Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Union Certification Campaigns: What Employers Can and Cannot Do

Union certification campaigns move quickly, and employers who respond wrongly can lose the vote, face remedial certification or end up in first-contract arbitration. The rules differ between card-check and vote-based jurisdictions, but everywhere the line between lawful employer expression and unlawful interference is drawn by labour boards with broad remedial powers.

Employees at a warehouse meeting during a union certification campaign

Key takeaways

  • Union certification is decided by provincial labour boards or, for federal undertakings, the CIRB.
  • The federal system and several provinces use card-check certification; others require a vote.
  • Ontario generally requires 40% membership support to apply and a vote within days.
  • Employers may communicate facts and opinions but cannot threaten, promise, interrogate or spy.
  • Unfair labour practices can lead to remedial certification and other orders.
  • First-contract arbitration is available in several jurisdictions after certification.

How union certification works

Union certification is the legal process by which a union becomes the exclusive bargaining agent for a defined group of employees, the bargaining unit. In most of Canada, it is administered by provincial labour relations boards under provincial statutes. Federally regulated employers, such as banks, airlines, rail, ports and telecommunications companies, are subject to the Canada Industrial Relations Board (CIRB) under Part I of the Canada Labour Code. Once a union is certified, the employer must recognize it and bargain in good faith toward a collective agreement.

Employees at a warehouse meeting during a union certification campaign
Union certification campaigns are governed by strict rules on employer communications and conduct.

The process varies by jurisdiction. Some jurisdictions certify on the basis of signed membership cards alone if a threshold of support is shown (card-check). Others require a secret ballot vote after an application shows a minimum level of support. Some use a hybrid, with card-check above a higher threshold and a vote below it. Timelines are short, often days, so employers have little time to respond once an application is filed.

Card-check versus vote in union certification

JurisdictionGeneral approach to union certification
Federal (Canada Labour Code)Card-check where a majority of employees in the unit are members; vote in some circumstances
Ontario (most sectors)Application with at least 40% membership support, followed by a vote, usually within five business days
Ontario (construction)Card-based certification available in many cases
QuebecCard-check where an absolute majority are members; vote in defined cases
British ColumbiaCard-based certification where a threshold of support is shown, with votes in defined cases
Other provincesVary between card-check, mandatory vote and hybrid systems

Because the rules change with governments, employers should check the current statute before responding to a campaign. In card-check systems, the employer may not learn of the campaign until the application is filed and the union has already reached the threshold. In vote systems, the employer has a short window to communicate before the vote.

Ontario's process

Under Ontario's Labour Relations Act, 1995, a union applies to the Ontario Labour Relations Board with evidence that at least 40% of employees in its proposed bargaining unit are members. The board generally directs a representation vote, typically held within five business days after the application. The union is certified if more than 50% of ballots cast favour the union. Disputes about who is in the unit, such as whether supervisors or part-time employees should be included, are often resolved after the vote by segregating disputed ballots.

Employers must respond to the application and provide lists of employees within very short deadlines. Missing a deadline can mean losing the opportunity to challenge the proposed unit or the union's evidence, so employers should know in advance who will handle a filing.

Bargaining unit disputes

The scope of the bargaining unit can decide the outcome. Unions often propose units that capture their strongest support, such as a single location or department. Employers may argue for broader units, for example all employees in a municipality, or for the exclusion of managers and those exercising managerial functions or employed in a confidential capacity in matters relating to labour relations. Labour boards decide whether the proposed unit is appropriate for collective bargaining, which does not need to be the most appropriate unit. Multi-location employers, retail chains and warehouses frequently face disputes about whether a single site is appropriate.

What employers can say

Labour statutes protect employer freedom of expression, but only within limits. Employers may generally communicate facts and opinions about unionization, the collective bargaining process and the employer's own record, as long as they do not use coercion, intimidation, threats, promises or undue influence. Lawful communications can include:

  • accurate information about the certification process and the right to a secret ballot where one applies;
  • the employer's opinion that employees do not need a union, expressed without threats;
  • facts about current wages and benefits and the employer's history of treating employees fairly;
  • the fact that collective bargaining can result in better, the same or worse terms;
  • information about union dues and how collective agreements work.
Practical point

Script and review all communications during a union certification campaign. Managers' informal comments, such as suggesting a location might close if a union arrives, are the most common source of unfair labour practice findings. Train supervisors on what they must not say before they talk to employees.

What employers cannot do

Unfair labour practices during a union certification campaign typically include:

  • threatening job loss, closure, relocation or reduced benefits if employees unionize;
  • promising raises, promotions or improvements if employees reject the union;
  • interrogating employees about their union support or activities;
  • surveillance of union meetings or monitoring of union activity;
  • disciplining, dismissing or changing terms for employees because of union activity;
  • soliciting employees to revoke union membership or assisting a decertification campaign;
  • changing terms and conditions of employment after an application is filed without the union's consent, contrary to the statutory freeze.

Many statutes impose a "freeze" once a certification application is filed: the employer may not change wages, benefits or working conditions without the union's consent or the board's approval, except in accordance with established practice.

Remedies, including remedial certification

Labour boards have wide remedial powers. They can order reinstatement with back pay, require the employer to post notices, give the union access to employees, order a new vote, and in serious cases certify the union without a vote or regardless of the vote result where the employer's misconduct means the true wishes of employees are unlikely to be ascertained. Ontario's Labour Relations Act, 1995 provides for remedial certification in those circumstances. Reverse onus provisions in several statutes require the employer to prove that a dismissal or discipline of a union supporter was not motivated by anti-union animus.

