Skip to content
Real Estate & Construction

Tenant Estoppel Certificates and SNDAs

Tenant estoppel certificates let purchasers and lenders rely on what a tenant confirms about its lease, and SNDAs fix how the lease ranks against a mortgage. Both are routine closing deliverables, but an inaccurate certificate or a subordination without non-disturbance protection can cost a tenant real money.

Property manager reviewing tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs before a commercial real estate closing in Canada

Key takeaways

  • An estoppel certificate prevents the tenant from later contradicting its statements against those who relied on them.
  • Lenders often add new covenants to certificates; tenants need only give what the lease requires.
  • Never sign a subordination without a matching non-disturbance covenant from the lender.
  • In Ontario, leases with more than three years to run should be protected by a registered notice of lease.
  • In Quebec, registering the lease protects a tenant against resiliation by a new owner under art. 1887 C.C.Q.

Tenant estoppel certificates: the short answer

Tenant estoppel certificates are signed statements by a tenant confirming key facts about its lease, such as the rent, the term, the absence of defaults and any prepaid amounts, so that a purchaser or lender can rely on them. Once a tenant gives a certificate, it is generally prevented (estopped) from later asserting facts inconsistent with it against the party who relied on it. Subordination, non-disturbance and attornment agreements (SNDAs) work alongside estoppels: they fix the priority between a lease and a mortgage, protect the tenant's possession if the lender enforces, and bind the tenant to recognize a new owner.

Property manager reviewing tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs before a commercial real estate closing in Canada
Tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs let buyers and lenders rely on what tenants confirm about their leases.

Most Canadian commercial leases oblige tenants to deliver both documents on request within a short period. In practice, they are among the most negotiated closing deliverables in property sales and financings. This article explains what tenant estoppel certificates cover, what lenders and purchasers typically ask for, how SNDAs operate under Canadian land registration systems, and how tenants can avoid giving inaccurate certificates. It is general information, not legal advice.

What tenant estoppel certificates bind tenants to

An estoppel certificate is not usually a contract amendment. Its legal force comes from the doctrine of estoppel: a party who makes a clear representation of fact, intending or expecting another to rely on it, and on which the other relies to its detriment, cannot later go back on it. The certificate therefore binds the tenant as against the addressees, typically the purchaser, the lender and their successors, but it does not ordinarily change the lease as between landlord and tenant.

The consequences can still be serious. If a tenant certifies that there are no landlord defaults and no rent abatements, it may lose the ability to claim against the purchaser for a pre-existing problem, such as an overcharge in operating costs or an unperformed landlord's work obligation. If it certifies that no rent has been prepaid beyond one month, a lender that enforces may not be bound by a larger prepayment. Courts generally interpret certificates according to their plain words, and qualifications in the certificate itself are the tenant's main protection.

Two further points are often overlooked. First, a tenant with a right of first refusal, purchase option or exclusive use covenant should make sure the certificate describes it, because a purchaser that relies on a certificate silent on those rights may argue it took free of them. Second, side letters and informal arrangements, such as a rent deferral agreed by email during a difficult year, must be listed; if they are not, the purchaser may be entitled to treat them as non-existent.

Typical lender and purchaser requests

Requests vary, but most tenant estoppel certificates address the same core items. The table below summarizes them and the usual tenant responses.

ItemWhy the requester wants itTenant's typical position
Lease documentsConfirms the full lease, amendments and side lettersList every document; attach copies where practical
Term, renewals and optionsConfirms income duration and any purchase or expansion rightsConfirm accurately, including ROFRs and ROFOs
Rent and additional rentConfirms current income and payment statusState amounts paid to date; avoid certifying reconciliations not yet done
Prepaid rent and depositsIdentifies amounts a purchaser or lender must honourDisclose deposits and prepayments precisely
DefaultsSeeks comfort that no claims existLimit to the tenant's actual knowledge; disclose known disputes
Landlord work and allowancesIdentifies unpaid inducementsList outstanding amounts and incomplete work
Assignments and subleasesConfirms who is in possessionDisclose all permitted transfers

Lenders also commonly ask tenants to confirm that they will give the lender notice of landlord defaults and an opportunity to cure before terminating, and that they will not amend the lease or prepay rent without the lender's consent. Those are new obligations, not statements of fact, and the tenant should check that its lease actually requires it to give them. Many leases require only a certificate of fact in a reasonable form.

