Non-Solicitation and Confidentiality Clauses That Work
With non-competes banned for most Ontario employees and rarely enforced elsewhere, well-drafted non solicitation clauses and confidentiality covenants are now an employer's main contractual protection. Courts enforce them when they are clear, tied to a legitimate interest and no wider than necessary, and they refuse to rescue clauses that overreach.

Key takeaways
- Restrictive covenants are presumed unenforceable unless shown to be reasonable.
- Customer non-solicits should be limited to customers the employee dealt with, for a reasonable period.
- Ambiguous terms are fatal; courts will not rewrite covenants (Shafron, 2009 SCC 6).
- Confidentiality obligations can last as long as the information remains confidential.
- Fiduciary employees owe duties beyond their contracts.
- Injunctions require a strong case, irreparable harm and a favourable balance of convenience.
Why non solicitation clauses matter more now
Restrictive covenants in employment contracts protect three main interests: customer relationships, the stability of the workforce and confidential information. Since Ontario prohibited most employee non-competes in October 2021, and given long-standing judicial reluctance elsewhere, non solicitation clauses and confidentiality obligations carry most of that load. They are not prohibited by Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000, and courts across Canada will enforce them if they are reasonable. Our insight on non-compete bans explains the statutory backdrop.

The starting point is still restraint of trade. Covenants that restrict what a former employee may do are presumed unenforceable. The employer must show that the covenant protects a legitimate proprietary interest and is reasonable in its terms, judged when the contract was made. The Supreme Court set out the modern framework in Elsley v. J.G. Collins Insurance Agencies Ltd., [1978] 2 SCR 916, and refined it in Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers (Western) Inc., 2009 SCC 6.
Courts distinguish non-solicitation from non-competition. A non-solicit leaves the employee free to work for a competitor but stops them from actively pursuing the employer's customers or staff. Because it is less restrictive, it is more likely to be enforced, and courts often hold that a non-solicit is all an employer needs to protect customer connections.
Customer non solicitation clauses
An enforceable customer non-solicit usually has these features:
- Defined customers. Limited to customers or prospective customers with whom the employee dealt, or about whom they obtained confidential information, during a look-back period such as the last 12 or 24 months of employment.
- Reasonable duration. Typically six to 12 months after employment ends, longer only where the sales cycle or relationship justifies it.
- Clear conduct. "Solicit" should be defined to cover initiating contact to divert business, with an explanation of whether accepting unsolicited business is restricted. Clauses that bar "accepting" or "dealing with" customers operate like non-competes and face stricter scrutiny.
- No unnecessary territory. Where customers are defined, a geographic limit is usually unnecessary and can create ambiguity.
Courts look at the employee's role. A covenant restraining a senior account manager from soliciting clients she managed is far more likely to be reasonable than a covenant restraining a junior support employee from dealing with all of the employer's customers.
Employee non solicitation clauses
Employee non-solicits restrict former employees from recruiting colleagues to join them. Courts generally accept that a stable workforce is a legitimate interest, particularly for key staff, but the clause should be limited in duration and should focus on active solicitation rather than general job advertisements or approaches initiated by the other employee. Covering employees the departing employee worked with or managed, rather than every employee worldwide, improves enforceability.
Agreements between employers not to solicit or hire each other's employees are different. Since 23 June 2023, unaffiliated employers that agree not to solicit or hire each other's employees may commit a criminal offence under s. 45(1.1) of the Competition Act. Employee-level non-solicits are not affected, but no-poach clauses in commercial and outsourcing contracts must be reviewed.
Ambiguity and blue-pencilling
In Shafron, the Supreme Court refused to enforce a covenant restricting competition in the "Metropolitan City of Vancouver", a term with no legal definition. The Court held that an ambiguous covenant is unreasonable because the employee cannot know what is prohibited, and that courts should not use notional severance to read down an unreasonable covenant into a reasonable one. Blue-pencil severance, deleting words without adding or changing others, is available only in rare cases where the part removed is trivial and not part of the main purpose of the covenant.
| Drafting feature | Risk | Better approach |
|---|---|---|
| Undefined terms ("clients", "the area", "business") | Ambiguity | Define each term precisely |
| All customers of the group, worldwide | Overbreadth | Customers the employee dealt with in a look-back period |
| "Solicit, accept or deal with" | Operates like a non-compete | Limit to active solicitation unless justified |
| Long durations (two years or more) | Unreasonable for most roles | Six to 12 months, tied to business reality |
| Step-down or "cascading" clauses | Invites rewriting, which courts refuse | Choose one reasonable restriction |
Draft for the specific role. Template covenants copied across every employee group are a common reason non solicitation clauses fail. A short schedule tailoring duration and scope by role level is easy to maintain and much easier to defend.
Confidentiality covenants
Confidentiality obligations are treated differently from restraints on trade. Employees owe an implied duty not to misuse their employer's confidential information, and express clauses reinforce and define it. A confidentiality covenant can last indefinitely for information that remains confidential, such as trade secrets, pricing models, source code and customer data compilations. It cannot prevent an employee from using general skill, knowledge and experience acquired during employment, or information that is public.
Effective confidentiality clauses define confidential information with examples, require return or deletion of materials on departure, address personal devices and cloud accounts, and preserve whistleblower rights under applicable law. They should be supported by practical controls: access restrictions, labelling, exit interviews and forensic review of downloads before departure.
Fiduciary employees
Senior employees who are fiduciaries, such as officers and key managers with significant discretion, owe duties of loyalty that continue for a period after they leave. Under the principles in Canadian Aero Service Ltd. v. O'Malley, [1974] SCR 592, they cannot usurp maturing business opportunities of the employer or unfairly solicit its customers using the advantages of their former position, even without a contract.
