Skip to content
Real Estate & Construction

Lease Assignment and Change-of-Control Clauses

A lease assignment or a change of control of a corporate tenant usually needs the landlord's consent. Ontario implies that consent cannot be unreasonably withheld unless the lease says otherwise, Quebec requires a serious reason for refusal, and recapture and profit-sharing clauses often decide the economics.

Commercial landlord and tenant signing a lease assignment consent for a retail unit in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Ontario's Commercial Tenancies Act s. 23 implies a reasonableness standard unless the lease expressly excludes it.
  • Quebec landlords need a serious reason to refuse and must respond within 15 days or are deemed to consent.
  • Change-of-control clauses treat share transfers as deemed assignments; negotiate exclusions for affiliates and public companies.
  • Recapture and profit-sharing provisions shift value to landlords and need careful drafting.
  • In bankruptcy and CCAA proceedings, courts can assign leases over a landlord's objection if monetary defaults are cured.

Lease assignment in Canada: the short answer

A lease assignment transfers the tenant's entire remaining interest in the premises to a new tenant; a sublease carves out a lesser interest while the original tenant stays in the chain. Almost every Canadian commercial lease restricts both without the landlord's consent, and many also treat a change of control of a corporate tenant as a deemed assignment. In Ontario, s. 23(1) of the Commercial Tenancies Act (CTA) implies that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld unless the lease expressly says otherwise, and in Quebec, art. 1871 of the Civil Code of Québec requires a serious reason for refusal.

Commercial landlord and tenant signing a lease assignment consent for a retail unit in Canada
Lease assignment and change-of-control clauses often decide whether a property-heavy deal closes on time.

For buyers and sellers of businesses, these clauses can become closing conditions, valuation issues or sources of leverage for landlords. For landlords, they are the main tool for controlling who occupies their buildings and protecting rent. This article explains the statutory backdrop, how courts approach reasonableness, deemed assignments on share transfers, recapture and profit-sharing provisions, and practical steps for handling leases in M&A. It is general information only.

The statutory backdrop: Ontario and Quebec

Ontario's CTA sets the default for leases made after 1 September 1911. Under s. 23(1), a covenant against assigning, subletting or parting with possession without consent is deemed subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld, "unless the lease contains an express provision to the contrary." Under s. 23(2), where a landlord refuses or neglects to consent, a judge of the Superior Court of Justice may, on application by the tenant or the proposed assignee or subtenant, decide whether consent was unreasonably withheld and, if so, permit the transaction; the order is equivalent to the landlord's consent.

Because the statutory proviso yields to an express provision, a landlord can draft an absolute prohibition or an unfettered discretion, and many institutional leases go part of the way by listing factors the landlord may consider. Courts read such clauses strictly against the party relying on them, so clear drafting matters on both sides.

Quebec takes a more protective approach. Under arts. 1870 to 1873 C.C.Q., the lessee must notify the lessor of an intended sublease or assignment, with the name and address of the proposed party, and obtain consent.

The lessor may not refuse without a serious reason and must give reasons within 15 days, failing which it is deemed to have consented; the lessor may charge only reasonable expenses resulting from the transaction; and an assignment discharges the former lessee unless, for non-residential leases, the parties agree otherwise. Commercial leases in Quebec often contract out of the release and the expense limit, so the drafting must be reviewed carefully. See our page on Quebec civil law contracts.

When is refusing a lease assignment reasonable?

Where consent may not be unreasonably withheld, courts generally ask whether a reasonable landlord, considering the circumstances at the time of the request, could have refused. The burden is on the tenant to show unreasonableness, and the landlord's reasons are assessed on the information it had. Recurring themes include:

  • Usually reasonable: genuine concerns about the assignee's financial strength or covenant, a proposed use that breaches the permitted use clause or another tenant's exclusive, or inadequate information from the tenant.
  • Usually unreasonable: using the request to extract concessions unrelated to the assignment, such as higher rent or a longer term, or refusing to protect the landlord's competing interests in other properties, unless the lease permits it.
  • Depends on the lease: refusal because the assignee is an existing tenant elsewhere in the landlord's portfolio, or because the landlord wants to recapture the space.

