Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Interlocutory Injunctions in Commercial Disputes

Interlocutory injunctions can stop a competitor, preserve a contract or halt a transaction long before trial. This guide explains the RJR-MacDonald test, the strong prima facie case required for mandatory orders after R. v. CBC, undertakings as to damages, worldwide orders against non-parties and injunctions protecting infrastructure from blockades.

Courtroom hearing on interlocutory injunctions in a Canadian commercial dispute

Key takeaways

  • Courts apply RJR-MacDonald: serious question, irreparable harm, balance of convenience.
  • Mandatory orders require a strong prima facie case (R. v. CBC, 2018 SCC 5).
  • Moving parties usually undertake to pay damages if the order proves wrong.
  • Ontario without-notice injunctions last at most ten days unless extended on notice.
  • Worldwide orders against non-parties are possible (Equustek, 2017 SCC 34).

What interlocutory injunctions do in commercial disputes

Interlocutory injunctions are court orders that preserve the position between the parties until a dispute is decided on its merits. In commercial cases they are used to stop a former employee from using confidential information, to prevent a supplier from cutting off a critical input, to restrain a share issuance or asset sale, or to keep a counterparty performing a contract while the parties litigate. Because they are granted before the facts are tested at trial, interlocutory injunctions are powerful and are subject to a structured test designed to limit the risk of injustice.

Courtroom hearing on interlocutory injunctions in a Canadian commercial dispute
Interlocutory injunctions preserve the status quo until trial, but the moving party must usually promise to pay damages if it turns out to be wrong.

The jurisdiction is statutory and equitable. In Ontario, s. 101(1) of the Courts of Justice Act allows the Superior Court of Justice to grant an interlocutory injunction or mandatory order "where it appears to a judge of the court to be just or convenient to do so", and Rule 40 of the Rules of Civil Procedure sets the procedure. Other provinces and the Federal Court have equivalent provisions. Across Canada, the substantive test comes from the Supreme Court of Canada.

The RJR-MacDonald three-part test

In RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1994] 1 S.C.R. 311, the Supreme Court of Canada confirmed a three-stage test that the Court later summarized in R. v. Canadian Broadcasting Corp., 2018 SCC 5 (para. 12):

  1. Serious question to be tried. A preliminary assessment of the merits to ensure the claim is neither frivolous nor vexatious. The threshold is low.
  2. Irreparable harm. Whether the applicant would suffer harm that cannot be quantified in money or cured by damages if the injunction were refused.
  3. Balance of convenience. Which party would suffer greater harm from granting or refusing the injunction pending a decision on the merits, including any public-interest considerations.

Courts do not apply the stages mechanically. A strong case on the merits can compensate for weaker evidence of irreparable harm, and the balance of convenience often decides close cases. In restrictive covenant disputes, many courts require a strong prima facie case at the first stage, because the injunction may effectively decide the dispute by the time a trial occurs. Interlocutory injunctions that would effectively end the litigation in this way are treated with particular caution.

Irreparable harm in commercial cases

Irreparable harm is often the hardest element for businesses to prove. Lost profits are usually compensable in damages, so a moving party must show something more: loss of market share that cannot be measured, permanent damage to reputation or goodwill, loss of a unique asset or opportunity, destruction of a business, or a defendant that will not be able to pay damages. The evidence must be clear and specific; general assertions of harm in an affidavit are not enough.

Mandatory interlocutory injunctions after R. v. CBC

Where the order sought would require the defendant to do something, rather than refrain from doing something, the first stage is stricter. In R. v. Canadian Broadcasting Corp., decided 9 February 2018, the Supreme Court held that an applicant for a mandatory interlocutory injunction must show a strong prima facie case, meaning "a strong likelihood on the law and the evidence presented that, at trial, the applicant will be ultimately successful" (para. 18). The irreparable harm and balance of convenience stages are unchanged.

The characterization question is substantive, not formal. Courts look at the practical effect of the order, not how the notice of motion is worded. An order requiring a supplier to keep delivering under a terminated contract, to reinstate access to a software platform or to remove online content is mandatory in substance, even if it is framed as an order "restraining" the supplier from refusing to deliver.

