Secure Energy: Lessons From a Contested Merger Challenge
Secure Energy's acquisition of Tervita is the leading recent example of a completed merger partly unwound by the Competition Tribunal. The Tribunal found harm in 136 local markets, ordered 29 facilities sold and rejected the efficiencies defence, and the Federal Court of Appeal upheld the order.

Key takeaways
- 2023 Comp Trib 02 (3 March 2023) found a substantial lessening of competition in 136 markets.
- Secure was ordered to divest 29 of the 41 facilities the Commissioner sought.
- The efficiencies defence failed against quantified price and non-price effects.
- 2023 FCA 172 (1 August 2023) upheld the order-driven efficiencies analysis.
- Today's presumptions and remedial standard would make a similar case harder to defend.
What happened in the Secure Energy case
In Canada (Commissioner of Competition) v. Secure Energy Services Inc., 2023 Comp Trib 02, the Competition Tribunal found on 3 March 2023 that Secure Energy's 2021 acquisition of Tervita Corporation substantially lessened competition in 136 local markets for oilfield waste services in Western Canada, and ordered Secure to divest 29 facilities. The Federal Court of Appeal dismissed Secure's appeal in Secure Energy Services Inc. v. Commissioner of Competition, 2023 FCA 172, on 1 August 2023. Secure Energy is the leading example of a completed merger unwound in part after a contested hearing, and of the efficiencies defence failing on the evidence.

The case is also a useful counterpoint to the Rogers–Shaw litigation decided weeks earlier, where the Commissioner lost because a credible fix had been built into the deal before the hearing. Here, no adequate remedy was agreed, the merger closed, and the Tribunal imposed its own. For merging parties, the case offers practical lessons on closing over a pending challenge, the evidence needed on competitive effects and remedies, and the burden of proving efficiencies, even though the efficiencies defence has since been repealed for new mergers. This note summarizes the facts, the Tribunal's findings, the appeal and the lessons. It is general information, not legal advice.
The facts: the two largest suppliers combine
According to the Competition Bureau's August 2023 release, Secure and Tervita were the two largest suppliers of oil and gas waste services in the Western Canadian Sedimentary Basin before the merger, and in many areas they were the only suppliers. Their facilities included treatment, recovery and disposal facilities, salt water disposal wells, landfills and disposal caverns used by producers to manage drilling and production waste.
The Commissioner filed an application with the Tribunal on 29 June 2021, and the Bureau's March 2023 release states that the harm had been ongoing since July 2021, as the merger closed while the challenge proceeded. The Commissioner alleged a substantial lessening of competition in 143 relevant local markets, drawn from 271 areas of competitive overlap, and sought divestiture of 41 facilities. The hearing ran from May to June 2022 before a panel of Chief Justice Crampton, Justice Gascon and Dr. Ted Horbulyk.
| Item | Detail |
|---|---|
| Commissioner's application | 29 June 2021 |
| Markets alleged / found | 143 alleged; substantial lessening found in 136 |
| Facilities sought / ordered | 41 sought (26 treatment facilities, 5 salt water disposal wells, 8 landfills, 2 caverns); 29 ordered |
| Tribunal decision | 3 March 2023, 2023 Comp Trib 02 |
| Appeal | Dismissed with costs, 1 August 2023, 2023 FCA 172 |
The Tribunal's findings in Secure Energy
The Tribunal's reasons proceeded in three stages: whether competition was substantially lessened, what remedy was required, and whether the efficiencies defence in former s. 96 of the Competition Act applied.
Competitive effects. The Tribunal found that the merger substantially lessened competition in 136 of the 143 markets. Pre-merger, the two firms had been close competitors, which, as the Commissioner put it in the Bureau's release, led to better outcomes for customers.
Remedy. Because the merger had already closed, the remedy question was what portion of the combined business had to be sold to restore competition, rather than whether a proposed fix would preserve it. The Tribunal held that the divestiture of 29 of the 41 facilities the Commissioner sought would be sufficient to restore competition to the requisite degree, subject to the efficiencies defence.
