Constructive Dismissal: Risks in Changing Employment Terms
Employers change jobs all the time, through reorganizations, new reporting lines, compensation redesign and relocations. When a change goes to the heart of the employment relationship without the employee's agreement, it can amount to constructive dismissal, entitling the employee to resign and claim damages as if dismissed without cause.

Key takeaways
- Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer substantially changes an essential term without consent.
- Potter, 2015 SCC 10, sets out two branches: a substantial breach of an essential term, or conduct showing an intention not to be bound.
- Significant pay cuts, demotions, relocations and unauthorized layoffs are common triggers.
- A poisoned or toxic work environment can also amount to constructive dismissal.
- Employees may have to mitigate by accepting the changed role in some circumstances.
- Changes can be made lawfully with consent and consideration or with reasonable working notice.
What constructive dismissal is
Constructive dismissal is the doctrine that treats an employee as dismissed when the employer, without terminating the employment expressly, breaches the contract in a way that shows it no longer intends to be bound by it. The employee may accept the breach, resign, and claim damages for wrongful dismissal, usually measured by reasonable notice. Because most employment contracts are not written in exhaustive detail, many disputes involve implied terms about compensation, duties, status and location.

The leading decision is Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10. The Supreme Court described two branches. Under the first, the employee must show a breach of an express or implied term, and that the breach substantially altered an essential term of the contract, judged objectively from the perspective of a reasonable person in the employee's situation. Under the second, the employee shows that the employer's conduct, viewed in light of all the circumstances, demonstrated an intention to no longer be bound by the contract, without needing to identify a specific term. In Potter, an indefinite administrative suspension with pay, without a legitimate business reason or explanation, was a constructive dismissal.
Earlier, in Farber v. Royal Trust Co., [1997] 1 SCR 846, the Court held that a transfer to a less prestigious and lower-paying position was a constructive dismissal. Those principles continue to guide courts across common law Canada, and Quebec courts apply similar concepts under the Civil Code.
Common triggers for constructive dismissal
| Change | Risk level | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Significant reduction in base pay | High | Courts have often treated reductions of roughly 10% to 15% or more as substantial, but context matters |
| Change in commission or bonus structure | Moderate to high | Depends on effect on total compensation and contractual discretion |
| Demotion or loss of reporting staff | High | Loss of status and responsibility can be decisive even without a pay cut |
| Relocation | Moderate to high | Unless the contract allows transfers or relocation was implied by the role |
| Temporary layoff without contractual right | High | At common law, an unauthorized layoff is usually a repudiation |
| Change in hours or schedule | Moderate | Significant changes to hours or shift patterns can qualify |
| Harassment or toxic environment | Varies | Conduct that makes continued employment intolerable |
There is no fixed percentage threshold for pay cuts or a checklist for duties. Courts look at the cumulative effect of changes on the employee's position. A change that seems modest on paper, such as a new reporting line, can be substantial if it signals a loss of status in a small organization.
Temporary layoffs
Employment standards statutes in several provinces allow temporary layoffs for defined periods without triggering statutory termination obligations. But the common law is different. Unless the employment contract expressly or impliedly permits layoffs, for example because layoffs are a well-known industry practice, a layoff without pay is generally a constructive dismissal at common law. The Court of Appeal for Ontario confirmed this approach in Elsegood v. Cambridge Spring Service (2001) Ltd., 2011 ONCA 831. Employers in cyclical industries should include clear layoff clauses in contracts and comply with the statutory conditions for temporary layoffs under, for example, Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000.
Poisoned work environments
The second branch of Potter covers conduct that makes continued employment intolerable, such as persistent harassment, humiliation or abuse by a supervisor, or a failure to address serious workplace harassment. The threshold is high: ordinary workplace conflict, a demanding manager or a performance improvement plan does not usually qualify. But employers who ignore complaints or retaliate against employees who raise them face both dismissal claims and liability under occupational health and safety and human rights legislation, which in Ontario require workplace harassment policies and investigations.
Performance management is not a repudiation of the contract if done in good faith. Document expectations, give the employee a fair chance to improve and avoid public criticism or changes to title or reporting during the process. A sudden demotion presented as performance management is the classic fact pattern for a claim.
How employees respond, and condonation
An employee faced with a fundamental change can accept it, expressly or by continuing to work without objection for more than a reasonable period; object and continue working under protest while seeking to negotiate; or resign and claim constructive dismissal. Continuing to work under the new terms for a long period without protest may amount to condonation, weakening a later claim. Employees who object in writing and continue working for a short period while they consider their options usually preserve their claim.
Employers should take employee objections seriously. A written objection is often the first step toward a claim, and a prompt meeting to explain the business reason, offer transition arrangements or reconsider the change can avoid litigation.
Mitigation by accepting the new role
An employee who resigns and sues must still mitigate. In Evans v. Teamsters Local Union No. 31, 2008 SCC 20, the Supreme Court held that a dismissed employee may be required to mitigate by accepting temporary re-employment with the same employer, where the salary is the same, working conditions are not substantially different and the relationship is not acrimonious, so that a reasonable person would accept it. Applied here, an employee offered a modestly changed role in a respectful environment may be expected to work in it during the notice period, which reduces damages. Where the change was demeaning, or the relationship has broken down, mitigation with the same employer is not required.
Implementing changes lawfully
- Check the contract. Does it allow changes to duties, location, compensation plans or layoffs? Reasonable flexibility clauses, applied in good faith, reduce risk.
