Arbitral Award Appeals and Set-Aside Applications
Arbitral award appeals in Canada are narrow by design, but the standard of review for those that are allowed is unsettled. With the Supreme Court granting leave in Buffalo Point in July 2026, parties should understand statutory appeal rights, set-aside grounds and how to draft clauses that deliver the finality they want.

Key takeaways
- Domestic statutes allow limited appeals, mostly on questions of law with leave or consent.
- International awards under Model Law statutes can only be set aside, never appealed on the merits.
- Ontario appeals and set-aside applications must start within 30 days of receiving the award.
- Courts split on correctness versus reasonableness after Vavilov.
- The SCC granted leave in Buffalo Point (2025 MBCA 72) on 23 July 2026.
- Clear drafting on appeals avoids litigation about whether an appeal exists.
Arbitral award appeals in brief
Arbitral award appeals in Canada depend first on the type of arbitration. Domestic commercial arbitrations are governed by provincial arbitration statutes that allow limited appeals, usually only on questions of law and often only with leave or the parties' consent. International commercial arbitrations are governed by provincial statutes adopting the UNCITRAL Model Law, which permit no appeal on the merits at all: the only recourse is an application to set aside the award on narrow grounds such as lack of jurisdiction, procedural unfairness or public policy.

Within those channels, the hardest question in recent years has been the standard of review a court should apply when a statutory appeal is available.
That question is now before the Supreme Court of Canada. On 23 July 2026, the Court granted leave to appeal from the Manitoba Court of Appeal's decision in Buffalo Point First Nation v. Buffalo Point Cottage Owners Association Inc., 2025 MBCA 72, according to the SCC docket for file 42053. This insight explains the current framework, the split the Court is expected to address, and how parties should draft and litigate in the meantime. It is general information, not legal advice.
Statutory appeal rights in domestic arbitration
Each province has its own domestic arbitration statute, and the differences matter.
Ontario
Under s. 45 of Ontario's Arbitration Act, 1991, if the arbitration agreement does not deal with appeals on questions of law, a party may appeal on a question of law with leave. Leave is granted only if the importance of the matters at stake justifies an appeal and the determination of the question will significantly affect the parties' rights (s. 45(1)). If the agreement so provides, a party may appeal on a question of law, or on questions of fact or mixed fact and law (s. 45(2)-(3)).
The court may confirm, vary or set aside the award, or remit it (s. 45(5)). An appeal or set-aside application must be commenced within 30 days after the appellant receives the award (s. 47(1)), unless corruption or fraud is alleged.
British Columbia
British Columbia's Arbitration Act, S.B.C. 2020, c. 2, sends appeals directly to the Court of Appeal. Section 59 provides that there is no appeal from an award other than under that section, and that a party may appeal on any question of law arising out of the award if all parties consent or a justice of the Court of Appeal grants leave. A party may seek leave unless the arbitration agreement expressly excludes appeals.
Other provinces and Quebec
Alberta, Manitoba and other common-law provinces have similar leave-based appeal regimes with their own conditions. Quebec is different: the Code of Civil Procedure does not provide for an appeal of an arbitral award on the merits; recourse is limited to annulment on grounds modelled on the New York Convention.
| Regime | Appeal on the merits? | Set-aside or annulment | Key time limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ontario domestic (Arbitration Act, 1991) | Question of law with leave, unless agreement deals with appeals; broader if agreement provides | s. 46 grounds (incapacity, invalid agreement, excess of jurisdiction, unfairness, bias, fraud, etc.) | 30 days from receipt of award (s. 47) |
| BC domestic (Arbitration Act, 2020) | Question of law with consent or Court of Appeal leave, unless expressly excluded | s. 58 grounds | Set by the Act; check promptly |
| International (Model Law statutes, e.g. Ontario ICAA, 2017) | No | Article 34 grounds only | Three months from receipt of award (art. 34(3)) |
| Quebec | No | Annulment under the Code of Civil Procedure | Short statutory delay |
Do "final and binding" clauses exclude arbitral award appeals?
