Suing Government: Crown, Municipal and Police Liability
Suing government in Canada is possible but procedurally demanding. Crown liability statutes, Ontario's 2019 reforms, the policy/operational distinction from Nelson v. Marchi, leave requirements for misfeasance and short municipal notice periods can decide a claim before the merits are heard.

Key takeaways
- The federal Crown is liable in tort as if it were a person (CLPA s. 3).
- Ontario requires 60 days' notice before suing the Crown for damages (CLPA 2019 s. 18).
- Ontario bars negligence claims for good-faith policy, legislative and certain regulatory decisions.
- Misfeasance claims against the Ontario Crown need leave, with no discovery on the motion.
- Nelson v. Marchi, 2021 SCC 41, narrows core policy immunity to high-level policy decisions.
- Ontario road-repair claims need written notice to the municipality within 10 days.
Suing government in Canada: the basics
Suing government in Canada is possible, but it is not the same as suing a private company. Federal and provincial Crowns, municipalities, police services and regulators can be liable in contract and in tort, yet statutes and the common law add special rules: immunities for policy decisions and legislative acts, short notice periods, leave requirements for some claims, and limits on remedies against the Crown. A business that has suffered loss because of a negligent inspection, a cancelled contract, an unlawful regulatory decision or a municipal failure to repair needs to identify the right defendant and the right procedure quickly, because the procedural traps are often more dangerous than the merits.

This insight outlines Crown liability statutes, Ontario's 2019 reforms, the distinction between policy and operational decisions, misfeasance in public office, municipal notice periods and claims of regulatory negligence. It focuses on federal law and Ontario, with notes on other provinces. It is general information, not legal advice.
Crown liability statutes
At common law, the Crown could not be sued in tort. Statutes changed that. Federally, the Crown Liability and Proceedings Act provides in s. 3 that the Crown is liable for the damages for which, if it were a person, it would be liable, including for torts committed by its servants and for breach of duties attaching to property. Claims are generally brought in the Federal Court or in provincial superior courts, depending on the claim.
In Ontario, the Crown Liability and Proceedings Act, 2019 (CLPA 2019) replaced the former Proceedings Against the Crown Act. It preserves Crown liability in tort but adds significant protections for government:
- Legislative functions. No cause of action arises for negligence in performing functions of a legislative nature, including developing or introducing bills and regulations (s. 11(1)).
- Regulatory decisions. No cause of action arises for negligence in making a good-faith regulatory decision where a person suffers harm from the conduct of the person regulated (s. 11(2)-(3)).
- Policy decisions. No cause of action arises for negligence in making a good-faith decision on a policy matter, defined broadly to include the design, funding, manner of delivery and termination of programs (s. 11(4)-(5)).
- Notice. No proceeding claiming damages may be brought against the Crown unless the claimant serves notice of the claim with sufficient particulars at least 60 days before commencing it (s. 18(1)).
- Leave for bad-faith torts. Proceedings alleging misfeasance in public office or a tort based on bad faith require leave of the court and are deemed stayed until leave is granted (s. 17).
| Defendant | Key statute or rule | Procedural requirement |
|---|---|---|
| Federal Crown | Crown Liability and Proceedings Act | Liability as if a person (s. 3); limitation rules of the province where the claim arose generally apply |
| Ontario Crown | CLPA 2019 | 60-day notice before suing for damages (s. 18); leave for misfeasance and bad-faith claims (s. 17) |
| Ontario municipality (road repair) | Municipal Act, 2001, s. 44 | Written notice within 10 days of the injury, subject to exceptions (s. 44(10)-(12)) |
| Police services | Provincial police statutes and common law | Claims against the board or service as employer; limitation and notice rules vary |
Policy versus operational decisions
Outside statutory immunities, the common law also protects "core policy" decisions from negligence claims. In Nelson (City) v. Marchi, 2021 SCC 41, a pedestrian was injured climbing over a snowbank created by the city's snow-clearing. The Supreme Court held that core policy decisions, which are immune, are those based on public policy considerations such as economic, social and political factors, and made at a high level of government with a degree of deliberation. Decisions about how to implement policy at an operational level are not immune. The city's snow-clearing practices were operational, so a duty of care applied.
