Skip to content
Disputes & Class Actions

Derivative Actions: Leave Test and Strategy

Derivative actions let a shareholder or other complainant sue in a corporation's name when the board will not, but only with the court's leave. This guide explains who qualifies, the three-part leave test in CBCA s. 239, how boards should respond, limitation and nunc pro tunc issues, and the court's powers over costs, control and settlement.

Shareholder and counsel preparing derivative actions leave application documents in Canada

Key takeaways

  • Leave under CBCA s. 239 requires 14 days' notice, good faith and apparent corporate benefit.
  • Former shareholders, directors and officers can be complainants.
  • Independent committee decisions not to sue are persuasive but not binding.
  • Complainants need not post security for costs; courts may order interim costs.
  • Derivative actions cannot be settled or discontinued without court approval.

What derivative actions are

Derivative actions allow a shareholder, director or other complainant to sue in the name of a corporation when the people who control it will not. The classic case is a claim against directors or a controlling shareholder for a wrong done to the corporation itself: diverting a corporate opportunity, approving a self-interested transaction, or failing to pursue a claim against a related party. Because the cause of action belongs to the corporation, the complainant needs the court's permission, called leave, before suing. For federal corporations the procedure is in ss. 239 and 240 of the Canada Business Corporations Act (CBCA); in Ontario, ss. 246 and 247 of the Business Corporations Act (OBCA) are closely similar.

Shareholder and counsel preparing derivative actions leave application documents in Canada
Derivative actions require leave because the claim belongs to the corporation, not to the shareholder bringing it.

The statutory scheme replaced the narrow common law rule that only the corporation could sue for a wrong done to it, a rule that left minority shareholders without a practical remedy when wrongdoers controlled the board. Today, derivative actions sit alongside the oppression remedy. The distinction matters: oppression protects the complainant's own interests and expectations; a derivative claim recovers the corporation's loss for the benefit of the corporation as a whole.

Who may apply for leave

Only a "complainant" may apply. Under s. 238 CBCA that includes a current or former registered holder or beneficial owner of a security of the corporation or any affiliate, a current or former director or officer, the Director under the Act, and any other person the court considers a proper person. Former shareholders can therefore bring derivative actions, which matters where the wrongdoing was discovered only after a squeeze-out or sale. Creditors occasionally qualify as proper persons, but courts are careful not to allow derivative claims to become a collection device.

Leave can be sought to bring an action, to intervene in an existing action to which the corporation or a subsidiary is a party, or to prosecute, defend or discontinue an action on the corporation's behalf (s. 239(1)). Leave can also be sought in respect of a subsidiary, which is important in group structures where the wrong occurred at the operating company level.

The leave test for derivative actions

Section 239(2) CBCA sets three conditions. The court must be satisfied that:

Condition (s. 239(2) CBCA)What courts look forCommon pitfalls
(a) Notice to the directors at least 14 days before applying, or as the court orders, if they do not bring, diligently prosecute or defend, or discontinue the actionA notice that identifies the claim with enough detail for the board to decide whether to actVague notices; notice to the wrong board in a group; applying before the period runs without seeking a dispensing order
(b) The complainant is acting in good faithA genuine belief in a colourable claim, pursued for the corporation's benefitEvidence that the application is leverage in a personal dispute, competitor motives, or ulterior purposes
(c) It appears to be in the interests of the corporation that the action be broughtAn arguable case and a sensible cost-benefit picture, not proof on the meritsClaims too speculative to justify the cost; recoveries that would flow mainly to wrongdoers

The third condition is deliberately framed as what "appears" to be in the corporation's interests. Courts do not try the merits at the leave stage, but they do look for a reasonable or arguable claim and ask whether pursuing it makes sense for the corporation, taking into account cost, collectability and disruption. Ontario's OBCA uses the same three conditions.

