Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Class Action Settlements: Approval, Fees and Distribution

Class action settlements bind absent class members, so Canadian courts must approve them, scrutinize class counsel fees and supervise distribution. This guide explains the fairness test, notice and objections, cy-près limits, administrator reporting and the release terms defendants need for national finality.

Judge reviewing a settlement agreement, representing court approval of class action settlements in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Ontario CPA s. 27.1 requires court approval; settlements must be fair, reasonable and in the class's best interests.
  • Detailed evidence on take-up, objectors and distribution costs is mandatory in Ontario.
  • Ontario cy-près payments are allowed only where direct compensation is impractical or impossible.
  • BC generally splits undistributed funds between the Law Foundation and uses benefiting the class.
  • Fees are approved separately, weighing results, risk and proportionality.
  • National deals need consistent releases and approvals in every court.

How class action settlements work in Canada

Class action settlements in Canada are not private contracts in the usual sense. Because a settlement binds absent class members who never instructed counsel, every Canadian class proceedings regime requires court approval before the deal takes effect. The court acts as a guardian of the class: it tests whether the settlement is fair, reasonable and in the class's best interests, approves class counsel's fees separately, and supervises how the money is distributed. For defendants, the approval process determines whether they obtain the finality they paid for. For plaintiffs and their counsel, it determines how much reaches class members and how much is paid in fees.

Judge reviewing a settlement agreement, representing court approval of class action settlements in Canada
Court approval turns a negotiated deal into class action settlements that bind every member who has not opted out.

This insight walks through the approval test, notice and objections, opt-outs, cy-près distributions, class counsel fees, claims administration and the release language that matters most when proceedings run in several provinces. It focuses on Ontario, British Columbia, Quebec and the Federal Court, where most national class actions are litigated, and it is general information rather than legal advice.

The approval test for class action settlements

In Ontario, s. 27.1 of the Class Proceedings Act, 1992 (CPA), added by the 2020 amendments in force on 1 October 2020, provides that a proceeding may be settled only with court approval and that a settlement is not binding unless approved. The court "shall not approve a settlement unless it determines that the settlement is fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class or subclass members" (s. 27.1(5)). Different terms for different class members, including the representative plaintiff, do not bar approval (s. 27.1(6)).

The moving party must make full and frank disclosure of all material facts. Section 27.1(7) lists the evidence the court must consider, including:

  • how the settlement meets the fairness standard and the risks of continued litigation;
  • the range of possible recoveries and the method used to value the settlement;
  • the number of class members, how many are expected to claim and how many are expected to receive money;
  • the number and nature of objections, actual or expected;
  • the distribution plan, any proposed administrator and the expected costs of distribution; and
  • the plan for giving notice of the settlement.

British Columbia's Class Proceedings Act provides in s. 35 that a class proceeding may be settled, discontinued or abandoned only with court approval and on terms the court considers appropriate. In the Federal Court, Rule 334.29 of the Federal Courts Rules requires a judge's approval and provides that, once approved, the settlement binds every class member who has not opted out or been excluded. Quebec's Code of Civil Procedure likewise requires court approval of any transaction in a class action, and the Superior Court applies a similar fairness analysis.

IssueOntario (CPA)British Columbia (CPA)Federal Court
Court approval of settlementRequired; fair, reasonable and in best interests (s. 27.1(5))Required; terms court considers appropriate (s. 35)Required (r. 334.29)
Approval of counsel feesFee agreement unenforceable without approval; statutory factors (s. 32)Fee agreement must be in writing and approved (s. 38)Payments to solicitors from proceeds require approval (r. 334.4)
Undistributed fundsCy-près to a charity or non-profit benefiting the class, otherwise Legal Aid Ontario (s. 27.2)Generally 50% to the Law Foundation of BC and 50% applied to benefit the class (s. 36.2)Court discretion
Post-distribution reportWithin 60 days of full distribution (s. 27.1(16))Court-directedCourt-directed

Notice, objectors and opt-outs

Notice is the mechanism that gives absent class members a voice. Ontario courts must consider whether notice of the approval hearing should be given and whether it should describe the purpose of the hearing and the process for objecting (s. 27.1(8)). Materials must be served on the Public Guardian and Trustee where it may act for class members, and the court may involve the Children's Lawyer where minors may be in the class (s. 27.1(9)-(11)). Modern notice programs combine direct email, mail to known members, digital advertising and settlement websites. Courts expect notice plans that are proportionate but realistic about reach.