Many arbitration clauses say the award will be "final and binding". Whether that language excludes arbitral award appeals depends on the statute. Under Ontario's s. 45(1), a leave-based appeal on a question of law exists only where the agreement "does not deal with appeals on questions of law". Courts have reached different results on whether "final and binding", without more, deals with appeals, and the outcome often turns on the rest of the clause and the institutional rules incorporated by reference. Wording stating that there shall be no appeal is far more reliable.
British Columbia's s. 59(3) requires that the agreement "expressly" state that parties may not appeal. In Uber Technologies Inc. v. Heller, 2020 SCC 16, the Supreme Court also showed that arbitration clauses can be set aside entirely where they are unconscionable, a reminder that drafting choices are reviewable.
If you want certainty, say so expressly. A clause that states "there shall be no appeal from the award on any question of law, fact or mixed fact and law" excludes statutory appeals more reliably than "final and binding". If you want appellate review, specify the scope (law only, or also fact) and the forum.
The standard of review for arbitral award appeals
Before 2019, the Supreme Court held in Sattva Capital Corp. v. Creston Moly Corp., 2014 SCC 53, and Teal Cedar Products Ltd. v. British Columbia, 2017 SCC 32, that commercial arbitral awards appealed under statute were generally reviewed for reasonableness, with correctness reserved for exceptional questions. Contractual interpretation was treated as a question of mixed fact and law, so most disputes could not even reach the appeal stage.
Then came Canada (Minister of Citizenship and Immigration) v. Vavilov, 2019 SCC 65. Vavilov held, in the administrative law context, that where a legislature provides a statutory appeal, courts apply appellate standards: correctness for questions of law and palpable and overriding error for questions of fact and mixed fact and law.
Because arbitration statutes also create statutory appeals, many courts reasoned that the Vavilov logic displaced Sattva, and applied correctness to questions of law in arbitral award appeals. In Wastech Services Ltd. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District, 2021 SCC 7, the Supreme Court decided the case on a correctness basis without resolving whether Vavilov governs commercial arbitration.
The Manitoba Court of Appeal took a different view in Buffalo Point, 2025 MBCA 72 (12 August 2025), holding that the reasonableness standard from Sattva and Teal Cedar continues to apply to appeals of commercial arbitral awards. The resulting split is what the Supreme Court has agreed to hear. The SCC docket shows the appellants' factum filed on 26 October 2026 and the respondent's materials due by 21 December 2026, so a hearing and decision are likely in 2027.
Why the answer matters
- Correctness gives appellate courts more room to substitute their own reading of the contract or law, which increases the value of an appeal right.
- Reasonableness preserves the arbitrator's decision unless it falls outside the range of acceptable outcomes, reinforcing finality.
- The answer will influence how parties draft appeal clauses, whether they choose arbitration over litigation, and how much they invest in reasons-focused advocacy before the tribunal.
What the Supreme Court may decide
The Court has several options. It could extend Vavilov's appellate-standards reasoning to arbitration, so that questions of law are reviewed for correctness whenever a statute provides an appeal. It could confirm Sattva's reasonableness approach on the basis that commercial arbitrators are chosen by the parties for their expertise and that party autonomy supports deference. Or it could draw distinctions, for example between appeals the parties expressly agreed to and appeals available only with leave.
The Court has declined earlier invitations: its docket shows that leave to appeal was dismissed in the British Columbia case of Escape 101 Ventures Inc. in April 2023. The grant of leave in Buffalo Point suggests the Court now considers the issue ripe.
Whatever the outcome, the decision will not change the narrow scope of set-aside applications or the absence of merits appeals for international awards. Its main effect will be on domestic commercial arbitrations, including construction, energy, shareholder and long-term supply disputes, where appeal rights are often preserved by default.
Set-aside grounds for domestic and international awards
Set-aside applications are not appeals. They test the legitimacy of the process, not the correctness of the result. Ontario's s. 46(1) lists grounds including legal incapacity, an invalid arbitration agreement, an award beyond the scope of the agreement, improper tribunal composition, non-arbitrable subject matter, unequal or unfair treatment, non-compliance with the Act, reasonable apprehension of bias, and fraud. Courts will not set aside on certain grounds if the applicant waived objections or failed to challenge the arbitrator in time (s. 46(3)-(5)).
