Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Defined Contribution Plan Governance

Defined contribution pension plans and group RRSPs now cover more Canadian workers than traditional defined benefit plans in the private sector. Members bear the investment risk, but sponsors and administrators still carry governance duties. Good defined contribution plan governance reduces legal risk and improves members' retirement outcomes.

Retirement plan committee meeting on defined contribution plan governance

Key takeaways

  • Registered DC pension plans are governed by pension standards legislation; group RRSPs and TFSAs by contract and general law.
  • The CAP guidelines set expectations for sponsors and service providers of capital accumulation plans.
  • Sponsors must select, monitor and document investment options and default funds.
  • Fee transparency and member communications are core governance obligations.
  • Decumulation options, including variable payment life annuities, are expanding.
  • Poor governance can lead to regulatory orders and member claims.

What defined contribution plan governance covers

In a defined contribution (DC) arrangement, contributions are made to individual member accounts, and the retirement benefit depends on contributions and investment returns. Common forms include registered DC pension plans, group registered retirement savings plans (group RRSPs), deferred profit sharing plans and group tax-free savings accounts. Collectively, they are often called capital accumulation plans (CAPs). Defined contribution plan governance refers to the structures, processes and documentation through which sponsors and administrators make decisions about these plans and oversee service providers.

Retirement plan committee meeting on defined contribution plan governance
Defined contribution plan governance focuses on investment choices, fees and the information members receive.

Because members choose investments within a menu designed by the sponsor, governance focuses on the quality of the menu, the default option for members who do not choose, the fees members pay, and the information and tools they receive. A sponsor that sets up a plan and then leaves it unattended for years may expose itself to regulatory action and claims if members receive poor outcomes because of high fees, inappropriate defaults or misleading information.

Registered DC pension plans are subject to pension standards legislation in the jurisdiction where members are employed, such as the federal Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985 for federally regulated employers or Ontario's Pension Benefits Act. Those statutes impose duties on administrators, including a standard of care equivalent to that of a person of ordinary prudence dealing with another person's property, and in Ontario the requirement to use relevant knowledge and skill that the administrator possesses or ought to possess. They also regulate investment, vesting, locking-in and disclosure. Plans must also comply with the Income Tax Act's registration rules.

Group RRSPs and group TFSAs are not pension plans under pension standards legislation. They are governed by contract, trust and agency principles, securities law where relevant, and the Income Tax Act. They are not locked in unless a contract provides otherwise. Sponsors of these arrangements are still expected to follow good governance practices, and courts and regulators may consider those practices in assessing claims.

The CAP guidelines

The Canadian Association of Pension Supervisory Authorities (CAPSA) publishes guidelines for capital accumulation plans, which set out the responsibilities of sponsors, administrators, service providers and members. The guidelines apply to DC pension plans and to other tax-assisted savings arrangements offered through an employer. They address establishing a plan, selecting service providers, choosing investment options, providing investment information and decision-making tools to members, maintaining records, and reviewing the plan regularly. While guidelines are not law, regulators and courts treat them as evidence of the standard of care.

Governance areaSponsor responsibility
Plan designDefine purpose, eligibility, contributions and plan types offered
Service providersSelect recordkeepers and investment managers through a documented process; monitor performance and fees
Investment menuOffer a reasonable range of options with different risk and return profiles
Default optionSelect an appropriate default, often a target date fund, for members who do not choose
Member informationProvide clear information on options, fees, and decision-making tools
ReviewReview the plan, providers and options periodically and document decisions

Investment menus and default options

A well-designed menu balances choice and simplicity. Too many options confuse members; too few may not suit different risk profiles. Many plans offer a set of target date funds, a small number of index and actively managed funds, and a money market option. The default option is critical, because many members never make an active choice. Target date funds, which shift from growth to more conservative assets as the target retirement date approaches, are the most common default. Sponsors should document why the default is appropriate for their workforce and review it periodically, including its glide path and fees.

Sponsors should also monitor fund performance against benchmarks and peers and be prepared to replace underperforming options. Decisions to retain or replace options should be minuted with reasons. When an option is replaced, members' balances are usually mapped to a comparable fund, and members should receive advance notice explaining the change, the new fund's characteristics and any opportunity to choose differently.

Fees and transparency

Fees have a large cumulative effect on retirement savings. Sponsors should understand the total fees members pay, including investment management, recordkeeping and other charges, and compare them with the market periodically. Group arrangements usually benefit from lower fees than retail products, but only if the sponsor negotiates and reviews them. Fee information should be disclosed to members clearly. In other jurisdictions, excessive fee litigation against DC plan sponsors has been common; Canadian claims have been less frequent, but the governance principles that would be applied in any claim are similar.

Practical point

Set a regular cycle, such as every three to five years, to benchmark recordkeeping and investment fees against the market, and document the outcome. A sponsor that can show it tested the market and negotiated fees is far better placed to defend its decisions than one that renewed the same arrangement for a decade without review.

Member communications and advice

Sponsors must provide information that enables members to make informed decisions: descriptions of investment options, risk and return information, fees, and tools such as retirement projections. Sponsors should avoid providing individualized investment advice unless they intend to accept responsibility for it; most rely on service providers or licensed advisers to deliver education and advice. Communications should be accurate, balanced and accessible, including for members with disabilities or limited financial literacy. Statements of account and pension standards-required disclosures must meet statutory content and timing rules.

Decumulation and retirement income

Historically, DC plans focused on accumulation, leaving members to buy annuities or transfer to retail retirement income funds at retirement. Recent changes broaden options. The Income Tax Regulations now permit variable payment life annuities (VPLAs) under registered DC pension plans and pooled registered pension plans, allowing members to pool longevity risk while receiving variable payments, and the Income Tax Act permits advanced life deferred annuities purchased with registered funds. Several provinces allow variable benefit accounts that pay retirement income directly from DC plans. Sponsors considering these options must assess governance, communication and provider capacity.

