable for the advancing of credit, by or on behalf of the borrower, whoever receives them. It excludes only repayment of the credit advanced, insurance charges, official fees for perfecting security, small overdraft charges by deposit-taking institutions and credit unions, required deposit balances and, for mortgages, property tax amounts.

In practice, the following can all be "interest" for criminal interest rate purposes:

  • stated interest, including default interest and payment-in-kind interest;
  • original issue discount and upfront, commitment, standby and arrangement fees;
  • prepayment premiums, make-whole amounts and exit fees;
  • monitoring, administration and extension fees paid to the lender or its affiliates;
  • warrants, equity kickers or other benefits given in exchange for the credit, at their value; and
  • broker or third-party fees paid by the borrower where they are charges for the advancing of credit.

"Credit advanced" is also defined: it is the money and the value of goods, services or benefits actually advanced, minus required deposit balances and any fees and similar charges. So a CAD 100,000 loan with a CAD 5,000 fee deducted at funding is a CAD 95,000 advance for this calculation. The APR is calculated actuarially over the actual life of the credit, which means that early repayment, when upfront fees and exit fees are spread over a short period, is the most common way a lawful loan becomes a criminal interest rate problem.

The commercial exemptions in the regulations

New s. 347.01 provides that s. 347 does not apply to agreements or arrangements provided for by regulation. Section 1 of the Criminal Interest Rate Regulations sets out the business and commercial exemption. Section 347 does not apply if all of these conditions are met:

  1. the borrower is not a natural person;
  2. the borrowing is for a business or commercial purpose; and
  3. either the credit advanced is more than CAD 500,000, or it is more than CAD 10,000 and up to CAD 500,000 and the APR does not exceed 48%.
Credit advancedBorrower and purposeLimit that applies
Any amountIndividual (natural person), any purpose35% APR under s. 347
Up to CAD 10,000Corporation or other non-individual, business purpose35% APR under s. 347
More than CAD 10,000 up to CAD 500,000Non-individual, business or commercial purposeExempt if APR does not exceed 48%; otherwise s. 347 applies
More than CAD 500,000Non-individual, business or commercial purposeSection 347 does not apply
Under CAD 1,000 pawn loanPawnbroking business, recourse limited to pawned goods (not vehicles)Exempt if APR does not exceed 48%

The regulations also set a limit on the total cost of borrowing for payday loans under s. 347.1, at 14% of the amount advanced, where a province has payday loan legislation designated under the Code. Payday lending remains primarily provincially regulated.

Points to watch

The exemption looks to the borrower, so a loan to a corporation with a personal co-borrower, or to a sole proprietor, needs separate analysis. The purpose test also matters: a loan to a holding company used to finance a personal residence may not be for a business purpose. And the CAD 500,000 test is measured on credit advanced, net of fees, so a facility that is only partly drawn, or a CAD 510,000 loan with significant upfront fees, may fall below the threshold.

Transition for existing loans

Section 614 of the Budget Implementation Act, 2023, No. 1 deals with agreements made before 1 January 2025. The new 35% APR definition does not apply to receipt of interest on or after that date if the payment arises from an agreement entered into before that date and the interest would not have been at a criminal rate under the former definition. Pre-2025 agreements are therefore tested against the old 60% effective annual rate. Material amendments, extensions or new advances after 1 January 2025 may, however, be treated as new agreements, so lenders amending older high-cost facilities should run a fresh analysis.

Practical point

Build a criminal interest rate test into credit approval for any loan to an individual, any loan of CAD 500,000 or less, and any facility with heavy fees or exit premiums. Model the APR on a worst-case early repayment and default scenario, and keep the actuarial calculation with the file. Section 347(4) allows a Fellow of the Canadian Institute of Actuaries to prove the APR by certificate in proceedings.

Drafting savings clauses and how courts respond

Because a borrower may challenge the enforceability of an agreement that provides for interest above the criminal interest rate, most Canadian loan documents include a savings clause (also called an interest limitation clause). A typical clause provides that if any amount payable would result in interest at a criminal rate, the amount is reduced to the maximum permitted, starting with specified items, and any excess received is credited against principal or refunded.

The leading case on civil consequences is Transport North American Express Inc. v. New Solutions Financial Corp., 2004 SCC 7. The Supreme Court of Canada confirmed that courts have discretion, when an agreement breaches s. 347, to apply "notional severance": reading down the agreement so that the lender receives interest at the highest lawful rate, rather than declaring the whole contract void. Relevant factors include whether the purpose of the statute would be undermined, whether the parties intended to break the law, their relative bargaining positions and whether the lender would be unjustly enriched.

In commercial dealings between sophisticated parties, courts have generally preferred to read down, because voiding the whole agreement would give the borrower a windfall. Savings clauses help, but they are not decisive: a court may decline to give effect to a clause in a predatory consumer loan.

