Skip to content
Real Estate & Construction

Relief From Forfeiture in Commercial Leases

Relief from forfeiture lets a court reinstate a commercial lease that a landlord has terminated, or stop a termination in progress. In Ontario it rests on s. 98 of the Courts of Justice Act and s. 20 of the Commercial Tenancies Act, and courts weigh conduct, gravity and disparity before granting it.

Locked storefront with a lease termination notice, illustrating relief from forfeiture for commercial tenants in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Ontario tenants may seek relief under Courts of Justice Act s. 98 and Commercial Tenancies Act s. 20.
  • For non-rent breaches, a landlord must first serve a notice under s. 19(2) of the Commercial Tenancies Act.
  • Paying all arrears and costs into court before judgment permanently stays a forfeiture proceeding for non-payment of rent.
  • Courts weigh the tenant's conduct, the gravity of the breach and the disparity between loss and harm.
  • Missed option deadlines are not true forfeitures, so relief is uncertain.

Relief from forfeiture in commercial leases: the short answer

Relief from forfeiture is an equitable power that lets a court undo or prevent a landlord's termination of a lease when enforcing the forfeiture would be disproportionate to the tenant's breach. In Ontario, tenants rely on two statutory sources: s. 98 of the Courts of Justice Act, which allows a court to grant relief against penalties and forfeitures on terms it considers just, and s. 20 of the Commercial Tenancies Act (CTA), which deals specifically with a landlord's re-entry or forfeiture of a lease. Other provinces have similar powers. Relief is discretionary, usually conditional on curing the default and paying the landlord's costs, and never guaranteed.

Locked storefront with a lease termination notice, illustrating relief from forfeiture for commercial tenants in Canada
Courts can restore a commercial tenancy after termination, but only on terms and in the exercise of discretion.

For landlords, the existence of relief from forfeiture means that a technically valid termination can be reversed months later, often after the premises have been marketed to new tenants. For tenants and their lenders, it is a last line of defence for a valuable leasehold. This article explains how the statutory rules work, how courts exercise discretion, the special issues of missed renewal deadlines and forfeited deposits, and practical strategies on both sides. It is general information, not legal advice.

The statutory framework in Ontario

The CTA sets procedural conditions before a landlord can forfeit for most breaches. Under s. 19(2), a right of re-entry or forfeiture for breach of a covenant other than payment of rent is not enforceable unless the landlord serves a notice specifying the breach, requiring it to be remedied if it is capable of remedy, and requiring compensation, and the tenant fails to comply within a reasonable time. A termination that skips this step is vulnerable on that ground alone.

Section 20(1) then allows the tenant, in the landlord's proceeding or in its own action or application in the Superior Court of Justice, to apply for relief. The court may grant relief "as, having regard to the proceeding and conduct of the parties" and all other circumstances, it thinks fit, on terms as to rent, costs, damages, compensation or otherwise, including an injunction against future breaches. Other features of s. 20 matter in practice:

  • Rent arrears: under s. 20(4), if the proceeding is for non-payment of rent and the tenant pays all arrears and costs into court before judgment, the proceeding is stayed permanently.
  • Effect: under s. 20(5), a tenant granted relief holds the premises under the original lease, without a new lease.
  • No contracting out: under s. 20(6), the section applies despite any stipulation to the contrary.
  • Exceptions: under s. 20(7), it does not extend to covenants against assigning, subletting or parting with possession, or to forfeiture on the tenant's bankruptcy or assignment for the benefit of creditors.
  • Insurance: under s. 20(8), relief for breach of a covenant to insure requires insurance to be in place.

Section 21 separately allows a subtenant to seek a vesting order when the head lease is forfeited, which can protect subtenants and their lenders. The general power in s. 98 of the Courts of Justice Act provides an additional, broader route, and courts have used it where the CTA does not apply or as a supplement to it.