Subordination, non-disturbance and attornment agreements

An SNDA combines three promises:

  • Subordination: the tenant agrees that its lease ranks behind the lender's mortgage (charge or hypothec), so that a lender enforcing the mortgage is not bound by the lease merely because the lease came first.
  • Non-disturbance: the lender agrees that, if it or a purchaser takes over the property on enforcement, it will not disturb the tenant's possession as long as the tenant is not in default.
  • Attornment: the tenant agrees to recognize the lender, a receiver or a purchaser as its landlord.

Priority between a lease and a mortgage depends on provincial land registration rules. In Ontario's land titles system, a lessee can register a notice of lease under s. 111 of the Land Titles Act, and under s. 44(1), paragraph 4, a lease with no more than three years left to run is an interest that binds registered land without registration where there is actual occupation under it. Longer unregistered leases are vulnerable against later registered interests. Tenants of significant premises therefore register notice of their lease, and lenders seek subordination of those that are registered or otherwise prior.

In Quebec, art. 1886 of the Civil Code of Québec provides that the alienation of leased property does not terminate the lease by operation of law. Under art. 1887, the acquirer of an immovable may resiliate a fixed-term lease with more than 12 months remaining, after the first 12 months, on six months' written notice, but not if the lease was registered before the act of alienation. Publication of the lease is therefore critical for Quebec tenants, and lenders and purchasers review the land register accordingly.

Practical point

A tenant should never sign a subordination without a matching non-disturbance covenant from the lender. Subordination alone can allow an enforcing lender or purchaser to treat the lease as terminated, which could cost the tenant its premises and its investment in improvements.

Avoiding inaccurate tenant estoppel certificates

Tenant estoppel certificates are often prepared by the landlord's or lender's counsel and sent to a tenant's property manager with a short deadline. Errors creep in easily. A disciplined process reduces the risk:

  1. route all requests to a responsible person with access to the lease file, the rent ledger and any dispute correspondence;
  2. compare every statement with the lease and amendments, and correct rather than delete inaccurate items;
  3. qualify statements about defaults and claims with "to the tenant's knowledge, without independent investigation";
  4. disclose ongoing audits of operating costs and reserve the right to complete them;
  5. refuse to add new covenants unless the lease requires them, or negotiate them separately;
  6. keep a copy of the signed certificate with the lease records.

Leases usually impose a deadline, often ten business days, and some provide that if the tenant fails to respond the landlord may sign as the tenant's attorney or that the statements are deemed correct. Tenants should take those provisions seriously: a deemed certificate can be as binding in practice as a signed one.

Illustration: an office tenant receives a certificate stating that all landlord's work has been completed and no allowances remain unpaid. In fact, CAD 150,000 of a tenant improvement allowance is outstanding. If the tenant signs without correction, the purchaser may resist paying the allowance after closing, leaving the tenant to pursue the former landlord, which may have distributed the sale proceeds.

Timing, form and who signs

In a sale, the purchaser usually specifies the form of certificate in the agreement of purchase and sale and makes delivery from a threshold of tenants, measured by rentable area or rent, a condition of closing. In a financing, the lender's commitment letter does the same. Because tenants are not parties to those agreements, landlords should negotiate forms that track their leases, not the purchaser's or lender's ideal wish list. A certificate dated close to closing is more valuable; many agreements require it to be dated no more than 30 days before closing, and an older certificate may need to be brought down.

