Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Defined Benefit Pension Funding Rules in Canada

Defined benefit pension funding rules decide how much a sponsor must contribute each year to keep promised pensions secure. They differ by jurisdiction, combine going-concern and solvency measures, and interact with surplus ownership and plan amendments. Sponsors need to understand them to manage cash, risk and corporate transactions.

Pension committee reviewing an actuarial valuation for defined benefit pension funding

Key takeaways

  • Funding is measured on a going-concern basis and, in most jurisdictions, a solvency basis.
  • Ontario requires going-concern funding with a provision for adverse deviations and solvency funding to 85%.
  • Quebec funds private plans on a going-concern basis with a stabilization provision rather than full solvency funding.
  • Federally regulated plans fund solvency deficits over five years, with letters of credit permitted within limits.
  • Surplus ownership depends on plan documents and trust law, following Schmidt v. Air Products.
  • Actuarial valuations, funding policies and contribution holidays require careful governance.

How defined benefit pension funding works

A defined benefit (DB) pension plan promises members a pension calculated by formula, usually based on salary and service. The sponsor must fund the plan so that its assets are sufficient to pay the promised benefits. Defined benefit pension funding rules, set by pension standards legislation in each jurisdiction, require periodic actuarial valuations that measure the plan's liabilities and assets and determine the contributions the sponsor must make: normal cost for benefits accruing in the year, plus special payments to amortize any deficit.

Pension committee reviewing an actuarial valuation for defined benefit pension funding
Defined benefit pension funding rules combine going-concern and solvency tests that differ by province.

Two measures dominate. A going-concern valuation assumes the plan continues indefinitely and uses long-term assumptions about returns, salary growth and mortality. A solvency valuation assumes the plan is wound up on the valuation date and measures whether assets would cover benefits if the plan ended. Solvency liabilities are sensitive to interest rates, so solvency deficits can rise sharply when rates fall. Jurisdictions differ in how much weight they give to each measure.

Plans are registered in the jurisdiction where most members work, and that jurisdiction's funding rules generally apply, subject to multi-jurisdictional agreements for members in other provinces. The Income Tax Act also limits contributions and surplus, so funding decisions must respect both pension standards and tax rules.

Ontario's framework

Under Ontario's Pension Benefits Act and its regulations, single-employer DB plans are funded on an enhanced going-concern basis that includes a provision for adverse deviations (PfAD), a reserve calculated by formula that depends on the plan's asset mix and whether it is open or closed. Going-concern deficits, including the PfAD, are amortized over a defined period. Solvency deficits must be funded only to the extent the plan's solvency ratio falls below 85%, which significantly reduced required contributions compared with the earlier full solvency regime. Plans must file valuations at least every three years, or annually if the solvency ratio falls below a threshold.

JurisdictionGoing-concern fundingSolvency funding
OntarioRequired, with a provision for adverse deviationsDeficits funded below 85% solvency
Quebec (private sector)Required, with a stabilization provisionNo solvency deficit funding for most plans; solvency still measured and disclosed
FederalRequiredDeficits funded over five years, using average solvency ratios; letters of credit within limits
Other provincesRequiredVaries; several have moved to reduced or no solvency funding with enhanced going-concern rules

Quebec's stabilization provision

Quebec reformed private-sector DB funding in 2016. Plans are funded on a going-concern basis, with a stabilization provision that builds a reserve against adverse experience. Solvency deficits no longer need to be funded for most private-sector plans, although solvency is still measured and reported, and benefit improvements are restricted when funding is weak. The approach reduces volatility in contributions but places more emphasis on going-concern assumptions and governance. Sponsors with members in Quebec and other provinces must track which rules apply to which members.

Federally regulated plans

Federally regulated DB plans, under the Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985 and its regulations, are subject to both going-concern and solvency funding. Solvency deficits are generally amortized over five years, using an average solvency ratio over three years to smooth volatility. Sponsors may, within limits, satisfy solvency special payments by providing letters of credit held in trust for the plan instead of cash, up to a cap expressed as a percentage of solvency liabilities. OSFI supervises these plans and expects sound funding policies and risk management.