Efficiencies. Because the merger predated the December 2023 repeal of s. 96, Secure could invoke the defence. The Tribunal accepted cognizable efficiencies of about CAD 32.2 million in net present value terms (about CAD 4.6 million annualized), but found that Secure had not met its burden on certain claimed savings, including from facility rationalizations and some corporate costs.
The Commissioner had quantified the anti-competitive effects as a deadweight loss of roughly CAD 30.2 million to at least CAD 39.4 million in net present value, including non-price effects of about CAD 3.68 million a year in higher transportation costs that customers would likely pay as Secure closed facilities. On that record, the defence failed, and the divestiture order stood as the Tribunal had framed it.
Closing a merger while the Commissioner's challenge is pending is possible, but the parties carry the risk of a later divestiture order covering facilities they have already integrated. Integration plans, facility closures and customer transitions should be designed so that assets can still be separated and sold if the Tribunal orders it.
The appeal: an order-driven efficiencies analysis
Secure appealed mainly on efficiencies. The Federal Court of Appeal (Woods, Locke and LeBlanc JJ.A., reasons by Justice Locke) applied correctness to questions of law and palpable and overriding error to questions of fact and mixed fact and law, noting that leave is required under s. 13(2) of the Competition Tribunal Act for appeals on questions of fact.
The key legal issue was how to compare efficiencies with anti-competitive effects when the Tribunal orders only a partial divestiture. The Court upheld the Tribunal's "order-driven" approach: only the efficiency gains that would not likely be attained if the order were made, the "foregone" efficiencies, are weighed, and the comparison is with the anti-competitive effects the order would address. The Court found this asymmetry clear from the text of s. 96(1) and rejected Secure's alternative. Drawing on the Supreme Court's Tervita decision, it also confirmed that unquantifiable effects may be weighed qualitatively and that the Tribunal retains discretion to reject the defence in close cases. The remaining grounds, on expert evidence, pricing and procedural fairness, failed, and the appeal was dismissed with costs.
Secure Energy and merger law today
Several features of the legal landscape have changed since the Secure Energy hearing, mostly in ways that strengthen the Commissioner's hand:
| Issue | In Secure Energy | Competition Act now |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiencies defence | Available (merger completed before repeal); failed on the evidence | Repealed for mergers notified or completed after 15 December 2023 |
| Presumption based on concentration | None | s. 92(2)-(3): HHI increase over 100 with HHI over 1,800 or combined share over 30% |
| Remedial standard | Restore competition "to the requisite degree" | s. 92(1)(e): restore competition to the level that would have prevailed but for the merger |
| Challenge period | One year after substantial completion | One year if notified; three years otherwise (s. 97) |
A merger between the two largest suppliers in many local markets would today very likely trigger the structural presumption, shifting the burden to the parties to show that competition will not be substantially lessened. And without an efficiencies defence, the economic case that cost savings outweigh harm is no longer a statutory answer. See our notes on structural presumptions and merger remedies.
The process: how a contested merger case unfolds
The Secure Energy litigation also shows how long and resource-intensive a contested merger case can be, even when it moves quickly by litigation standards. The Commissioner applied in June 2021, the hearing took place in May and June 2022, the Tribunal ruled in March 2023 and the appeal was decided in August 2023. For more than two years, the merged business operated under the shadow of a possible divestiture order.
During that period the parties had to manage several parallel workstreams:
- Evidence. Documentary production, fact witnesses from the business and its customers, and competing economic experts on market definition, competitive effects, price elasticity and efficiencies.
- Integration. Decisions on which facilities to keep open, close or consolidate, made knowing that closures could be cited as evidence of harm and could complicate a later divestiture.
- Remedy readiness. Preparing for the possibility of a sale of facilities, including identifying potential buyers and the contracts, permits and personnel each facility would need.
- Stakeholder communications. Customers, employees, regulators and investors all needed to understand the uncertainty, and public statements could become evidence.
The appeal was confined largely to questions of law and to issues on which leave was granted. Parties should assume that the Tribunal's factual findings, including on market definition and competitive effects, will be very difficult to overturn, and should invest accordingly at first instance.
