Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Fraud Recovery: Tracing Assets and Ponzi Schemes

Fraud recovery in Canada is a race against the movement of money. This guide explains how victims freeze assets and obtain bank and exchange records, trace funds into property and crypto-assets, use receivers and trustees in Ponzi collapses, pursue facilitators who helped the fraud and enforce judgments in other countries.

Forensic accountant tracing transactions as part of a fraud recovery investigation in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Freezing and Norwich disclosure orders should be sought within days, often without notice.
  • Tracing supports constructive trusts that rank ahead of unsecured creditors.
  • Crypto exchanges are the chokepoint for identifying and freezing digital assets.
  • Ponzi trustees' claims against investors were not statute-barred (Golden Oaks, 2024 SCC 32).
  • Fraud debts generally survive bankruptcy under BIA s. 178(1)(d)–(e).

What fraud recovery involves in Canada

Fraud recovery is the process of finding and getting back money or property taken through commercial fraud: an embezzling employee, a fake supplier, a business email compromise, an investment scheme or a Ponzi scheme. Criminal prosecution may punish the fraudster, but it rarely returns the money quickly. Recovery depends on civil tools that move faster than the funds: freezing orders, disclosure orders against banks and exchanges, tracing claims, receivers and bankruptcy trustees, and claims against the people and institutions that facilitated the fraud.

Forensic accountant tracing transactions as part of a fraud recovery investigation in Canada
Fraud recovery depends on moving faster than the money, then following it through accounts, assets and intermediaries.

The first 72 hours often decide how much can be recovered. Funds sent by wire or converted to crypto-assets can move through several jurisdictions in a day. A victim that notifies its bank immediately, preserves evidence and obtains urgent court orders has a far better chance than one that waits for an internal investigation to finish.

First steps: freeze and find

The opening phase combines three types of relief, usually obtained together and without notice:

  • Mareva injunctions freezing the assets of the fraudster and known recipients up to the amount at stake, with an obligation to disclose assets under oath.
  • Norwich orders requiring banks, payment processors and crypto-asset exchanges to disclose account holder information and transaction histories, and often to freeze identified accounts.
  • Anton Piller orders where there is a real risk that evidence, including devices and records, will be destroyed.

Our insight on Mareva injunctions and Anton Piller orders explains the tests and the disclosure duties. In Ontario, the Superior Court's power to grant interlocutory injunctions and appoint receivers where it is "just or convenient" comes from s. 101 of the Courts of Justice Act. Where assets have left Canada, the Supreme Court's recognition in Google Inc. v. Equustek Solutions Inc., 2017 SCC 34 (SCC docket 36602) that interlocutory orders may have worldwide effect supports worldwide freezing orders, which are then paired with proceedings in the destination country.

Tracing and constructive trusts in fraud recovery

Tracing is the process of identifying the property that now represents the victim's original money. It is not itself a claim, but it supports proprietary claims that can give the victim priority over the fraudster's other creditors. Canadian courts recognize both common law and equitable tracing; equitable tracing is more flexible and can follow money through mixed bank accounts using recognized rules for allocating withdrawals and deposits.

Where property can be traced, the victim may ask the court to declare that the fraudster, or a recipient who is not a good-faith purchaser for value, holds it on a constructive trust. A proprietary remedy matters most when the defendant is insolvent: property held on trust for the victim does not form part of the estate available to general creditors. Proprietary claims can also capture increases in value, for example where stolen funds were used to buy real estate that has since appreciated.

Recovery routeAgainst whomMain advantageMain limitation
Personal claim (fraud, conversion, breach of trust)Fraudster and knowing participantsFull loss plus interest; debts from fraud generally survive bankruptcyOnly as good as the defendant's assets
Tracing and constructive trustHolders of traceable proceedsPriority over unsecured creditors; captures gainsTracing breaks down where funds are dissipated or reach good-faith purchasers
Knowing receipt or knowing assistanceThird parties who received funds or helped the breachReaches solvent defendantsRequires proof of knowledge to the required standard
Receiver or bankruptcy trustee claimsInvestors and transferees, including in Ponzi schemesCollective, cost-shared recovery; statutory avoidance powersRecovery shared rateably; slower
Recognition of a Canadian judgment abroadAssets outside CanadaReaches offshore assetsForeign law and cost

Crypto-asset tracing

Crypto-assets are often described as untraceable, but public blockchains create a permanent transaction record. Specialist analysts can follow funds from a victim's wallet through intermediate addresses to exchanges, where the assets are usually converted to fiat or other tokens. The exchange is the chokepoint: once funds reach a regulated platform, a Norwich order can identify the account holder, and a freezing order can stop withdrawals. Exchanges outside Canada may respond to a Canadian order voluntarily or may require proceedings in their home jurisdiction.

