Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Executive Employment Agreements in Canada

Executive employment agreements set the terms on which senior leaders join, perform and leave a company. In Canada they must work within employment standards minimums and a strict judicial approach to termination clauses, while addressing change of control, incentive plans, restrictive covenants and the tax treatment of separation payments.

Board compensation committee reviewing executive employment agreements

Key takeaways

  • Executive employment agreements should define severance clearly and comply with employment standards in every scenario.
  • Double-trigger change-of-control provisions are standard for public and private companies.
  • Incentive plan treatment on termination must be drafted to survive Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition.
  • Ontario permits non-competes for listed C-suite executives, subject to common law reasonableness.
  • Clawback policies should be incorporated contractually.
  • Separation payments may qualify as retiring allowances with specific tax consequences.

Why executive employment agreements need special care

Senior executives usually negotiate their terms, often with their own counsel, and the stakes on termination are high: common law reasonable notice for a long-serving executive can approach two years of total compensation, including bonuses and equity. Well-drafted executive employment agreements give both sides certainty, reduce litigation, and align incentives with shareholders. Poorly drafted ones can fail at the moment they matter, leaving the company exposed to full common law damages.

Board compensation committee reviewing executive employment agreements
Executive employment agreements must be clear on severance, change of control and incentives.

Canadian courts treat executives as employees, so employment standards legislation applies to them, subject to limited exemptions for some managerial employees from hours of work and overtime rules. Termination clauses in executive employment agreements are interpreted with the same strictness as for other employees, although courts sometimes acknowledge that sophisticated executives with legal advice negotiated their terms. Employers should not assume that seniority makes an imperfect clause enforceable.

For public companies, executive agreements are also disclosure documents. Material terms, including severance and change-of-control payments, must be described in proxy circulars, and shareholder advisory votes on compensation create reputational pressure on outsized arrangements.

Core terms

TermTypical approachWatch points
Position and dutiesTitle, reporting line, authorityChanges can ground constructive dismissal; include flexibility language
Base salary and reviewAnnual review, no automatic increaseReductions may be fundamental changes
Short-term incentiveTarget bonus as a percentage of salary, plan-governedEntitlement during notice period
Long-term incentiveOptions, RSUs, PSUs under omnibus plansVesting and forfeiture on termination
Termination without causeFixed months of pay or formula, plus benefitsMust include ESA entitlements and comply in every scenario
Change of controlDouble-trigger enhanced severanceDefinition of change of control and good reason
Restrictive covenantsNon-solicit, confidentiality, non-compete where lawfulReasonableness and statutory limits
ClawbackRecovery of incentive pay on restatement or misconductMust be contractual and clear

Severance provisions

Most executive employment agreements specify a fixed severance amount on termination without cause, such as 12 to 24 months of base salary plus target bonus and benefits continuation, sometimes increasing with service. To be enforceable, the clause must provide at least the employee's statutory entitlements in every scenario, including termination pay, benefits continuation and statutory severance, and must not be contradicted by other provisions, such as a cause definition that would deny statutory entitlements. After Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391, the termination provisions are read as a whole, so the cause clause and any probation or resignation provisions must be checked too. Our insight on termination clauses explains the drafting rules.

Severance can be paid as a lump sum or by salary continuance. Salary continuance allows mitigation provisions and preserves benefits, but extends the relationship and complicates tax and benefits administration. Lump sums are simpler and more common for senior executives.

Change of control and double triggers

Change-of-control provisions protect executives through a sale or merger. A "single trigger" pays severance, or accelerates equity, on the change of control alone. A "double trigger" requires both a change of control and a qualifying termination within a protected period, typically 12 to 24 months, either by the employer without cause or by the executive for "good reason". Institutional investors and proxy advisers strongly prefer double triggers, and most Canadian public company plans now use them for equity acceleration and enhanced severance.