Type of orderFirst-stage thresholdTypical commercial use
Prohibitive interlocutory injunctionSerious question to be triedRestraining use of confidential information, a share issuance or a sale
Prohibitive injunction that will effectively decide the caseOften a strong prima facie case in practiceEnforcing non-solicitation or non-competition covenants
Mandatory interlocutory injunctionStrong prima facie case (R. v. CBC, 2018 SCC 5)Compelling continued supply, reinstating access, delivering up property
Interim injunction without noticeSame test plus full and frank disclosure; maximum 10 days in Ontario (r. 40.02)Urgent cases where notice would defeat the purpose

Undertakings as to damages

The price of interlocutory relief is usually an undertaking as to damages. Rule 40.03 of Ontario's Rules of Civil Procedure provides that, unless the court orders otherwise, the moving party must undertake to abide by any order concerning damages the court may make if it later appears that the injunction caused damage to the responding party for which the moving party ought to compensate it. Other jurisdictions apply the same principle.

Companies seeking an injunction should treat the undertaking as a real liability. If the injunction delays a competitor's product launch, freezes a transaction or interrupts a supply chain, and the moving party loses at trial, the damages inquiry can be substantial. A foreign plaintiff with no assets in Canada may be asked to fortify the undertaking with security. Conversely, a responding party should put evidence of its potential losses before the court at the injunction hearing, because that evidence affects both the balance of convenience and the court's assessment of the undertaking's adequacy.

Courts can dispense with the undertaking, but they rarely do so in commercial cases between private parties. Public authorities, and some public-interest litigants, may be treated differently.

Practical point

Speed is evidence. A party that waits weeks after learning of the conduct before moving for an injunction will struggle to persuade a court that the harm is urgent and irreparable. Build the evidentiary record, including expert or financial evidence of irreparable harm, in parallel with the decision to sue, and be ready to move within days.

Worldwide orders and injunctions against non-parties

Canadian courts can grant interlocutory injunctions with effects outside Canada and against non-parties. In Google Inc. v. Equustek Solutions Inc., 2017 SCC 34, decided on 28 June 2017, the Supreme Court upheld a worldwide interlocutory injunction requiring Google, which was not a party to the underlying dispute, to de-index websites through which the defendants were selling products in breach of court orders. The Court applied the RJR-MacDonald test and held that where the infringing conduct takes place globally, an injunction with global reach may be necessary to make the remedy effective.

For businesses, Equustek has two implications. Plaintiffs can sometimes enlist platforms, banks or other intermediaries to make an injunction effective, and intermediaries can find themselves subject to Canadian orders in disputes they have no stake in. Intermediaries served with such a motion should engage early, both to raise any conflict with foreign law and to shape the terms of the order. The same reasoning underlies the use of worldwide freezing orders discussed in our insight on Mareva injunctions and Anton Piller orders.

Infrastructure and protest injunctions

Owners and operators of pipelines, mines, rail lines, ports and construction projects regularly seek injunctions against blockades and protests that obstruct access to their sites. These cases apply the same test but raise distinctive issues. Defendants are often unnamed ("John Doe" or "persons unknown"), so courts scrutinize service and notice. Orders frequently include enforcement provisions authorizing police to arrest and remove persons who breach them, which courts grant only where they are necessary. The balance of convenience can engage the public interest, including the constitutional rights of protesters and, where Indigenous rights and title are asserted, the Crown's duty to consult and the honour of the Crown. Our Indigenous law work addresses that intersection.

Breach of an injunction is enforced through contempt proceedings. Civil contempt must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt, and courts have stressed that an injunction must be clear enough for a person to know what conduct is prohibited. Project proponents should therefore seek orders that are specific about locations, conduct and duration, and should document service carefully.