The tenant should give the landlord a complete package: financial statements, business plan, intended use, experience and proposed guarantees. A refusal based on missing information is far easier for a landlord to defend than one on the merits, and a tenant that supplies a full package early is better placed if it later needs to apply to court.

Change-of-control clauses and deemed assignments

A share sale does not, by itself, transfer the lease: the corporate tenant stays the same. Landlords therefore add change-of-control clauses providing that a transfer of shares, partnership interests or voting control, directly or indirectly, is a deemed assignment requiring consent. Typical drafting issues include:

IssueLandlord positionTenant position
TriggerAny change in direct or indirect control, including upstream transfersOnly a change in direct control of the tenant entity
Public companiesCoveredExcluded where shares are listed on a recognized exchange
Affiliate transfersConsent requiredPermitted transfers to affiliates without consent
Amalgamations and mergersDeemed assignmentPermitted if the successor meets a net worth test
Original tenant liabilityRemains liable after any assignmentReleased once the assignee meets financial criteria

Upstream change-of-control triggers can capture transactions far removed from the property, such as a sale of a parent company or a private equity fund's exit. Buyers should map every lease and identify which ones the deal will trigger. Whether the CTA's reasonableness proviso applies to a deemed assignment depends on how the clause is framed; tenants should negotiate an express reasonableness standard rather than rely on the statute.

Practical point

In an acquisition, request landlord consents early and in parallel with other closing conditions. Landlords often take weeks to respond, and an unanticipated change-of-control clause in a key location lease can delay closing or shift value to the landlord.

Recapture rights and profit sharing

Many leases give the landlord a recapture or termination right when the tenant asks to assign or sublet: instead of consenting, the landlord may terminate the lease for the affected space. Recapture lets the landlord capture market rent upside itself. Tenants should seek to exclude permitted transfers and corporate transactions from recapture, and to have the right to withdraw the request if the landlord elects to recapture.

Profit-sharing clauses require the tenant to pay over some or all of the amount by which sublease rent or assignment consideration exceeds the lease rent. Tenants negotiate deductions for their costs, such as brokerage commissions, inducements and unamortized improvements, and exclusion of consideration paid for the business itself. In Ontario these provisions are generally enforceable if clearly drafted; in Quebec, art. 1872 C.C.Q. limits the lessor to reasonable expenses unless the parties validly agree otherwise in a non-residential lease.

Sublease versus lease assignment: who stays liable

The choice between a sublease and a lease assignment has lasting consequences. On a true assignment, the assignee takes over the tenant's estate and becomes directly bound to the landlord on covenants that run with the land. At common law, however, the original tenant usually remains liable on its own contractual covenants for the rest of the term unless the landlord releases it. Many leases make this explicit and add that the original tenant stays liable through renewals and amendments, which can surprise a seller years after it has left the premises.

On a sublease, the head tenant remains the landlord's tenant and stays fully responsible for rent and other obligations; the subtenant has no direct contract with the landlord and depends on the head lease surviving. Subtenants should therefore seek a non-disturbance agreement from the head landlord, and both parties should check whether the head lease's restrictions on use, alterations and signage flow down. In Quebec, art. 1873 C.C.Q. provides that an assignment discharges the former lessee unless, for a non-residential lease, the parties agree otherwise, so the drafting of commercial leases in that province is especially important.

Negotiating checklist for tenants

Tenants who expect growth, restructuring or an eventual sale should address transfers when the lease is signed, when leverage is greatest. Points to seek include:

  • an express statement that consent will not be unreasonably withheld, conditioned or delayed, with a deemed consent if the landlord does not respond within a set period;
  • permitted transfers without consent to affiliates, to a purchaser of all or substantially all of the business, and on amalgamation, subject to notice;
  • exclusion of public company share trading and internal reorganizations from change-of-control triggers;
  • release of the tenant and its guarantors on an assignment to a party meeting an objective net worth or credit test;
  • a cap on the landlord's processing fees and legal costs for consent requests;
  • limits on recapture and profit sharing, including deductions for transaction costs and unamortized improvements.

