Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Defamation and Anti-SLAPP Motions

Anti SLAPP motions let defendants end defamation claims about expression on matters of public interest early, with full indemnity costs if they succeed. For businesses suing critics or defending their own statements, the Ontario and BC tests after Pointes Protection, short media limitation periods and AI-generated content all shape strategy.

Smartphone showing online reviews, illustrating defamation claims and anti SLAPP motions in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Ontario's CJA s. 137.1 freezes the action and requires a hearing within 60 days.
  • Plaintiffs must show substantial merit, no valid defence and serious harm outweighing the public interest.
  • Pointes Protection, 2020 SCC 22, makes the final weighing the core of the analysis.
  • Successful defendants presumptively recover full indemnity costs in Ontario.
  • Ontario requires six-week notice and a three-month limitation for newspaper or broadcast libel.
  • Liability for AI-generated defamatory statements remains unsettled in Canada.

Anti SLAPP motions explained

Anti SLAPP motions are early applications to dismiss lawsuits that target expression on matters of public interest. "SLAPP" stands for strategic lawsuit against public participation: a claim, often in defamation, brought less to win than to silence critics through cost and delay. Ontario, British Columbia and Quebec have statutory tools that let a defendant bring the case to an early hearing, freeze other steps, and, if successful, recover full indemnity costs.

Smartphone showing online reviews, illustrating defamation claims and anti SLAPP motions in Canada
Anti SLAPP motions let courts screen out defamation claims that would chill expression on matters of public interest.

For businesses and executives, anti SLAPP motions cut both ways. A company that sues a critic, a short-seller, a former employee or a reviewer may face a motion that ends the case and leaves it paying the defendant's legal fees. A company that is sued over its own public statements may use the same procedure to obtain an early dismissal.

This insight explains the Ontario and BC tests after the Supreme Court of Canada's 2020 decisions, how courts treat online reviews and social media, the short limitation periods that apply to some media defamation, and emerging questions about AI-generated statements. It is general information, not legal advice.

Ontario: section 137.1 of the Courts of Justice Act

Ontario's regime is in ss. 137.1 to 137.5 of the Courts of Justice Act (CJA), in force since 3 November 2015. The stated purposes include encouraging expression on matters of public interest and discouraging the use of litigation to unduly limit it (s. 137.1(1)). The test has two stages:

  1. Threshold. The moving defendant must satisfy the judge that the proceeding arises from an expression it made that relates to a matter of public interest (s. 137.1(3)). "Expression" is broad: any communication, verbal or non-verbal, public or private (s. 137.1(2)).
  2. Merits-based hurdle and public interest weighing. The judge must dismiss unless the plaintiff shows grounds to believe that the proceeding has substantial merit and the defendant has no valid defence, and that the harm likely suffered is sufficiently serious that the public interest in permitting the proceeding to continue outweighs the public interest in protecting the expression (s. 137.1(4)).

Procedural features make the motion powerful. Once it is brought, no further steps may be taken until it is finally disposed of, including appeals (s. 137.1(5)). The motion must be heard within 60 days of filing the notice, and cross-examinations are limited to seven hours per side (s. 137.2). A successful defendant is presumptively entitled to full indemnity costs (s. 137.1(7)), and damages may be awarded if the claim was brought in bad faith or for an improper purpose (s. 137.1(9)). An unsuccessful moving party is generally not exposed to costs (s. 137.1(8)).

The Supreme Court's framework: Pointes Protection and Bent v. Platnick

In 1704604 Ontario Ltd. v. Pointes Protection Association, 2020 SCC 22, the Supreme Court interpreted s. 137.1 for the first time. A developer sued a ratepayers' association for breach of a settlement agreement after a member testified against its project. The Court held that the threshold question of public interest is to be read generously and does not depend on whether the expression is desirable. At the merits stage, "grounds to believe" requires a basis in the record and the law, less than a balance of probabilities. The heart of the analysis is the final weighing, which asks whether the harm to the plaintiff is serious enough to outweigh the public interest in protecting the expression.

