Skip to content
Real Estate & Construction

REIT Structuring and the SIFT Rules

The SIFT rules tax listed trusts much like corporations, unless they qualify for the REIT exception in s. 122.1 of the Income Tax Act. This note explains the five REIT tests, mutual fund trust status, stapled structures, foreign property and how private REITs are structured to stay outside the SIFT rules.

Downtown office towers held by a listed Canadian REIT structured to fall outside the SIFT rules

Key takeaways

  • A listed Canadian trust holding non-portfolio property is a SIFT trust unless it meets the REIT exception.
  • The REIT exception requires 90% qualified REIT property, 90% and 75% revenue tests, a 75% asset test and listing.
  • The property and asset tests apply at each time in the year, so temporary breaches matter.
  • Mutual fund trust status needs at least 150 unitholders each holding units worth $500 or more.
  • Unlisted private REITs are not SIFT trusts but still need mutual fund trust and securities law planning.

What the SIFT rules do to real estate trusts

The SIFT rules tax certain publicly traded trusts and partnerships much like corporations. A "SIFT trust" under s. 122.1(1) of the Income Tax Act (ITA) is a Canadian-resident trust whose investments are listed or traded on a stock exchange or other public market and that holds one or more "non-portfolio properties". Its distributions of non-portfolio earnings become non-deductible, the trust pays tax on them at a rate approximating the corporate rate, and unitholders receive them as eligible dividends (s. 104(16)).

The main escape for real estate is the REIT exception: a trust that meets the five conditions in the definition of "real estate investment trust" in s. 122.1(1) is excluded from the SIFT trust definition and remains a flow-through vehicle.

Downtown office towers held by a listed Canadian REIT structured to fall outside the SIFT rules
Qualifying for the REIT exception keeps a listed real estate trust outside the SIFT rules.

This note explains the SIFT rules as they affect real estate: the REIT exception's property and revenue tests, how mutual fund trust status fits in, stapled structures, foreign property, and the way private REITs are structured to avoid the SIFT rules altogether. It is general information on federal tax law, not advice on any trust's status.

The REIT exception: five conditions

A trust is a "real estate investment trust" for a taxation year if it is resident in Canada throughout the year and meets all of these conditions:

TestThresholdMeasured
(a) Qualified REIT propertyAt least 90% of the fair market value of non-portfolio properties held by the trust are "qualified REIT properties"At each time in the year
(b) Broad revenue testAt least 90% of gross REIT revenue from rent from real or immovable properties, interest, capital dispositions of real or immovable properties, dividends, royalties and dispositions of eligible resale propertiesFor the year
(c) Real estate revenue testAt least 75% of gross REIT revenue from rent from real or immovable properties, mortgage or hypothec interest on such properties, and capital dispositions of such propertiesFor the year
(d) Asset testReal or immovable capital property, eligible resale property, cash-like deposits, bankers' acceptances and certain government debt equal at least 75% of the trust's equity valueAt each time in the year
(e) ListingInvestments in the trust are listed or traded on a stock exchange or other public marketAt any time in the year

Two features make compliance demanding. First, tests (a) and (d) apply "at each time" in the year, so a temporary breach — for example while sale proceeds are held in a non-qualifying form or after an acquisition of a business — can disqualify the trust for the whole year. Second, the tests look at the trust's own revenue and property, so the activities of subsidiaries matter through what they pay up to the trust and how the trust's securities in them are classified.

Key definitions under the SIFT rules

Rent from real or immovable properties

"Rent from real or immovable properties" includes rent for the use of real property and payment for services ancillary to the rental that are "customarily supplied or rendered" with such rentals. Revenue from operating hotels, seniors housing services, parking businesses or other active operations is generally not rent. REITs holding such assets typically lease them to an operating subsidiary or third-party operator and receive rent, or keep the non-rental revenue within the 10% and 25% baskets.