For businesses suing government, Marchi helps: many harmful decisions are implementation choices, not high-level policy. But in Ontario, the CLPA 2019 definition of "policy matter" is broader than the common law and expressly covers program design, funding and the manner in which programs are carried out. Claims against the Ontario Crown must therefore be framed with the statute in mind.
Suing government for misfeasance in public office
Misfeasance in public office is an intentional tort. Following Odhavji Estate v. Woodhouse, 2003 SCC 69, a plaintiff must show that a public officer engaged in deliberate unlawful conduct in the exercise of public functions, and that the officer was aware that the conduct was unlawful and likely to harm the plaintiff. Two categories exist: conduct specifically intended to injure, and conduct the officer knew was beyond their powers and likely to injure. The tort is useful where a regulator or official has deliberately abused authority, for example by refusing a licence for an improper purpose.
In Ontario, s. 17 of the CLPA 2019 requires leave before such a claim proceeds against the Crown or its officers. The claimant must file a concise affidavit of material facts and an affidavit of documents; the defendant is not subject to discovery on the motion; each party bears its own costs; and the court grants leave only if satisfied that the proceeding is brought in good faith and there is a reasonable possibility that the claim would succeed (s. 17(7)). This is a meaningful screen: claimants need documentary evidence of bad faith early.
If you are considering suing government in Ontario, serve the 60-day notice under s. 18 of the CLPA 2019 as soon as the claim is identified, and well before any limitation period expires. Where misfeasance is alleged, gather documents through access-to-information requests and judicial review records before the leave motion, because discovery will not be available.
Municipal and police liability
Municipalities are not the Crown, but they have their own statutory regime. Under s. 44 of Ontario's Municipal Act, 2001, a municipality must keep highways and bridges in a reasonable state of repair. A claim for damages for failure to repair requires written notice to the clerk within 10 days after the injury, including date, time and location (s. 44(10)). Failure to give notice does not bar a claim where the injured person died, or where a judge finds a reasonable excuse and no prejudice to the municipality (s. 44(11)-(12)). Statutory defences, such as compliance with minimum maintenance standards, also apply.
Municipal liability extends beyond roads to building inspections, permits, water systems and land use. Claims involving negligent building inspection have a long history in Canadian law, but courts examine whether the inspection was operational and whether the claimant's loss falls within the purpose of the regime. For land-use disputes, see our page on municipal and land use planning.
Police services can be liable for negligent investigation, recognized in Hill v. Hamilton-Wentworth Regional Police Services Board, 2007 SCC 41, as well as for malicious prosecution, false imprisonment and Charter breaches. For businesses, police liability most often arises in fraud investigations, seizures of property and the handling of seized data.
Regulatory negligence and Charter damages
Businesses harmed by a regulator's failure to supervise others, such as a failed financial intermediary or a negligent product approval, often struggle to establish a private-law duty of care. Courts ask whether the statute creates a relationship of proximity with the plaintiff, and they are reluctant to find one where the regulator acts for the public at large. Ontario's s. 11(2) adds a statutory bar for good-faith regulatory decisions where harm flows from the regulated person's conduct.
Where government action is unlawful but not tortious, judicial review is usually the primary remedy, under the standards set by Vavilov. Charter damages under s. 24(1) are available in limited cases following Vancouver (City) v. Ward, 2010 SCC 27, but corporations' Charter rights are narrower than individuals'; see our insight on division of powers challenges.