Good faith is often the real battleground in closely held companies. A shareholder locked in a personal dispute with the majority can still act in good faith, but evidence that the derivative claim is a bargaining chip, or that the applicant is acting for a competitor, can defeat leave. Applicants should put forward evidence of their investigation, their attempts to have the board act and the benefit to the corporation.

Practical point

Treat the s. 239 notice as the first step of the litigation, not a formality. A notice that sets out the claim, the evidence and the relief sought, and gives the board a real opportunity to act, strengthens the good-faith case and makes it harder for the defendants to argue that the board was never properly asked.

The board's response and independent committees

Once the notice arrives, the board must decide whether the corporation will pursue the claim itself. Where some directors are implicated, best practice is to refer the decision to a committee of independent directors with its own advisers. A well-run committee that investigates and concludes, for documented reasons, that the claim is not worth pursuing can be persuasive evidence at the leave stage, although it does not bind the court.

The business judgment rule shapes this analysis. Canadian courts defer to reasonable business decisions made honestly, prudently and on an informed basis, as the Supreme Court explained in BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69, and earlier in Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise (see our case note). The deference applies to a decision not to sue as well, but only where the decision-makers were independent and properly informed. Shareholder ratification of the impugned conduct does not end the matter: s. 242(1) CBCA provides that a derivative action cannot be stayed or dismissed only because shareholders have approved, or may approve, the alleged breach, though the court may take their approval into account.

Timing, limitation periods and nunc pro tunc leave

Derivative actions raise awkward timing problems. The corporation's limitation period may be running while the complainant gives notice and waits for the leave hearing. Practitioners address this in several ways: applying for leave early with an abridged notice period where urgency justifies it, seeking a standstill or tolling agreement with the proposed defendants, or, where an action has already been started to protect the limitation period, seeking leave nunc pro tunc, meaning with retroactive effect. Courts have granted retroactive leave in appropriate cases, but it is discretionary and should not be relied on as a plan. Our insight on limitation periods explains how the clock runs.

Illustration: a hypothetical minority shareholder in an Ontario manufacturing company learns that the CEO, who is also the majority shareholder, has been routing purchasing through a supplier he secretly owns. The two-year limitation period for the corporation's claim may already be running. The shareholder serves a detailed notice on the board, proposes a tolling agreement and, when the CEO's allies on the board refuse both, applies for leave on short notice with evidence of the overcharges. The court can then decide whether leave should be granted and who controls the claim.

Costs, control of the litigation and recovery

Once leave is granted, the court's powers under s. 240 CBCA are broad. It may make any order it thinks fit, including orders:

  • authorizing the complainant or any other person to control the conduct of the action;
  • giving directions for the conduct of the action;
  • directing that any amount payable by a defendant be paid directly to former and present security holders rather than to the corporation, which is useful where a corporate recovery would flow back to the wrongdoers; and
  • requiring the corporation to pay the complainant's reasonable legal fees.

Section 242 adds important protections for complainants: no security for costs (s. 242(3)); the possibility of interim costs, including legal fees, paid by the corporation, subject to accountability at the end (s. 242(4)); and a requirement of court approval before the action is stayed, discontinued, settled or dismissed for delay (s. 242(2)). Because the claim belongs to the corporation, the complainant cannot simply settle privately for its own account; settlements must be presented to the court, which considers whether they serve the corporation and other security holders. For defendants, the same rule means that a deal with the complainant alone is not final until approved.

Derivative actions are therefore expensive and slow compared with an oppression application, and many disputes that begin as derivative claims are reframed or combined with oppression claims. The Supreme Court's 2017 decision in Wilson v. Alharayeri, which confirmed personal director liability in the oppression context, has made that combination more attractive in some cases.

Derivative actions in other settings

The CBCA model has been copied, with variations, across Canada. Ontario's OBCA mirrors the federal leave test and court powers, and the other provinces have comparable statutory derivative procedures, although notice periods, the definition of complainant and the treatment of costs differ in detail. Before applying, counsel should check the governing statute of the specific corporation, which may not be the province where it operates. A company carrying on business in Alberta may be incorporated federally or in British Columbia, and the leave application must follow the statute of incorporation.