Real or immovable property

The definition excludes most depreciable property other than buildings in Classes 1, 3 and 31, property ancillary to them, and leasehold interests. It includes securities of an entity that itself meets REIT conditions (a) to (d), which allows a REIT to hold property through subsidiary trusts and partnerships that are themselves REIT-like.

Qualified REIT property

Qualified REIT property includes real or immovable capital property and eligible resale property, securities of subsidiaries whose gross REIT revenue is all or substantially all from maintaining, improving, leasing or managing the REIT group's real properties, bare-trustee title-holding entities, and property ancillary to earning rent and capital gains from real property (other than equity and mezzanine-type debt).

Non-portfolio property

Securities of an entity are non-portfolio property if the holder owns more than 10% of the entity's equity value, or the holding (with affiliates) exceeds 50% of the holder's equity value; Canadian real, immovable or resource property is non-portfolio property if it exceeds 50% of the holder's equity value; and any property used in a business carried on in Canada qualifies too. In practice, a listed real estate trust will almost always hold non-portfolio property, so the REIT exception is the only route to flow-through treatment.

Mutual fund trust status

REITs are almost always mutual fund trusts as well. Under s. 132(6) ITA, a mutual fund trust is a Canadian-resident unit trust whose only undertaking is investing in property, or acquiring, holding, maintaining, improving, leasing or managing real property that is capital property, and that meets prescribed conditions. Under s. 4801 of the Income Tax Regulations, a class of units must be qualified for distribution to the public (or meet alternative conditions), and there must be at least 150 beneficiaries each holding at least one block of units with a fair market value of at least $500.

Mutual fund trust status matters for several reasons: units are qualified investments for registered plans, the trust can use the capital gains refund mechanism, the trust avoids the 21-year deemed disposition rule, and the trust is generally protected from being treated as a taxable Canadian property owner subject to s. 116 on unit dispositions by non-residents. A real estate trust whose "only undertaking" includes development for sale or operating businesses may fail the s. 132(6) test, which is a separate risk from the SIFT rules.

Practical point

Run REIT and mutual fund trust compliance monitoring quarterly, not only at year-end. Because the qualified REIT property and asset tests apply at every moment, acquisitions, dispositions, joint ventures and changes in tenant services should be tested before they close, with a plan to cure any temporary shortfall.

Stapled structures and foreign property

Stapled securities

Some REITs historically stapled their units to shares or units of an operating entity, so that investors held both and the operating entity could pay deductible amounts to the REIT. The stapled security rules in s. 18.3 ITA deny the deduction of amounts paid or payable by an entity whose securities are stapled to those of a REIT or SIFT where the amount flows to the REIT group, subject to narrow exceptions for entities that are themselves subsidiaries of the REIT. New stapled structures are therefore designed with the s. 18.3 restrictions in mind, typically to separate real estate and operating businesses for commercial reasons rather than to shift income.

Foreign property

Canadian REITs increasingly own US and European property, usually through foreign subsidiaries or foreign REIT structures. The REIT tests in s. 122.1 are not limited to Canadian real property, so foreign rental property can count toward the revenue and asset tests when held in a qualifying way. Foreign income is subject to local tax, and withholding and treaty planning, including foreign REIT regimes, often determines the structure. Unitholders may be entitled to foreign tax credits through the trust's designations. Investors should also consider interest deductibility limits such as the EIFEL rules in foreign and Canadian subsidiaries; see our note on EIFEL.

How private REITs avoid the SIFT rules

The SIFT rules apply only to trusts whose investments are listed or traded on a stock exchange or other public market. A private REIT — units sold under prospectus exemptions such as the accredited investor or offering memorandum exemptions, with no listing and no organized trading facility — is not a SIFT trust at all, whatever it holds. It does not need to satisfy the REIT exception for SIFT purposes, although many private REITs still follow REIT-like investment restrictions to keep the option of listing later.