Ordinary employees are not fiduciaries, but they owe a duty of good faith during employment and may not misuse confidential information afterwards. In RBC Dominion Securities Inc. v. Merrill Lynch Canada Inc., 2008 SCC 54, the Supreme Court upheld damages against a branch manager who orchestrated a mass departure of investment advisers to a competitor, while confirming that ordinary employees may compete after giving reasonable notice.
Remedies and injunctions
When a former employee breaches a covenant, the employer can seek damages, an accounting of profits and, most urgently, an interlocutory injunction. Courts apply the test in RJR-MacDonald Inc. v. Canada (Attorney General), [1994] 1 SCR 311: a serious question to be tried (often a strong prima facie case in restrictive covenant cases), irreparable harm, and the balance of convenience. Because an injunction effectively decides restrictive covenant disputes, many courts require a strong prima facie case. Evidence of actual solicitation, such as emails, texts and customer statements, is critical. Our insight on interlocutory injunctions explains the process.
How courts read non solicitation clauses
Courts interpret non solicitation clauses in the context of the whole agreement and the employee's role at signing. They ask what "solicitation" means on the facts: an announcement on a professional networking site that the employee has joined a competitor is generally not solicitation, while personal emails to former clients inviting them to move their business usually are. Where a customer approaches the former employee unprompted, a clause limited to solicitation is not breached, although a clause that also bars "accepting" business may be. The burden of proving breach rests on the employer, which is why evidence gathering at departure matters.
Courts also consider whether the employer itself has acted properly. An employer that dismissed the employee without notice, or breached the contract in other ways, may face arguments that it cannot enforce restrictive covenants. Some decisions have refused relief to employers that came to court with unclean hands or delayed in seeking an injunction.
Technology, data and modern non solicitation clauses
Customer relationships increasingly live in systems rather than in individuals' contact books. Customer relationship management platforms, shared inboxes and social networks make it easier for departing employees to take and use contact information, and easier for employers to prove what was taken. Non solicitation clauses should be paired with confidentiality obligations covering customer data, express rules about personal devices and social media connections made for business purposes, and a requirement to hand over credentials for accounts used for work. Privacy law also applies: customer personal information belongs to the business relationship, and its misuse by a former employee may engage privacy statutes as well as contract.
Employers should also think about what they ask employees to delete. Requiring deletion of business contacts from a personal phone may be reasonable; demanding access to an employee's entire personal social network is unlikely to be.
Consideration and timing
Restrictive covenants must be supported by consideration. Covenants signed at hiring are supported by the employment itself. Covenants introduced later require fresh consideration, such as a raise, bonus or promotion. Covenants signed after the employee started work without any new benefit may be unenforceable. Employers also lose the benefit of covenants if they wrongfully dismiss an employee in some jurisdictions or circumstances, and in Quebec, article 2095 of the Civil Code bars reliance on a non-competition clause after dismissal without a serious reason.
Managing departures
- Remind the departing employee in writing of continuing obligations and attach the relevant clauses.
- Recover devices and disable access promptly, preserving data for review.
- Review recent downloads, forwarding and customer contacts for red flags.
- Contact key customers to maintain relationships, without making defamatory statements.
- If solicitation is occurring, send a demand letter and consider urgent injunctive relief.
- If hiring from a competitor, obtain the new employee's covenants and instruct them not to bring confidential information.
- Keep a record of every step taken, since the timeline will matter if the dispute reaches court.
- Assess quickly whether the expected loss justifies litigation, given that injunction motions are fast and costly.
Risks for hiring employers
Employers recruiting from competitors face claims for inducing breach of contract and for misuse of confidential information brought in by new hires. Onboarding should include written confirmations that the new employee has not brought confidential materials and will honour enforceable covenants, plus instructions to managers not to ask about the former employer's confidential information. Where a team moves together, coordinated planning increases the risk of claims and should be reviewed with counsel.
Hiring employers should also review the incoming employee's restrictive covenants before the start date, assess whether the planned role would breach them, and decide whether to restrict the employee from certain clients for a period. A hiring employer that knowingly benefits from a breach can be liable alongside the employee, and courts can extend injunctions to the new employer. Indemnities offered to new hires for litigation costs should be considered carefully, since they can be evidence of inducement.
How TRW & Co helps
We draft non solicitation clauses, confidentiality agreements and IP covenants tailored to roles and businesses, advise on departures and team moves, and act for employers and employees in injunction proceedings. We work within our employment law and trade secrets practices and with our litigation team. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review your covenants.
Frequently asked questions
Are non-solicitation clauses enforceable in Ontario?
Yes, if reasonable. Ontario's ESA bans most employee non-competes but not non-solicitation or confidentiality clauses. Courts enforce non-solicits that protect a legitimate interest, are clear, and are limited to what is necessary in duration and scope.
How long can a customer non-solicit last?
There is no fixed rule, but six to 12 months after employment is common and more likely to be reasonable. Longer periods need justification, such as long sales cycles or deep personal relationships, and should be tied to the employee's role.
Will a court fix an overbroad clause?
Generally no. In Shafron v. KRG Insurance Brokers, 2009 SCC 6, the Supreme Court refused to rewrite an ambiguous covenant through notional severance. Blue-pencilling is available only in rare cases, so an overbroad or ambiguous clause is usually struck.
How long do confidentiality obligations last?
As long as the information remains confidential. Confidentiality covenants can protect trade secrets and similar information indefinitely, but cannot stop an employee from using general skills and knowledge or information that is publicly available.
What must an employer show to get an injunction?
Under RJR-MacDonald, a serious question to be tried, often elevated to a strong prima facie case in restrictive covenant cases, irreparable harm and a balance of convenience in its favour. Evidence of actual solicitation or misuse of information is usually decisive.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


