Return to Office and Remote Work: Legal Risks for Employers
Many Canadian employers are tightening hybrid arrangements and issuing return to office mandates. Others are expanding remote hiring across provinces and countries. Both moves carry legal risk: constructive dismissal and accommodation claims on one side, and payroll, tax, employment standards and safety obligations in new jurisdictions on the other.

Key takeaways
- Return to office mandates are usually lawful where the contract specifies an office location and remote work was temporary.
- Where remote work became an express or implied term, a mandate can amount to constructive dismissal.
- Human rights law may require accommodation for disability, family status or religion.
- Employees working in another province are generally governed by that province's employment standards.
- Work from another country raises immigration, tax, payroll and permanent establishment issues.
- Clear policies, notice periods and documented reasons reduce disputes.
Why return to office decisions carry legal risk
When employers moved staff home in 2020, most did so without changing employment contracts. Some arrangements were plainly temporary; others became permanent in practice, with employees relocating, managers approving fully remote roles and new hires recruited for remote work. As employers now require attendance in the office several days a week, the legal question is whether the return to office decision enforces an existing term or changes one. The answer depends on the contract, the communications around remote work and how long the arrangement lasted.

The risk runs both ways. Employers that expand remote work, letting employees work from other provinces or countries, take on obligations under the laws of those places. Employers that contract it may face constructive dismissal claims, human rights complaints and, in unionized workplaces, grievances. A careful process reduces both sets of risks.
Start with the contract and the history
Employment contracts often name a work location or office. Where a contract specifies an office location, remote work was introduced as a temporary measure, and the employer communicated that it could be reversed, a return to office requirement on reasonable notice is generally an exercise of existing rights. Where the employee was hired into a remote role, or the employer agreed in writing that the role would be permanently remote, a mandate may change an essential term. Between those poles, courts look at the whole history, including policies, emails, approvals for relocation and how long the arrangement lasted.
| Situation | Risk of constructive dismissal | Approach |
|---|---|---|
| Office location in contract; remote work described as temporary | Low | Give reasonable notice of the return date |
| Hybrid policy that reserves the right to change | Low to moderate | Apply the policy consistently and in good faith |
| Hired as fully remote, or written permanent remote agreement | High | Seek agreement with consideration or give notice equal to reasonable notice |
| Employee relocated far away with employer approval | Moderate to high | Consider exceptions, relocation support or a negotiated exit |
The constructive dismissal test in Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10 asks whether a change substantially alters an essential term, judged objectively. A shift from fully remote to five days in an office several hundred kilometres away clearly can. A move from two to three office days for an employee who lives nearby is unlikely to. Our insight on constructive dismissal explains the test.
Accommodation duties
A return to office policy must yield to human rights obligations. Employees with disabilities may need remote work or modified schedules as an accommodation, supported by appropriate medical information. Caregiving obligations can engage the ground of family status; the Federal Court of Appeal in Canada (Attorney General) v. Johnstone, 2014 FCA 110 set out a test for family status discrimination in federally regulated workplaces that considers the child's age, the legal responsibility involved, reasonable efforts to meet the obligation through other means, and whether the rule interferes in a manner that is more than trivial. Provincial tribunals apply their own tests. Religious observance can also require scheduling flexibility.
The duty to accommodate is to the point of undue hardship, but it is a duty to provide reasonable accommodation, not the employee's preferred option. An employer can require attendance where it can show that in-person work is a genuine requirement of the job and accommodation in other forms has been explored. Our insight on workplace accommodation covers the process.
Set up a clear process for exception requests before announcing the return to office date. Ask for information relevant to the need, decide promptly, record the reasons and revisit decisions periodically. Inconsistent exceptions granted informally by managers are a common source of discrimination claims.
Unionized workplaces
Where employees are unionized, the collective agreement and any letters of understanding on remote work govern. Unions may grieve a mandate as a breach of the agreement or of management rights clauses exercised unreasonably. In federally regulated and public sector workplaces, return to office directives have prompted grievances and policy disputes. Employers should check whether remote work has become a term through past practice and whether consultation obligations apply.
Employees working in another province
Employment standards legislation generally applies based on where the work is performed. Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000, for example, applies to work performed in Ontario, and to work performed both in and outside Ontario where the outside work is a continuation of work in the province. An Ontario employer that lets an employee work from Nova Scotia must usually comply with Nova Scotia's employment standards for that employee, including minimum notice, holidays and leave.
Payroll withholding follows the province of the employer's establishment to which the employee reports, which may not be where the employee lives, and provincial health premiums or payroll taxes may apply. Workers' compensation coverage depends on registration in the right province. And the employee's presence may create a permanent establishment for corporate tax allocation, as discussed in our insight on permanent establishment risk.
Quebec raises additional points: the Charter of the French Language governs language of work, and Quebec's privacy law, Law 25, applies to monitoring employees located there.
Employees working from another country
Allowing an employee to work from abroad can trigger foreign immigration requirements, foreign employment law protections, local payroll and social security obligations, and corporate tax exposure if the employee's activities create a permanent establishment. Canadian benefit plans may not cover employees outside Canada. The employee's own tax residence may change. Many employers limit work from abroad to short periods, such as a few weeks a year, and require approval for anything longer. Foreign employees working remotely into Canada for a foreign employer need Canadian work authorization unless they are citizens or permanent residents.
