Skip to content
Real Estate & Construction

Surety Bonds and Construction Insurance

Surety bonds guarantee that a contractor will finish the work and pay its trades, and in Ontario they are mandatory on most public construction contracts. This note explains bond types, the statutory regime, how claims work, the insurance programme that sits alongside bonding, and what happens to bonds and indemnities when a contractor becomes insolvent.

Bridge construction site in Ontario backed by surety bonds and builder's risk insurance

Key takeaways

  • Ontario requires performance and payment bonds on public contracts of $500,000 or more under s. 85.1 of the Construction Act.
  • Each statutory bond must cover at least 50% of the contract price, using prescribed Forms 31 and 32.
  • Payment bond notice and limitation periods run separately from lien deadlines.
  • Valard v. Bird, 2018 SCC 8, means obligees should publicize payment bonds to potential claimants.
  • Builder's risk and wrap-up liability insurance cover physical loss and third-party claims; bonds cover default.

What surety bonds do on a Canadian project

Surety bonds are three-party instruments: the contractor (principal) and a surety company jointly promise an obligee — usually the owner — that the contractor will perform the contract or pay its subcontractors and suppliers. Unlike insurance, a bond does not transfer risk away from the contractor; the surety expects to be repaid through its indemnity agreement if it has to pay. In Ontario, surety bonds are mandatory on most public construction contracts under s. 85.1 of the Construction Act, and on private projects owners and lenders commonly require them as a condition of award or financing.

Bridge construction site in Ontario backed by surety bonds and builder's risk insurance
Performance and payment surety bonds sit alongside builder's risk and wrap-up liability insurance on major projects.

This note explains the main bond types, Ontario's statutory bonding regime for public contracts, how claims work, the insurance programme that usually accompanies bonding, and what happens to bonds and indemnities when a contractor becomes insolvent. It focuses on Ontario because it has the most detailed statutory scheme, and flags where other provinces differ. It is general information, not legal advice on a specific bond or policy.

Types of surety bonds in construction

BondWho it protectsTypical trigger
Bid bondOwner running a tenderBidder refuses to sign the contract or provide required security after award
Performance bondOwner (obligee)Contractor default declared by the owner; surety may remedy, complete or pay up to the bond amount
Labour and material payment bondSubcontractors and suppliers with a direct contract with the principal (and often their suppliers)Principal fails to pay for labour, materials or services supplied to the project
Lien bond (security to vacate)Lien claimantPosted to remove a registered lien from title while the claim is decided
Holdback repayment bondOwner releasing holdback earlyReleased holdback must be repaid because liens later prove valid
Warranty or maintenance bondOwnerDefects arising during the warranty period are not corrected

The performance bond and the labour and material payment bond are the pair most owners ask for, often each at 50% of the contract price. Both are written by insurers licensed to write surety business, and the bond wording — not general insurance principles — determines who can claim, for what, and by when. Standard Canadian forms are widely used, but owners on complex projects sometimes negotiate enhanced wording, such as shortened surety response times or broader beneficiary definitions.

Statutory surety bonds on Ontario public contracts

Section 85.1 of the Construction Act applies to a "public contract", meaning a contract between a contractor and an owner that is the Crown, a municipality or a broader public sector organization. Under s. 12 of O. Reg. 304/18, the section applies where the contract price is $500,000 or more. On entering into the contract, the contractor must furnish both a labour and material payment bond and a performance bond in the prescribed forms, issued by an insurer licensed under the Insurance Act to write surety and fidelity insurance. Architects and engineers are excluded.

  • Coverage: under s. 12.1 of O. Reg. 304/18, each bond must cover at least 50% of the contract price. For contracts above $500 million, the owner specifies the limit, which must be at least $250 million.
  • Forms: the labour and material payment bond must be in Form 31 and the performance bond in Form 32 under O. Reg. 303/18. A prescribed form may set out the claims process (s. 85.1(6)).
  • Payment bond reach: the payment bond must extend protection to subcontractors and persons supplying labour or materials to the improvement (s. 85.1(4)(c)).
  • Other security: owners may require other bonds or security in addition (s. 85.1(7)).
  • Alternative financing and procurement (P3) projects: s. 3 of O. Reg. 304/18 sets minimum coverage of 50% of the contract price up to $100 million, and $50 million above that.