"Good reason" definitions deserve careful negotiation. Common triggers include a material reduction in compensation, a material diminution in duties, a change in reporting line, and a relocation beyond a set distance. Executives typically must give notice and an opportunity to cure before resigning for good reason. Without a contractual definition, a resigning executive would have to establish constructive dismissal at common law.

Retention agreements are often added around a transaction to keep key executives through closing and integration. They should state whether retention payments are in addition to or instead of severance, what happens if the executive is terminated before the retention date, and whether payments are forfeited on resignation. Clear interaction clauses avoid double recovery arguments and make the total cost of a transaction easier for buyers to price.

Practical point

Define "change of control" by reference to objective events, such as acquisition of a percentage of voting securities or sale of substantially all assets, and align it across the employment agreement, the equity plan and any retention agreements. Inconsistent definitions are a frequent source of disputes after a transaction.

Incentives on termination

In Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26, the Supreme Court held that an employee entitled to reasonable notice is presumed to be entitled to incentive compensation that would have been earned during the notice period, unless the plan contains clear and unambiguous language removing that entitlement. Terms requiring the employee to be "active" or "full-time" at the payment date may not be enough. Plans and agreements should state expressly what happens to bonuses and unvested equity on termination with and without cause, during any notice period, and on resignation, and those terms should be brought to the executive's attention. Our insight on forfeiture clauses covers the drafting.

Restrictive covenants for executives

Ontario's Employment Standards Act, 2000 prohibits non-compete agreements with employees, but exempts employees in listed executive positions, such as chief executive officer, president, chief financial officer, chief operating officer and other chief executive roles. Even for those executives, a non-compete must be reasonable at common law in duration, geography and scope, and courts will not rewrite an unreasonable covenant. Non-solicitation and confidentiality covenants are available for all employees and should be drafted precisely. Executives who are fiduciaries owe duties not to usurp corporate opportunities, which continue for a period after departure. See our insight on non-compete bans.

Clawbacks and malus

Clawback policies allow a company to recover incentive compensation paid on the basis of financial results later restated, or after misconduct. US-listed issuers must adopt recovery policies under US stock exchange rules, which affects many Canadian cross-listed companies, and Canadian institutional investors expect them. Recovering pay from an executive in Canada is far easier if the employment agreement and plans expressly incorporate the policy and the executive has agreed to it. Malus provisions, which reduce or cancel unvested awards before payment, are simpler to enforce than recovery of amounts already paid.

Garden leave and transition

Garden leave provisions allow the employer to relieve an executive of duties during a notice period while continuing pay and benefits. They keep the executive out of the market without relying on a post-employment restraint, but they must be expressly authorized in the agreement, since removing duties without contractual authority can be a constructive dismissal. Transition clauses may also require the executive to assist with handover for a period, which can be valuable in succession planning.

Tax treatment of separation payments

Payments on termination, including damages for wrongful dismissal and severance, are generally "retiring allowances" under the Income Tax Act. They are subject to withholding at lump-sum rates, are not subject to CPP contributions or EI premiums in most cases, and can be transferred to an RRSP only to the extent of available contribution room, the special rollover for pre-1996 service having been closed to later years. Payments for continued salary during working notice are employment income. Equity awards settled after termination are taxed under the applicable rules, and salary deferral arrangement risks should be managed for deferred payments. Cross-border executives raise additional issues, including US tax rules on deferred compensation for US taxpayers.

Governance and approval

For public companies, executive employment agreements are typically approved by the board's compensation committee, with advice from independent compensation consultants and counsel. Directors must act in the best interests of the corporation, and approval processes should be documented. Shareholder agreements in private companies may require investor consent for executive hires and compensation. Related-party considerations arise where an executive is also a significant shareholder.