Handling leases in M&A transactions

Leases are often among the most important contracts in an acquisition of a retail, restaurant, industrial or office-based business. A practical approach to lease assignment in a deal includes:

  1. build a lease schedule identifying assignment and change-of-control provisions, recapture rights, radius restrictions, guarantees and renewal options;
  2. decide the structure, since an asset purchase needs a true lease assignment while a share purchase engages only change-of-control clauses;
  3. prioritize consents for critical locations and plan for refusal, including price adjustments or excluded sites;
  4. negotiate releases of the seller and its guarantors, or price the continuing liability;
  5. obtain estoppel certificates confirming the lease terms and the absence of defaults.

Illustration: a buyer acquires all the shares of a regional chain with 30 store leases. Twelve leases treat any change in control as a deemed assignment; four give the landlord recapture rights. The buyer conditions closing on consents for the eight highest-revenue stores, negotiates a holdback for the rest and agrees with the seller that refusals at minor sites will not delay closing. Our pages on mergers and acquisitions and commercial real estate describe the wider process.

Lease assignment in insolvency

Insolvency can override a landlord's veto. Under s. 84.1 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA), a court may, on a trustee's application and notice to the counterparties, assign a bankrupt's rights and obligations under an agreement to a person who agrees to take them, considering whether the assignee can perform and whether assignment is appropriate. All monetary defaults, other than those arising only from insolvency, must be remedied by a date the court fixes.

Section 11.3 of the Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act provides a similar power in CCAA proceedings. Landlords facing a tenant restructuring should therefore engage early on the identity and covenant of a proposed assignee. Our distressed M&A page explains how leases are dealt with in insolvency sales.

How TRW & Co helps with lease assignment issues

We act for buyers, sellers, tenants, landlords and lenders on lease assignment and change-of-control issues in Canada: reviewing lease portfolios in due diligence, negotiating consents and releases, drafting assignment and change-of-control provisions in new leases, and advising on applications where consent is unreasonably withheld. Where a court application is needed, it is brought by counsel licensed in the relevant province, with whom we coordinate. Related insights cover tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs. To discuss a transaction or a lease, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Can a landlord refuse consent to a lease assignment in Ontario?

Yes, but under s. 23(1) of the Commercial Tenancies Act a covenant requiring consent is deemed subject to a proviso that consent is not to be unreasonably withheld, unless the lease expressly provides otherwise. A tenant may apply to the Superior Court of Justice under s. 23(2) for an order permitting the assignment if consent is unreasonably withheld.

Is a share sale an assignment of the lease?

Not in itself, because the tenant entity does not change. Many commercial leases, however, contain change-of-control clauses deeming a transfer of shares or control to be an assignment that requires the landlord's consent. Their scope varies widely, so each lease must be reviewed.

How does Quebec law treat lease assignments?

Under arts. 1870 to 1873 of the Civil Code of Québec, the lessee must notify the lessor and obtain consent, the lessor may not refuse without a serious reason and must give reasons within 15 days or is deemed to consent, and the lessor may claim only reasonable expenses. Non-residential leases can vary some of these rules.

What is a recapture clause?

A recapture clause lets the landlord terminate the lease, in whole or for the affected space, when the tenant requests consent to assign or sublet. Tenants usually negotiate to exclude permitted and corporate transfers and to be able to withdraw the request if the landlord elects to recapture.

Can a lease be assigned without consent in insolvency proceedings?

Yes. Under s. 84.1 of the Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act and s. 11.3 of the CCAA, a court may assign a debtor's agreement to a willing assignee after considering whether the assignee can perform. Monetary defaults, other than those arising only from insolvency, must be cured.

Sources

  1. Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7
  2. Civil Code of Québec, arts. 1870-1873
  3. Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act, s. 84.1
  4. Companies' Creditors Arrangement Act, s. 11.3

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.