Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Division of Powers: Constitutional Challenges to Business Regulation

The division of powers decides whether Parliament or a province can regulate a business, which labour regime applies and whether a law can be enforced at all. Recent Supreme Court decisions in Opsis (2025) and SGS Canada (2026) show these doctrines remain powerful tools for companies challenging regulation.

Parliament and provincial legislature buildings, illustrating the division of powers over business regulation in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Laws can be challenged for validity, inapplicability (interjurisdictional immunity) or inoperability (paramountcy).
  • Opsis, 2025 SCC 17, held Quebec's Private Security Act inapplicable to airport and marine security firms.
  • SGS Canada, 2026 SCC 37, put grain inspectors serving federal elevators under federal labour law.
  • Corporations cannot claim s. 7 or s. 12 Charter rights as their own.
  • The notwithstanding clause cannot rescue a law outside its government's jurisdiction.
  • Constitutional notices to attorneys general are usually mandatory.

Why the division of powers matters to business

The division of powers in Canada's Constitution decides which level of government can regulate a business activity. Sections 91 and 92 of the Constitution Act, 1867 allocate legislative authority between Parliament and the provincial legislatures: banking, interprovincial transportation, telecommunications, aeronautics, criminal law and trade and commerce to Parliament; property and civil rights, local works and undertakings, and matters of a merely local or private nature to the provinces. When a law strays outside its government's jurisdiction, or collides with a valid law of the other level, a business affected by it can challenge its validity, its applicability or its operability.

Parliament and provincial legislature buildings, illustrating the division of powers over business regulation in Canada
Division of powers arguments can determine which regulator, labour regime and rules apply to a business.

These arguments are not academic. The division of powers determines whether a company's employees fall under the Canada Labour Code or provincial labour law, whether a provincial licensing regime applies to an airport contractor, and whether a national securities or climate scheme can stand. This insight explains the main doctrines (validity, interjurisdictional immunity and paramountcy), federal undertakings, the reference procedure, Charter arguments available to corporations and the notwithstanding clause. It is general information, not legal advice.

Three ways to challenge a law on division of powers grounds

1. Validity: pith and substance

The first question is whether the law, in its dominant purpose and effect (its "pith and substance"), falls within a head of power of the enacting government. Incidental effects on the other government's sphere are acceptable. Major recent examples include References re Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act, 2021 SCC 11, which upheld the federal carbon pricing backstop under the national concern branch of peace, order and good government, and Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23, which held the designated-projects scheme of the federal impact assessment law largely beyond Parliament's jurisdiction while upholding the provisions on federal projects on federal lands.

2. Interjurisdictional immunity

This doctrine protects the core of an exclusive head of power from being impaired by a valid law of the other level of government.

It is applied with restraint after Canadian Western Bank v. Alberta, 2007 SCC 22, but it remains alive. In Opsis Airport Services Inc. v. Quebec (Attorney General), 2025 SCC 17, the Supreme Court unanimously held that Quebec's Private Security Act was inapplicable to enterprises providing airport and marine security services, because applying it would intrude on and impair the core of federal jurisdiction over aeronautics and navigation and shipping. The Court restated the two conditions: intrusion on the core of an exclusive head of power, and impairment of that core.

3. Federal paramountcy

Where valid federal and provincial laws conflict, the federal law prevails and the provincial law is inoperative to the extent of the conflict. Conflict exists where it is impossible to comply with both laws (operational conflict) or where the provincial law frustrates the purpose of the federal law. Paramountcy is significant in insolvency, where provincial regulatory and enforcement schemes can be rendered inoperative if they frustrate the priorities and discharge provisions of federal bankruptcy law; see our insight on Alberta v. Moloney and paramountcy.