Not-for-profit corporations raise their own issues. Members of federal not-for-profits can use a derivative procedure under the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act, and Ontario's Not-for-Profit Corporations Act, 2010 contains a similar mechanism; our insight on not-for-profit corporations discusses governance under those statutes. Membership disputes in charities and associations often look like oppression claims but involve corporate wrongs that belong in a derivative claim.

In public companies, derivative actions are less common than in private ones. Shareholders who suffer trading losses usually pursue statutory secondary-market misrepresentation claims or class actions, which compensate investors directly rather than the issuer. A derivative claim may still make sense where directors or officers caused the company itself a loss, for example through an improper related-party transaction or a failure of oversight that led to regulatory penalties, and where insurance under a directors' and officers' policy makes a recovery realistic. Coverage analysis should therefore come early: many D&O policies respond differently to claims brought by or on behalf of the insured entity, and the structure of the claim can determine whether a recovery is collectable.

Finally, a successful derivative claim does not always benefit the complainant directly. Recoveries are paid to the corporation unless the court orders otherwise under s. 240(c). Where the wrongdoers remain controlling shareholders, that order, or a combined oppression claim, may be essential. Complainants should therefore think about the remedy they ultimately want before choosing between a derivative claim, an oppression claim or both, because that choice shapes evidence, costs and settlement dynamics from the start.

How TRW & Co helps

We act for shareholders, boards, independent committees and directors in disputes about derivative actions as part of our commercial litigation and corporate governance work. We prepare and respond to s. 239 notices, advise independent committees on investigations and decisions whether to sue, prepare leave applications and oppositions, negotiate tolling and standstill agreements, and structure settlements for court approval. Court proceedings in Canada require Canadian-licensed counsel, and we work with them where needed. This page is general information, not legal advice. To discuss a potential claim, contact us.

Frequently asked questions

Why do derivative actions need leave of the court?

Because the cause of action belongs to the corporation, not to the shareholder. Leave under s. 239 CBCA protects the corporation's right to manage its own claims while allowing a complainant to step in where those in control will not act. The court checks notice, good faith and whether the action appears to be in the corporation's interests.

How much notice must be given to the directors?

Under s. 239(2)(a) CBCA, the complainant must give the directors notice of the intention to apply not less than 14 days before applying, or as otherwise ordered by the court, if the directors do not bring, diligently prosecute or defend, or discontinue the action. Courts can abridge the notice period in urgent cases.

Who pays the costs of a derivative action?

The court can order the corporation to pay the complainant's reasonable legal fees (s. 240(d)) and interim costs during the proceeding (s. 242(4)), subject to accountability at the end. The complainant is not required to post security for costs. Costs exposure still depends on how the court exercises its discretion.

Can shareholders approve the conduct and end the claim?

Not on its own. Section 242(1) CBCA provides that an action cannot be stayed or dismissed only because shareholders have approved, or may approve, the alleged breach of a duty owed to the corporation. The court may consider shareholder approval in deciding what order to make.

Can a derivative action be settled privately?

No. Under s. 242(2) CBCA, a derivative action cannot be stayed, discontinued, settled or dismissed for want of prosecution without court approval, and the court may require notice to other complainants. Settlements must serve the corporation, not only the complainant.

Sources

  1. Canada Business Corporations Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. C-44, ss. 238–242
  2. Business Corporations Act (Ontario), R.S.O. 1990, c. B.16, ss. 246–247
  3. Supreme Court of Canada docket 32647 (BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69)
  4. Supreme Court of Canada docket 36689 (Wilson v. Alharayeri)

General information only, not legal advice. References to statutes, courts and authorities describe published law and practice at the date shown.