Limited Recourse Capital Notes and Hybrid Capital in Canada
Limited recourse capital notes let Canadian banks and insurers raise Additional Tier 1 capital in debt form, with investor recourse limited to preferred shares held in trust. This note explains the structure, OSFI's capital ruling and issuance caps, tax and rating considerations, and what investors actually own.

Key takeaways
- LRCNs are 60-year subordinated notes; missed cash payments are settled by delivering trust-held preferred shares.
- OSFI Ruling 2020-01, last revised 14 December 2022, allows AT1 treatment subject to conditions.
- Deposit-takers face a cap of the greater of CAD 150 million, 0.75% of RWA or 50% of net AT1.
- Interest deductibility and institutional demand make LRCNs an alternative to rate-reset preferred shares.
- Redemptions require OSFI approval, and non-viability triggers conversion into common shares.
What are limited recourse capital notes?
Limited recourse capital notes (LRCNs) are deeply subordinated, long-dated notes that Canadian banks, insurers and some other issuers use to raise hybrid capital. Their defining feature is that the holder's recourse is limited to assets held in a trust: if the issuer does not pay interest or principal in cash, the noteholders' sole remedy is delivery of the preferred shares (or other assets) held by that limited recourse trust. Limited recourse capital notes were designed to combine the regulatory capital treatment of preferred shares with the investor base, pricing and tax features of debt.

A Canadian bank issued the first LRCNs in 2020. On 18 July 2020 the Office of the Superintendent of Financial Institutions (OSFI) issued a capital ruling, No. 2020-01, concluding that federally regulated financial institutions (FRFIs) may recognize LRCNs as Additional Tier 1 (AT1) capital, subject to conditions. OSFI revised the ruling in March 2021 and again on 14 December 2022, the latter mainly to clarify limits for property and casualty and mortgage insurers. Since then, LRCNs have become a regular part of Canadian bank and insurer capital stacks, and the format has been adapted by some non-financial issuers seeking hybrid capital.
How the LRCN structure works
OSFI's ruling describes the structure in two parts:
- The notes. Deeply subordinated, interest-bearing LRCNs with a term of 60 years are issued by the bank directly to investors for cash.
- The trust assets. The bank issues perpetual, non-cumulative preferred shares to a special purpose vehicle, typically a limited recourse trust, which holds them for the benefit of LRCN holders.
If the issuer fails to pay interest or principal in cash on a payment date, on an event of default, or at maturity, the sole recourse of LRCN holders against the issuer is delivery of the preferred shares held by the trust. Events of default for regulatory capital instruments are limited to liquidation, insolvency, winding-up and bankruptcy. On a non-viability trigger event under Chapter 2 of OSFI's Capital Adequacy Requirements (CAR) Guideline, the notes' principal and accrued interest become due, and on non-payment the holders receive common shares issued on conversion of the preferred shares in the trust. Any redemption or purchase of the LRCNs or the underlying preferred shares requires the Superintendent's prior approval.
| Feature | LRCNs | Traditional preferred shares | Subordinated debt (Tier 2) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Form | Subordinated note, recourse limited to trust assets | Equity | Debt |
| OSFI treatment (banks) | AT1, within issuance cap | AT1 | Tier 2 |
| Missed payment | Delivery of trust preferred shares, not default | Dividend not paid; non-cumulative | Default only in insolvency events for regulatory capital |
| Non-viability | Conversion via preferred shares into common shares | Conversion into common shares | Conversion into common shares |
| Typical investors | Institutional, fixed income funds | Retail and institutional | Institutional |
OSFI capital treatment and limits on limited recourse capital notes
OSFI considers structures holistically and emphasizes economic substance over legal form. It assessed the LRCNs and the preferred shares both individually and together against the AT1 criteria in Chapter 2 of the CAR Guideline, and concluded that the combination could qualify. Institutions are encouraged to seek a ruling or capital confirmation before issuing instruments with equivalent terms, even if not called LRCNs.
The ruling imposes issuance limits by sector, set out in its appendix:
- Deposit-taking institutions: a cap equal to the greater of CAD 150 million, 0.75% of risk-weighted assets or 50% of aggregate net AT1 capital. Amounts above the cap count as Tier 2 capital, and may later be reallocated to AT1 when capacity exists.