Other provinces take different routes. Several rely on procurement policy rather than statute to require bonding on public work, and federal departments typically require contract security in their construction tender documents. Contractors bidding across provinces should check each owner's tender requirements rather than assume Ontario's thresholds apply.

How surety bonds claims work

Performance bond claims

Under s. 85.2(2), if a performance bond is in effect and the contractor defaults, the owner has a right of action against the surety and the contractor in accordance with the bond's terms. In practice the owner must declare the contractor in default in the manner the bond requires and must itself have performed its obligations, including payment. The surety then investigates and chooses among the options in the bond, typically remedying the default, arranging completion by another contractor, or paying the owner up to the bond amount. Owners who terminate without following the bond's default procedure, or who keep paying the contractor after default, risk prejudicing their claim.

Labour and material payment bond claims

Under s. 85.2(1), a person to whom payment is guaranteed may sue the surety and the principal if the principal defaults. Payment bonds contain strict notice and limitation periods — often written notice to the principal, surety and owner within a fixed number of days after the claimant last supplied labour or materials, and suit within a fixed period after the principal ceased work. These periods are separate from lien deadlines, so a supplier can preserve a lien on time and still lose its bond claim, or the reverse.

Limits on the surety's liability

Section 85.2(3) confirms that the surety is never liable beyond the bond amount, and that good-faith payments reduce its liability. The surety is not liable as principal and is not a party to the construction contract (s. 85.2(4)). Once it pays, it is subrogated to the rights of the person paid (s. 85.2(5)).

Lien bonds to clear title

Surety bonds are also used to remove liens from title. Under s. 44(1) of the Construction Act, the court must vacate a registered claim for lien where security is posted equal to the full amount claimed plus, as security for costs, the lesser of $250,000 or 25% of that amount; s. 44(2) lets the court accept a lower amount it considers reasonable. A lien bond in the prescribed form (Form 21) is the usual security. Owners and lenders use it to keep advances flowing and to close sales or refinancings, while the claimant's rights shift from the land to the bond. The lien dispute itself continues and is decided on its merits.

Practical point

Owners and general contractors holding a labour and material payment bond should tell subcontractors and suppliers that it exists, for example by posting it on site and referencing it in subcontracts. In Valard Construction Ltd. v. Bird Construction Co., 2018 SCC 8, the Supreme Court held that an obligee holding such a bond as trustee for claimants can be liable for failing to take reasonable steps to make its existence known before the claim period expired.

Construction insurance alongside surety bonds

Surety bonds protect against contractor default; insurance protects against physical loss and third-party liability. A typical Canadian project insurance programme includes:

  • Builder's risk (course of construction) insurance: all-risks property cover for the works, materials on site and often materials in transit or stored off site. Key issues are who buys it (owner or contractor), the named insureds (owner, contractor, subcontractors and lender), deductibles, exclusions for faulty workmanship or design and the "resulting damage" carve-back, and waivers of subrogation among project participants.
  • Wrap-up liability insurance: a single project-specific commercial general liability policy covering the owner, contractor and all trades for third-party injury and property damage, usually with completed operations cover extending beyond substantial performance. Wrap-ups reduce gaps and cross-claims between trades' separate policies.
  • Professional liability: for designers, and for design-build contractors, project-specific professional cover may be required.
  • Delay in start-up (soft costs): covers lost revenue or financing costs when a covered physical loss delays completion, often required by lenders on income-producing projects.
  • Environmental and contractor's pollution liability: increasingly required on brownfield and infrastructure sites.

Standard-form contracts set baseline insurance obligations, and owners and lenders frequently layer project-specific requirements on top. Bespoke requirements should be checked with the contractor's broker before bid, because cover that is unavailable at a reasonable premium becomes a pricing or default risk.

Surety bonds and indemnity in contractor insolvency

When a contractor fails, surety bonds come into their own, and the surety's indemnity rights become central. Before issuing bonds, sureties require a general indemnity agreement from the contractor and, commonly, from its principals and affiliates personally. The indemnity usually obliges the indemnitors to reimburse every loss and expense, to post collateral when the surety establishes a reserve, and to assign contract funds and rights to the surety on default.

