Skip to content
Leading Court Decisions

The Tervita Decision: The Efficiencies Defence and Its Repeal

The Tervita decision let a merger that was likely to prevent competition proceed because its efficiencies outweighed anti-competitive effects the Commissioner had not quantified. Its prevention framework still guides merger review, but Parliament repealed the efficiencies defence in December 2023.

The Tervita decision explained: merger efficiencies defence, prevention of competition and the 2023 repeal

Key takeaways

  • Tervita Corp. v. Canada (Commissioner of Competition), 2015 SCC 3, was decided on 22 January 2015.
  • The Court set aside a divestiture order despite finding a likely substantial prevention of competition.
  • Unquantified but quantifiable anti-competitive effects were fixed at zero in the efficiencies balance.
  • The 'but for' prevention framework remains the Tribunal's approach.
  • Bill C-56 repealed the merger efficiencies defence effective 15 December 2023.

What the Tervita decision held

The Tervita decision, Tervita Corp. v. Canada (Commissioner of Competition), 2015 SCC 3, released on 22 January 2015, is the Supreme Court of Canada's leading merger decision. The Court set aside a Competition Tribunal order requiring Tervita to divest a small landfill business, holding that although the merger was likely to prevent competition substantially, the efficiencies defence then in s. 96 of the Competition Act saved it. Justice Karakatsanis dissented.

The Tervita decision explained: merger efficiencies defence, prevention of competition and the 2023 repeal
The Tervita decision defined "prevention" of competition and gave the efficiencies defence real force until Parliament repealed it in 2023.

The Tervita decision shaped Canadian merger law in two lasting ways. Its framework for assessing whether a merger prevents competition, comparing the likely future with and without the merger, is still applied by the Tribunal. Its reading of the efficiencies defence, by contrast, made Canada an outlier among major jurisdictions and was a key reason Parliament repealed the defence in December 2023. This note explains both parts and what they mean for merging parties today. It is general information, not legal advice.

The facts: a small landfill in northeastern British Columbia

Tervita Corporation operated secure landfills for hazardous oilfield waste in northeastern British Columbia. It acquired Complete Environmental Inc., whose subsidiary Babkirk Land Services Inc. held a permit to operate a secure landfill that had not yet begun operating. The Commissioner of Competition challenged the acquisition under s. 92, arguing that Babkirk would likely have entered the market and competed with Tervita, and that the merger prevented that competition.

The Competition Tribunal agreed, found that the merger was likely to prevent competition substantially in secure hazardous waste landfill services in northeastern British Columbia, held that Tervita had not proved efficiencies that were greater than and offset the anti-competitive effects, and ordered divestiture of the shares or assets of Babkirk. The Federal Court of Appeal upheld that decision in 2013 FCA 28. On 22 January 2015 the Supreme Court allowed Tervita's appeal, set aside the divestiture order and dismissed the Commissioner's application, according to the Court's case record.

CourtResult
Competition TribunalSubstantial prevention of competition; efficiencies defence fails; divestiture of Babkirk ordered
Federal Court of Appeal (2013 FCA 28)Tribunal's order upheld
Supreme Court of Canada (2015 SCC 3)Appeal allowed; divestiture order set aside; application dismissed; Karakatsanis J. dissenting

Prevention of competition after the Tervita decision

Section 92 covers mergers that "prevent or lessen" competition substantially. Before Tervita, prevention cases were rare and their test unsettled. The Supreme Court's framework, as later summarized by the Tribunal in the Rogers–Shaw decision, has several elements:

  • The "but for" comparison. The Tribunal compares the likely state of competition with the merger to the likely state without it, looking at price and non-price dimensions such as service, quality, variety and innovation.
  • Prevention versus lessening. Lessening asks whether the merger facilitates new or increased market power. Prevention asks whether it preserves existing market power by preventing the erosion that would likely otherwise have occurred, for example through entry or expansion.
  • Forward-looking but disciplined. The analysis must be forward-looking, but the likelihood of future entry must be shown on the evidence. If other firms would likely enter or expand on a similar scale within the relevant timeframe, prevention is unlikely to be substantial.
  • Magnitude, scope and duration. Substantiality depends on the degree and duration of the likely effects, not rigid numerical thresholds.