Illustration: a hypothetical mining company's haul road is blocked by a group opposing an expansion. The company moves without notice for an interim order and obtains a ten-day injunction under Rule 40.02, then returns on notice for an interlocutory injunction. At that hearing, the court considers evidence of the economic harm and safety risks of the blockade, the protesters' rights, the state of consultation with an affected First Nation and whether a narrower order would suffice. The result is an order limited to the road and its access points, with an enforcement clause and a requirement to post the order at the site.

Resisting interlocutory injunctions

Responding parties often have only days to prepare, but a disciplined response can defeat or narrow the order. The main lines of defence are:

  • Delay. Evidence that the moving party knew of the conduct for weeks or months undermines urgency and irreparable harm.
  • Adequacy of damages. Showing that the moving party's losses are measurable, and that the responding party can pay, goes to the heart of the second stage.
  • Characterization. Arguing that the order sought is mandatory in substance raises the bar to a strong prima facie case.
  • Breadth. Even where some relief is justified, courts tailor orders. Offering a narrower undertaking, such as segregating disputed funds or ring-fencing confidential information, can persuade the court that a broad injunction is unnecessary.
  • Disclosure failures. Where an interim order was obtained without notice, any failure to make full and frank disclosure can justify setting it aside, regardless of the merits.
  • Clean hands and contractual allocation. Equitable relief can be refused where the moving party's own conduct is improper, and commercial contracts sometimes limit remedies or set out exclusive dispute mechanisms that bear on the balance of convenience.

Timetabling matters too. Courts sometimes resolve a motion by ordering an expedited trial instead of a long interlocutory hearing, especially where the injunction would effectively decide the dispute. Offering an early trial date can be an effective response, because it reduces the harm the moving party can show from waiting. Where arbitration agreements apply, the parties should consider whether interim measures should be sought from the arbitral tribunal or the court, and how any order will be enforced.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise companies seeking or resisting interlocutory injunctions as part of our commercial litigation practice. That includes urgent assessments of whether the test can be met, building evidence of irreparable harm and balance of convenience, drafting undertakings and assessing exposure under them, defending applications for mandatory relief, advising platforms and banks served with third-party orders, and advising project proponents on access and protest injunctions. Court applications in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel, and we work alongside them. This page is general information rather than legal advice. If you need urgent relief or have been served, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What test applies to interlocutory injunctions in Canada?

Courts apply the three-part test from RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1994] 1 S.C.R. 311: a serious question to be tried, irreparable harm if the injunction is refused, and a balance of convenience favouring the order. For mandatory injunctions, the first stage requires a strong prima facie case.

When is an injunction mandatory rather than prohibitive?

When, in substance, it requires the defendant to take positive action, such as continuing to supply goods, restoring access to a system or removing content. Courts look at the practical effect of the order rather than its wording, as the Supreme Court explained in R. v. Canadian Broadcasting Corp., 2018 SCC 5.

Do I have to give an undertaking as to damages?

Usually yes. In Ontario, Rule 40.03 requires the moving party to undertake to abide by any order concerning damages caused by the injunction unless the court orders otherwise. If the injunction was wrongly granted, the responding party can recover its losses, which may be significant in commercial cases.

Can I get an injunction without notifying the other side?

In urgent cases, or where notice would defeat the purpose of the order, a court can grant an interim injunction without notice. In Ontario, such an order lasts no more than ten days unless extended on notice (Rule 40.02), and the moving party must make full and frank disclosure of all material facts, including those unfavourable to it.

Can a Canadian court order a non-party abroad to comply with an injunction?

In Google Inc. v. Equustek Solutions Inc., 2017 SCC 34, the Supreme Court upheld a worldwide interlocutory injunction against a non-party that was facilitating the defendants' wrongdoing. Such orders are exceptional and depend on the facts, including any conflict with foreign law.

Sources

  1. R. v. Canadian Broadcasting Corp., 2018 SCC 5
  2. Supreme Court of Canada docket 36602 (Google Inc. v. Equustek Solutions Inc.)
  3. Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 101
  4. Rules of Civil Procedure, R.R.O. 1990, Reg. 194, Rule 40

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.