DoctrineQuestionResult if successfulRecent example
Validity (pith and substance)Is the law within the enacting government's powers?Law is invalid (ultra vires)Reference re Impact Assessment Act, 2023 SCC 23
Interjurisdictional immunityDoes a valid law impair the core of the other government's exclusive power?Law is inapplicable to the protected activityOpsis, 2025 SCC 17
ParamountcyDoes a valid provincial law conflict with a valid federal law?Provincial law is inoperative to the extent of conflictInsolvency priority cases

Federal undertakings and labour law

Labour relations are presumptively provincial, but Parliament regulates labour relations in federal works, undertakings and businesses, such as airlines, interprovincial transportation, banks, telecommunications and ports, and in operations integral to them. Whether a business is federally regulated affects which employment standards, labour relations, human rights and health and safety laws apply, including federal rules such as the ban on replacement workers in the Canada Labour Code.

The test is functional. In Quebec (Attorney General) v. SGS Canada inc., 2026 SCC 37 (6 November 2026), a divided Supreme Court held that inspectors and graders employed by a testing company's Montréal branch, who worked almost exclusively for six federally regulated grain elevators, fell under federal labour law because their services were integral to the operation of those elevators. The decision shows that a provincially incorporated service provider can become federally regulated for labour purposes through the work it performs for a federal undertaking. See our page on labour relations and our insight on federally regulated employers.

Practical point

Contractors that work mainly for airports, railways, ports, grain elevators, banks or telecom carriers should map whether their workforce could be federally regulated. The answer changes certification procedures, strike rules, minimum standards and which regulators can inspect.

The reference procedure and how challenges reach court

Governments can ask courts for advisory opinions through references. The federal government may refer questions directly to the Supreme Court, and provinces may refer questions to their courts of appeal, with an appeal as of right to the Supreme Court. Many of the most consequential division of powers rulings for business came through references, including Reference re Securities Act, 2011 SCC 66, which rejected a single federal securities regulator, and Reference re Pan-Canadian Securities Regulation, 2018 SCC 48, which upheld a cooperative model.

Private parties raise division of powers arguments in ordinary litigation, regulatory prosecutions and judicial review. A business charged with a provincial offence can argue the law is inapplicable to it, as the airport contractors did in Opsis. Notice of a constitutional question must usually be served on the federal and provincial attorneys general, and failure to give notice can be fatal. Telecommunications offers another example: in Telus Communications Inc. v. Federation of Canadian Municipalities, 2025 SCC 15, the Court addressed the limits of the CRTC's statutory power to grant carriers access to municipal property for 5G equipment, showing how jurisdictional questions also arise through statutory interpretation.

Charter arguments for corporations

Corporations can rely on some Charter rights but not others. A corporation can challenge a law under any Charter provision when it is a defendant in a penal proceeding, but it cannot claim the s. 7 rights to life, liberty and security of the person as its own. In Quebec (Attorney General) v. 9147-0732 Québec inc., 2020 SCC 32, the Supreme Court held that the s. 12 protection against cruel and unusual punishment does not extend to corporations.

Section 15 equality rights protect individuals; corporations have rarely succeeded under it. More useful for business are s. 2(b) freedom of expression, which protects commercial expression such as advertising, and s. 8 protection against unreasonable search and seizure, which applies with reduced expectations in regulatory contexts.

Corporations can also invoke the constitutional limits on taxation, such as the requirement that taxes be imposed by legislation (s. 53 of the Constitution Act, 1867) and the distinction between valid regulatory charges and taxes.

The notwithstanding clause and its limits

Section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows Parliament or a legislature to declare that a law operates notwithstanding s. 2 or ss. 7 to 15 of the Charter, for renewable periods of five years. Provinces have used it more often in recent years, including in Quebec's language and secularism laws and in Ontario and Saskatchewan legislation.

For business, two points matter. First, s. 33 does not override the division of powers: a law outside the enacting government's jurisdiction remains invalid regardless of any notwithstanding declaration. Second, it does not shield laws from challenges under other constitutional provisions, such as language rights or the requirements of s. 96 courts. For Quebec's language regime, see our page on the Charter of the French Language.

Division of powers in energy, climate and internal trade

Some of the most active division of powers questions concern resource development and climate policy. Provinces own their natural resources and have exclusive authority over their development under s. 92A of the Constitution Act, 1867, while Parliament has authority over interprovincial pipelines and transmission lines, navigation, fisheries and federal lands, as well as criminal law tools used in environmental protection. After the 2023 impact assessment reference, Parliament amended the federal regime to focus on effects within federal jurisdiction, and later legislation created a fast-track listing process for national-interest projects. Each of these schemes invites argument about where federal authority ends; see our insight on national-interest projects.

