Jurisdiction Over Foreign Defendants: Real and Substantial Connection
Canadian courts take jurisdiction over foreign defendants only where there is a real and substantial connection between the province and the dispute. Van Breda's presumptive factors, the 2025 Sinclair decision on contract-based jurisdiction, forum selection clauses and forum non conveniens together decide where cross-border cases are heard.

Key takeaways
- Van Breda, 2012 SCC 17, sets four presumptive connecting factors for tort claims.
- Website access or advertising alone does not mean a defendant carries on business in a province.
- Sinclair, 2025 SCC 27, held a tangential Ontario contract did not ground jurisdiction over Italian companies.
- Forum selection clauses apply unless there is strong cause; consumer clauses face closer scrutiny after Douez.
- Forum non conveniens lets courts decline jurisdiction where another forum is clearly more appropriate.
- BC, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia codify the test in CJPTA statutes.
What is the real and substantial connection test?
The real and substantial connection test decides whether a Canadian court can take jurisdiction over a claim against a defendant who is not present in the province. A court will assume jurisdiction only if there is a real and substantial connection between the province, the subject matter of the dispute and the defendant.

The test is constitutional in origin, because provinces cannot reach beyond their territorial limits, and it is applied through a framework of presumptive connecting factors set by the Supreme Court of Canada in Club Resorts Ltd. v. Van Breda, 2012 SCC 17. Even where jurisdiction exists, a court may decline to exercise it if another forum is clearly more appropriate.
For foreign companies that sell into Canada, and for Canadian businesses suing foreign counterparties, the framework determines where litigation happens, which law applies and how expensive it will be. The Supreme Court's 2025 decision in Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo shows that the framework still has teeth. This insight explains the test, the presumptive factors, online businesses, contracts, forum selection clauses and forum non conveniens. It is general information, not legal advice.
The Van Breda framework and its presumptive factors
Van Breda involved Ontario residents injured at resorts in Cuba. The Court set out a structured approach for tort claims. A plaintiff establishes a presumptive real and substantial connection by showing one of four factors:
- the defendant is domiciled or resident in the province;
- the defendant carries on business in the province;
- the tort was committed in the province; or
- a contract connected with the dispute was made in the province.
The list is not closed. Courts may recognize new presumptive factors by analogy, considering similarity to the listed factors, treatment in the case law and statute law, and private international law in other legal systems. Once a presumptive factor is shown, the defendant may rebut the presumption by demonstrating that the factor points only to a weak relationship between the forum and the subject matter. If no presumptive factor applies, the court has no jurisdiction on the basis of the test.
Several provinces, including British Columbia, Saskatchewan and Nova Scotia, have codified the analysis in a Court Jurisdiction and Proceedings Transfer Act. BC's CJPTA lists in s. 10 circumstances in which the required connection is presumed, while preserving the plaintiff's right to prove other circumstances. The statutory lists are broader in places, covering contracts to be performed in the province, restitutionary obligations and business carried on there.
| Connecting factor | What it usually requires | Common rebuttal arguments |
|---|---|---|
| Domicile or residence | Head office, registered office or ordinary residence in the province | Rarely rebuttable |
| Carrying on business | Actual presence: an office, staff, agents or regular physical activity | Mere advertising or website access is not enough; business unrelated to the claim |
| Tort committed in the province | Where the wrong occurred; for defamation, where the publication was read | Only minor damage felt in the province |
| Contract made in the province | A contract connected with the dispute was concluded there | The contract is only remotely connected to the dispute (Sinclair) |
Online businesses and "carrying on business" in a province
For e-commerce and software companies, the critical factor is whether they carry on business in the province. Van Breda cautioned that carrying on business requires some form of actual, not merely virtual, presence. Active advertising in the province, or the fact that a website can be accessed there, does not on its own establish that a defendant carries on business. Courts look for indicators such as local offices, employees or agents, servers or warehouses, local bank accounts, regular visits to customers, or a business model targeted at and integrated into the provincial market.