Practical point

Letters of credit preserve corporate liquidity but must be renewed and are a contingent liability for the sponsor. If the sponsor becomes insolvent, the letter of credit can be drawn for the plan's benefit. Treasury and pension teams should coordinate letter of credit capacity with banking facilities and covenants.

Actuarial valuations and assumptions

Valuations are prepared by the plan actuary in accordance with actuarial standards and filed with the regulator and the CRA. Key assumptions include the discount rate, salary growth, mortality and retirement patterns. Sponsors and administrators should understand the assumptions, challenge them where appropriate, and document the reasons for choices that affect contributions. Choosing a valuation date strategically, within the rules, can affect the timing of contributions. Regulators review valuations and can require changes if assumptions are not reasonable.

Funding policies and governance

Regulators expect DB plans to have a written funding policy that sets out the sponsor's objectives, risk tolerance, approach to deficits and surplus, and how contribution decisions are made. The funding policy should align with the investment policy, since asset allocation drives both expected returns and the PfAD in Ontario. Governance should distinguish the sponsor's role in making funding decisions as employer from the administrator's fiduciary role in managing the plan in members' interests.

Surplus and contribution holidays

Surplus raises two questions: whether the sponsor may use it to reduce contributions (a contribution holiday), and who owns it on wind-up. In Schmidt v. Air Products Canada Ltd., [1994] 2 SCR 611, the Supreme Court held that entitlement to surplus depends on the plan documents and, where the fund is held in trust, on trust law.

Where the original trust excluded employer entitlement, later amendments could not give surplus to the employer. Contribution holidays may be permitted where the plan terms allow them and the plan has surplus, subject to statutory restrictions that, in several jurisdictions, depend on funding levels and solvency reserves. Ontario and other jurisdictions have introduced rules on surplus withdrawal that require member consent or regulator approval.

De-risking options

  • Liability-driven investing. Matching asset duration to liabilities to reduce interest rate sensitivity.
  • Annuity purchases. Buying annuities from insurers for retirees to transfer longevity and investment risk; some jurisdictions provide discharge on annuity purchase when conditions are met.
  • Plan closure and conversion. Closing the DB plan to new members or future accrual and moving to DC, subject to notice and bargaining obligations.
  • Plan mergers or transfers. Moving liabilities to another plan, including jointly sponsored or target benefit plans where legislation allows, with regulatory consent.

Interest rates and defined benefit pension funding

Interest rates are the single most important driver of solvency results. When long-term rates fall, the cost of buying annuities or settling benefits rises, so solvency liabilities increase even if nothing else changes. When rates rise, as they did after 2022, solvency positions often improve substantially. Defined benefit pension funding strategies should therefore consider how the plan's assets respond to rate changes. Plans with large allocations to equities and short-duration bonds may see funded status swing widely, while plans using liability-driven investing hedge part of the exposure. Sponsors whose plans moved into surplus after recent rate increases have used the opportunity to purchase annuities or close plans, locking in gains.

Going-concern results are less sensitive to market rates but depend on the actuary's long-term return assumptions, which regulators expect to be consistent with the plan's investment policy. An aggressive return assumption lowers required contributions in the short term but can create deficits later if returns fall short.

Accounting versus funding

Defined benefit pension funding measures differ from the measures used in financial statements. Accounting standards measure the obligation using a discount rate based on high-quality corporate bonds and report the net position on the balance sheet, with remeasurements in other comprehensive income. A plan can therefore show an accounting deficit while having no required solvency payments, or the reverse. Boards and lenders should understand both measures and avoid treating the accounting number as the cash requirement. Credit agreements sometimes include pension-related covenants or reserves that rely on one measure or the other, so definitions in financing documents should be checked.