Objectors are not a veto. Judges weigh the number and substance of objections against the benefits and risks, and a small number of objections in a large class is often read as tacit acceptance. That said, well-reasoned objections from sophisticated class members or public bodies can lead to amendments, particularly on distribution formulas, claims deadlines and the scope of releases.

Opt-outs raise strategic questions for defendants. If a settlement is reached before or soon after certification, the opt-out period may run alongside the settlement notice. Defendants commonly negotiate an opt-out threshold that allows them to terminate if too many class members exclude themselves, because large opt-outs undermine the finality that class action settlements are meant to deliver.

Practical point

Build the evidentiary record for approval while negotiating, not afterwards. Ontario's s. 27.1(7) requires best-information evidence on take-up rates, expected objectors and distribution costs. Settlements that model claims rates realistically and explain the valuation method are approved faster and are less vulnerable to objections.

Cy-près distributions and claims administration

Distribution is where class action settlements often succeed or fail in practice. Ontario's s. 27.2 now limits cy-près payments: a court may approve settlement terms paying funds on a cy-près basis only if it is satisfied that, using best reasonable efforts, it is not practical or possible to compensate class members directly. The recipient must be a registered charity or non-profit agreed on by the parties that would reasonably be expected to benefit the class, failing which the money goes to Legal Aid Ontario.

British Columbia takes a different approach: s. 36.2 directs that undistributed amounts generally be split, with half paid to the Law Foundation of British Columbia and half applied in a way that may reasonably be expected to benefit class members, subject to exceptions including claims primarily concerning Indigenous people. In Quebec, statutory rules also allow part of unclaimed balances to go to the Fonds d'aide aux actions collectives.

Administrators must act competently and diligently (s. 27.1(15) CPA). Within 60 days after full distribution, the administrator must file a report covering amounts paid, claimants, rejected claims, cy-près payments, any reversion to the defendant, objectors, opt-outs, administrative costs and solicitor fees (s. 27.1(16)). These reports are public and have made take-up rates more visible to judges, which in turn shapes how future settlements are designed.

Design choices that affect take-up

  • Automatic payments using defendant records, where privacy law permits, rather than claim forms.
  • Simple online claims with minimal documentation for low-value claims.
  • Tiered compensation with heightened proof only for higher payments.
  • Reasonable claims deadlines with discretion to accept late claims.

Class counsel fees

Fees are approved separately from the settlement, and the court can approve a settlement while reducing the fee. In Ontario, a fee agreement between counsel and the representative plaintiff must be in writing and is unenforceable unless approved (s. 32(1)-(2)). The court must find the fees fair and reasonable, considering the results achieved (including how many class members are expected to receive money), the degree of risk assumed, proportionality to the recovery and other relevant matters (s. 32(2.1)). Risk is assessed by reference to the likelihood that certification or the action would fail and any factor, such as a parallel regulatory investigation or third-party funding, that reduced the risk (s. 32(2.2)).

Percentage-based contingency fees are common in practice, but there is no automatic entitlement to the agreed percentage. Courts scrutinize fees more closely where an early settlement followed a regulatory finding or a foreign settlement that reduced the risk. Defendants usually take no position on fees, but a settlement that pays fees from a separate fund can affect how the court views the overall benefit to the class. Where a third-party funder is involved, s. 33.1 requires court approval of the funding agreement, and the funder's return is reported after distribution.