In proceedings under the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act or the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, several questions recur:

  1. Trust funds: provincial construction statutes impose trusts on project money received by contractors for the benefit of subcontractors and suppliers. A surety that pays claimants is subrogated to their position and may assert those trust claims against funds held by the trustee or monitor.
  2. Contract balances: unpaid contract balances and holdbacks held by the owner are contested between the surety completing the work, the trustee and secured lenders. Equitable subrogation and the bond's assignment provisions are the surety's main tools.
  3. Stays and completion: a stay of proceedings may prevent the owner terminating the contract for insolvency alone. Owners need to coordinate with the monitor or trustee and the surety before declaring default.
  4. Personal indemnitors: claims against individual indemnitors usually proceed outside the corporate insolvency and can be significant.

See our notes on distressed real estate and construction insolvency and construction lending and lien priority.

Checklist for owners, contractors and lenders

  • Confirm whether statutory surety bonds are required (Ontario public contracts of $500,000 or more) and use the prescribed forms.
  • Check the surety is licensed to write surety business in the province and review its financial strength.
  • Align bond amounts, beneficiaries and claim periods with the contract, lien deadlines and lender requirements.
  • Publicize the payment bond to trades and suppliers.
  • Follow the performance bond's default procedure exactly before terminating a contractor.
  • Coordinate builder's risk, wrap-up and delay-in-start-up cover, with lenders as named insureds or loss payees.
  • For contractors and their principals, review the indemnity agreement's collateral and personal liability terms before signing.

Illustration: a municipality awards a CAD 40 million road contract. The contractor delivers a Form 31 payment bond and a Form 32 performance bond, each for CAD 20 million. When the contractor stops paying its paving subcontractor, the subcontractor serves notice under the payment bond within its claim period and recovers from the surety, which then pursues the contractor and its principals under their indemnity agreement.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise owners, developers, lenders, contractors and investors on bonding and insurance in Canadian projects. We review and negotiate bond wording, insurance schedules and indemnity agreements, map statutory bonding obligations on public work, and coordinate with brokers and sureties. When a contractor defaults or becomes insolvent, we help owners and lenders protect their position under the bonds and work with licensed insolvency trustees, monitors and Canadian-licensed litigation counsel as required. This work connects with our construction law and infrastructure and P3 practices. To discuss a project or claim, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

When are surety bonds mandatory in Ontario?

Under s. 85.1 of the Construction Act and s. 12 of O. Reg. 304/18, a contractor entering into a public contract with the Crown, a municipality or a broader public sector organization with a price of $500,000 or more must provide a labour and material payment bond and a performance bond in the prescribed forms, each covering at least 50% of the contract price.

What is the difference between a surety bond and insurance?

Insurance transfers risk to the insurer, which does not expect repayment. A surety bond is a guarantee of the contractor's obligations; if the surety pays, it recovers from the contractor and other indemnitors under a general indemnity agreement. Bonds cover default in performance or payment, while builder's risk and liability insurance cover physical loss and third-party claims.

Who can claim under a labour and material payment bond?

The bond wording governs. Typically subcontractors and suppliers with a direct contract with the principal can claim, and often those who contract with a subcontractor. Ontario's statutory bond must extend protection to subcontractors and persons supplying labour or materials. Claimants must meet the bond's notice and suit deadlines.

What happens to surety bonds if the contractor goes bankrupt?

The bonds remain in force. The surety may complete the work or pay the owner under the performance bond and pay trades under the payment bond, then step into their rights by subrogation, including trust claims over project funds, and pursue the indemnitors. The owner should coordinate with the surety and the trustee or monitor before declaring default.

Sources

  1. Construction Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.30, ss. 85.1–85.2 (Ontario e-Laws)
  2. O. Reg. 304/18: General (Construction Act), ss. 3, 12, 12.1
  3. O. Reg. 303/18: Forms (Construction Act)
  4. Supreme Court of Canada case information: Valard Construction Ltd. v. Bird Construction Company (37272)
  5. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.