- Life insurers and fraternal benefit societies: a cap equal to the greater of CAD 150 million or 12.5% of net Tier 1 capital.
- Property and casualty and mortgage insurers: a cap equal to the greater of CAD 150 million or 20% of total capital available excluding accumulated other comprehensive income, for Category B treatment, with excess treated as Category C.
An institution can ask OSFI's Capital Definition and Assessment Division to remove the cap if it shows that its other AT1 instruments issued to institutional investors or affiliates meet a sector-specific floor. The ruling also requires disclosure and marketing to explain clearly how the LRCNs' risks are equivalent to investing directly in the trust assets.
OSFI's statement of 20 March 2023, issued after turmoil in international AT1 markets, reinforced that Canada's regime preserves the creditor hierarchy: at non-viability, AT1 and Tier 2 instruments convert into common shares in a way that leaves their holders better off than existing common shareholders, who absorb losses first. That message is central to investor appetite for Canadian limited recourse capital notes.
Tax deductibility and rating agency equity credit
For issuers, part of the appeal of LRCNs over preferred shares is tax. Interest on the notes is generally intended to be deductible under s. 20(1)(c) of the Income Tax Act (ITA), as interest on borrowed money used to earn income from a business, whereas dividends on preferred shares are paid from after-tax income and may attract Part VI.1 tax for the issuer. Deductibility depends on the precise terms, the use of proceeds and any applicable anti-avoidance rules, including the excessive interest and financing expenses limitation (EIFEL) rules in s. 18.2 for issuers within their scope. Issuers typically obtain tax advice confirming the characterization before launch.
For investors, LRCNs pay interest rather than dividends, so they do not benefit from the dividend tax credit available to individual holders of preferred shares. That is one reason LRCNs are sold mainly to institutional investors and funds, while retail investors continue to buy rate-reset preferred shares.
Credit rating agencies assess hybrids for "equity credit" based on subordination, permanence and the ability to defer payments without default. LRCNs issued by banks are usually rated by reference to the issuer's preferred share or AT1 rating. Corporate issuers, such as utilities and pipeline companies, have used hybrid subordinated notes, sometimes with limited recourse features, to obtain partial equity credit while keeping debt-like tax treatment. Each agency's methodology differs and may change, so issuers should confirm expected treatment before pricing.
Investors in limited recourse capital notes are effectively investors in the preferred shares held in trust. Read the trust declaration, the preferred share terms and the non-viability provisions together. For issuers, the cap and floor calculations in the OSFI ruling must be refreshed at each issuance, using the latest reported capital adjusted for subsequent transactions.
Preferred share alternatives and investor recourse
Before 2020, AT1 capital for Canadian banks came mainly from non-cumulative rate-reset preferred shares sold largely to retail investors. Limited recourse capital notes broadened the investor base to institutional fixed-income buyers, including foreign investors who cannot easily hold Canadian preferred shares, and offered longer tenor and pricing linked to government bond yields. Issuers now choose among LRCNs, preferred shares and, for insurers, other Tier 1 instruments depending on cost, capacity under the OSFI cap and investor demand. Market conditions shift the balance: when retail preferred share demand weakens or institutional credit spreads tighten, the note format tends to be cheaper, and when rate-reset preferred shares trade well, issuers may return to them. Keeping both channels open gives treasury teams flexibility over the capital planning cycle.
For investors, the key legal features are:
- Limited recourse. Failure to pay in cash does not give a right to sue the issuer for the debt or to petition for its bankruptcy; it gives a right to the trust assets.
- Trust structure. The limited recourse trust holds the preferred shares; its trustee acts for noteholders, and the trust agreement governs voting, delivery and conversion.
- Subordination. The notes rank below deposit liabilities and senior and subordinated debt, so in a liquidation holders would expect to recover little unless more senior claims are paid in full.
- Non-viability conversion. On a trigger event, holders receive common shares through the preferred share conversion mechanism, with dilution set by the conversion formula.
