Estate Litigation: Will Challenges and Trust Disputes
Estate litigation in Canada spans will challenges, family support claims, trustee disputes and fights over family businesses. Rules differ sharply by province: BC allows wills variation within 180 days of the grant, Ontario relies on dependant support claims, and Quebec follows the Civil Code. Deadlines and evidence decide many cases.

Key takeaways
- Vout v. Hay sets the burden structure for capacity, knowledge and approval, and suspicious circumstances.
- BC's WESA s. 60 lets spouses and children vary wills that lack adequate provision.
- BC wills variation claims must start within 180 days of the representation grant.
- Ontario relies on SLRA Part V dependant support claims rather than wills variation.
- Since 2022, marriage no longer revokes a will in Ontario.
- Family business disputes often combine estate, corporate and tax issues.
What estate litigation covers
Estate litigation covers disputes about wills, trusts and the administration of estates: challenges to the validity of a will, claims by family members for support or a larger share, disputes over the conduct and compensation of executors and trustees, and conflicts over family businesses held in estates or trusts. In Canada, these disputes are governed by provincial law, so the rules differ significantly between Ontario, British Columbia, Quebec and the other provinces. Many estate litigation files involve significant business assets, cross-border beneficiaries and tax consequences, which raises the stakes beyond family relationships.

This insight explains the main grounds for challenging a will, British Columbia's wills variation regime, Ontario dependant support claims, the removal of estate trustees, passing of accounts and the particular issues raised by family businesses. It is general information, not legal advice; succession planning is covered on our private client, trusts and estates page.
Will challenges: formal validity, capacity and undue influence
Formal validity
A will must meet formal requirements, such as writing, signature and witnesses, unless it is a valid holograph will where permitted. Several provinces now allow courts to validate documents that do not strictly comply. British Columbia's Wills, Estates and Succession Act (WESA) gives the court power to cure deficiencies where a document represents the deceased's testamentary intentions, and Ontario added a similar power to the Succession Law Reform Act (SLRA) in s. 21.1 effective 2022.
Testamentary capacity
The testator must understand the nature and effect of making a will, the extent of their property, and the claims of those who might expect to benefit, and must not be affected by a disorder of mind that influences the dispositions. Capacity is assessed at the time the will was made (or instructions given). Evidence comes from the drafting lawyer's notes, medical records, witnesses and expert opinion based on those records.
Suspicious circumstances and undue influence
Under Vout v. Hay, [1995] 2 S.C.R. 876, the person propounding the will benefits from a presumption of knowledge, approval and capacity once due execution is proven. Where suspicious circumstances are shown, such as a beneficiary's involvement in preparing the will, the presumption falls away and the propounder must prove knowledge, approval and capacity on a balance of probabilities. Undue influence, by contrast, must be proven by the person alleging it: coercion that overpowers the testator's free will, not merely persuasion or appeals to affection.
| Ground | Who bears the burden | Typical evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Due execution | Person propounding the will | Witness affidavits, original will |
| Capacity and knowledge and approval | Presumed on due execution; propounder must prove if suspicious circumstances shown | Lawyer's file, medical records, expert opinion |
| Undue influence | Person challenging the will | Dependency, isolation, control of finances, timing of changes |
| Wills variation (BC) | Spouse or child applying under WESA s. 60 | Needs, moral claims, estate size |
British Columbia wills variation
British Columbia gives spouses and children an unusual remedy. Under s. 60 of WESA, if a will does not, in the court's opinion, make adequate provision for the proper maintenance and support of the will-maker's spouse or children, the court may order the provision it thinks "adequate, just and equitable in the circumstances" out of the estate.
The Supreme Court in Tataryn v. Tataryn Estate, [1994] 2 S.C.R. 807, held that the court considers both legal obligations (what the deceased would have owed during life) and moral obligations based on contemporary community standards. Adult independent children can succeed, although their claims are weighed against the testator's autonomy and any valid reasons for disinheritance.
Timing is strict. Under s. 61, a wills variation proceeding must be commenced within 180 days from the date the representation grant is issued in British Columbia, and the initiating pleading must be served on the executor within 30 days after that period, unless the court extends the time for service. Executors often wait for the 180 days to pass before distributing.
Ontario dependant support claims and spousal rights
Ontario does not have wills variation. Instead, Part V of the SLRA allows a dependant (including a spouse, child, parent or sibling whom the deceased was supporting or legally obliged to support) to apply for support where the deceased did not make adequate provision for their proper support.
The court considers the dependant's needs and circumstances, the deceased's obligations and the size of the estate, and may order support from the estate, including in some cases from assets passing outside the will, such as certain insurance proceeds and jointly held property. These claims must generally be brought within a short period after the certificate of appointment is issued, so prompt advice matters.
A surviving married spouse may also elect under the Family Law Act to take an equalization of net family property instead of the entitlement under the will or intestacy, within a strict statutory time limit. Since 2022, Ontario rules provide that marriage no longer revokes a will, and that a separated spouse may be treated as having predeceased for purposes of the will and intestacy where the statutory conditions of separation are met. These changes have generated new disputes about whether spouses were "living separate and apart".
Calendar every limitation period on day one: wills variation (180 days from the grant in BC), dependant support (a short period from the certificate of appointment in Ontario), spousal elections and general limitation periods for breach of trust. Missing these deadlines can end a strong claim.
Removal of trustees and passing of accounts
Executors and trustees owe fiduciary duties of loyalty, impartiality and prudence, and must keep accurate accounts. Beneficiaries who believe an estate trustee is acting in conflict, failing to administer the estate, or favouring some beneficiaries can apply to court for removal and replacement. Courts do not remove trustees lightly, because the testator chose them, but they will act where the trustee's conduct endangers the estate or the beneficiaries' welfare, or where conflict makes proper administration impossible.
