Time of the Essence Clauses in Canadian Contracts
A time of the essence clause turns contractual deadlines into conditions, so a missed closing can end the deal and forfeit the deposit. Canadian courts enforce these clauses strictly but police waiver, tender and forfeiture. The Supreme Court is now considering how they apply to obligations without fixed dates.

Key takeaways
- Time of the essence clauses allow termination for missing a deadline, even by minutes.
- The terminating party must itself be ready, willing and able to perform.
- Extensions and conduct can waive strict compliance; reinstatement needs clear, reasonable notice.
- Ontario courts may relieve against forfeiture under s. 98 of the Courts of Justice Act.
- The SCC heard Cold Ocean Salmon on 14 October 2026 and reserved judgment.
- Draft outside dates expressly rather than relying on vague promptness obligations.
What "time of the essence" means
A "time of the essence" clause makes contractual deadlines conditions of the contract rather than mere warranties. If a party fails to perform by the stipulated time, the other party may treat the contract as at an end, even if the delay is short and causes no loss.

Without such a clause, courts traditionally treat a missed date in many commercial contracts as a breach sounding only in damages, unless the delay is so serious that it deprives the innocent party of substantially the whole benefit of the contract. Time of the essence clauses are standard in Canadian agreements of purchase and sale of real estate and common in share and asset purchase agreements, options and financing documents.
The consequences are significant and sometimes harsh, which is why courts police the edges: waiver, reinstatement, tender, relief from forfeiture and the interaction with obligations that have no fixed date. That last issue is now before the Supreme Court of Canada in Cold Ocean Salmon Inc. v. Nova Fish Farms Inc., heard on 14 October 2026. This insight explains how these clauses operate and what parties should do now. It is general information, not legal advice.
Strict compliance with time of the essence clauses
Where time is of the essence, compliance is strict. A purchaser who is not ready to close at the stipulated time on the closing date, or a vendor who cannot deliver good title, is in breach of a condition, and the other party may terminate. Courts have enforced these clauses even where the defaulting party was only minutes late, on the basis that commercial certainty requires that parties be able to rely on bright-line deadlines. The leading common-law authority often cited is the Privy Council's decision in Union Eagle Ltd. v. Golden Achievement Ltd. (1997), where a purchaser who tendered ten minutes late lost its deposit and the deal.
Strict enforcement has limits. The party seeking to terminate must itself be ready, willing and able to close, and must not have caused or contributed to the delay. Where both parties are in default at the closing time, neither can terminate on the other's default, and strict timing may fall away until reinstated.
| Situation | General rule | Practical consequence |
|---|---|---|
| One party misses a time-of-the-essence deadline; the other is ready | Innocent party may terminate | Deposit and deal may be lost |
| Both parties are not ready at the deadline | Neither may terminate on that default | New date must be set with reasonable notice |
| Party grants extension or keeps negotiating after deadline | Possible waiver of strict compliance | Time must be reinstated by clear notice |
| Obligation has no fixed date (e.g. "as promptly as practicable") | Unsettled; issue before the SCC in Cold Ocean Salmon | Draft outside dates expressly |
Waiver and reinstatement
Strict compliance can be waived, expressly or by conduct. A party that agrees to extend the closing, accepts late performance, or continues to treat the contract as alive after a missed deadline may lose the right to terminate for that default. Many agreements address this risk by providing that time remains of the essence for any extended date, and that extensions must be in writing.
Once waived, strict compliance can be reinstated, but only by clear notice that sets a new, reasonable date for performance. In Saskatchewan River Bungalows Ltd. v. Maritime Life Assurance Co., [1994] 2 S.C.R. 490, the Supreme Court discussed waiver in the context of an insurance policy, holding that waiver requires full knowledge of rights and an unequivocal and conscious intention to abandon them, and that a party who has waived a requirement may reinstate it by reasonable notice. The same logic is applied in commercial and real estate settings.
If you agree to an extension, say expressly in writing that time remains of the essence and that all other terms are unchanged. If you are on the receiving end of a missed deadline and want to preserve your right to terminate, do not engage in conduct, such as continued negotiations on other terms, that could be read as affirming the contract without a reservation of rights.
Tender: proving readiness to close
A party that wants to terminate or sue for specific performance should generally prove that it was ready, willing and able to perform at the stipulated time, often by tender. In real estate transactions, tender traditionally meant attending with the closing funds and documents; with electronic registration, tender is usually made by delivering closing documents and confirmation of funds through counsel, with a written tender letter. Tender is excused where it would be futile, for example where the other side has clearly repudiated, but relying on futility is risky.
Electronic closings add their own timing risks: wire transfers can be delayed, land registry systems can be unavailable, and escrow arrangements between lawyers may leave it unclear who was ready when. Agreements and closing protocols should say what happens in those cases.
Evidence of tender is often decisive in later litigation over deposits and specific performance. Parties should keep records of the closing timeline, communications with the other side and the status of funds and documents at the relevant time.
Relief from forfeiture
Courts have an equitable and, in Ontario, a statutory power under s. 98 of the Courts of Justice Act to grant relief against penalties and forfeitures on terms. A purchaser who loses a large deposit or a valuable option because of a minor delay may ask the court for relief.
Courts consider the conduct of the party seeking relief, the gravity of the breach and the disparity between the value of what is forfeited and the damage caused. Relief is more readily granted where the forfeited amount is disproportionate to any loss and the breach was not wilful, and less readily in time-critical commercial deals between sophisticated parties. Deposits that are a genuine pre-estimate or reasonable earnest money are generally retained; amounts far exceeding that may be recoverable as penalties. See our insight on relief from forfeiture in commercial leases.
