Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Solicitor-Client and Litigation Privilege in Canada

Solicitor-client privilege is one of the strongest protections in Canadian law, but businesses lose it more often than they expect. This guide explains the elements of the privilege, in-house counsel communications, litigation privilege after Blank and Lizotte, common-interest sharing, waiver by pleading or disclosure, investigation reports and the risks of public AI tools.

In-house lawyer reviewing documents marked for solicitor-client privilege in a Canadian company

Key takeaways

  • Privilege requires a lawyer-client communication, for legal advice, intended to be confidential.
  • In-house counsel communications qualify only when counsel acts in a legal capacity.
  • Litigation privilege ends with the litigation (Blank, 2006 SCC 39).
  • General statutory powers to compel documents do not override privilege (Lizotte, 2016 SCC 52).
  • Entering privileged material into public AI tools risks losing confidentiality.

What solicitor-client privilege protects

Solicitor-client privilege protects confidential communications between a client and its lawyer made for the purpose of seeking or giving legal advice. In Canada it is more than a rule of evidence: the Supreme Court of Canada has repeatedly described it as a principle of fundamental justice and a substantive right that should be as close to absolute as possible. For businesses, that means legal advice obtained properly can be kept from opposing parties, regulators and the public, but only if the communication fits the definition and the privilege is not lost through careless handling.

In-house lawyer reviewing documents marked for solicitor-client privilege in a Canadian company
Solicitor-client privilege covers legal advice; litigation privilege covers material prepared for litigation. They are distinct, with different scope and duration.

Canadian law recognizes several related privileges. The two that matter most in commercial practice are solicitor-client privilege (also called legal advice privilege) and litigation privilege. Common-interest privilege allows privileged material to be shared with parties with a common interest without waiver. Each has its own test and its own ways of being lost.

PrivilegeProtectsDurationKey authority
Solicitor client (legal advice) privilegeConfidential communications between lawyer and client for the purpose of legal advicePermanent, unless waived or an exception appliesLong line of SCC authority; applies to in-house counsel (Pritchard, 2004 SCC 31)
Litigation privilegeDocuments and communications whose dominant purpose is existing or reasonably contemplated litigation, including with third partiesEnds with the litigation and closely related proceedingsBlank v. Canada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39; Lizotte v. Aviva, 2016 SCC 52
Common-interest privilegePrivileged material shared with parties having a common legal or commercial interestAs long as the underlying privilege lastsRecognized in transactions and joint defence settings
Settlement privilegeCommunications made to settle a disputeGenerally continues after settlementCommon law rule protecting settlement negotiations

The elements of solicitor-client privilege

A communication is protected by solicitor-client privilege where it is (1) between a client and a lawyer, (2) made for the purpose of seeking or giving legal advice, and (3) intended to be confidential. Each element is tested against the facts. Business advice, even if given by a lawyer, is not privileged; nor is a communication copied to a lawyer merely to attach privilege to it. Facts do not become privileged because they were communicated to counsel, although the lawyer's advice about them is protected.

The privilege belongs to the client, not the lawyer, and only the client can waive it. For a corporation, that means the board or authorized officers control waiver, which becomes important when management changes or when a trustee, receiver or purchaser takes control of the company's records.

Exceptions are narrow. Privilege does not protect communications made to further a crime or fraud, and courts have recognized limited exceptions where public safety or the innocence of an accused is at stake. Disputes about the existence of privilege are decided by the court, which can review the documents itself. Outside those exceptions, Canadian courts protect the privilege rigorously, including against government bodies seeking information under general statutory powers.

Cross-border groups should remember that privilege rules differ. A communication that is privileged in Canada may not be in another jurisdiction, and the reverse is also true. In particular, the treatment of in-house counsel varies internationally. Where legal advice will be shared across a multinational group, structure the communication so that it qualifies for protection in each jurisdiction where it may later be sought.

