Rights of First Refusal and First Offer in Real Estate
Rights of first refusal and first offer decide who gets the chance to buy a property before anyone else. They are common in leases, joint ventures and co-ownership deals, and they cause disputes when properties are sold in portfolios, through share sales or under long-dated terms that collide with perpetuities rules.

Key takeaways
- A ROFR lets the holder match a third-party offer; a ROFO requires the owner to offer first.
- Share sales and affiliate transfers trigger a ROFR only if the clause says so.
- Package-deal clauses with good-faith price allocation and appraisal prevent most disputes.
- In Ontario, options to acquire land are void after 21 years unless an exception applies.
- In Quebec, a sale in breach of a first refusal agreement may be set up against the holder, leaving damages.
Rights of first refusal in real estate: the short answer
Rights of first refusal (ROFRs) give their holder the right to buy a property on the same terms as a bona fide third-party offer that the owner is prepared to accept. A right of first offer (ROFO) works earlier in the process: before marketing the property, the owner must offer it to the holder, and may sell to others only on terms no better than those the holder declined. Both are common in Canadian leases, joint ventures, co-ownership agreements, development deals and agreements with municipalities or institutions that sell surplus land. Both also generate disputes, particularly when a property is sold as part of a portfolio, through a share sale, or at a price that is hard to allocate.

This article explains how rights of first refusal and first offer work, what triggers them, how package deals are valued, the perpetuities and planning rules that can invalidate them, and how disputes are resolved. It is general information, not legal advice.
ROFR versus ROFO: mechanics compared
The two rights allocate leverage differently. A ROFR favours the holder because it can wait for the market to set a price and then match it, but it chills third-party interest: bidders know their work may simply hand the deal to someone else. A ROFO favours the owner because it preserves a clean marketing process once the holder declines, but the holder must price the property without a market test.
| Feature | Right of first refusal | Right of first offer |
|---|---|---|
| When it operates | After the owner receives an acceptable third-party offer | Before the owner markets the property |
| Price set by | The third-party offer | The owner's offer to the holder |
| Effect on market | Deters bidders; may depress price | Limited once the holder declines |
| Owner's later freedom | Must re-offer if terms change materially | May sell on terms not materially better for the buyer, within a set period |
| Typical dispute | Whether a transaction triggered the right and what "same terms" means | Whether the later sale was on materially better terms |
Good drafting specifies the notice to be given, the information to be disclosed (usually a copy of the offer), the time to exercise (often 10 to 30 days), how the holder exercises (a binding acceptance, with deposit), the closing timeline, and what happens if the holder declines but the third-party deal fails or changes.
Triggers: portfolio sales, share sales and transfers to affiliates
Most litigation over rights of first refusal concerns whether the right was triggered at all. Common problem cases include:
- Share or unit sales. If the owner is a corporation or partnership and its shares or units are sold, the registered owner does not change. Unless the clause expressly treats a change of control as a sale, the right may not be triggered.
- Affiliate transfers and reorganizations. Transfers to related entities, amalgamations and estate freezes are usually carved out, but only if the clause says so.
- Gifts, expropriations and enforcement sales. A ROFR typically responds to a voluntary sale for value. Whether a power of sale by a mortgagee or a court-approved sale in insolvency triggers the right depends on the wording and the court's approach.
- Long-term leases and options. Granting a long ground lease or an option to a third party may or may not count as a disposition.
Co-ownership and joint venture agreements raise their own variant: a ROFR on a co-owner's undivided interest often sits alongside buy-sell (shotgun) clauses and partition restrictions, and the agreement should state which mechanism prevails if both are engaged at once.
Holders should insist on broad triggering language that captures indirect transfers, while owners should seek clear carve-outs. Ambiguity tends to be resolved by courts reading the clause as a whole in light of its commercial purpose, so both sides should spell out the intended result.
Valuing package deals
A frequent problem arises when the owner agrees to sell the ROFR property together with other properties for a single price. The holder cannot match an offer for assets it has no right to buy, and the owner cannot be required to break up a portfolio deal without limit. Courts have approached these cases by asking whether the owner acted in good faith, whether the bundling was a device to defeat the right, and whether a fair allocation of price to the ROFR property can be made. Clauses that address package deals directly avoid most of the uncertainty. Common solutions include:
- an allocation of price by the owner, acting reasonably and in good faith, with an appraisal process if the holder disputes it;
- a right for the holder to buy the entire package;
- a prohibition on bundling the ROFR property without the holder's consent;
- an exclusion of portfolio sales above a set size, with compensation or a continuing right against the new owner.
The general duty of honest performance in contracts also matters. An owner that knowingly misleads the holder about the terms of a third-party offer, or structures a deal to defeat the right, risks liability even where the clause is silent.
Before signing a portfolio sale, an owner should list every ROFR, ROFO and option affecting each property and decide how each will be handled. Purchasers should require this disclosure and confirm it through tenant estoppel certificates.
Perpetuities, planning law and registration
Rights to acquire land can be invalidated by technical rules. In Ontario, s. 13(3) of the Perpetuities Act provides that the perpetuity period for options to acquire for valuable consideration an interest in land is twenty-one years, and that an option exercisable more than twenty-one years after its creation is void on the expiry of twenty-one years as between the original parties and those claiming through them.