How courts decide whether to grant relief from forfeiture

Because the remedy is equitable, courts look at the whole picture. The leading Supreme Court of Canada authority, Saskatchewan River Bungalows Ltd. v. Maritime Life Assurance Co., [1994] 2 S.C.R. 490 (judgment of 23 June 1994), described relief from forfeiture as discretionary and identified three main considerations, which Canadian courts apply to leases:

FactorQuestions the court asksFavours relief when
Conduct of the applicantWas the breach wilful, repeated or concealed? Has the tenant acted in good faith and promptly?The default was inadvertent and the tenant moved quickly to cure it
Gravity of the breachDoes the breach go to the root of the lease? Can it be remedied?The breach is curable, such as late rent now paid in full
DisparityHow does the value lost by the tenant compare with the harm to the landlord?The tenant would lose a valuable leasehold or improvements for a modest default

Other relevant circumstances include whether the landlord has already re-let the premises to an innocent third party, whether it has relied on the termination to its detriment, the tenant's ability to perform in the future, and whether the tenant has clean hands. Courts are reluctant to grant relief to a chronically defaulting tenant or where the landlord-tenant relationship has broken down irretrievably.

Practical point

A tenant seeking relief from forfeiture should act immediately: tender all arrears, interest and reasonable costs, and bring the application before the landlord re-lets. Delay is one of the most common reasons relief is refused, and a new tenant in possession changes the balance sharply.

Missed renewal and option deadlines

A frequent and difficult scenario is a tenant that fails to exercise a renewal or extension option on time. Strictly, a missed option deadline is not a forfeiture: the tenant does not lose an existing right because of a breach; it simply fails to satisfy a condition for acquiring a new term. Courts have therefore been cautious about using relief from forfeiture to rescue late option notices, especially where the lease makes time of the essence.

That said, Ontario courts have considered the general power in s. 98 in some option cases, and outcomes depend heavily on the facts: how late the notice was, whether the landlord was prejudiced, the value of improvements the tenant would lose, and whether the landlord's own conduct contributed to the delay. Tenants should not rely on the possibility. Diarize option windows, deliver notice in the exact manner the lease requires, and keep proof of delivery.

Illustration: a restaurant tenant has invested heavily in a fit-out and has a five-year renewal option exercisable by notice at least six months before expiry. Its notice is delivered ten days late. The landlord, which has received a higher offer from another operator, refuses to recognize the renewal. The tenant's prospects depend on whether a court treats the situation as one where equitable relief can apply at all, and if so on the shortness of the delay and absence of prejudice; the outcome is uncertain, and litigation is costly.

Deposits, acceleration clauses and penalties

The same statutory language also allows relief against penalties. In commercial leasing, this arises when a landlord retains a large deposit, accelerates rent for the balance of the term, or claims a fixed sum that bears no relation to its actual loss. Courts distinguish a genuine pre-estimate of damages, which is enforceable, from a sum intended to punish or deter, which may be relieved against. A security deposit that the lease applies against actual losses is usually unobjectionable; a clause forfeiting a substantial prepayment for any minor default may be treated as a penalty or a forfeiture eligible for relief.

British Columbia's Law and Equity Act provides in s. 24 that the court "may relieve against all penalties and forfeitures" on terms, and s. 25 specifically addresses relief against acceleration provisions on default in payment. Landlords drafting national lease forms should expect provincial courts to examine acceleration and liquidated damages clauses closely.

Relief from forfeiture outside Ontario

Each common law province has a statutory or equitable basis for relief from forfeiture, and the same discretionary factors generally apply.

In British Columbia, s. 24 of the Law and Equity Act is the general source. Quebec, as a civil law jurisdiction, approaches the issue differently: there is no equitable doctrine of forfeiture as such, but art. 1883 of the Civil Code of Québec allows a lessee facing proceedings to resiliate a lease for non-payment of rent to avoid resiliation by paying, before judgment, the rent due, costs and interest. Courts also control the resiliation of leases under the Code's general rules on non-performance and good faith. See our page on Quebec civil law contracts.

Procedure and the terms courts impose

Applications for relief from forfeiture are usually brought urgently, often with a motion for an interim injunction restraining the landlord from re-letting or changing the locks. The tenant should file evidence explaining the default, showing that it has been or will be cured, and demonstrating the value at stake, such as leasehold improvements, goodwill tied to the location and the remaining term. Landlords respond with evidence of the history of defaults, prejudice from the delay and any steps taken to re-let.