Internal trade is another frontier. Section 121 of the Constitution Act, 1867 prohibits tariff-like barriers between provinces, but the Supreme Court read it narrowly in R. v. Comeau, 2018 SCC 15, holding that it targets laws whose primary purpose is to restrict trade across provincial borders. As a result, removing non-tariff barriers has depended largely on intergovernmental agreements and federal and provincial legislation rather than constitutional litigation.

Remedies and timing in division of powers cases

The remedy depends on the doctrine. An invalid law is struck down, sometimes with a suspended declaration to give the legislature time to respond. An inapplicable law is "read down" so that it does not apply to the protected activity, leaving it in force for everyone else. An inoperative law has no effect only while and to the extent the conflict with federal law exists. Interim relief is difficult to obtain: courts presume that legislation serves the public interest, so businesses usually have to comply while a challenge proceeds unless they can show exceptional circumstances. Planning for that period, including potential refunds of fees or charges if a law is later held invalid, is part of a sound strategy.

Building a division of powers strategy

  1. Identify the precise activity. Courts characterize the operations of the specific business unit, not the corporate group in general.
  2. Gather functional evidence. Contracts, revenue sources, operational integration and regulatory licences show whether work is integral to a federal undertaking.
  3. Choose the forum and timing. Raising the issue early in a regulatory process can avoid years of proceedings under the wrong regime.
  4. Serve constitutional notices. Comply with notice requirements to attorneys general before the hearing.
  5. Consider intervention. Industry associations often intervene in references and appeals that will shape sector-wide rules.

Our appellate and public law page describes how these challenges fit with judicial review and appeals, including the framework from Vavilov.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise businesses and industry groups on division of powers questions and constitutional challenges to regulation. Our work includes assessing whether operations are federally or provincially regulated for labour, licensing and regulatory purposes, analyzing validity, interjurisdictional immunity and paramountcy arguments, preparing constitutional notices and evidentiary records, and advising on interventions in references and appeals. Where pleadings must be filed by counsel licensed in a province, or before the Supreme Court of Canada, we work with appropriately licensed counsel. To discuss a regulatory challenge, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is interjurisdictional immunity?

It is a doctrine that protects the core of an exclusive federal or provincial head of power from being impaired by a valid law of the other level of government. It requires intrusion on the core and impairment of that core. In Opsis, 2025 SCC 17, it made Quebec's Private Security Act inapplicable to certain airport and marine security enterprises.

How do I know whether my business is federally regulated for labour law?

Courts look at the normal and habitual activities of the business unit. If it is itself a federal undertaking, or its work is integral to one, federal labour law applies. SGS Canada, 2026 SCC 37, shows that a contractor serving federally regulated grain elevators can fall under federal jurisdiction.

Can a corporation rely on the Charter?

Partly. Corporations benefit from rights such as freedom of expression and protection against unreasonable search and seizure, and can challenge laws as defendants in penal proceedings. They cannot claim s. 7 rights as their own, and the Supreme Court held in 2020 SCC 32 that s. 12 does not protect corporations.

What is federal paramountcy?

When valid federal and provincial laws conflict, the federal law prevails and the provincial law is inoperative to the extent of the conflict. Conflict means either impossibility of dual compliance or frustration of the federal purpose. It frequently arises in insolvency and in regulated industries.

Does the notwithstanding clause protect provincial business regulation?

Only from challenges under s. 2 and ss. 7 to 15 of the Charter. It does not cure a division of powers defect, so a provincial law outside provincial jurisdiction remains invalid even with a notwithstanding declaration.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Canada: Opsis Airport Services Inc. v. Quebec (AG), 2025 SCC 17 (Case in Brief)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada: Quebec (AG) v. SGS Canada inc., 2026 SCC 37 (Case in Brief)
  3. Constitution Acts, 1867 to 1982 (Justice Laws)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.