Lower courts have not always applied this consistently to digital platforms. Some decisions treat sustained, targeted commercial activity with residents, such as subscription contracts, local pricing and payment processing, as sufficient presence, while others insist on a physical footprint. The safest assumption for a foreign platform with large numbers of Canadian customers is that a Canadian court may find a presumptive connection, especially in consumer and privacy claims, and that any forum selection clause will be closely scrutinized.
Foreign companies cannot control every connecting factor, but they can manage their record. Keep corporate roles clear (which entity contracts with Canadian customers, which entity employs local staff), document where contracts are concluded, and make sure terms of service are presented in a way that will survive a fairness review. These facts often decide a jurisdiction motion.
Contract-based jurisdiction after Sinclair
The contract factor is attractive to plaintiffs because many consumer and commercial relationships involve a contract concluded in the plaintiff's home province. In Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo, 2025 SCC 27 (31 July 2025), an Ontario resident booked a European trip, including a Venice water taxi, through a credit-card concierge service based in Ontario. He was seriously injured when the water taxi crashed and sued three Italian companies, among others, in Ontario.
A 5-4 majority held that Ontario courts lacked jurisdiction over the Italian companies. Although the cardmember agreement was an Ontario contract capable of grounding a presumptive connection, the presumption was rebutted because a real and substantial connection between the dispute and Ontario was simply not present. Assuming jurisdiction, the majority said, would result in jurisdictional overreach contrary to the principles of order and fairness. The dissent would have allowed the appeal.
For businesses, Sinclair confirms that the contract factor requires a genuine link between the contract and the dispute with the foreign defendant. A plaintiff cannot rely on a tangential domestic contract to draw foreign service providers into a Canadian court. Equally, foreign defendants should not assume a quick win: the decision was closely divided, and much depends on how directly the domestic contract governs the foreign defendant's conduct.
Forum selection clauses and the real and substantial connection test
A forum selection clause does not oust the real and substantial connection analysis, but it often decides the outcome. Under Z.I. Pompey Industrie v. ECU-Line N.V., 2003 SCC 27, a court enforces a valid clause unless the plaintiff shows "strong cause" not to. In consumer contracts of adhesion, the Supreme Court modified that test in Douez v. Facebook, Inc., 2017 SCC 33, where a plurality declined to enforce a California forum clause against a BC resident bringing a statutory privacy claim, emphasizing unequal bargaining power, the quasi-constitutional nature of the privacy right and the convenience of the local court.
Commercial parties with comparable bargaining power will usually be held to their chosen forum. Consumer-facing businesses should expect closer scrutiny, and Quebec's Consumer Protection Act and Civil Code limit clauses that would deprive consumers of access to Quebec courts. For drafting points on liability and remedies, see our insight on limitation of liability clauses.
Quebec rules and service outside the province
Quebec applies its own civil-law rules rather than the common-law framework, although the results are often similar. Article 3148 of the Civil Code of Québec gives Quebec authorities jurisdiction in personal actions of a patrimonial nature in listed situations, including where the defendant is domiciled or resident in Quebec, has an establishment there and the dispute relates to its activities in Quebec, a fault was committed or an injury suffered in Quebec, or an obligation arising from a contract was to be performed in Quebec. Quebec courts may also decline jurisdiction under art. 3135 C.C.Q. where another authority is in a better position to decide.
In the common-law provinces, the procedural rules on service outside the province work alongside the real and substantial connection test. In Ontario, Rule 17.02 of the Rules of Civil Procedure lists categories in which originating process may be served outside Ontario without leave, such as claims about property in Ontario, contracts made or breached in Ontario, and torts committed in Ontario. Serving under a listed category does not settle jurisdiction; the defendant can still move to set aside service or stay the action. Service in countries party to the Hague Service Convention must also follow the methods that convention permits, which can add months to the timetable.