Questions for boards considering a competitor acquisition
Directors approving an acquisition of a close competitor in concentrated local markets can draw on the Secure Energy experience to frame their review:
- In how many local or regional markets will the merged firm be the only or the largest supplier, and what alternatives will customers realistically have?
- Does the integration plan rely on closing facilities, and what will that mean for customers' costs and choices?
- What remedy could we offer, to whom, and would it be enough to restore or preserve competition in each area of concern?
- If we close before the Commissioner's review or challenge is resolved, what is our exposure to a later divestiture, and how is that risk priced?
- Have we modelled the s. 92(2) presumption and the s. 97 limitation period?
Lessons for merging parties
- Local markets matter. Secure Energy turned on many small geographic markets defined around facilities and customer haul distances. National market shares can mask local overlaps.
- Non-price effects count. Higher transportation costs for customers, caused by facility closures, were quantified and weighed. Integration plans that close facilities can themselves be evidence of harm, because customers may have to haul waste further to reach the remaining sites.
- Remedies are calibrated, not all-or-nothing. The Tribunal ordered 29 of 41 facilities, reflecting a market-by-market analysis of what was needed. Parties should prepare their own remedy proposals early, with buyer-ready packages that include the permits, contracts, equipment and staff each facility needs to operate independently.
- Evidence of efficiencies must be specific. Claimed savings that are not proven on a balance of probabilities will be excluded; that lesson applies to efficiency evidence in competitive effects analysis even after repeal.
- Allocate risk in the deal documents. Divestiture covenants, closing conditions and price adjustments should reflect the possibility of a post-closing order.
Illustration (hypothetical): two regional providers of industrial waste disposal agree to merge, overlapping in 20 local areas. Applying the reasoning in Secure Energy and the amended Act, the parties should map each local market, model customers' alternatives and transport costs, test the s. 92(2) presumption area by area, and prepare a divestiture package for areas where they would be the only or the two closest suppliers, rather than counting on cost savings.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise Canadian and international businesses on Competition Act merger review, including local market analysis, structural presumptions, remedy design, divestiture agreements and strategy where the Commissioner challenges a deal before or after closing. We coordinate economic evidence and work with Canadian-licensed litigation counsel in Tribunal proceedings and appeals. See our merger review and oil, gas and LNG pages, or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Why did the Tribunal order only 29 facilities to be sold?
The Tribunal assessed each relevant market and found that divesting 29 of the 41 facilities the Commissioner sought would be sufficient to restore competition to the requisite degree. Remedies are calibrated to the markets where harm is found rather than unwinding the entire merger.
Why did the efficiencies defence fail?
Secure proved cognizable efficiencies of about CAD 32.2 million in net present value but did not prove certain other claimed savings. The Commissioner quantified the anti-competitive effects, including non-price effects from higher transportation costs, and the Tribunal concluded Secure had not shown efficiencies greater than and offsetting those effects.
What is the order-driven approach to efficiencies?
Under former s. 96(1), only efficiency gains that would not likely be attained if the order were made are weighed against the anti-competitive effects. Where the Tribunal orders a partial divestiture, the relevant efficiencies are those lost because of that order. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld this approach in 2023 FCA 172.
Could Secure have relied on the efficiencies defence if it merged today?
No. The defence was repealed by S.C. 2023, c. 31, effective 15 December 2023, subject to transitional rules for transactions notified or completed earlier. Secure's merger closed in 2021, so the defence was still available to it.
Can parties close a merger while the Commissioner is challenging it?
Closing may be possible if no injunction or interim order prevents it and the statutory waiting period has expired, but the parties risk a later divestiture order. Integration should preserve the ability to separate and sell assets, and deal documents should allocate that risk.
Sources
- Canada (Commissioner of Competition) v Secure Energy Services Inc., 2023 Comp Trib 02 (reasons, public version)
- Competition Tribunal information note on the Secure Energy decision (3 March 2023)
- Secure Energy Services Inc. v. Commissioner of Competition, 2023 FCA 172
- Competition Bureau, Competition Bureau successful in challenge of Secure and Tervita merger (7 March 2023)
- Competition Bureau, Federal Court of Appeal upholds challenge of Secure and Tervita merger (2 August 2023)
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