For international awards, Article 34 of the Model Law, adopted in Ontario by the International Commercial Arbitration Act, 2017 and in other provinces by parallel statutes, permits set-aside only for incapacity or invalidity, lack of notice or inability to present one's case, excess of mandate, irregular composition or procedure, non-arbitrability or conflict with public policy. Canadian courts have applied these grounds narrowly and have shown deference on jurisdictional findings that turn on the facts. For a broader view of Canadian arbitration practice, see our arbitration in Canada page.
Strategy for arbitral award appeals while the law is unsettled
- Calendar deadlines immediately. Ontario's 30-day limit and the Model Law's three-month limit run from receipt of the award, not from a later decision to challenge it.
- Frame the question of law precisely. Courts will not grant leave for disputes that are really about how the arbitrator weighed the evidence or read the contract as a whole.
- Plead both standards. Until the Supreme Court decides Buffalo Point, argue why the award fails on correctness and why it is unreasonable in any event.
- Consider set-aside in the alternative. Where procedural fairness or jurisdiction is genuinely in issue, a set-aside application may be available even if an appeal is excluded.
- Review the clause for future deals. Update templates to state expressly whether appeals are permitted, on what questions and to which court.
Parties should also plan for enforcement and stays. An appeal or set-aside application does not automatically suspend enforcement; the court has discretion, and the successful party may seek recognition while the challenge is pending. Security for the award amount is a common condition of a stay.
Related issues arise where arbitration is resisted at the outset; see our insight on Uber v. Heller and arbitration clauses. Where enforcement of a foreign award or judgment is the issue, see enforcing foreign judgments in Canada.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise companies and investors on Canadian arbitral award appeals and set-aside applications, and on drafting arbitration clauses that deliver the level of finality the business wants. Our work includes assessing whether an appeal right exists under the governing statute and agreement, framing questions of law for leave applications, preparing set-aside strategies for domestic and international awards, and reviewing template clauses in light of the pending Supreme Court guidance. Where a court application must be brought by counsel licensed in the province, we work with locally licensed litigation counsel. Find more on our disputes practice or contact us to discuss an award.
Frequently asked questions
Can you appeal an arbitration award in Canada?
Sometimes. Domestic arbitration statutes generally allow appeals on questions of law, with leave or with the parties' consent, unless the agreement excludes them. International commercial awards governed by Model Law statutes cannot be appealed on the merits; they can only be set aside on limited grounds such as lack of jurisdiction, unfairness or public policy.
What standard of review applies to arbitral award appeals?
It is unsettled. Many courts applied correctness to questions of law after Vavilov, while the Manitoba Court of Appeal held in 2025 MBCA 72 that Sattva's reasonableness standard still applies to commercial awards. The Supreme Court granted leave in that case on 23 July 2026, so parties should argue both standards until it rules.
Does a 'final and binding' clause exclude appeals?
Not always. In Ontario, the leave-based appeal applies where the agreement does not deal with appeals on questions of law, and courts look for language that actually addresses appeals. BC requires an express statement that the parties may not appeal. Clear wording such as 'no appeal on any question of law, fact or mixed fact and law' is safer.
How long do I have to challenge an award in Ontario?
Under s. 47 of the Arbitration Act, 1991, an appeal or set-aside application must be commenced within 30 days after the party receives the award or the relevant correction or reasons, except where corruption or fraud is alleged. International awards follow the Model Law's three-month limit.
Is a set-aside application the same as an appeal?
No. Set-aside addresses the legitimacy of the process: jurisdiction, fairness, bias, fraud or public policy. An appeal addresses whether the tribunal decided a question correctly or reasonably. A party may have a set-aside remedy even where appeals are excluded.
Sources
- Supreme Court of Canada, case information, docket 42053 (Buffalo Point First Nation v. Buffalo Point Cottage Owners Association Inc.)
- Arbitration Act, 1991, S.O. 1991, c. 17 (Ontario e-Laws)
- Arbitration Act, S.B.C. 2020, c. 2 (BC Laws)
- Supreme Court of Canada, case information, docket 40439 (leave dismissed in Escape 101)
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


