Skip to content
Employment, Labour & Pensions

Pension Issues in M&A Transactions

Pension issues in M&A can change the economics of a Canadian deal. Defined benefit deficits, surplus entitlements, plan transfers that need regulatory consent and multi-employer plan exposures all affect price, structure and timing. Identifying them early in due diligence lets the parties allocate risk deliberately rather than discovering it after closing.

Deal team reviewing actuarial reports to assess pension issues in M&A

Key takeaways

  • Share purchases transfer pension plans automatically; asset purchases require deliberate choices.
  • Moving pension assets to a successor plan generally requires regulatory consent.
  • Surplus entitlement depends on plan documents and trust law, following Schmidt v. Air Products.
  • Deficits can be priced on going-concern, solvency or accounting bases, with very different results.
  • Multi-employer plans can carry withdrawal and underfunding risks.
  • Purchase agreements should contain pension-specific representations, covenants and indemnities.

Why pension issues in M&A matter

Pension issues in M&A arise whenever a target has employees in a registered pension plan, whether defined benefit (DB), defined contribution (DC) or a multi-employer plan. DC plans are usually straightforward. DB plans can carry large liabilities that are sensitive to interest rates and assumptions, and the funding rules, surplus ownership and transfer mechanics differ across Canadian jurisdictions. Buyers that treat the pension plan as an accounting line item risk underestimating cash obligations and legal constraints.

Deal team reviewing actuarial reports to assess pension issues in M&A
Pension issues in M&A often turn on whether the deal is a share purchase or an asset purchase.

The analysis starts with deal structure. In a share purchase, the buyer acquires the target with its plans, liabilities and history. In an asset purchase, the buyer chooses whether to offer employees a plan and whether to take over past service liabilities, and transfers require regulatory steps.

Due diligence on pension issues in M&A

ItemWhy it matters
Plan texts, amendments and trust agreements since inceptionDetermine surplus entitlement, amendment powers and benefit promises
Latest actuarial valuations and regulatory filingsGoing-concern and solvency position, required contributions
Funding and investment policiesRisk profile and governance quality
Contribution remittance recordsLate or missing contributions and deemed trust exposure
Collective agreementsBargained benefits and restrictions on plan changes
Multi-employer plan participationContribution obligations and potential withdrawal exposure
Regulatory correspondence and litigationOrders, complaints and disputes over surplus or benefits

Share purchases

In a share purchase, the target remains the sponsor and administrator of its plans. Liabilities, including funding deficits, past administrative errors and surplus disputes, stay with the target and therefore with the buyer. The buyer's protection lies in price, representations and indemnities. Post-closing, the buyer may want to merge the target's plan into its own, close it to future accrual, or purchase annuities, each of which has its own regulatory and member-notice requirements.

Asset purchases and successor plans

In an asset purchase, the seller's plan does not move automatically. The buyer can offer transferred employees a new plan for future service only, leaving past service liabilities with the seller, or establish a successor plan that assumes past service liabilities in exchange for a transfer of assets from the seller's plan. Under Ontario's Pension Benefits Act and comparable statutes, an asset transfer between plans on the sale of a business requires regulatory consent and must protect members' benefits, typically by transferring assets on a basis that maintains funded status. Successor employer rules also give transferred employees continuity of membership for vesting and eligibility.

Agreeing the transfer basis

When liabilities move, the parties must agree how much in assets moves with them. Options include transferring assets equal to liabilities on a going-concern basis, on a solvency basis, or proportionally to the funded status of the seller's plan. Each produces a different amount, and the regulator will require that the transfer not impair benefit security in either plan. The purchase agreement should specify the actuarial basis, assumptions, valuation date, true-up mechanism and what happens if consent is delayed or refused.

Practical point

Regulatory consent to an asset transfer can take many months. Build interim arrangements into the deal, such as continued participation in the seller's plan under a transition services agreement or an escrow for the transfer amount, and set a long-stop date with a fallback if consent is not obtained.