Under s. 13(1), the rule does not apply to a lessee's option to acquire the reversion if it is exercisable only by the lessee or its successors and ends within one year after the lease ends. Whether, and when, a ROFR is treated as an option for these purposes depends on its terms and the case law; long-dated rights should be drafted with a perpetuity-compliant end date. Other provinces have their own perpetuities legislation, and some have reformed or abolished the rule.
Planning law can also intervene. Under s. 50(3) of Ontario's Planning Act, subdivision control restricts conveyances and agreements of sale and purchase of part of a parcel, and agreements granting rights in land for twenty-one years or more, unless an exception or consent applies. A ROFR over part of a property, such as one unit of a multi-tenant building that is not a condominium, may therefore require consent before it can be exercised, and an agreement that contravenes subdivision control does not create or convey an interest in land under s. 50(21), unless it is expressly conditional on compliance.
Registration protects the holder against purchasers. In Ontario's land titles system, interests that are not registered may not bind a purchaser who registers first; holders of significant rights of first refusal often register a notice or caution under the Land Titles Act, where the right is registrable. Where the ROFR is in a lease, a registered notice of lease generally gives notice of its terms.
Rights of first refusal in Quebec
The Civil Code of Québec expressly recognizes first refusal agreements. Under art. 1397 of the Civil Code, a contract made in violation of a promise to contract may be set up against the beneficiary, without affecting its remedy in damages against the promisor and against a third party that contracted in bad faith; the same rule applies to a contract made in violation of a first refusal agreement.
In other words, the holder's main remedy against a completed sale to a good-faith third party is damages, unless the right was published or the purchaser acted in bad faith. Holders of Quebec rights should therefore consider publication in the land register and clear provisions on the transmission of the right to successors.
Drafting checklist for rights of first refusal
Most disputes over rights of first refusal can be traced to a clause that left a key question unanswered. Before signing, the parties should confirm that the clause deals with each of the following:
- Scope: the exact property, including whether it covers part of a property, air rights or adjoining land acquired later.
- Triggering events: direct sales, indirect transfers, long leases, options, mortgagee and court-ordered sales, with listed exceptions.
- Offer requirements: what qualifies as a bona fide offer, whether non-cash consideration must be converted to a cash equivalent, and what documents the holder receives.
- Exercise: the time limit, the form of acceptance, deposits, financing conditions and closing timeline.
- Afterlife: whether the right survives a declined offer, for how long the owner may sell on the declined terms, and when a change in price or terms requires a new offer.
- Duration and transfer: an end date that respects perpetuities rules, and whether the right passes to successors of the holder and binds successors of the owner.
Enforcement disputes and remedies
When a right is breached, the holder may seek specific performance, an injunction restraining a sale, or damages. Specific performance of a contract to sell land is not automatic in Canada; courts ask whether the property is unique to the holder and whether damages would be an adequate remedy. Holders often register a certificate of pending litigation to prevent the property being sold while the dispute proceeds, which requires them to show a reasonable claim to an interest in land. Owners and third-party purchasers face delay and cost if the right is uncertain, which is why title insurers, lenders and purchasers scrutinize rights of first refusal closely in due diligence and may require a waiver from the holder before closing.
Illustration: a tenant of a single-tenant industrial building holds a ROFR. The owner agrees to sell the building as part of a ten-property portfolio and allocates a price the tenant considers inflated. The lease requires a good-faith allocation with an appraisal mechanism. The tenant invokes the appraisal and buys at the appraised value; without the clause, the parties would likely have litigated the meaning of "same terms."
How TRW & Co helps with rights of first refusal
We advise owners, tenants, co-owners, joint venture partners and purchasers on rights of first refusal and first offer in Canadian real estate: drafting and negotiating ROFR and ROFO provisions, assessing whether a transaction triggers them, structuring portfolio and share sales, and resolving disputes. Registrations and litigation steps are taken by counsel licensed in the relevant province, with whom we coordinate. See our commercial real estate and commercial litigation pages, our insights on tenant estoppel certificates and lease assignment, or contact us.
Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between a ROFR and a ROFO?
A right of first refusal lets the holder buy on the same terms as an acceptable third-party offer the owner has received. A right of first offer requires the owner to offer the property to the holder before marketing it, and then limits the owner to selling to others on terms not materially better than those offered to the holder.
Does a share sale trigger a right of first refusal?
Only if the clause says so. A sale of the shares or units of the owning entity does not change the registered owner, so a ROFR limited to a sale of the property may not be triggered. Holders should negotiate express change-of-control language; owners should seek carve-outs for affiliate transfers and reorganizations.
How are package deals handled under a ROFR?
Courts look at good faith, whether bundling was used to defeat the right and whether a fair allocation is possible. Well-drafted clauses avoid the issue by requiring a reasonable allocation with an appraisal mechanism, allowing the holder to buy the whole package, or prohibiting bundling without consent.
Can a right of first refusal be void for perpetuity?
It can be at risk. In Ontario, s. 13(3) of the Perpetuities Act limits options to acquire an interest in land for value to twenty-one years. Whether a ROFR is treated as an option depends on its terms and case law, so long-dated rights should include a compliant end date.
What remedies does a ROFR holder have if the owner sells to someone else?
The holder may seek specific performance, an injunction or damages, and may register a certificate of pending litigation in the meantime. Specific performance is discretionary. In Quebec, art. 1397 C.C.Q. allows the sale to be set up against the holder, preserving damages against the promisor and a bad-faith purchaser.
Sources
General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.