- Redemption. Calls require OSFI approval, so investors should not assume redemption at the first call date, and pricing should reflect extension risk.
Governance and approvals for issuers
For a federally regulated issuer, an LRCN program touches several approval tracks at once. The board, or a committee with delegated authority, must approve the issue of notes and of the preferred shares to the trust, the capital plan and the use of proceeds. The issuer's articles or by-laws must authorize the preferred share series. OSFI's capital confirmation is sought before launch, and redemption of an outstanding instrument will later require the Superintendent's approval. Treasury teams should also model how the new issue interacts with internal capital targets, the leverage ratio and total loss-absorbing capacity requirements for domestic systemically important banks.
Non-financial issuers that adopt similar structures face a different checklist: no OSFI ruling is needed, but the rating agency's equity credit assessment, the tax analysis and covenant capacity under existing credit agreements and indentures become the gating items. Senior lenders may need to consent to the new subordinated instrument, and the hybrid's terms should be checked against restricted payment and change of control clauses.
Securities law and documentation
Bank LRCN offerings are typically made by prospectus supplement under a shelf prospectus in Canada, sometimes with a US private placement tranche, or on a private placement basis to institutional investors. Documentation includes a trust indenture for the notes, a declaration of trust for the limited recourse trust, preferred share terms in the issuer's by-laws or articles, and an underwriting agreement. Federally regulated issuers also need to consider Bank Act or Insurance Companies Act requirements for issuing shares and, for the trust, investment restrictions on its assets.
Illustration (hypothetical): a Canadian life insurer wants CAD 750 million of Tier 1 capital other than common shares. Its net Tier 1 capital is CAD 8 billion, so 12.5% gives a cap of CAD 1 billion, above the CAD 150 million minimum. It issues CAD 750 million of 60-year limited recourse capital notes with a five-year reset, backed by preferred shares held in a limited recourse trust, and obtains OSFI confirmation of capital treatment before launch.
How TRW & Co helps with limited recourse capital notes
We advise issuers, underwriters and investors on limited recourse capital notes and other hybrid capital instruments in Canada. Our work includes structuring LRCN and preferred share terms, preparing OSFI capital confirmation requests, drafting trust and indenture documentation, analysing cap and floor capacity, and coordinating tax and rating agency analysis. Where a Canadian-licensed lawyer must give an opinion or file a document, we work alongside licensed counsel. Our debt capital markets, financial services regulatory and insurance regulatory work covers related issues; see also our notes on OSFI licensing and private credit. To discuss a hybrid capital issue, contact us. This note is general information, not legal or tax advice.
Frequently asked questions
Are limited recourse capital notes debt or equity?
Legally they are notes, so the issuer pays interest. For bank capital purposes, OSFI treats them as Additional Tier 1 capital, within issuance limits, because missed payments are settled by delivering non-cumulative preferred shares held in a limited recourse trust and the structure converts to common shares at non-viability.
What happens if the issuer does not pay interest?
Non-payment in cash is not an event of default that lets holders sue for the debt. Their sole recourse is delivery of the preferred shares held by the limited recourse trust. Events of default for regulatory capital instruments are limited to liquidation, insolvency, winding-up and bankruptcy.
How much can a bank issue?
Under OSFI's ruling, a deposit-taking institution can count LRCNs as AT1 up to the greater of CAD 150 million, 0.75% of risk-weighted assets or 50% of aggregate net AT1 capital. Amounts above the cap count as Tier 2. The cap can be removed if the institution meets a floor of other AT1 issued to institutional investors.
Can insurers issue LRCNs?
Yes. The ruling sets separate limits for life insurers and fraternal benefit societies, based on net Tier 1 capital, and for property and casualty and mortgage insurers, based on total capital available excluding accumulated other comprehensive income. The December 2022 revision clarified the P&C and mortgage insurer limits.
Why do issuers prefer LRCNs over preferred shares?
LRCNs reach institutional fixed-income investors, can be priced off government bond yields and are generally structured so that interest is tax deductible, subject to the terms and anti-avoidance rules. Preferred share dividends are paid from after-tax income. Choice depends on cost, OSFI capacity and investor demand.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