A passing of accounts is the formal process by which the court reviews the trustee's transactions and approves compensation. Beneficiaries can file objections to particular transactions, expenses or compensation claims. Passings are often the forum for broader disputes, such as challenges to related-party transactions, delays in selling assets, or management of a family business. In Ontario, trustee compensation is commonly measured by reference to established percentage guidelines, adjusted for the complexity and results of the work.
Estate litigation and family businesses
When a business owner dies, estate litigation often merges with corporate disputes. Typical issues include:
- Control. Whether the estate trustee may vote shares to elect directors, and whether a shareholder agreement restricts transfers or triggers buy-sell obligations on death.
- Valuation. Disputes about the value of shares for equalization, buyouts or tax, including discounts for minority interests.
- Conflicts. Executors who are also directors, employees or co-shareholders face conflicts that may require independent trustees or court directions.
- Oppression remedy. Family shareholders may use corporate statutes' oppression remedy alongside estate claims; see our insight on the oppression remedy.
- Tax. Deemed disposition at death, post-mortem planning and estate freezes affect what is available for distribution; see estate freezes under s. 86 and family business succession.
Practical tools for avoiding these disputes include shareholder agreements with clear provisions on death, independent corporate trustees or protectors, insurance-funded buyouts, and letters of wishes that explain the founder's intentions without binding the trustees. Where litigation does arise, interim orders appointing an estate trustee during litigation can keep the business running.
Mediation is mandatory for many estate matters in Toronto, Ottawa and Windsor under Ontario's rules, and is frequently productive because family members can negotiate business arrangements that a court could not impose.
Costs and evidence in estate litigation
Historically, Canadian courts often ordered that all parties' costs in estate litigation be paid from the estate, on the theory that the testator caused the dispute. Modern courts are more selective. In Ontario, the general rule is that costs follow the event as in other civil litigation, with the estate bearing costs only where the dispute arose from the testator's conduct or where there were reasonable grounds to investigate the will's validity. Unsuccessful challengers can therefore face personal costs awards, and executors who litigate unreasonably may be denied indemnity from the estate.
Courts also screen weak challenges. A person seeking to challenge a will in Ontario generally needs to show some evidence that, if accepted, would call the will's validity into question before the court will order full production and examinations. Early evidence gathering, including requests for the drafting lawyer's file and medical records, is therefore critical.
Trust disputes and assets outside the estate
Much wealth now passes outside the will through jointly held accounts, beneficiary designations on life insurance and registered plans, inter vivos trusts and corporate structures. Estate litigation increasingly involves claims that such assets belong to the estate. Where a parent placed assets in joint names with an adult child, the law presumes a resulting trust in favour of the estate unless the child proves a gift was intended. Beneficiaries of inter vivos and family trusts can seek accounting, removal of trustees and enforcement of the trust terms, and courts may scrutinize discretionary distributions for good faith. These disputes often interact with tax filings, including trust reporting obligations discussed in our insight on trust reporting rules.
Cross-border estates
Estates with property or beneficiaries in several jurisdictions raise questions about which law governs succession to movables and immovables, where probate must be obtained, and how foreign beneficiaries are taxed. Canadian provinces generally apply the law of the deceased's domicile to movables and the law of the place where land is located to immovables. Executors may need ancillary grants in other provinces or countries, and non-resident beneficiaries may face withholding tax and clearance certificate requirements before distribution.
Quebec specifics
Quebec estate litigation follows the Civil Code of Québec. Notarial wills do not require probate, while holograph wills and wills made before witnesses must be probated before the court or a notary. Liquidators of successions have defined duties, including making an inventory, and heirs may accept or renounce a succession within time limits. Quebec has no wills variation regime, but the survivorship claim for support and the family patrimony rules can give spouses and certain relatives claims against the estate.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise executors, trustees, beneficiaries and family-owned businesses on Canadian estate litigation, including will challenges, wills variation and dependant support claims, removal of trustees, passings of accounts and disputes over shares and control. We help clients assess evidence of capacity and undue influence, track statutory deadlines, plan mediation strategies and align estate outcomes with corporate and tax structures. Where a step requires a Quebec notary or counsel licensed in the relevant province, we coordinate with them. See our commercial litigation page or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
On what grounds can a will be challenged?
Common grounds include improper execution, lack of testamentary capacity, lack of knowledge and approval, undue influence and fraud. In BC, spouses and children may also seek variation under WESA if the will does not make adequate provision for them, even if the will is valid.
Who has to prove capacity?
Once due execution is proven, capacity and knowledge and approval are presumed. If the challenger shows suspicious circumstances, the presumption falls away and the person propounding the will must prove capacity and knowledge and approval. Undue influence must always be proven by the person alleging it.
How long do I have to bring a wills variation claim in BC?
Under WESA s. 61, the proceeding must be commenced within 180 days from the date the representation grant is issued in British Columbia, and served on the executor within 30 days after that period unless the court extends the time.
Can adult children challenge a will in Ontario?
Ontario has no wills variation regime, so adult independent children generally cannot claim simply because they were left out. They may challenge validity, or claim support under Part V of the SLRA if they were dependants whom the deceased was supporting or obliged to support.
Can an executor be removed?
Yes, but courts are cautious because the testator chose the executor. Removal is ordered where the trustee's conduct endangers the estate or beneficiaries, for example through serious conflict, misconduct or failure to administer. Beneficiaries can also scrutinize transactions through a passing of accounts.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