Indefinite obligations: the Cold Ocean Salmon appeal
A harder question is how a time of the essence clause applies to obligations with no fixed deadline. According to the Supreme Court's case summary, Cold Ocean Salmon agreed in February 2020 to sell trout farms to Nova Fish Farms. The agreement had no fixed or outside closing date: closing was to occur seven days after conditions, including government approval, were satisfied. Each party was to take steps to obtain approval "as promptly as practicable" and use commercially reasonable efforts. The agreement said time was of the essence. Nova Fish did not apply for transfer approval until June 2021; approval came in October 2021, and Cold Ocean declined to close in May 2022.
At a summary trial, the judge found that Nova Fish had breached the promptness and efforts obligations and that the clause entitled Cold Ocean to terminate without first prompting Nova Fish to perform. The Court of Appeal of Newfoundland and Labrador reversed (2025 NLCA 28). The Supreme Court granted leave and heard the appeal on 14 October 2026, reserving judgment. The questions include whether the clause was interpreted as an extricable question of law in isolation from the agreement and its factual matrix, and whether, under the modern approach to interpretation set out in Sattva, a time of the essence clause can apply to a contextual temporal obligation where the parties so intend.
Until judgment, parties should assume that a time of the essence clause may not by itself allow termination for breach of a vague timing obligation, and should draft outside dates and notice-and-cure mechanisms expressly.
Remedies after a missed deadline
When a deal fails because of a missed deadline, the dispute usually turns to remedies. The innocent party that validly terminates may keep a deposit, subject to relief from forfeiture, and may sue for damages, typically measured by the difference between the contract price and the market value or resale price, plus reasonable carrying costs. A party that wrongly purports to terminate is itself in repudiatory breach and may face a claim for specific performance or damages.
Specific performance is available for land only where the property has unique value to the purchaser or damages are inadequate; courts no longer presume that every parcel of land is unique. Purchasers seeking specific performance should register a certificate of pending litigation promptly to protect their position, and must show they remained ready and willing to complete throughout.
Deadlines in M&A and financing agreements
In share and asset purchase agreements, the key timing provisions are usually the outside date, after which either party may terminate if closing has not occurred, and the conditions precedent that must be satisfied or waived by then. Regulatory approvals, such as Competition Act and Investment Canada Act clearances, often drive timing, and well-drafted agreements allocate the risk of delay through efforts covenants, automatic extensions for pending approvals and reverse termination fees. In financing documents, payment and reporting deadlines are typically tied to events of default with grace periods, which provide a structured alternative to strict termination. Parties should ensure these mechanisms and any clause making timing essential are consistent.
Drafting time of the essence clauses
- State fixed dates and times for key steps, including an outside date for satisfaction of conditions and for each party's filings with regulators.
- Specify the consequences of missing each date: automatic termination, a termination right, or a cure period.
- Confirm that time remains of the essence for any extended date and that extensions must be in writing.
- Define "business day" and time zones, especially for cross-border deals, and set a precise closing time on the closing date.
- Provide a mechanism for extending dates when land registration or payment systems are unavailable, so that a system outage does not trigger a termination right.
- Coordinate the timing clause with conditions precedent, best-efforts covenants and termination provisions so they work together.
- Address deposits explicitly, including when they are forfeited, whether they are the sole remedy, and who holds them in trust pending closing.
For broader drafting points in M&A, see our page on mergers and acquisitions, and for real estate deals, commercial real estate.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise buyers, sellers, lenders and landlords on time of the essence clauses in Canadian contracts. Our work includes drafting closing mechanics, outside dates and extension letters, advising on termination rights when a deadline is missed, preparing tender documentation, assessing relief from forfeiture and deposit disputes, and monitoring the Supreme Court's decision in Cold Ocean Salmon for its effect on existing agreements. Where litigation requires counsel licensed in a province, we work with locally licensed litigation counsel. To discuss a closing or dispute, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What happens if a party misses a deadline where time is of the essence?
The other party may treat the contract as terminated, provided it was itself ready, willing and able to perform and did not cause the delay. In real estate transactions, this often means the defaulting purchaser loses the deal and possibly the deposit, subject to relief from forfeiture.
Can time of the essence be waived?
Yes. Granting an extension, accepting late performance or continuing to treat the contract as alive can waive strict compliance. Waiver requires knowledge of the right and an unequivocal intention to give it up. Time can then be reinstated only by clear notice setting a new, reasonable date.
Do I need to tender to keep my rights?
Generally, a party seeking to terminate or sue for specific performance should show it was ready, willing and able to close, usually by tender. Tender may be excused if futile, for example after a clear repudiation, but relying on that exception is risky.
What is the Cold Ocean Salmon case about?
It concerns whether a time of the essence clause allowed a seller to terminate a fish-farm sale for the buyer's failure to seek government approval as promptly as practicable, where there was no fixed closing date. The Supreme Court heard the appeal from 2025 NLCA 28 on 14 October 2026 and reserved judgment.
Can a court relieve a buyer from losing a deposit?
Possibly. Courts can grant relief from forfeiture, considering the conduct of the party seeking relief, the gravity of the breach and the disproportion between the forfeiture and the loss. Relief is harder to obtain in time-critical deals between sophisticated parties.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