When relief is granted, it almost always comes with conditions. Typical terms include:

  • payment of all arrears with interest at the lease rate within a short period;
  • payment of the landlord's legal costs, sometimes on a full indemnity basis where the lease provides for it;
  • a cure of non-monetary defaults by a fixed date, such as repairs or reinstated insurance;
  • an additional security deposit or letter of credit;
  • a provision that the lease terminates automatically if the tenant defaults again within a set period.

Failure to meet the conditions usually ends the matter in the landlord's favour, so tenants should only accept terms they can realistically perform. Landlords, for their part, can often achieve a better commercial result by negotiating reinstatement terms, such as a payment plan secured by a guarantee, than by contesting the application to the end.

Strategies for landlords and tenants

For landlords, the aim is a termination that withstands an application for relief from forfeiture:

  1. serve a CTA s. 19(2) notice for non-monetary breaches, with a realistic cure period;
  2. document defaults, communications and any waiver risks, since accepting rent after knowing of a breach can affect the right to forfeit;
  3. consider whether distress or a damages claim is a better remedy than termination;
  4. notify known leasehold mortgagees and subtenants where the lease or a non-disturbance agreement requires it;
  5. pause before re-letting if a tenant has signalled an intention to seek relief.

For tenants and lenders, prevention is cheaper than litigation: monitor rent and option dates, insist on notice and cure rights for lenders in leasehold financing, and respond immediately to default notices. Our insights on lease assignment and change-of-control clauses and tenant estoppel certificates and SNDAs address related protections, and our commercial real estate and commercial litigation pages describe how we work on leasing disputes.

How TRW & Co helps

We advise landlords, tenants and leasehold lenders on Canadian commercial leasing disputes, including terminations, applications for relief from forfeiture, missed renewal options and challenges to deposits and acceleration clauses. We review default notices before they are served, assess the strength of a relief application, and help negotiate reinstatement terms or exit arrangements. Court proceedings are conducted by counsel licensed in the relevant province, with whom we work closely. To discuss a lease default, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

What is relief from forfeiture in a commercial lease?

It is a discretionary remedy that allows a court to prevent or reverse a landlord's termination of a lease where forfeiture would be out of proportion to the tenant's breach. Relief is usually granted on terms, such as paying all arrears, interest and the landlord's costs, and curing any other default.

Which statutes govern relief from forfeiture in Ontario?

Section 98 of the Courts of Justice Act gives courts a general power to grant relief against penalties and forfeitures. Section 20 of the Commercial Tenancies Act deals specifically with a landlord's re-entry or forfeiture of a lease and cannot be excluded by contract, although it does not apply to covenants against assignment or to bankruptcy-related forfeiture.

Can a tenant get relief after missing a renewal deadline?

Sometimes, but it is uncertain. A missed option deadline is not a classic forfeiture because the tenant fails to meet a condition rather than losing an existing right. Some courts have considered the general power in s. 98 of the Courts of Justice Act, but results turn on the length of delay, prejudice to the landlord and the terms of the lease.

Does a landlord have to give notice before terminating for a non-monetary breach?

In Ontario, yes. Under s. 19(2) of the Commercial Tenancies Act, a right of re-entry or forfeiture for breach of a covenant other than payment of rent is not enforceable unless the landlord serves notice specifying the breach, requiring remedy if possible and compensation, and the tenant fails to comply within a reasonable time.

How does Quebec law treat lease termination for unpaid rent?

Quebec uses civil law concepts rather than equitable relief from forfeiture. Under art. 1883 of the Civil Code of Québec, a lessee facing proceedings to resiliate a lease for non-payment of rent may avoid resiliation by paying, before judgment, the rent due, costs and interest.

Sources

  1. Courts of Justice Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. C.43, s. 98
  2. Commercial Tenancies Act, R.S.O. 1990, c. L.7
  3. Law and Equity Act, R.S.B.C. 1996, c. 253
  4. Civil Code of Québec, art. 1883
  5. Supreme Court of Canada, docket 23194 (Saskatchewan River Bungalows)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.