Pricing deficits

Deficits can be measured on several bases: the accounting obligation under financial reporting standards, the going-concern funding deficit, the solvency deficit, or a buyer-specific estimate of the cost to settle or annuitize. The choice can move the price by large amounts, especially for mature plans. Buyers often price on a basis close to the cash they expect to contribute, while sellers argue for accounting or going-concern measures. Adjustments may be fixed at signing or trued up at closing based on an updated valuation. Because interest rates can move between signing and closing, the parties should decide who bears that market risk and draft the adjustment accordingly, rather than leaving it to argument after closing.

Surplus

A plan in surplus can be an asset, but only if the sponsor can use it. In Schmidt v. Air Products Canada Ltd., [1994] 2 SCR 611, the Supreme Court held that surplus entitlement depends on the plan documents and, where assets are held in trust, trust law; amendments cannot override an original trust that excluded employer entitlement. Contribution holidays may be permitted under plan terms and statute. Buyers should not pay for surplus without reviewing the full documentary history and the statutory rules on surplus withdrawal, which often require member consent and regulatory approval.

Multi-employer plans

Unionized targets often contribute to multi-employer pension plans under collective agreements. Contributions are usually fixed, and the employer's liability is generally limited to those contributions while it participates. However, plans may reduce benefits or seek higher contributions when underfunded, and withdrawal or a change in the bargaining unit can raise questions about ongoing obligations. Buyers should review the plan's funded status, any rehabilitation plans and the collective agreement terms, and ask the plan administrator for its latest public financial information.

Distressed deals

In restructurings, pension liabilities interact with insolvency law. Deemed trusts for unpaid contributions, the priority of certain pension claims, and the administrator's fiduciary duties when the sponsor is also the debtor have been litigated extensively. In Sun Indalex Finance, LLC v. United Steelworkers, 2013 SCC 6, the Supreme Court considered the priority of a wind-up deficit deemed trust against court-ordered financing in a CCAA proceeding. Buyers in distressed sales often exclude DB plans and leave them with the insolvent estate, which may lead to plan wind-up. Our distressed M&A practice addresses these situations.

DC plans and group RRSPs

DC plans raise fewer valuation issues but still require attention. Buyers should confirm that contributions were remitted on time, that the plan was administered according to its terms, and that member communications were accurate. In asset deals, the buyer typically offers a new DC plan or group RRSP, and members' existing balances remain in the seller's arrangement or are transferred under the applicable rules. Differences in employer contribution levels between the seller's and buyer's plans may affect retention.

Retiree and other benefits

Post-retirement health and life benefits are often unfunded and can be large liabilities. They are not governed by pension standards legislation, so the analysis depends on the documents and communications promising them and on collective agreements. Buyers should quantify these obligations and assess whether they can be changed. Our insight on group benefits plans discusses retiree benefit changes.

Lenders and pension issues in M&A

Acquisition lenders look closely at pension issues in M&A because deemed trusts and statutory priorities can rank ahead of secured creditors in some circumstances, and because required special payments reduce cash available for debt service. Credit agreements commonly include pension representations, covenants restricting plan amendments and new DB plans, reporting obligations for valuations, and events of default tied to plan wind-ups or regulatory orders. Some lenders reserve against pension deficits in borrowing base calculations. Buyers should model required contributions under the applicable funding rules and share that model with lenders early, so that financing terms reflect the plan's real cash needs.

Employee and union considerations

Pension changes are among the most sensitive issues for employees in a transaction. In asset deals, employees who are offered employment on materially different pension terms may decline or may later argue that their terms were fundamentally changed if successor employer rules apply. Unionized employees' pension terms are usually fixed by collective agreements that bind successor employers under labour relations legislation, so changes require bargaining. Early, accurate communication about what will happen to accrued and future benefits reduces uncertainty and retention risk. Sellers should avoid promising outcomes that depend on regulatory consent or buyer decisions not yet made.