Speed is again critical. Victims should preserve wallet addresses, transaction hashes and communications, notify the exchanges involved, and move for court orders before the assets are withdrawn to self-custody or mixing services. Courts in several provinces have granted freezing and disclosure orders over crypto-assets, treating them as property capable of being frozen and traced.

Ponzi schemes, receivers and bankruptcy trustees

Ponzi schemes pay early investors with money from later ones. When they collapse, the main recovery vehicle is usually a court-appointed receiver or a trustee in bankruptcy, who gathers the remaining assets and pursues claims for the benefit of all victims.

Under s. 96 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), a trustee can ask the court to set aside transfers at undervalue or order the recipient to pay the difference in value. For arm's-length parties the look-back is one year before the initial bankruptcy event and requires insolvency and an intent to defraud, defeat or delay a creditor; for non-arm's-length parties it extends to five years in some circumstances. Secured creditors can also seek a national receiver under s. 243 BIA where the debtor is insolvent.

The Supreme Court of Canada's decision in Scott v. Golden Oaks Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 32 is a key fraud recovery authority for Ponzi cases. The trustee of a rent-to-own company that operated as a Ponzi scheme sued investors and a recruiter to recover unlawful interest and commission payments.

The investors argued the claims were statute-barred because the knowledge of the company's sole officer and shareholder, the fraudster, should be attributed to the company. The majority disagreed: the corporate attribution doctrine must be applied purposively, contextually and pragmatically, and attributing the fraudster's knowledge would not have promoted the purposes of Ontario's Limitations Act, 2002 or the BIA. The trustee's claims could proceed. Our insight on discoverability and limitation periods explains the wider rules.

Fraud debts are also hard to escape through bankruptcy. Section 178(1)(d) and (e) BIA provide that a discharge does not release debts arising from fraud, embezzlement, misappropriation or defalcation while acting in a fiduciary capacity, or from obtaining property by false pretences or fraudulent misrepresentation. A fraudster's bankruptcy pauses enforcement but rarely ends it.

Practical point

In a Ponzi collapse, individual investors racing to sue separately often recover less than a coordinated process run by a receiver or trustee. Early coordination among victims, including agreement on who will seek the appointment and how costs will be funded, usually increases the net recovery for everyone.

Fraud recovery alongside criminal and regulatory proceedings

Most significant frauds attract more than one proceeding. Police may investigate, securities regulators may act where investors were solicited, and professional regulators may discipline lawyers, accountants or advisers involved. Each process can help or complicate fraud recovery, and victims should plan for the interaction from the start.

  • Police involvement can produce seizures and restraint orders over proceeds of crime, and criminal courts can order restitution on sentencing. But police timelines are long, and seized property may be held for years. Civil proceedings usually continue in parallel.
  • Securities regulators can freeze property, obtain disgorgement orders and, in some provinces, distribute recovered funds to investors. In Poonian v. British Columbia (Securities Commission), 2024 SCC 28, the Supreme Court held that a securities regulator’s disgorgement orders for fraud proceeds survive bankruptcy under s. 178(1)(e) BIA, while the administrative penalties in that case did not.
  • Provincial civil forfeiture regimes allow the Crown to seek forfeiture of proceeds of unlawful activity without a conviction, and some provide for compensation to victims.
  • Disclosure and privilege require care: evidence the victim gives to police may be disclosed to the accused, and internal investigation reports may lose privilege if shared widely.

Coordination also matters for evidence. A civil freezing order with asset disclosure can provide information that police and regulators later use, and vice versa, subject to the rules on the use of compelled evidence. Victims should avoid making allegations publicly that they cannot yet prove, which can expose them to defamation claims and undermine the credibility of a later court application. A clear internal protocol for who communicates with authorities, insurers and the media keeps the fraud recovery effort consistent.