Applying that framework, the Court dismissed the developer's claim.

In the companion case, Bent v. Platnick, 2020 SCC 23, the Court reached the opposite result. A physician sued a lawyer over an email to a professional listserv alleging he had altered medical reports. The claim was allowed to proceed because there were grounds to believe it had substantial merit and that the defences would fail, and the serious reputational harm to a professional outweighed the public interest in protecting that particular expression. Together the cases show that anti SLAPP motions are not automatic wins for defendants; serious, well-supported claims survive.

British Columbia and Quebec

British Columbia's Protection of Public Participation Act, S.B.C. 2019, c. 3 (PPPA), closely mirrors Ontario's test. Under s. 4, once the applicant shows the proceeding arises from expression on a matter of public interest, the court must dismiss unless the respondent shows grounds to believe the claim has substantial merit and there is no valid defence, and that the harm is serious enough to outweigh the public interest in protecting the expression.

In Hansman v. Neufeld, 2023 SCC 14, the Supreme Court applied the PPPA to dismiss a defamation claim by a school trustee against a teachers' union leader who had criticized his public statements on gender identity education, emphasizing the weighing stage and the value of counter-speech on public issues.

Quebec takes a procedural approach. The Code of Civil Procedure allows courts to sanction abuse of procedure, including a proceeding that is excessive or unreasonable or aimed at limiting freedom of expression in public debate, and to declare it abusive early in the case, with remedies including dismissal, costs and damages. The burden shifts to the plaintiff once the defendant makes a summary showing that the proceeding may be abusive.

FeatureOntario (CJA s. 137.1)British Columbia (PPPA)Quebec (CCP abuse provisions)
ThresholdExpression relates to matter of public interestSameSummary showing that the proceeding may be abusive
Plaintiff's burdenSubstantial merit, no valid defence, harm outweighs public interestSame structureShow the proceeding is not excessive or unreasonable and is justified
Stay of other stepsYes, until motion and appeals decidedYesCourt-managed
Costs if dismissedFull indemnity presumptionFull costs presumptionCosts and possible damages

Anti SLAPP motions, online reviews and social media

Many business defamation claims now arise from online reviews, social media posts, short-seller reports, employee posts on professional networks and complaints to regulators. Courts have generally accepted that consumer reviews of a business, commentary on the conduct of public companies and criticism of products can relate to matters of public interest. That shifts the burden to the business plaintiff. The plaintiff must then show grounds to believe the statements are false and defamatory, that defences such as justification, fair comment, qualified privilege or responsible communication (recognized in Grant v. Torstar Corp., 2009 SCC 61) would fail, and that the harm is serious and causally linked to the expression.

Harm evidence is often decisive. A business that cannot show lost customers, cancelled contracts or other concrete damage linked to the particular post may lose at the weighing stage even if the statement was false. Conversely, a coordinated campaign of fabricated reviews, or statements alleging criminality or professional misconduct, can justify the claim continuing.

Practical point

Before suing a critic, gather evidence of falsity and of specific financial harm, and assess the costs exposure if an anti SLAPP motion succeeds. Alternatives such as platform takedown requests, a public correction, a regulatory complaint or a carefully worded response may achieve more at lower risk.

Notice requirements and limitation periods for media defamation

Ontario's Libel and Slander Act imposes special rules for libel in a "newspaper" or "broadcast". As consolidated, s. 5(1) requires the plaintiff to serve written notice specifying the matter complained of within six weeks after the alleged libel comes to the plaintiff's knowledge, and s. 6 requires an action to be commenced within three months after the libel comes to the plaintiff's knowledge.

Whether online publications, websites and social media posts fall within "newspaper" or "broadcast" depends on the medium and has been litigated, so plaintiffs should assume the short periods may apply and act quickly. For other defamation claims, Ontario's general two-year limitation period under the Limitations Act, 2002 applies. Other provinces have their own notice and limitation rules for media defamation.