First-contract arbitration

After certification, the parties must bargain in good faith toward a first collective agreement. First agreements are often the hardest to conclude. Several jurisdictions, including Ontario and the federal jurisdiction, allow a party to apply for first-contract arbitration if bargaining fails, in which an arbitrator or the board settles the terms. Employers who take hard-line positions designed to frustrate a first agreement risk bad faith bargaining findings and imposed terms.

Organizing in retail, warehousing and technology

Recent organizing has focused on sectors with historically low union density, including retail stores, coffee chains, warehouses, distribution centres and some technology and gig workplaces. Campaigns often target single locations and use social media and online card signing, where permitted. Employers with many locations need consistent policies, manager training and a rapid response plan, since a campaign at one site can spread. Closing a location in response to organizing can itself be an unfair labour practice if motivated by anti-union animus, even where the employer has economic reasons, and boards look closely at timing.

Online organizing and digital communications

Many union certification campaigns now run largely online, through private chat groups, social media and electronic membership cards where the statute permits them. Employers should not attempt to access private union chats or monitor employees' personal social media for union activity, which labour boards treat as surveillance. Workplace IT policies that restrict personal use of company systems are lawful if applied consistently, but enforcing them only against union supporters invites an unfair labour practice finding. Employer communications through email and intranet are permissible if their content is lawful, but employers should be careful with frequency and tone, since a flood of anti-union messaging can be viewed as undue influence.

Decertification and displacement

Once certified, a union can be removed only through statutory processes, such as a decertification application by employees during defined open periods, or displaced by another union. Employers must not initiate, support or assist decertification efforts, and labour boards will dismiss applications tainted by employer involvement. Managers should be trained to refer employees who ask about decertification to the board's public information rather than offering help. The same restraint applies to raids by rival unions: the employer should remain neutral.

After union certification

When union certification is granted, the employer must give notice to bargain within prescribed timelines and begin good faith bargaining. Existing terms and conditions are generally frozen until a collective agreement is reached or the parties are in a legal strike or lockout position. Employers should prepare bargaining proposals, costing and data, and consider how to integrate collective bargaining with their HR systems. The relationship that develops in the first round of bargaining often shapes labour relations for years.

Sale of business and successor rights

Certification and collective agreements generally bind a purchaser of a business under successor rights provisions. Buyers cannot avoid a union by purchasing the business's assets, and changes to the business structure designed to defeat a union can be challenged. Due diligence in acquisitions should identify pending certification applications as well as existing bargaining rights, together with any unfair labour practice complaints and outstanding board orders that the buyer may inherit.

The constitutional backdrop

Freedom of association under s. 2(d) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects a meaningful process of collective bargaining, and in Saskatchewan Federation of Labour v. Saskatchewan, 2015 SCC 4, the Supreme Court recognized that the right to strike is an essential part of that process. The Charter applies to governments rather than private employers, but it shapes the labour statutes that govern union certification and bargaining, and legislatures and boards interpret those statutes with its values in mind. Employers should expect labour boards to protect employees' choice to organize robustly.

An employer response plan

  1. Prepare in advance: up-to-date employee lists, organizational charts and an understanding of likely bargaining units.
  2. Designate a small response team, including labour counsel.
  3. Train managers on lawful and unlawful conduct.
  4. Respond to the application within the statutory deadlines and identify unit disputes.
  5. Communicate through reviewed, factual messages.
  6. Observe the statutory freeze and document business-as-usual decisions.
  7. Prepare for bargaining if the union is certified.
  8. Keep a log of communications and decisions during the campaign, so the employer can respond accurately to any complaint.

Federal specifics

Under the Canada Labour Code, the CIRB may certify a union without a vote if satisfied that a majority of employees in the unit wish to be represented, based on membership evidence. Federally regulated employers also face Part I's unfair labour practice provisions and, since 20 June 2025, the prohibition on using replacement workers during a lawful strike or lockout. Our insight on back to work laws discusses federal labour disputes.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise employers on union certification campaigns: response planning, manager training, communications review, bargaining unit and voter disputes, unfair labour practice complaints and first-contract bargaining. Our labour relations practice works with our employment law team. See also our insight on federally regulated employers. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us when a campaign begins.

Frequently asked questions

Is union certification by card-check or vote?

It depends on the jurisdiction. The federal system and Quebec use card-check where a majority support is shown, Ontario generally requires an application with 40% support followed by a vote, and other provinces use card-check, mandatory votes or hybrids. Rules change, so check the current statute.

What can employers say during a campaign?

Facts and opinions about unionization, bargaining and the employer's record, without coercion, intimidation, threats, promises or undue influence. Communications should be scripted and reviewed, and supervisors trained, because informal comments are a common source of violations.

What is remedial certification?

A labour board remedy that certifies a union without a vote, or despite a vote result, where the employer's unfair labour practices mean the true wishes of employees are unlikely to be ascertained. Ontario's Labour Relations Act, 1995 provides for it.

Can employers change wages during a campaign?

Generally not after a certification application is filed. Statutory freeze provisions prohibit changes to terms and conditions without the union's consent or board approval, except in accordance with established business practice.

What is first-contract arbitration?

A process available in several jurisdictions, including Ontario and the federal jurisdiction, by which an arbitrator or the board settles the terms of a first collective agreement where bargaining fails after certification.

Sources

  1. Labour Relations Act, 1995 (Ontario)
  2. Canada Labour Code, Part I
  3. Saskatchewan Federation of Labour v. Saskatchewan, 2015 SCC 4

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.