Forum non conveniens: declining jurisdiction
Jurisdiction and its exercise are distinct. A defendant who loses the jurisdiction argument may still ask the court to decline jurisdiction because another forum is clearly more appropriate. The defendant bears the burden and must identify the alternative forum. Relevant factors include the location of parties and witnesses, the applicable law, the cost and convenience of proceedings, the risk of parallel proceedings and the enforceability of any judgment.
In Haaretz.com v. Goldhar, 2018 SCC 28, a divided Supreme Court stayed an Ontario defamation action against an Israeli newspaper. Although publication in Ontario gave a presumptive connection, Israel was clearly more appropriate given where the witnesses and evidence were and the applicable law. The case illustrates how online publication can create jurisdiction while forum non conveniens moderates its consequences.
Strategy for foreign defendants and Canadian plaintiffs
For foreign defendants
- Do not attorn by taking steps on the merits before bringing a jurisdiction motion; follow the court's procedure for challenging jurisdiction.
- Build an evidentiary record on corporate structure, contracting entities and actual activities in the province.
- Plead forum non conveniens in the alternative and identify the alternative forum with evidence of its availability.
- Remember that a decision not to defend can have consequences later: a Canadian court with jurisdiction may give a judgment that is enforceable elsewhere, and foreign judgments against Canadian assets are readily recognized, as explained in enforcing foreign judgments in Canada.
For Canadian plaintiffs
- Identify the strongest presumptive factor and the evidence supporting it before serving outside the province, and expect the defendant to test that evidence through affidavits and cross-examination.
- Consider whether claims against foreign defendants are better brought where they are located, especially if enforcement will be needed there.
- In multi-defendant cases, assess whether the claim against a local defendant actually connects the foreign defendants to the forum.
Jurisdiction motions are a frequent feature of commercial litigation and of class actions against foreign companies. The real and substantial connection test also shapes multi-province consumer claims and product liability cases.
How TRW & Co helps
We advise foreign companies and Canadian businesses on Canadian jurisdiction questions, including the real and substantial connection test, forum selection clauses and forum non conveniens. Our work includes assessing exposure before market entry, structuring contracting entities and terms of service, preparing evidence for jurisdiction motions, and coordinating parallel proceedings in Canada and abroad. Where court appearances require counsel licensed in a particular province, we work with locally licensed litigation counsel. Clients from the United States will find related guidance on our United States desk. To discuss a jurisdiction issue, contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What are the Van Breda presumptive factors?
For tort claims, a presumptive real and substantial connection exists if the defendant is domiciled or resident in the province, carries on business there, the tort was committed there, or a contract connected with the dispute was made there. New factors can be recognized by analogy, and the defendant can rebut a presumption by showing only a weak connection.
Does selling online to Canadians mean a foreign company can be sued in Canada?
Not automatically. Van Breda said a virtual presence, such as a website accessible in the province or advertising there, is not enough to show the defendant carries on business. But other factors, such as a tort committed in the province or a contract made there, may still apply, and courts look closely at targeted commercial activity.
What did Sinclair v. Venezia Turismo decide?
In 2025 SCC 27, a 5-4 majority held that Ontario courts lacked jurisdiction over Italian companies involved in a Venice water taxi accident. An Ontario credit card agreement used to book the trip could ground a presumption, but the presumption was rebutted because the dispute had no real and substantial connection to Ontario.
Will a Canadian court enforce my forum selection clause?
Generally yes in commercial contracts, unless the plaintiff shows strong cause. In consumer contracts of adhesion, Douez v. Facebook shows courts may refuse enforcement where bargaining power is unequal and public policy, such as quasi-constitutional privacy rights, favours the local forum. Quebec consumer law adds further limits.
What is forum non conveniens?
It is a discretionary doctrine allowing a court with jurisdiction to decline to hear a case because another available forum is clearly more appropriate, considering witnesses, evidence, applicable law, cost and the risk of parallel proceedings. The defendant bears the burden of showing the alternative forum is clearly better.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