Insurance often provides the fastest money. Crime, fidelity and cyber policies may respond to employee theft, social engineering and funds transfer fraud, but they impose notice deadlines, proof-of-loss requirements and cooperation duties. Recovery actions against third parties may need the insurer's consent, and any recovery may have to be shared through subrogation.

Claims against facilitators and cross-border enforcement

When the fraudster has nothing left, recovery turns to solvent third parties. Banks that processed suspicious transactions, professionals who structured or blessed the scheme, auditors who missed red flags, and recipients who knew or ought to have known the funds were misappropriated can all be targets. The main theories are:

  • Knowing receipt, against a party that received trust property for its own benefit with knowledge of the breach of trust;
  • Knowing assistance, against a party that knowingly assisted a fraudulent and dishonest breach of trust;
  • Negligence and negligent misrepresentation, against professionals whose work investors relied on (see our insight on accountant liability);
  • Contract and banking claims, against institutions that breached mandates or account agreements.

Enforcement across borders is the final stage. Canadian courts generally recognize foreign money judgments where the foreign court had a real and substantial connection to the dispute, subject to defences such as fraud, natural justice and public policy, and Canadian judgments can be enforced abroad under the rules of the destination country. Planning for enforcement should begin when the claim is filed, by choosing a forum and remedies that will travel. Our insight on enforcing foreign judgments covers the Canadian rules.

Illustration: a hypothetical Alberta company loses CAD 2.5 million through a business email compromise in which a fraudster impersonated a supplier. Within two days it obtains a Norwich order against the receiving bank, learns that most of the money was converted to crypto-assets, traces them to a foreign exchange, and obtains a worldwide freezing order. The exchange freezes the account after receiving the order, and the company brings recognition proceedings where the exchange is based. Meanwhile, it notifies its crime insurer and reviews whether its own bank followed its payment verification procedures.

How TRW & Co helps

We act for victims of commercial fraud and for receivers and trustees on fraud recovery matters as part of our commercial litigation and receiverships and enforcement work. That includes urgent freezing and disclosure orders, tracing with forensic accountants and blockchain analysts, proprietary and personal claims, avoidance claims in Ponzi insolvencies, claims against facilitators, and coordinated enforcement in other countries. Court proceedings in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel, and insolvency appointments require licensed insolvency trustees; we work alongside them. This page is general information, not legal advice. If you have discovered a fraud, contact us promptly.

Frequently asked questions

What should a company do in the first hours after discovering a fraud?

Notify its bank and any receiving bank or exchange immediately, preserve emails, devices and payment records, and engage counsel to assess urgent freezing and disclosure orders. Notify crime or fidelity insurers early. The faster the response, the more likely funds can be frozen before they move again.

Can stolen funds be recovered from someone who received them innocently?

It depends. A good-faith purchaser for value generally takes free of the victim's claim, but a recipient who gave no value, or who knew or ought to have known of the fraud, may be subject to tracing, a constructive trust or a knowing receipt claim. The facts of each transfer matter.

Do fraud debts survive bankruptcy?

Generally yes. Section 178(1)(d) and (e) of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act provide that a bankruptcy discharge does not release debts arising from fraud, embezzlement or misappropriation by a fiduciary, or from obtaining property by false pretences or fraudulent misrepresentation.

Can investors who were paid by a Ponzi scheme be forced to repay?

Often, yes. Trustees and receivers can pursue payments that were unlawful or that are reviewable under insolvency law. In Scott v. Golden Oaks Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 32, the Supreme Court held that a trustee's claims against investors in a Ponzi scheme were not statute-barred, declining to attribute the fraudster's knowledge to the company.

Can crypto-assets be frozen by a Canadian court?

Yes. Courts have treated crypto-assets as property that can be frozen and traced. Freezing and disclosure orders directed at exchanges are the usual route, because exchanges hold customer identity information and can stop withdrawals. Foreign exchanges may require proceedings in their own jurisdiction.

Sources

  1. Scott v. Golden Oaks Enterprises Inc., 2024 SCC 32 (case in brief)
  2. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. B-3, ss. 96, 178, 243
  3. Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 101
  4. Supreme Court of Canada docket 36602 (Google Inc. v. Equustek Solutions Inc.)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.