Liability for poor governance

Regulators can issue orders, require corrective action and, in some cases, prosecute administrators that breach pension standards legislation. Members may bring claims alleging breach of fiduciary duty, negligence or breach of contract, for example where investment options were imprudent, fees excessive, information misleading or contributions not remitted on time. Late or missing remittances are a recurring compliance issue and may engage deemed trust provisions. Strong defined contribution plan governance, documented at each step, is the best defence.

Data, cybersecurity and recordkeeping

Recordkeepers hold detailed personal and financial information about every member, and errors in data can lead to incorrect contributions, missed vesting or wrong payouts. Defined contribution plan governance therefore includes oversight of data quality and cybersecurity. Sponsors should reconcile payroll and plan data regularly, require recordkeepers to maintain appropriate security controls and breach notification obligations, and review service organization control reports where available. Fraud involving member accounts, such as unauthorized withdrawal requests, is a growing risk, and contracts should allocate responsibility for losses clearly.

Responsible investment and sustainability

Members increasingly ask about environmental, social and governance factors in investment options. Pension standards legislation in several jurisdictions requires the statement of investment policies and procedures for DC pension plans, where applicable, to state whether ESG factors are considered. Sponsors can offer ESG-focused funds as options while remaining focused on prudence, diversification and fees. Defined contribution plan governance should address how such options are selected and monitored, and how their characteristics are described to members, to avoid overstating sustainability claims.

Governance for smaller sponsors

Small and mid-sized employers often lack in-house pension expertise. They can still meet expectations by relying on bundled providers, adopting a simple governance policy, meeting at least annually with the provider and an independent adviser, and documenting decisions. Pooled registered pension plans, offered by licensed administrators in several provinces and federally, can shift much of the administrative burden to a professional administrator, although the employer remains responsible for remitting contributions and for its choice of plan.

Governance structures

Many sponsors establish a pension or retirement plan committee with a written mandate, defined membership, regular meetings and reporting to the board. The committee oversees service providers, the investment menu, fees, communications and compliance. Members should have relevant expertise or access to independent advice. Where the sponsor is also the administrator, as is common, it should manage conflicts of interest between its role as employer, which bears costs, and its role as administrator, which owes duties to members.

Defined contribution plan governance checklist

  1. Adopt a written governance policy and committee mandate.
  2. Maintain an inventory of plans, service providers and contracts.
  3. Document the investment menu, default option and monitoring process.
  4. Benchmark fees periodically and record decisions.
  5. Review member communications for accuracy and accessibility.
  6. Monitor remittance timeliness and data accuracy.
  7. Consider decumulation options and their governance implications.
  8. Review the program at least every few years against the CAP guidelines.
  9. Keep minutes and supporting materials for every committee meeting, and retain them for the life of the plan.
  10. Train committee members on their duties and on conflicts between employer and administrator roles.

Illustration

A manufacturer with 400 employees offers a group RRSP and a DC pension plan through an insurer it selected ten years ago. The plan has 25 fund options, a money market fund as default, and fees that have never been reviewed. A new retirement committee benchmarks the arrangement and finds that fees are well above market and that most members are in the default money market fund, which is unlikely to meet retirement goals.

The committee negotiates lower fees, reduces the menu to a set of target date funds plus a few core options, changes the default to an age-appropriate target date fund after member communication, and adopts a written governance policy with an annual review cycle. Each step is minuted. This is what sound defined contribution plan governance looks like in practice.

Transactions and plan changes

When a business is sold or reorganized, DC plans may be transferred, merged or wound up. Plan mergers require regulatory approvals and member notices; changes in recordkeepers require transition planning to avoid gaps in contributions and blackout periods. In asset sales, buyers must decide whether to offer a comparable plan, since a materially less valuable arrangement may affect employees' decisions and claims. Our insight on pension issues in M&A covers these transitions.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise sponsors, administrators and committees on defined contribution plan governance: plan design, governance policies, service provider agreements, investment menu and default decisions, fee reviews, member communications, decumulation options and regulatory compliance. Our pensions and benefits practice works with our employment law team. See also our insight on defined benefit funding. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your plan.

Frequently asked questions

Are group RRSPs regulated like pension plans?

No. Registered DC pension plans are governed by pension standards legislation. Group RRSPs and group TFSAs are governed by contract, trust and agency principles, securities law where relevant and the Income Tax Act. Sponsors are still expected to follow good governance practices such as the CAP guidelines.

What are the CAP guidelines?

Guidelines published by CAPSA for capital accumulation plans, setting out responsibilities of sponsors, administrators, service providers and members, including service provider selection, investment options, member information and periodic review. They are not law but are treated as evidence of the expected standard.

How should a default investment option be chosen?

Based on a documented assessment of the workforce and the option's design, risk and fees. Target date funds are the most common default. Sponsors should review the default periodically, including its glide path and costs.

Can DC plans pay retirement income directly?

Increasingly, yes. The Income Tax Regulations permit variable payment life annuities in registered DC plans and pooled registered pension plans, and several provinces allow variable benefit accounts. Sponsors must consider governance and communication before offering them.

What exposes sponsors to liability?

Imprudent investment options, excessive fees, misleading communications, poor oversight of providers and late or missing contributions. Regulators can issue orders, and members can bring claims. Documented, regular governance is the best protection.

Sources

  1. Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985 (federal)
  2. Pension Benefits Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. P.8 (Ontario)
  3. Income Tax Regulations, s. 8506 (VPLA)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.