In-house counsel communications

Communications with in-house lawyers can be privileged on the same basis as those with external counsel. In Pritchard v. Ontario (Human Rights Commission), 2004 SCC 31 (SCC docket 29677), the Supreme Court confirmed that a legal opinion from in-house counsel to a public body was privileged, while noting that in-house lawyers often have business as well as legal functions, and only communications in their legal capacity are protected.

That distinction is where most disputes arise. A general counsel who also sits on the executive committee, approves pricing or negotiates commercial terms will generate many communications that are not privileged. Practical steps to protect solicitor-client privilege for in-house teams include:

  • labelling requests for legal advice clearly and addressing them to counsel in their legal role;
  • keeping legal advice in separate documents rather than embedding it in business emails or presentations;
  • limiting distribution to those who need the advice to act on it;
  • recording when counsel is acting in a business capacity, so that the privileged material is easier to identify later.

Litigation privilege after Blank and Lizotte

Litigation privilege serves a different purpose: it creates a "zone of privacy" for preparing a case. It covers documents and communications whose dominant purpose is existing or reasonably contemplated litigation, and, unlike solicitor-client privilege, it can extend to communications with third parties such as experts, investigators and witnesses. In Blank v. Canada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39 (SCC docket 30553), the Supreme Court held that litigation privilege is distinct from solicitor-client privilege and ends when the litigation ends, unless related litigation remains pending or apprehended.

In Lizotte v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, 2016 SCC 52 (SCC docket 36373), the Court confirmed that litigation privilege is a class privilege that can be overridden only by clear and explicit statutory language, so a general power to compel documents does not displace it.

The dominant purpose test is demanding. A report commissioned for several purposes, for example to satisfy a regulator, to fix a process and to prepare for litigation, may not meet it. Documents prepared in the ordinary course of business before litigation was reasonably contemplated are not protected, even if they later become central to the case.

Waiver, investigation reports and regulators

Privilege is lost most often through waiver. Waiver can be express, as when a company voluntarily discloses advice, or implied, as when fairness requires disclosure. Common examples include:

  • Waiver by pleading. A party that relies on legal advice to justify its conduct, for example by pleading that it acted on counsel's advice, may be found to have waived privilege over that advice.
  • Selective disclosure. Disclosing part of an advice or report can lead to an order requiring disclosure of the rest, to avoid a misleading partial picture.
  • Sharing outside the circle. Distributing advice widely, or to third parties without a common interest, can defeat the confidentiality element.

Internal investigations are a frequent battleground. Where a company retains counsel to investigate allegations and provide legal advice, the investigation report and underlying interview notes may be privileged; where the investigation is a human resources or compliance exercise that happens to be run by a lawyer, they may not be. Our insight on human rights tribunal claims discusses how investigation reports surface in employment disputes. Regulators also test privilege: statutory powers to compel documents generally do not override solicitor-client privilege without clear language, and disclosure to a regulator can create waiver arguments in later civil litigation unless protected by agreement or statute.

Practical point

Decide before an investigation starts whether you want it to be privileged. If so, have counsel retain the investigator in writing for the purpose of giving legal advice, limit the report's circulation, and prepare a separate non-privileged summary for any audience that needs to see the outcome.

Common interest and asserting privilege in discovery

Businesses regularly need to share legal advice with others: a buyer and seller exchanging regulatory analysis before closing, co-defendants coordinating a defence, or an insurer and insured working on a claim. Common-interest privilege allows privileged material to be shared with a party that has a sufficiently common interest without waiving the underlying privilege. It is not a free-standing privilege; the material must already be privileged, and the sharing must be confidential and connected to the common interest.

In transactions, the common interest is usually in completing the deal and in a shared view of regulatory or legal risk. A short written common-interest agreement, signed before advice is exchanged, records the purpose, confirms that sharing is not intended to waive privilege, and limits onward disclosure. After closing, the parties should consider who controls privilege over pre-closing communications of the target, which purchase agreements frequently address expressly.