- Obtain consent with consideration. A raise, bonus, title or other benefit in exchange for agreeing to new terms makes the change contractual.
- Give working notice of the change. Notice of a change equal to the employee's reasonable notice period allows the employer to implement it at the end of the period, effectively terminating the old contract and offering a new one.
- Phase and grandparent. Introducing compensation changes gradually or for new hires only reduces the impact on existing staff.
- Communicate. Explain the business reasons, consult where possible and document employee responses.
In unionized workplaces, changes are governed by the collective agreement and labour relations legislation, not the common law doctrine. Changes to terms may require bargaining or may be grievable.
Constructive dismissal in reorganizations and acquisitions
Corporate events generate many claims. After an acquisition, the buyer may integrate teams, change titles, consolidate offices or move employees onto new compensation plans. Employees whose roles shrink, or who are asked to report to someone who was formerly their peer, may argue that their positions have been fundamentally changed. In a share purchase, employment continues with the same employer, so changes are tested against the existing contracts. In an asset purchase, employees who accept offers from the buyer usually start new contracts, and the terms of those offers become the reference point.
Integration planning should therefore map every proposed change for each employee group and identify those that could be treated as a fundamental breach. Retention agreements, transition bonuses and clear communications reduce the risk. Where reductions are unavoidable, it may be cheaper and cleaner to terminate with a package than to impose a change that invites a claim and damages the remaining workforce's morale.
Return-to-office mandates and remote work
Requiring employees who have worked remotely to return to the office has become a frequent source of disputes. Whether a return-to-office mandate is a constructive dismissal depends on the contract and the history. Where the contract specifies an office location and remote work was a temporary accommodation, a reasonable recall with notice is generally lawful. Where the employee was hired as a remote worker, or remote work became an established term, a mandate may change an essential term. Accommodation obligations under human rights law also apply where an employee's disability or family status is engaged.
Workplace investigations and suspensions
Potter arose from an administrative suspension. Employers may suspend employees with pay during a genuine investigation, but the suspension should be reasonable in length, explained, and tied to a legitimate business reason. Unpaid suspensions are generally permissible only where the contract or a policy forming part of it allows them, or for serious misconduct after due process. Indefinite suspensions without explanation, or used to push an employee out, carry a real risk of constructive dismissal.
Damages
Damages in these cases are measured like damages for wrongful dismissal: pay in lieu of reasonable notice, subject to mitigation, plus any statutory entitlements, and possibly moral or punitive damages where the employer acted in bad faith in the manner of dismissal. Where the employment contract contains an enforceable termination clause, the clause usually caps damages. Our insight on reasonable notice explains how courts calculate the period.
Illustration: a sales manager with eight years' service is moved from a role managing a team of six, with a base salary of CAD 120,000 plus commission, to an individual contributor role with the same base salary but no team and a reduced commission plan. She objects in writing and resigns three weeks later. A court is likely to find a fundamental breach because of the loss of status and the effect on total compensation, and to award damages based on reasonable notice, reduced by any income from new employment.
Pre-change checklist
- Identify every employee affected and the contract terms that apply to each.
- Quantify the effect on total compensation, not just base salary.
- Assess changes in title, reporting, staff, hours and location together.
- Decide whether to seek consent, give working notice of the change or restructure the role.
- Prepare communications that explain the business rationale and the timetable.
- Plan for employees who object, including a fallback termination package.
Running through this list before announcing a change takes little time and often reveals that a small adjustment, such as preserving a title or phasing in a compensation change, removes most of the legal risk.
Quebec and federal employees
In Quebec, the Civil Code governs, and courts recognize "congédiement déguisé", applying a similar analysis to substantial unilateral changes. Employees with two years of continuous service may also complain to the labour standards tribunal under the Act respecting labour standards for dismissal without good and sufficient cause, which can lead to reinstatement. Federally regulated non-managerial employees with 12 months' service can use the Canada Labour Code's unjust dismissal process.
How TRW & Co helps
We help employers plan reorganizations, compensation changes and relocations to minimize constructive dismissal risk, draft flexibility and layoff clauses, respond to employee objections and defend claims. Our work is part of our employment law and workplace investigations practices. See also our insights on termination clauses and return-to-office mandates. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us before implementing changes.
Frequently asked questions
What is the test for constructive dismissal?
Under Potter v. New Brunswick Legal Aid Services Commission, 2015 SCC 10, an employee must show either a breach that substantially alters an essential term of the contract, assessed objectively, or employer conduct that shows an intention not to be bound by the contract. Either branch allows the employee to resign and claim damages.
Is any pay cut a constructive dismissal?
No. Courts look at the size of the cut, its effect on total compensation and the whole context. Significant reductions, often in the range of 10% to 15% or more, have frequently been found substantial, but there is no fixed threshold, and smaller changes combined with loss of status can qualify.
Can we lay off employees temporarily?
Employment standards statutes may permit temporary layoffs, but at common law a layoff without a contractual right is generally a constructive dismissal. Contracts should include a clear layoff clause, and statutory conditions must be met.
Must the employee stay in the new role?
Sometimes. Under Evans v. Teamsters, 2008 SCC 20, mitigation can require accepting re-employment with the same employer where pay and conditions are similar and the relationship is not acrimonious. Where the change is demeaning or the relationship has broken down, it is not required.
How can employers change terms safely?
Use contractual flexibility in good faith, obtain the employee's consent with fresh consideration, or give working notice of the change equal to reasonable notice before implementing it. Clear communication and documentation also reduce the risk of claims.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