The certificate should be signed by an officer with authority to bind the tenant, and for national tenants it is worth confirming who that is in advance. Where a lease has been assigned or the premises sublet, the requester may want certificates from both the tenant and the occupant. Guarantors are sometimes asked to confirm that their guarantee remains in force; that is a separate request the guarantor should review on its own terms.

Landlord estoppels and reciprocal protection

Estoppels can run both ways. A tenant that is assigning its lease, selling its business or financing its leasehold interest may need the landlord to certify that the lease is in good standing, that rent is paid and that there are no defaults. Tenants should negotiate a reciprocal obligation in the lease, on the same timelines, so that a landlord cannot hold up the tenant's own transaction. Leasehold lenders also seek direct agreements with landlords giving them notice of tenant defaults, cure rights and, if the lease terminates, the right to a new lease on the same terms. These protections complement tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs and are a standard part of leasehold financing.

Points for landlords, purchasers and lenders

Each party to a sale or financing has its own priorities when dealing with tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs:

  • Landlords selling or refinancing often face estoppels as a closing condition, and slow tenants can delay a deal. Landlords should include delivery obligations with tight timelines in every new lease, agree a standard form with major tenants, and start requests as soon as a transaction is likely.
  • Purchasers should review certificates against the leases and rent rolls, investigate discrepancies before waiving conditions, and require the vendor to give its own estoppel, backed by a survival period and holdback, for tenants that do not respond.
  • Lenders should ensure that SNDAs will work on enforcement, including a receiver's ability to collect rent directly, and that they are registered where needed to protect priority.

Related issues arise in lease assignment and change-of-control clauses and rights of first refusal, which certificates should always disclose. Lease priorities in tenant insolvencies and enforcement are also relevant: our receiverships and enforcement page explains how receivers deal with leases, and Ontario's Commercial Tenancies Act governs forfeiture and subtenant protection.

How TRW & Co helps

We act for tenants, landlords, purchasers and lenders on tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs in Canadian real estate transactions: preparing and negotiating standard forms, reviewing certificates against lease files, resolving discrepancies before closing, and negotiating non-disturbance protection in financings. Registrations on title are completed by licensed practitioners in the relevant province, with whom we coordinate. See our commercial real estate and lending and acquisition finance pages, or contact us to discuss a transaction.

Frequently asked questions

Is a tenant estoppel certificate legally binding?

It binds the tenant as against those entitled to rely on it, typically the purchaser and lender, through the doctrine of estoppel. The tenant cannot later assert facts inconsistent with its statements to their detriment. It does not usually amend the lease between landlord and tenant, but its practical effect can be equivalent.

Do tenants have to sign estoppel certificates?

Usually yes, because most commercial leases require the tenant to deliver a certificate of specified facts within a set period on request. The obligation is limited to what the lease describes. Some leases also deem the landlord's statements correct, or authorize the landlord to sign, if the tenant fails to respond in time.

What is an SNDA?

A subordination, non-disturbance and attornment agreement. The tenant subordinates its lease to the lender's mortgage, the lender agrees not to disturb the tenant's possession on enforcement while the tenant is not in default, and the tenant agrees to recognize the lender or a purchaser as landlord.

Does a sale of the building end my lease?

Not automatically. In common law provinces, a purchaser generally takes subject to leases that bind the land under registration rules, such as a registered notice of lease in Ontario. In Quebec, art. 1886 C.C.Q. provides that alienation does not terminate a lease, although art. 1887 allows resiliation of some unregistered fixed-term leases.

How should a tenant handle a certificate with errors?

Correct each inaccurate statement rather than deleting it, qualify statements about defaults to the tenant's knowledge, disclose ongoing disputes and audits, and refuse new covenants that the lease does not require. Return it within the lease deadline and keep a copy.

Sources

  1. Land Titles Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.5
  2. Civil Code of Québec, arts. 1886-1887
  3. Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.