Private REITs still need careful structuring:

  • Public market: "public market" includes any trading system or organized facility on which publicly distributable securities are listed or traded, but excludes facilities used only for issuance or redemption by the issuer. Secondary trading platforms for private units should be reviewed carefully.
  • Mutual fund trust status: achieving 150 qualifying unitholders and public distribution (or the alternative conditions) is needed for registered plan eligibility and other benefits.
  • Redemptions and liquidity: redemption programs must be managed so that the trust remains a unit trust and does not face a liquidity crisis that forces non-qualifying asset sales.
  • Securities law: offering memorandum rules, exempt market dealer distribution, and continuous disclosure for reporting issuers in some provinces.
  • Non-resident investors: the trust should avoid being a "mutual fund trust" that is maintained primarily for non-residents, and should plan for Part XIII and s. 116 implications.

Illustration: a sponsor launches a private multi-residential REIT, selling units to accredited investors through dealers, with no listing. It is not a SIFT trust. Once it reaches 150 unitholders holding $500 or more each and qualifies its units for distribution, it becomes a mutual fund trust and its units are eligible for registered plans. If it later lists on the TSX, it must satisfy the five REIT conditions from that year onward or face SIFT tax on its non-portfolio earnings.

Consequences of failing the REIT exception

A listed trust that fails the REIT exception for a year is a SIFT trust for that year. Its non-portfolio earnings, broadly income from businesses carried on in Canada and from non-portfolio properties plus net taxable capital gains on non-portfolio properties, become non-deductible distributions. The trust pays tax under s. 122(1)(b) at a rate made up of the net federal corporate rate (15% for most corporations, per the CRA's corporate rates page) and a provincial SIFT component set by regulation, and unitholders are taxed on the distributions as eligible dividends.

The cost is usually significant for tax-exempt and non-resident unitholders, who lose the benefit of pre-tax flow-through. Because the tests are annual, a trust can requalify in a later year, but the lost year cannot be undone. For that reason, declarations of trust usually instruct trustees to manage the trust so that it continues to qualify, and acquisition agreements include representations and covenants addressing REIT status.

Conversions between REIT, corporate and SIFT forms raise further questions, including the SIFT wind-up rules that allowed tax-deferred conversions to corporations, and the treatment of unitholders on exchanges.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise sponsors, REITs, pension funds and foreign investors on REIT structuring and the SIFT rules. We design public and private REIT structures, review declarations of trust and investment guidelines against the s. 122.1 tests and mutual fund trust conditions, analyse acquisitions, joint ventures and foreign expansion for REIT compliance, and help with conversions and reorganizations. We work alongside tax accountants and Canadian-licensed counsel where filings or opinions require them. This work connects with our corporate and international tax and real estate and REITs practices, and with our note on section 116 certificates. To discuss a structure, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is a SIFT trust?

Under s. 122.1(1) ITA, a SIFT trust is a trust resident in Canada whose investments are listed or traded on a stock exchange or other public market and that holds one or more non-portfolio properties. Excluded subsidiary entities and trusts that qualify as real estate investment trusts for the year are not SIFT trusts.

Do the SIFT rules apply to private REITs?

No, as long as investments in the trust are not listed or traded on a stock exchange or other public market. A private REIT distributed under prospectus exemptions is outside the SIFT definition, though it should monitor secondary trading platforms and still needs mutual fund trust status for registered plan eligibility.

Can a REIT own hotels or seniors housing?

It can hold the real estate, but revenue from operating those businesses is generally not rent from real property. REITs usually lease such properties to operators, including taxable subsidiaries, and collect rent, or keep operating revenue within the limits of the 90% and 75% revenue tests.

What happens if a listed REIT fails one of the tests?

It is a SIFT trust for that year. Distributions of its non-portfolio earnings become non-deductible, the trust pays tax on them at a rate approximating the combined corporate rate, and unitholders are taxed on them as eligible dividends. The trust can requalify in a later year if it meets the tests.

Sources

  1. Income Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. 1 (5th Supp.), ss. 104, 122, 122.1, 132 (Justice Laws)
  2. Income Tax Regulations, C.R.C., c. 945, s. 4801 (Justice Laws)
  3. Canada Revenue Agency: corporation tax rates

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.