These principles remain good law, and they matter more now that s. 92 contains structural presumptions based on concentration. Acquisitions of nascent or potential competitors, including start-ups and permit holders, are classic prevention cases. See our page on merger review.

The efficiencies defence as applied in the Tervita decision

Former s. 96(1) of the Competition Act barred the Tribunal from making an order if the merger had brought about or was likely to bring about gains in efficiency that would be greater than, and would offset, the effects of any prevention or lessening of competition, and that would not likely be attained if the order were made. Income redistribution could not be counted as an efficiency.

The decisive point in the Tervita decision was procedural. The Commissioner had not quantified the anti-competitive effects that could have been quantified. As the Tribunal later explained in Secure Energy, the Supreme Court held that, in those circumstances, the anti-competitive effects were fixed at zero for the purposes of Tervita's efficiencies defence. The efficiencies Tervita proved were then enough to outweigh and offset effects with no assigned weight, and the defence succeeded. The Court also recognized that effects that genuinely cannot be quantified may be weighed qualitatively, that efficiencies need not pass a formal significance threshold, and that in close cases the Tribunal retains discretion to reject the defence if it explains its reasons.

Practical point

The efficiencies defence no longer applies to mergers notified or completed after the 2023 repeal, but Tervita's evidentiary lessons survive: the party with the burden must quantify what can be quantified, explain uncertainty in its models, and give the Tribunal a clear basis for weighing qualitative effects.

The dissent and the policy debate

Justice Karakatsanis would have dismissed the appeal. The broader debate that followed focused on the outcome: a merger found likely to prevent competition substantially could nonetheless proceed because of small cost savings, with consumers bearing the price effects. Critics argued that the defence, as interpreted, protected anti-competitive mergers and placed a heavy quantification burden on the Commissioner. Supporters argued that it rewarded genuine productivity gains. Those competing views framed later reform, including the government's consultations on competition policy and the amendments that followed in 2023 and 2024.

ElementUnder the Tervita decisionCompetition Act today
Prevention test"But for" comparison; erosion of market power that would otherwise occurSame framework applied by the Tribunal
Efficiencies defenceAvailable; effects not quantified by the Commissioner could carry no weightRepealed by S.C. 2023, c. 31, s. 10 (s. 96 now reads "Repealed")
Concentration-based presumptionNones. 92(2)-(3): HHI increase over 100 plus HHI over 1,800 or share over 30%
Remedial standardNot stated in s. 92Restore or preserve the competition that would have prevailed but for the merger

How the Tervita decision has been applied since

The two most significant contested mergers after 2015 both drew on the decision, in different ways.

Rogers–Shaw (2023). In 2023 Comp Trib 1, the Tribunal relied extensively on the Tervita decision for its statement of the s. 92 framework: the "but for" comparison, the distinction between prevention and lessening, the evaluation of magnitude, scope and duration, and the focus on whether the merged firm could exercise materially greater market power. It also cited the decision for the proposition that, under s. 92 itself, the Commissioner need not quantify the overall deadweight loss to the economy. The Tribunal found no substantial lessening and did not need to reach efficiencies. See our note on the Rogers–Shaw ruling.

Secure Energy (2023). In 2023 Comp Trib 02, the Tribunal found a substantial lessening of competition in 136 local markets for oilfield waste services and ordered the divestiture of 29 facilities. Secure invoked the efficiencies defence, which still applied to its 2021 merger. This time the Commissioner had quantified the anti-competitive effects, including non-price effects, and the defence failed. On appeal in 2023 FCA 172, the Federal Court of Appeal relied on the Tervita decision for the points that unquantifiable effects may be weighed qualitatively, that "greater than" and "offset" combine quantitative comparison with judgment, and that the Tribunal retains discretion to reject the defence in close cases.

The lesson of the two outcomes

The contrast between Tervita and Secure illustrates how much the efficiencies defence depended on evidence. Where the Commissioner left quantifiable effects unquantified, efficiencies prevailed; where the Commissioner quantified price and non-price effects in detail, the defence failed even though the Tribunal accepted cognizable efficiencies of about CAD 32 million in net present value terms, because the quantified anti-competitive effects, including higher transportation costs for customers, were not outweighed and offset. That dependence on contested economic modelling, and the risk that consumers would bear price increases from mergers saved by cost savings, were central to the policy case for repeal.