Releases and finality in national class action settlements

For defendants, the release is the point of class action settlements. National settlements typically require parallel approval in each court where a proposed class proceeding is pending, so that Ontario, Quebec and British Columbia classes are bound by consistent releases. Key drafting issues include:

  • Scope of released claims. Releases should track the factual allegations in the pleadings; courts resist releases of unrelated claims.
  • Third-party releases. Releasing non-settling co-defendants, insurers or affiliates requires a clear rationale and may affect bar orders.
  • Bar orders. In partial settlements, bar orders protect settling defendants from contribution claims by non-settling defendants while preserving fairness to them in the continuing litigation.
  • Opt-out and termination rights. These should be harmonized across jurisdictions so one court's refusal to approve does not leave the defendant bound elsewhere.
  • Subrogated claims. Ontario's s. 27.3 requires notice to, and written approval from, prescribed persons, such as provincial health insurers, before releasing prescribed subrogated claims.

Coordination across courts is covered in our insight on multi-jurisdictional class actions. Data breach and competition claims raise their own settlement design questions; see data breach class actions and competition class actions under s. 36.

Parallel regulatory proceedings and insurance

Many class action settlements follow, or run alongside, a regulatory resolution: a Competition Bureau prosecution, a securities commission settlement or a privacy commissioner finding. Defendants should align the facts admitted in a regulatory settlement with positions in the civil case, because admissions can be used by class plaintiffs, and courts assessing fees will take the regulatory work into account when measuring class counsel's risk. Insurers also need to be engaged early. D&O, cyber and general liability policies often require insurer consent to settle, and allocation between covered and uncovered claims can affect how the settlement fund is funded. A settlement that the insurer has not approved may jeopardize coverage, so consent provisions should be reviewed before any mediation.

Negotiating class action settlements: a checklist

  1. Agree early on a mediator and on information exchange that supports a defensible valuation.
  2. Model the claims rate, administration costs and distribution scenarios before signing a term sheet.
  3. Decide whether the settlement is claims-made, fixed-fund or uncapped, and address any reversion expressly.
  4. Draft the notice plan and claims process alongside the settlement agreement.
  5. Coordinate approval hearings and release wording in each jurisdiction.
  6. Address insurer consent and contribution, and any regulatory settlements running in parallel.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise defendants, insurers and corporate boards on Canadian class action settlements, from early resolution strategy through approval and distribution. Our work includes valuing exposure, structuring settlement funds and releases, coordinating approvals in Ontario, Quebec, British Columbia and the Federal Court, preparing approval evidence on take-up and distribution, and managing administrator selection and reporting. Where an approval hearing requires counsel licensed in a particular province, we work with locally licensed litigation counsel and keep positions consistent across courts. We also help organizations align class settlements with parallel regulatory resolutions and insurance recoveries. More on the wider practice is on our class actions page, or our commercial litigation page, or contact us to discuss a matter.

Frequently asked questions

Can a class action be settled without court approval?

No. Ontario's Class Proceedings Act, 1992, British Columbia's Class Proceedings Act, Quebec's Code of Civil Procedure and the Federal Courts Rules all require court approval. In Ontario, an unapproved settlement is expressly not binding. Approval is what makes the settlement bind class members who did not opt out.

What does 'fair, reasonable and in the best interests of the class' mean?

The court compares the settlement with the likely outcome of continued litigation, considering risks, the range of recoveries, the valuation method, the number of claimants expected to receive money, objections and the distribution plan. A settlement need not be perfect; it must fall within a range of reasonable outcomes given the risks.

How are class counsel fees decided?

Fees are approved separately. In Ontario the court considers the results for class members, the risk counsel assumed, proportionality to the recovery and other relevant factors, and may compare alternative fee structures. Courts can reduce requested fees even while approving the settlement itself.

What happens to unclaimed settlement money?

It depends on the jurisdiction and the settlement terms. Ontario allows cy-près payments only where direct compensation is not practical or possible, to a charity or non-profit benefiting the class, or otherwise to Legal Aid Ontario. British Columbia generally splits undistributed amounts between the Law Foundation and uses benefiting the class.

How do defendants get finality across Canada?

By obtaining approval in each court where related proposed class actions are pending, with harmonized class definitions, releases, opt-out thresholds and termination rights. Bar orders may be needed when only some defendants settle.

Sources

  1. Class Proceedings Act, 1992, S.O. 1992, c. 6 (Ontario e-Laws)
  2. Class Proceedings Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 50 (BC Laws)
  3. Federal Courts Rules, SOR/98-106 (Justice Laws)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.