Good drafting practice includes:

  • specifying the order in which charges are reduced (for example, exit fees first, then default interest, then other fees);
  • stating that the APR will be calculated actuarially over the term of the credit, consistent with s. 347;
  • providing for refund or credit of any overpayment;
  • making the clause apply in all scenarios, including prepayment and acceleration; and
  • confirming that the borrower is not a natural person and the purpose is commercial where the regulatory exemption is relied on, with representations to that effect.

Illustration (hypothetical): a fintech lender advances CAD 250,000 to an incorporated restaurant for equipment. The APR on scheduled repayment is 29%, but a 5% prepayment fee would push the APR above 48% if the loan were repaid in the first three months. Because the loan is between CAD 10,000 and CAD 500,000, the 48% cap governs the exemption. The lender caps the prepayment fee so the APR stays at or below 48% in every scenario, and keeps a savings clause as a backstop.

Provincial consumer credit and other limits

The criminal interest rate is a ceiling, not a licence. Provincial consumer protection and cost of borrowing legislation imposes disclosure requirements, cancellation rights and sometimes rate limits on high-cost credit to individuals, and several provinces license high-cost lenders. Federally regulated banks must also comply with the cost of borrowing disclosure rules under the Bank Act. Mortgage lenders and brokers are licensed provincially, and the federal Interest Act imposes separate disclosure and prepayment rules for some loans. A product that complies with s. 347 can still breach these regimes.

Fintech products and recharacterization

Some fintech products are structured as something other than a loan: merchant cash advances that purchase a share of future receivables, revenue-based financing, buy-now-pay-later plans and earned wage access. Whether s. 347 applies depends on whether, in substance, there is an "agreement or arrangement" for the advancing of credit. Courts look past labels.

If the provider has recourse to the business or its owners regardless of whether the receivables materialize, or if fixed amounts are payable on a schedule, the product may be treated as credit, and its effective cost can easily exceed the criminal interest rate when measured as an APR over a short term. Providers should document the true risk transfer, avoid personal guarantees of repayment (as opposed to performance) where possible, and consider whether the commercial exemption applies to their customers.

How TRW & Co helps with the criminal interest rate

We advise lenders, fintechs, private credit funds and borrowers on the criminal interest rate and related cost-of-credit rules. That includes reviewing pricing and fee structures, applying the commercial exemptions, drafting savings clauses and representations, assessing legacy loans under the transitional rule, and advising on disputes where a borrower alleges a criminal rate. Where an actuarial certificate or a court proceeding is needed, we work with Canadian actuaries and licensed Canadian counsel. Our lending and fintech work covers related issues; see also our notes on the Interest Act and private credit. To discuss a product or loan, contact us. This note is general information, not legal advice.

Frequently asked questions

What is the criminal interest rate in Canada now?

Since 1 January 2025, it is an annual percentage rate, calculated using generally accepted actuarial practices and principles, that exceeds 35% on the credit advanced. Previously it was an effective annual rate above 60%. The change was made by the Budget Implementation Act, 2023, No. 1.

Which commercial loans are exempt?

Under the Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, s. 347 does not apply where the borrower is not a natural person, the borrowing is for a business or commercial purpose, and either the credit advanced exceeds CAD 500,000, or it is over CAD 10,000 and up to CAD 500,000 with an APR not exceeding 48%.

Do fees count towards the criminal interest rate?

Yes. Interest is defined as all charges and expenses paid or payable for the advancing of credit, including fees, fines, penalties and commissions. Upfront fees, prepayment premiums, exit fees and default interest are all counted. Only listed items such as insurance charges, official fees and required deposit balances are excluded.

Does the 35% limit apply to loans made before 2025?

Generally not. Under the transitional provision, the new definition does not apply to interest received on or after 1 January 2025 under an agreement made before that date if the interest would not have been criminal under the former 60% definition. Amendments or new advances may need fresh analysis.

Will a court void a loan that exceeds the criminal rate?

Not necessarily. In Transport North American Express Inc. v. New Solutions Financial Corp., 2004 SCC 7, the Supreme Court confirmed that courts may apply notional severance and read the agreement down to a lawful rate. The outcome depends on factors such as the parties' intent and bargaining power; savings clauses help but are not decisive.

Sources

  1. Criminal Code, s. 347 (criminal interest rate)
  2. Criminal Interest Rate Regulations, SOR/2024-114
  3. Canada Gazette Part II: SOR/2024-114 and Regulatory Impact Analysis Statement
  4. Budget Implementation Act, 2023, No. 1, S.C. 2023, c. 26 (ss. 610-615)
  5. SCC case information: Transport North American Express Inc. v. New Solutions Financial Corp. (docket 29355)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.