In litigation, privilege is asserted in the affidavit of documents or equivalent disclosure list, where privileged documents must be identified in a way that allows the other side to assess the claim without revealing the content. Over-claiming is a common mistake: blanket claims over every email copied to counsel invite motions, and courts can review disputed documents themselves to decide whether privilege applies. A defensible privilege log describes each document's date, author, recipients, general nature and the privilege claimed.

Inadvertent disclosure is a practical risk in large productions. Canadian courts generally consider whether disclosure was truly inadvertent, how quickly the producing party acted, the scale of the production and fairness to both sides. Agreeing a "claw-back" protocol at the start of discovery, under which inadvertently produced privileged documents must be returned without argument about waiver, is the simplest protection. Lawyers who receive material that appears privileged also have professional obligations to notify the sender.

Public AI tools and solicitor-client privilege

Generative AI raises a newer risk. Pasting privileged advice, draft pleadings or investigation notes into a public AI tool may disclose them to a third-party provider on terms that allow retention, review or training, which can undermine the confidentiality element of solicitor-client privilege and create waiver arguments. It can also breach confidentiality obligations and privacy laws: under the federal Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA), organizations remain responsible for personal information transferred to service providers.

Companies should set policies that distinguish enterprise AI tools with contractual confidentiality and no-training commitments from consumer tools, prohibit entering privileged material into the latter, and log the use of AI in legal workstreams. Our insights on generative AI policies and AI in litigation cover the wider issues.

Illustration: a hypothetical Canadian manufacturer receives a whistleblower complaint about bribery by a foreign agent. The general counsel retains external counsel, who engages forensic accountants under a privileged retainer and interviews employees. A manager later pastes interview notes into a consumer chatbot to "summarize" them. The company now faces an argument that confidentiality over those notes was lost, an issue that a clear AI policy and access controls would have avoided.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise companies on protecting solicitor-client privilege and litigation privilege in commercial litigation, internal investigations and regulatory matters. That includes structuring investigations, drafting retainer and common-interest agreements, setting privilege protocols for in-house teams and AI tools, asserting and challenging privilege claims in discovery, and managing disclosures to regulators. Court proceedings in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel, and privilege disputes are often decided by the court; we work with local counsel where needed. This page is general information rather than legal advice. To discuss a privilege issue, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Are communications with in-house lawyers privileged in Canada?

Yes, when the in-house lawyer is acting as a lawyer and the communication is confidential and made for the purpose of legal advice. In Pritchard v. Ontario (Human Rights Commission), 2004 SCC 31, the Supreme Court confirmed this, while noting that communications in a business capacity are not protected.

How long does litigation privilege last?

Until the litigation ends, unless related litigation remains pending or reasonably apprehended. The Supreme Court so held in Blank v. Canada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39. Solicitor-client privilege, by contrast, is permanent unless waived or subject to a recognized exception.

Is an internal investigation report privileged?

It can be, but it depends on why and how it was commissioned. A report prepared by or for counsel for the purpose of legal advice, or with litigation as its dominant purpose, may be privileged. A report prepared as an ordinary HR or compliance exercise may not be, even if a lawyer wrote it.

Can a regulator force a company to hand over privileged documents?

Generally not without clear and explicit statutory language. In Lizotte v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, 2016 SCC 52, the Supreme Court held that a general statutory power to compel documents did not override litigation privilege. Solicitor-client privilege receives at least the same protection.

Does using a public AI tool waive privilege?

There is no definitive Canadian appellate ruling, but entering privileged material into a public tool whose terms allow the provider to retain, review or train on inputs creates a real risk that confidentiality, an essential element of privilege, will be found lost. Enterprise tools with strong confidentiality terms reduce the risk.

Sources

  1. Supreme Court of Canada docket 30553 (Blank v. Canada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39)
  2. Supreme Court of Canada docket 36373 (Lizotte v. Aviva Insurance Company of Canada, 2016 SCC 52)
  3. Supreme Court of Canada docket 29677 (Pritchard v. Ontario (Human Rights Commission), 2004 SCC 31)
  4. Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, S.C. 2000, c. 5

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.