Contract claims and procurement disputes
Many disputes with government are contractual: terminated supply contracts, cancelled projects, funding agreements and procurement processes. Government contracts often include termination-for-convenience clauses, limits on damages and dispute resolution procedures that must be followed. Procurement complaints for covered federal procurements go to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal under strict timelines, and bid disputes in the provinces may be governed by trade agreements and common-law duties of fairness. Legislation can also cancel contracts and extinguish claims, as some provinces have done for energy and infrastructure contracts, subject to constitutional limits. See our insight on bid-rigging and public procurement.
Limitation periods and evidence when suing government
Limitation periods apply to claims against government much as they do to private claims, but the interaction with notice requirements creates risk. In Ontario, the general two-year discoverability period under the Limitations Act, 2002 applies to claims against the Crown, so a claimant who waits until late in that period may find that the 60-day notice under the CLPA 2019 pushes the earliest permissible filing date beyond the deadline. Federally, the Crown Liability and Proceedings Act generally applies the limitation laws of the province where the claim arose, and a six-year period for claims arising otherwise than in a province.
Evidence is the other recurring challenge when suing government. Decisions are often made through internal briefings, emails and ministerial approvals that a business never sees. Access-to-information requests under federal and provincial statutes can surface key documents, although exemptions for advice to ministers, Cabinet confidences and third-party information are common and timelines can be long. In judicial review, the certified record will include what the decision-maker had before it, which can be supplemented in limited circumstances. Planning the evidentiary route early, and preserving the business's own records of communications with officials, strengthens any later claim. Our insight on freedom of information requests explains the process.
A checklist for suing government
- Identify the correct defendant: federal Crown, provincial Crown, agency, Crown corporation, municipality or police board. Crown corporations and agencies may have their own statutes and may not share the Crown's immunities.
- Calendar notice periods (60 days for the Ontario Crown, 10 days for Ontario road-repair claims) and limitation periods.
- Decide whether judicial review, a damages action or both are appropriate, and in which court.
- Assess statutory immunities and the policy/operational distinction before pleading.
- For bad-faith torts in Ontario, prepare the leave motion evidence early.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise businesses on suing government and on defending against claims involving public bodies, including Crown liability, municipal liability, regulatory negligence and misfeasance. Our work includes identifying the correct defendant and forum, preparing statutory notices, assessing immunities under the CLPA 2019 and the common law, coordinating judicial review with damages claims, and assembling evidence through access-to-information requests. Where proceedings must be brought by counsel licensed in a province, we work with locally licensed litigation counsel. See our appellate and public law page or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
Can I sue the government for negligence in Canada?
Yes, in many cases. The federal Crown and provincial Crowns are liable in tort under Crown liability statutes, and municipalities and police services can be sued like other defendants. But core policy decisions are immune, Ontario's CLPA 2019 bars several categories of negligence claims, and special notice and leave rules apply.
What notice is required before suing the Ontario government?
Under s. 18 of the Crown Liability and Proceedings Act, 2019, a claimant must serve notice of the claim with sufficient particulars at least 60 days before commencing a proceeding that includes a claim for damages. Separate notice rules apply to municipalities, such as 10 days for highway repair claims.
What is the difference between policy and operational decisions?
Core policy decisions are high-level choices based on economic, social or political considerations, made with deliberation, and are immune from negligence claims. Operational decisions implement policy and can attract a duty of care. Nelson (City) v. Marchi, 2021 SCC 41, held a city's snow-clearing practices were operational.
What do I need to prove misfeasance in public office?
Deliberate unlawful conduct by a public officer in exercising public functions, with awareness that the conduct was unlawful and likely to harm the plaintiff. In Ontario, claims against the Crown require leave, granted only if the claim is brought in good faith and has a reasonable possibility of success.
Is judicial review better than a damages claim?
They serve different purposes. Judicial review can quash an unlawful decision but usually does not award damages. A damages action compensates loss but faces immunities and duty-of-care hurdles. Many disputes require both, coordinated so that limitation and notice deadlines are met.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