AI-generated defamation and emerging issues

Generative AI tools can produce false statements about real people and companies, such as invented regulatory sanctions or fabricated quotations. Canadian courts have not yet settled who is liable when an AI output is defamatory: the developer, the deployer that integrated the model, or the user who republished the output. Traditional principles provide a starting point. Defamation requires publication to a third party, and those who republish a defamatory statement can be liable for it.

Defendants may argue innocent dissemination or that no reasonable reader treats an AI output as a factual assertion. Businesses deploying customer-facing AI should treat output accuracy as a legal risk, as our insight on AI chatbots and liability explains.

Jurisdiction is another live issue. Online defamation can be read anywhere, and Canadian courts may take jurisdiction where the publication was read in the province, subject to forum non conveniens, as in Haaretz.com v. Goldhar, 2018 SCC 28; see our insight on real and substantial connection.

A checklist for anti SLAPP motions

Whether you expect to bring or respond to anti SLAPP motions, the same preparation points recur:

  • Capture the expression precisely. Preserve screenshots, metadata, archived versions and the audience reached. Courts analyze the words actually published, in context.
  • Frame the public interest honestly. Defendants should explain why the subject matters to a segment of the public; plaintiffs gain little by arguing the threshold is not met, given its generous reading.
  • Prove falsity and harm early. Plaintiffs need affidavit evidence of falsity and of concrete harm, ideally financial, tied to the impugned expression rather than to other criticism.
  • Address every defence. Justification, fair comment, qualified privilege and responsible communication each require a response showing why it would fail.
  • Budget for the timetable. The 60-day hearing requirement in Ontario compresses evidence gathering, and cross-examinations are capped.
  • Price the costs risk. Full indemnity costs for successful defendants can exceed the damages a business hoped to recover, and insurers may not cover them.

Appeals of decisions on anti SLAPP motions are expedited in Ontario (s. 137.3 CJA), but the stay of the main action continues while they are pending, which can add many months before a claim proceeds.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise businesses, executives and organizations on Canadian defamation risk and on anti SLAPP motions, whether they are considering a claim or defending one. Our work includes evaluating whether expression relates to a matter of public interest, assembling evidence of falsity and harm, assessing defences, estimating costs exposure under the full-indemnity regime, and developing non-litigation responses such as takedown requests and corrections. We also advise on communications policies for executives and employees, and on governance of AI-generated content. Where motions must be argued by counsel licensed in the province, we work with locally licensed litigation counsel. See our commercial litigation page for the broader practice, or our appellate and public law page, or contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is an anti-SLAPP motion?

It is an early motion to dismiss a lawsuit that arises from expression on a matter of public interest. In Ontario and BC, the defendant shows the expression relates to a public-interest matter; the plaintiff must then show grounds to believe the claim has substantial merit, there is no valid defence, and the harm outweighs the public interest in protecting the expression.

Can a business sue over a negative online review?

It can, but the review will often be treated as expression on a matter of public interest, triggering anti-SLAPP protection. The business must then show the review is false and defamatory, that defences like fair comment fail, and that it suffered serious harm caused by the review. Losing exposes the business to full indemnity costs in Ontario.

What did Pointes Protection decide?

In 2020 SCC 22, the Supreme Court held that the public-interest threshold is read generously, that 'grounds to believe' requires a basis in the record and law below a balance of probabilities, and that the decisive question is whether the harm to the plaintiff outweighs the public interest in protecting the expression.

How quickly must I act on media defamation in Ontario?

For libel in a newspaper or broadcast, the Libel and Slander Act requires written notice within six weeks after the libel comes to the plaintiff's knowledge and an action within three months. Whether online content qualifies depends on the medium, so act promptly and obtain advice early.

Who is liable for defamatory AI output?

Canadian law has not settled this. Potentially liable parties include anyone who publishes or republishes the statement, and possibly deployers of AI tools. Organizations using generative AI in public-facing roles should implement review and correction processes.

Sources

  1. Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, ss. 137.1-137.5 (Ontario e-Laws)
  2. Protection of Public Participation Act, S.B.C. 2019, c. 3 (BC Laws)
  3. Libel and Slander Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.12 (Ontario e-Laws)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.