Executive employment agreements in private and PE-backed companies

Private equity and venture-backed companies use executive employment agreements alongside equity arrangements that differ from public company plans. Management often invests alongside the sponsor and holds shares subject to a shareholders' agreement with "good leaver" and "bad leaver" provisions that determine the price at which shares are repurchased on departure. Those provisions interact with the employment agreement: a termination without cause may make the executive a good leaver entitled to fair market value, while a resignation or cause termination may trigger repurchase at cost. Inconsistent definitions of cause between the two documents are a common source of disputes.

Sponsors also expect strong restrictive covenants from management investors. Where the executive is a selling shareholder in the sponsor's acquisition, covenants given in the purchase agreement may be assessed under the more generous sale-of-business standard. Covenants in the employment agreement alone are assessed as employment covenants and, in Ontario, are subject to the ESA's non-compete rules unless an exception applies.

When executive employment agreements are litigated

Executive disputes tend to focus on a few issues: whether a termination clause is enforceable, whether the executive had good reason to resign, whether cause existed, and what incentive compensation is owed. Litigation is costly and public, so many executive employment agreements include arbitration clauses for disputes, which offer confidentiality and expertise. Arbitration clauses should be drafted to cover statutory claims where permissible and to set out the seat, rules and number of arbitrators. Even with arbitration, employment standards complaints and human rights applications may proceed in their own forums.

Negotiation checklist for executive employment agreements

  1. Confirm all statutory entitlements are preserved in the termination provisions.
  2. Align the agreement with equity, bonus and clawback plan terms.
  3. Define cause, good reason and change of control precisely.
  4. Set restrictive covenants that are lawful and reasonable for the executive's role and jurisdiction.
  5. Address garden leave, transition and cooperation obligations.
  6. Consider tax structuring of separation payments and equity, including for cross-border executives.
  7. Obtain independent legal advice acknowledgments to support enforceability.

Quebec executives

In Quebec, the Civil Code governs employment contracts, and an employee cannot renounce in advance the right to compensation for insufficient notice or abusive termination. Fixed severance clauses for executives are therefore generally treated as minimums rather than caps, although courts give weight to negotiated terms. Non-competition clauses must be in writing, limited in time, place and type of work, and cannot be relied on if the executive is dismissed without serious reason. Executive agreements for Quebec-based leaders should be drafted under Quebec law with these rules in mind.

How TRW & Co helps

We draft and negotiate executive employment agreements for companies and boards, advise on change of control and incentive plan design, restrictive covenants, clawbacks and separation arrangements, and handle disputes. Our employment law, corporate governance and tax teams work together. See also our insight on employee stock options. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us to review an agreement.

Frequently asked questions

Can an executive's severance be capped by contract?

Outside Quebec, yes, if the clause is clear, provides at least statutory entitlements in every scenario, and is consistent with the rest of the agreement. Courts read executive termination clauses strictly, and a defect can restore common law notice. In Quebec, contractual limits are generally treated as minimums.

What is a double-trigger change of control provision?

It pays enhanced severance or accelerates equity only if two events occur: a change of control and a qualifying termination, by the employer without cause or by the executive for good reason, within a protected period after the transaction. Investors generally prefer double triggers.

Do executives keep bonuses and equity during the notice period?

Under Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition, 2020 SCC 26, they are presumed to, unless plan language clearly and unambiguously removes the entitlement and was brought to their attention. Agreements and plans should state expressly what happens on each type of termination.

Can Ontario companies use non-competes for executives?

Yes, for employees in listed chief executive positions, which are exempt from the ESA prohibition. The non-compete must still be reasonable at common law, and courts will not rewrite unreasonable covenants. Non-solicitation and confidentiality covenants are available for all employees.

How are severance payments taxed?

Generally as retiring allowances: withholding applies at lump-sum rates, CPP and EI usually do not apply, and RRSP transfers are limited to available room. Salary paid during working notice is ordinary employment income.

Sources

  1. Matthews v. Ocean Nutrition Canada Ltd., 2020 SCC 26
  2. Employment Standards Act, 2000 (Ontario)
  3. Waksdale v. Swegon North America Inc., 2020 ONCA 391

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.