Why the 2023 amendments removed the defence

Bill C-56, enacted as S.C. 2023, c. 31, became law on 15 December 2023 and repealed the efficiencies defence for mergers; the Competition Bureau's guide to the December 2023 amendments explains that the efficiency exception was also removed from the civil competitor collaboration provision, effective 15 December 2024. According to the Bureau's guide, the merger defence continues to apply to proposed transactions for which notice was given, or mergers substantially completed, before the amendments came into force. That transitional rule is why the defence could still be argued in the Secure Energy litigation, which concerned a 2021 merger; see our note on Secure Energy.

Efficiencies have not become irrelevant. Merging parties can still present evidence of efficiencies as part of the competitive effects analysis, for example to show that a merger will lower costs and make the merged firm a stronger rival, and the Bureau considers such evidence in review. But efficiencies no longer operate as a statutory trump that can save a merger found to substantially lessen or prevent competition.

Practical points for merging parties today

  1. Do not rely on efficiencies to save a problematic deal. Plan for clearance on competitive effects, with remedies where needed.
  2. Take potential competition seriously. Acquisitions of nascent rivals, permit holders and expansion-ready firms can be challenged as preventing competition, applying the Tervita decision's framework.
  3. Model concentration. Compute HHI and shares in each plausible market to see whether the s. 92(2) presumption could be engaged.
  4. Watch the limitation period. Under s. 97, the Commissioner has one year after substantial completion to challenge a notified merger and three years otherwise; small deals below notification thresholds, like the one in Tervita, are not immune.
  5. Prepare quantitative evidence. Quantify what can be quantified, as both the Commissioner and the parties will be held to their evidentiary burdens; see our note on non-notifiable mergers.

Illustration (hypothetical): an incumbent waste services firm buys a local competitor's unbuilt but permitted facility. In 2015, the parties might have argued that cost savings outweighed any harm. Today, with the efficiencies defence repealed, the question is simply whether the acquisition prevents competition substantially by eliminating likely entry, and if so, what remedy restores or preserves the competition that would have prevailed.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise Canadian and international businesses on merger review under the amended Competition Act, including competitive effects analysis, potential-competition and nascent-competitor issues, structural presumptions, remedies and contested proceedings before the Competition Tribunal. We coordinate economic evidence and work with Canadian-licensed litigation counsel where a case proceeds. Learn more on our competition and foreign investment page, or contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What does 'prevention of competition' mean?

A merger prevents competition where it preserves existing market power by eliminating erosion that would likely have occurred without the merger, for example through a rival's entry or expansion. Following the Tervita decision, the Tribunal compares the likely future with and without the merger and requires evidence that the eliminated competition was likely.

Why did Tervita win on efficiencies?

The Commissioner had not quantified anti-competitive effects that could have been quantified. The Supreme Court held that, for the purposes of the defence, those effects were therefore fixed at zero, so the efficiencies Tervita proved were enough to outweigh and offset them.

Is the efficiencies defence still available?

Not for new mergers. Section 96 was repealed by S.C. 2023, c. 31, effective 15 December 2023. The Bureau's guide explains it continues to apply to transactions notified, or mergers substantially completed, before the amendments came into force, which is why it was argued in Secure Energy.

Can efficiencies still help a merger get cleared?

Yes, as evidence. Parties can show that cost savings or other efficiencies make the merged firm a more effective competitor, which can bear on the competitive effects analysis. But efficiencies can no longer override a finding of substantial lessening or prevention of competition.

Can a small, non-notifiable merger be challenged?

Yes. The Tervita acquisition was small. Under s. 97, the Commissioner can challenge a non-notified merger up to three years after substantial completion, and one year after completion for notified mergers.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Canada, case record 35314: Tervita Corporation et al. v. Commissioner of Competition (judgment of 22 January 2015)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada, judgment release listing 2015 SCC 3
  3. Competition Act (s. 92; s. 96 repealed)
  4. Competition Bureau, Guide to the December 2023 amendments to the Competition Act
  5. Canada (Commissioner of Competition) v Secure Energy Services Inc., 2023 Comp Trib 02

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.