Multi-employer and target benefit plans

Multi-employer pension plans, common in construction, trucking and other unionized sectors, are usually funded by fixed contributions negotiated in collective agreements, with benefits adjusted if funding falls short. Several provinces have specific funding rules for these plans and for target benefit plans, in which benefits can be reduced if funding deteriorates. Participating employers generally have no obligation beyond their negotiated contributions while the plan continues, but withdrawal and wind-up can raise questions. Our insight on pension issues in M&A discusses how buyers assess these exposures.

Insolvency and deemed trusts

When a sponsor becomes insolvent, unfunded DB liabilities become a major issue. Pension standards legislation creates deemed trusts for certain unpaid contributions, and the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act give priority to unpaid normal cost and certain amounts, while wind-up deficits have been the subject of extensive litigation. Ontario's Pension Benefits Guarantee Fund provides limited protection for some members. For lenders and buyers, the pension deficit is a key credit and valuation consideration.

Transactions

In share purchases, the buyer inherits the plan and its funding obligations. In asset purchases, the buyer may establish a successor plan and arrange a transfer of assets and liabilities, which requires regulatory consent and must protect members' benefits. Purchase price adjustments often reflect the deficit on an agreed basis, and the choice between going-concern and solvency measures can move the price significantly. Our insight on pension issues in M&A explains the structuring.

Member communications and benefit changes

Funding decisions affect members directly. Plan amendments that reduce future accrual, close the plan or change early retirement subsidies require notice to members and, where employees are unionized, bargaining. Accrued benefits are generally protected and cannot be reduced except in limited circumstances, such as certain multi-employer or target benefit arrangements. Annual statements must disclose the plan's funded status in prescribed form, and members are entitled to information about the plan's financial position. Clear communication about funding and any changes reduces the risk of complaints to regulators and litigation.

Where a plan is wound up, the administrator must distribute assets according to statute and plan terms, and members may have options to transfer the commuted value of their benefits or receive annuities. Any wind-up deficit must generally be funded by the sponsor, subject to the applicable rules.

Defined benefit pension funding checklist

  1. Confirm the jurisdiction of registration and the funding rules for each member group.
  2. Maintain a written funding policy aligned with the investment policy.
  3. Review valuation assumptions and timing with the actuary.
  4. Assess letters of credit or other funding tools where permitted.
  5. Track surplus rules and contribution holiday restrictions.
  6. Consider de-risking options and their regulatory requirements.
  7. Document governance decisions, distinguishing sponsor and administrator roles.
  8. Model the funding impact of transactions, plan changes and interest rate scenarios before committing.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise DB plan sponsors and administrators on defined benefit pension funding, funding and investment policies, surplus, contribution holidays, annuity purchases, plan conversions, mergers, insolvency issues and transactions. Our pensions and benefits practice works with our restructuring and M&A teams. See also our insight on defined contribution plan governance. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to discuss your plan.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between going-concern and solvency funding?

A going-concern valuation assumes the plan continues and uses long-term assumptions. A solvency valuation assumes the plan is wound up on the valuation date. Jurisdictions differ in how much each measure drives required contributions.

How does Ontario fund DB plans?

Ontario requires enhanced going-concern funding including a provision for adverse deviations, and requires solvency deficits to be funded only to the extent the solvency ratio is below 85%. Valuations are filed at least every three years, or more often if solvency is low.

Does Quebec require solvency funding?

For most private-sector plans, no. Since 2016, Quebec funds these plans on a going-concern basis with a stabilization provision. Solvency is still measured and disclosed, and weak funding restricts benefit improvements.

Who owns pension surplus?

It depends on the plan documents and, where assets are held in trust, trust law, following Schmidt v. Air Products, [1994] 2 SCR 611. Statutes also regulate surplus withdrawal and contribution holidays, often requiring member consent or regulatory approval.

Can sponsors use letters of credit instead of cash?

In the federal jurisdiction and some provinces, sponsors may satisfy certain solvency special payments with letters of credit held in trust for the plan, within statutory limits. They preserve liquidity but are contingent liabilities that can be drawn on insolvency.

Sources

  1. Pension Benefits Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.8 (Ontario)
  2. Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985 (federal)
  3. Schmidt v. Air Products Canada Ltd., [1994] 2 SCR 611

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.