Health and safety, expenses and privacy
Employers owe health and safety duties to employees wherever they work, although the scope of occupational health and safety statutes in private residences varies by province. Ergonomic assessments, policies on reporting injuries at home, and guidance on psychosocial risks such as isolation are prudent. Workplace harassment policies apply to online interactions. Home office expenses are a matter of contract and policy; for tax purposes, employees can claim certain home office expenses only if the employer certifies that working from home was required. Electronic monitoring of remote staff must comply with Ontario's written policy requirement for larger employers and with privacy laws, discussed in our insight on electronic monitoring.
Implementing a return to office mandate
- Review contracts, offer letters, remote work agreements and policies for each employee group.
- Identify employees hired as remote or who relocated with approval, and plan separately for them.
- Give reasonable notice of the new requirement, with a clear start date and expectations.
- Publish an exception and accommodation process.
- Apply the policy consistently and monitor attendance in a proportionate, transparent way.
- Address non-compliance through ordinary performance and discipline processes, with warnings before termination.
Illustration: a technology company hired a developer in 2022 under an offer letter stating that the role is "fully remote". In 2026 it requires three office days a week in Toronto; the developer lives in Halifax. Because remote work was an express term, the mandate likely changes an essential term. The employer could seek agreement with consideration, offer relocation support, give working notice of the change equal to reasonable notice, or end the employment with a package.
Communicating a return to office decision
How a return to office policy is communicated affects both employee relations and legal risk. Announcements should explain the business reasons, such as collaboration, mentoring, client service or security, and avoid suggesting that remote workers are less committed, which can fuel discrimination claims if remote work was disproportionately used by employees with caregiving responsibilities or disabilities. Give a realistic lead time, typically several weeks to a few months depending on the size of the change, and provide a channel for questions. Written communications become evidence, so they should be consistent with the contracts and the policy.
Managers need briefing. They should know how to respond to accommodation requests, how to handle employees who say they were promised permanent remote work, and when to escalate. Informal promises by managers during the transition can later be argued to have changed terms of employment.
Designing a durable hybrid policy
A well-drafted hybrid policy reduces future disputes. It should state that remote and hybrid arrangements are a privilege that the employer may modify or end on reasonable notice, define eligibility by role, set expectations about availability, equipment, security and confidentiality, and explain how location changes must be approved. It should also address work from other provinces and countries, expenses and the process for accommodation. New offer letters should incorporate the policy by reference and state the employee's primary work location.
The policy is only as strong as its application. Employers that allow broad exceptions informally, then try to enforce the policy against one employee, invite claims of inconsistent or discriminatory treatment. Periodic audits of who works where help keep practice aligned with policy.
Termination where remote work is a term
Where an employer concludes that a remote employee will not or cannot return, and remote work was a term of employment, ending the relationship with notice or a package may be the cleanest path. The employee is then entitled to statutory and common law or contractual notice. Offering relocation assistance, a transition period or a role change may reduce exposure and maintain goodwill. Releases should be obtained in exchange for any amount above statutory entitlements.
Discipline for non-compliance
Where a return to office requirement is lawful, an employee who refuses to comply may be disciplined like any other employee who ignores a reasonable instruction. Progressive discipline is usually expected: a written reminder, then a warning that continued refusal may lead to termination. Summary dismissal for a first refusal is risky, particularly for long-service employees. Before disciplining, check whether the employee has raised an accommodation request or a safety concern, since discipline in that context can be treated as reprisal.
Attendance tracking used to enforce the policy should be proportionate. Badge data and calendar records are usually sufficient; more intrusive tracking raises privacy questions and, for larger Ontario employers, must be described in the written electronic monitoring policy. Decisions should be based on reliable records, reviewed by a manager who can take account of approved exceptions.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise employers on return to office strategies and on remote work across provinces and borders: contract and policy review, accommodation processes, communications, discipline and dispute resolution, and coordination with tax, payroll and immigration advisers. Our employment law and business immigration teams work together on these issues. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us before announcing a new policy.
Frequently asked questions
Can an employer require employees to return to the office?
Often yes, where the contract names an office location and remote work was introduced as temporary. Reasonable notice of the change helps. Where remote work became an express or implied term, a mandate may be a constructive dismissal unless the employee agrees or reasonable notice of the change is given.
Do we have to accommodate requests to keep working remotely?
Where a request is based on a protected ground, such as disability, family status or religion, the employer must accommodate to the point of undue hardship. That may involve remote work, modified schedules or other measures, but not necessarily the employee's preferred option.
Which employment standards apply to an employee working from another province?
Generally those of the province where the work is performed. An employee working remotely from Nova Scotia for an Ontario employer is usually covered by Nova Scotia's employment standards, while payroll, workers' compensation and tax allocation have their own rules.
Can employees work remotely from another country?
Only with careful planning. Foreign immigration, employment, payroll, social security and tax rules may apply, and the employee's activities could create a permanent establishment. Many employers allow only short periods abroad with approval.
Can we dismiss an employee who refuses to return?
If the return to office requirement is lawful, refusal can be addressed through progressive discipline, ending in termination if the employee persists after clear warnings. Check first for accommodation requests or safety concerns, which change the analysis.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