Tax and registration

Registered pension plans must remain compliant with the Income Tax Act's registration rules through any transaction. Plan mergers, asset transfers and successor plans require filings with the CRA as well as pension regulators, and contribution limits and past service pension adjustments affect members of DB and DC plans. Transfers between registered plans can generally occur on a tax-deferred basis if made directly under the prescribed rules. Buyers should confirm that the target's plans have been administered in accordance with their registered terms, since registration problems can have tax consequences for members and the sponsor.

Purchase agreement terms for pension issues in M&A

  1. Representations on plan compliance, funding, contributions, valuations and absence of disputes.
  2. Covenants on conduct before closing, including no plan amendments or surplus withdrawals.
  3. Price adjustment mechanisms for deficits on an agreed actuarial basis.
  4. Asset transfer provisions, consent conditions and true-ups for successor plans.
  5. Specific indemnities for pre-closing administrative errors and identified risks.
  6. Employee transfer and benefits continuity covenants.
  7. Cooperation covenants for regulatory filings, member communications and data transfer between administrators.
  8. Survival periods for pension representations that reflect the long tail of pension claims.

Post-closing integration

After closing, buyers commonly harmonize plans, which may involve plan mergers, conversions from DB to DC for future service, or annuity purchases to de-risk. Each step requires notices to members, regulatory filings and, for unionized employees, bargaining. Changes to future benefits are generally permitted with notice; reductions to accrued benefits are not. Governance should be established quickly so that the buyer's administrator role is properly discharged from day one, including appointment of a committee, transfer of records and confirmation of service provider arrangements.

Federal and Quebec plans

Federally regulated targets have plans under the Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985, supervised by OSFI, with solvency funding and specific rules on asset transfers. Quebec plans follow Quebec's Supplemental Pension Plans Act, with its going-concern funding and stabilization provision. Multi-jurisdictional plans may be subject to rules from several regulators, and the jurisdiction of registration governs most decisions.

Illustration

A buyer acquires the assets of an Ontario manufacturer whose DB plan has 600 active and retired members. The buyer agrees to establish a successor plan for the 300 transferred active employees and assume their past service liabilities. The parties agree to transfer assets equal to the transferred liabilities multiplied by the seller plan's solvency ratio, subject to regulatory consent, with a true-up after the final valuation. Retirees stay with the seller's plan. Until consent is obtained, the transferred employees continue to accrue in the seller's plan under a transition agreement, with the buyer reimbursing contributions.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise buyers, sellers and lenders on pension issues in M&A: due diligence, structuring, pricing, successor plans and asset transfers, regulatory consents, purchase agreement terms and post-closing integration. Our pensions and benefits practice works with our M&A team. See also our insights on defined benefit funding and mass termination. This page is general information, not legal advice. Contact us about your transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Does a buyer inherit the pension plan in a share purchase?

Yes. The target remains sponsor and administrator, so its plans and liabilities, including deficits and past errors, stay with it and therefore with the buyer. Protection comes from price, representations and indemnities.

What happens to pensions in an asset purchase?

The seller's plan does not transfer automatically. The buyer may offer a plan for future service only or establish a successor plan that assumes past service liabilities with a transfer of assets, which generally requires regulatory consent and must protect benefit security.

How are pension deficits priced?

On an agreed basis, such as the accounting obligation, the going-concern or solvency funding deficit, or an estimate of settlement cost. The basis can change the price substantially, so the agreement should specify assumptions and any true-up.

Can a buyer use pension surplus?

Only if the plan documents and statute allow it. Under Schmidt v. Air Products, [1994] 2 SCR 611, entitlement depends on the documents and trust law. Surplus withdrawal and contribution holidays are regulated and often require member consent and regulatory approval.

What should a purchase agreement include?

Pension-specific representations, pre-closing covenants, deficit price adjustments, asset transfer provisions with consent conditions and true-ups, specific indemnities and employee transfer covenants.

Sources

  1. Pension Benefits Act (Ontario)
  2. Pension Benefits Standards Act, 1985 (federal)
  3. Schmidt v. Air Products Canada Ltd., [1994] 2 SCR 611

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.